One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 25, 2009, 11:13:34 PM
-
What changes, if any, would you make for the Swans game?
-
make cuzins a sweeper and stp bloody handballing it so much
-
What changes, if any, would you make for the Swans game?
Out:Despair and Negative
In: Hope and Positive
-
What changes, if any, would you make for the Swans game?
Out:Despair and Negative
In: Hope and Positive
Great Post :clapping Changes depend on injuries, ie Richo. As a reward, i believe the team should be left alone! Great to Cuz in the rooms after the game, he looked be genuinely happy wwith the win!
-
The key for the club next week is to build on this momentum. I know it will be hard based on Sydney's loss as I am posting this but the RFC and the players must not just feel relief b/c the pressure is off due to us winning so play each week as if it is your last ever game Tigers.
-
depends on richos injury
if richo is injured
out richo
in snake or sarge
-
Out.....zone defence
In.....Man on Man
-
Really hate to make changes to a winning side.
However Schulz has had two good games so I think he should be in, if Richo is out then I would go for Schulz.
Simmonds did OK for Coburg so maybe him for Patto.
If Cuz and Cotch are ready they will probably demand selection but I don't know who to drop, I dont think we had any bad performers
-
If Cuz and Cotch are ready they will probably demand selection
Cotchin isn't an option having only played his first game of the year on Saturday
Cousins has missed 4 weeks and should come back via Coburg, not worth taking any chances
I actually don't think you can make changes for the sake of it
If Richo isn't 100% right then he shouldn't play but if he is
Ins: NIL
Outs: NIL
-
I actually don't think you can make changes for the sake of it
Agree there, but I worry about two things; Sydney's bigger bodies and our forward line which needs to kick more goals. Like I said hate to change a winning side but you have to pick the side best capable of beating your opponents.
Our current side from last night has a few light bodies and questionable defensive players, in playing Sydney this probably needs ot be looked at.
-
I actually don't think you can make changes for the sake of it
Agree there, but I worry about two things; Sydney's bigger bodies and our forward line which needs to kick more goals. Like I said hate to change a winning side but you have to pick the side best capable of beating your opponents.
Our current side from last night has a few light bodies and questionable defensive players, in playing Sydney this probably needs ot be looked at.
True
But I reckon the key to beating Sydney will be our ability to out run them
They are not a quick side and we are (well at least when we are switched on we are :P)
-
Out: McMahon, Richo (hammy)
In: Cousins, Cotchin
-
In: Cousins, Cotchin
I want Cotchin out there as much as anyone
But he hasn't had a proper pre-season and has played about 70% of 1 VFL game
He isn't ready...
-
Richo in doubt for Swans
By Mic Cullen 12:03 AM Sun 26 April, 2009
RICHMOND star Matthew Richardson is in doubt for next week's clash with the Sydney Swans after injuring his glute muscle in Saturday night's breakthrough 36-point win over North Melbourne.
Richardson limped form the field in the first minute of the second term with what appeared to be a hamstring injury and went straight to the rooms, but reappeared with his leg heavily iced.
"He had a glute strain, high up in the buttocks – it wasn't a tear or anything like that," coach Terry Wallace said post-match.
"It was certainly very, very restrictive so he just couldn't get into any stride at all."
Full article at:
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/75642/default.aspx
-
Out: McMahon, Richo (hammy)
In: Cousins, Cotchin
why should jordy be dropped, u have no idea
NO IDEA
AND BTW, richos hammy is fine, he strained a gluteal muscle, thats in his arse not leg!
-
The SCG is a very small ground, as we all know, where the CHF and CHB positions are practically defunk. As a result if Richo is ommitted then we need a big target leading from the goal square. Schulz is the obvious choice but Vickery could be one from left field. Cotchin doesn't need to be rushed in and given that he only played half a game for Coburg, I would say he would need one full game (at least) at the VFL level before he is recalled. Cousins may be included for....hard call really - Collins at a squeeze but I don't think this is fair so best to let CoBenny earn his inclusion coming back through the Burgers.
Stripes
-
AND BTW, richos hammy is fine, he strained a gluteal muscle, thats in his behind not leg!
Glutes can be tricky and painfull... can lead to hammy problems if not treated properly
My lower back problem is hamstring and glute related - so the experts tell me :P :lol
-
at least 2 player need to be dropped to accommodate Cotchin and Cousins - if not next week then the game after.
Brown is prolly worth a spot in the side too at some stage. And the like of Raines & Thomson you would think should start knocking on the door.
Collins, Polo, JON, Tambling etc. all worth staying i team at this stage. + i still don't like McMahon and Bowden in the same backline.
-
browns form was deplorable in first 4 games , a HFF that cant kick goals has as much use as yesterdays paper...No rush for his return...Cotch needs 1 more run as does Cuz...If richo is out Id bring in sarge
-
With Richo apparently okay then no change.
-
Deledio was good on the Half-Back stuff. and there is McMahon and Bowden too. i personally would not have McMahon in the team, and have Deledio as the HBF. Joel is 'servicable' in the BP/Sweeper. i am not a 'Joel Fan', however he is worth that BP spot. however North Melbourne did not show McMahon respect and therefore McMahon got his touches at ease. Sydney are a lot more disiplined team then North Melbourne, so McMahon shouldn't expect the 'easy touches'.
Oakley-Nicholls kept fudging up! he is so slow and it annoys me. he has sticky hands, but he is slow. though our forward line needs something (a big strong forward).
Richardson - not sure if we should risk him. look, this match if we can pinch a 'win' would do us wonders. Sydney another team who loves playing Richmond. if we risk Richardson, then we should risk Cousins and Cotchin. though i doubt that Cousins and Cotchin will play.
every match now is a must win match. LMAO!
should we bring back Simmonds for Pattison?
Morton needs to lift a bit more and work on his kicking like Jack should.
drop JON for Jay? need a tall forward.
i would say:
In: Schulz, Simmonds
Out: Oakley-Nicholls, Pattison
-
torch, im glad you are not in charge at rfc!
btw, u say jon kept fudging up......................wrong
u say jon is slow........................... u have no idea, he keeps up with deledio foley and white!
-
I think they should bring in Schulz for Richo or, from a bit left field, Simmo to play in the goal square rotating with Gus and Patto to give the younger two are break against Jolly.
Just my thoughts
Stripes
-
if richo is remotely restricted he must not play. we must have 22 100% fit men on the park
if he is fine the team must remain unchanged
otherwise
richo out
sarge in
-
Simmonds did OK for Coburg so maybe him for Patto.
Patto didn't get a lot of it, but I liked his game. I'd leave him.
-
I think they should bring in Schulz for Richo or, from a bit left field, Simmo to play in the goal square rotating with Gus and Patto to give the younger two are break against Jolly.
Just my thoughts
Stripes
I like that idea alot. :bow It could be the move like moving Richo to the wing was last year. Not saying Simmo will be as good as Richo of course. But it would give Gus and Patto and good run and maybe a missing big body in our forward line with Simmo. Verry good idea.
Smaller ground long kick from the middle Simmo marks or breaks packs open smaller players at ground level, :gotigers sounds like a simple game plan.
-
Deledio was good on the Half-Back stuff. and there is McMahon and Bowden too. i personally would not have McMahon in the team, and have Deledio as the HBF. Joel is 'servicable' in the BP/Sweeper. i am not a 'Joel Fan', however he is worth that BP spot. however North Melbourne did not show McMahon respect and therefore McMahon got his touches at ease. Sydney are a lot more disiplined team then North Melbourne, so McMahon shouldn't expect the 'easy touches'.
Oakley-Nicholls kept fudging up! he is so slow and it annoys me. he has sticky hands, but he is slow. though our forward line needs something (a big strong forward).
Richardson - not sure if we should risk him. look, this match if we can pinch a 'win' would do us wonders. Sydney another team who loves playing Richmond. if we risk Richardson, then we should risk Cousins and Cotchin. though i doubt that Cousins and Cotchin will play.
every match now is a must win match. LMAO!
should we bring back Simmonds for Pattison?
Morton needs to lift a bit more and work on his kicking like Jack should.
drop JON for Jay? need a tall forward.
i would say:
In: Schulz, Simmonds
Out: Oakley-Nicholls, Pattison
What! No!
Patto was great. Simmonds struggled in all games
Schulz has been given opputunities and he hasn't taken them, give JON minimum 4 games. JON was servicable. Give him a chance.
Team stays the same. End of story.
If Richo is out you'd bring in Schultz as a forward or Simmonds and stick him in the goal sqaure and told do not leave the forward 50 arc.
-
JON needs an extended run in the team-at least a month.He may be TWs "project player" but I if last Saturday was JONs first ever game I would be thinking this kid shows promise.I do agree with most people that this year is JONs last chance to show somthing.
-
anyone wanting Simmonds back after a week needs a head check cause his one of the reason we been losing
Graham & Patto did a great job
Out: Richo
In: Vickery
-
if richo is remotely restricted he must not play. we must have 22 100% fit men on the parkif he is fine the team must remain unchanged
Absolutely 150% spot on
-
anyone wanting Simmonds back after a week needs a head check cause his one of the reason we been losing
Graham & Patto did a great job
Out: Richo
In: Vickery
yes yes yes great post TM.
our future is NOT browny, simmo or Schulz. They have had their chances in particluar the last 2.
If richo is out then Vickery must come in.
If not i would stick with the same team including JON. In fact i would put JON on Goodes. Surely he can do better than Hyde last year.
Still LMAO over that move.
-
anyone wanting Simmonds back after a week needs a head check cause his one of the reason we been losing
Graham & Patto did a great job
Out: Richo
In: Vickery
yes yes yes great post TM.
our future is NOT browny, simmo or Schulz. They have had their chances in particluar the last 2.
If richo is out then Vickery must come in.
If not i would stick with the same team including JON. In fact i would put JON on Goodes. Surely he can do better than Hyde last year.
Still LMAO over that move.
hahaha yes one of VFL/AFL History moments Hyde on Goodes hahahahahahahaha
JON on Goodes hahaah made my week
-
Is Cotchin a chance to play against the Swans?
If so I'd go
Outs: Richo(inj), Tambling
In: Schulz, Cotchin
-
Barring late injury there won't be a change.
Nor should there be.
-
Is Cotchin a chance to play against the Swans?
If so I'd go
Outs: Richo(inj), Tambling
In: Schulz, Cotchin
Tambling out ? what a pathetic suggestion, that proves that you have no idea
-
No change.
Cotch is a class above but needs another week at least, no rush.
Vickery is good too as a long term prospect, may be a bit green this year but may get a few games later on.
Rainsey was OK too but who misses ? No one.
If Richo is out, Schulz to get most probably one of his last chances.
Other richmond listed players as Rawlings mentioned after the match are playing for themselves and need to learn to work hard and play a team game at VFL before they deserve promotion. Losing to Box Hill with the side we had was unacceptable in the extreme.
-
If Richo is out, Schulz to get most probably one of his last chances.
When he does I hope they give him a few games and keep him at FF so we can find out. My memory is fading in my old age but I dont think he has been given two full games at FF in quiet a while.
It would also be nice if he could get some decent supply in there as well although that might be pushing things
-
Got a feeling if Richo misses then Simmo will come in.
-
Tambling out ? what a pathetic suggestion, that proves that you have no idea
Sorry. I bow to your superior knowledge.
Personally felt whilst Bling's game was OK and he did do some nice things obviously that he still didn't have as much impact over 4 quarters as he should for a player with his experience.
With good players like Cotchin & Cousins to come back he'd want to lift his performance on what he has served up so far as he is yet to cement his spot.
I am a Tambling supporter btw numbnuts.
-
Tambling out ? what a pathetic suggestion, that proves that you have no idea
Sorry. I bow to your superior knowledge.
Personally felt whilst Bling's game was OK and he did do some nice things obviously that he still didn't have as much impact over 4 quarters as he should for a player with his experience.
With good players like Cotchin & Cousins to come back he'd want to lift his performance on what he has served up so far as he is yet to cement his spot.
I am a Tambling supporter btw numbnuts.
you are the numbnuts and onviously have no idea what tamblings main role for the night was, and that was to prptect deledio and make space for him, its not just about possessions u twit, its about your role for the team and even deledio thanked ritchie for the role he played for him
look at the bigger picture imbecile
deledio owed jacked and tambling alot, and he did appreciate it! unlike yourself
-
Stick to the topic and leave out the namecalling folks ::)
Ch 10 news just stated the obvious - Richo in doubt because he hasn't trained for the second day in a row.
-
considering Terry was in sydney a couple of weeks ago can we expect the unexpected when it comes to game plan. :shh
-
richo has a pretty good record of coming up when least expected, be a brave man to count him out, Id hate to see Vickery come in ...way too early, needs to consolidate some form...have never liked simmo as a key forward...shocking kick for goal and at best an average overhead mark, making him as useful as an extra light tower...if there's a gap then sarge deserves a shot...at least capable of being good for a couple or a few on a day out ::)
-
have never liked simmo as a key forward...shocking kick for goal
Are you sure about that?
In his last two full seasons Troy's conversion has been 13 goals 6 and 25 goals 10
-
have never liked simmo as a key forward...shocking kick for goal
Are you sure about that?
In his last two full seasons Troy's conversion has been 13 goals 6 and 25 goals 10
here's a thought not necessarliy to you Infamy but how about we forget about Simmo and forget about the saviour "SCHULZ' and focus on youth.
BRING VICKERY IN.
Kruzer played his first season and look at him go now. He has proved he can mix it at Coburg the last few weeks so BRING HIM NOW.
I believe we dont take enough chances at our club. Same old players get the same old chances.
Enough is enough no more "Schulz" and no "SIMMO"
-
Vickery isn't ready, he has only just got promoted from Coburg Reserves
Let him develop and dominate at a lower level first
-
No changes this week...Richo will play.
-
No changes this week...Richo will play.
Cheers Goohuc. Good news :).