One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Infamy on May 30, 2009, 10:28:56 PM

Title: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Infamy on May 30, 2009, 10:28:56 PM
Out: Simmonds, Bowden, White (inj)
In: Rance, Graham, Coughlan/Thomson

Obviously I'd revise this after the Coburg match but the old guys were stuffing useless tonight, time to get rid of them
Hard to make that many changes to a winning side, but Simmo was a liability, Bowden did nothing and White is a clearly forced change

Wouldn't surprise me if they bring back McMahon to replace White unfortunately
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: sabartooth on May 30, 2009, 10:32:13 PM
out : simmo, white, petts
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Chuck17 on May 30, 2009, 10:39:56 PM
Out  Simmo(Please Oh Please) White (Inj)  Thursfield (didnt do anything wrong just want Rance back in)

In Gus Thompson Rance
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Siberian on May 30, 2009, 10:41:25 PM
Just Simmo and White would be fine for mine
I have no time for pitiful but he seems to be putting in for now
one more week, wont wont to see him next year though, far ahead of Jordan or JON right now
Would understand if Thompson got a shot
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: yellowandback on May 30, 2009, 10:56:31 PM
Just Simmo and White would be fine for mine
I have no time for pitiful but he seems to be putting in for now
one more week, wont wont to see him next year though, far ahead of Jordan or JON right now
Would understand if Thompson got a shot

Simmo and White along with a change in mindset that we can compete for 100 minutes!!!
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: mightytiges on May 30, 2009, 11:13:25 PM
Out: Simmo, Petts, White (inj), Brown (inj?)

In: Gus, Rance, Thomson, Vickery
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: TigerTime on May 30, 2009, 11:17:46 PM
glad white got injured , he was costing us badly and when he went off , we started winning

anyway, out white, foley snake  petts

in cogs vickery edwards and gourdis(if thats possible)
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: sabartooth on May 31, 2009, 12:27:09 AM
like to see vickery get a go seems very competitive
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Chuck17 on May 31, 2009, 02:40:12 PM
glad white got injured , he was costing us badly and when he went off , we started winning


What a supporter, glad when our players get injured
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: 1965 on May 31, 2009, 04:46:46 PM

Tempted to suggest Schulz gets a game next week.

 :outtahere
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: wayne on May 31, 2009, 05:03:01 PM

Tempted to suggest Schulz gets a game next week.

 :outtahere

I know he's had plenty of chances, but why can't we have a set-up that makes him the sole focal point like other teams do??

Not just him though, anyone playing forward doesn't get space to lead into directly in front of goal.

Even little Mark Le Cras gets space to lead into for the Eagles.
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Infamy on May 31, 2009, 05:10:50 PM
You have to wonder if we should bring him in for Brown. Another tall down forward would take some of the heat off Riewoldt.
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Hellenic Tiger on May 31, 2009, 07:15:19 PM
Simmonds please oh please especially if Angus is fit. If Angus stays fit Simmo must never play

White for Thompson due to Matt's hammy.

Vickery for Bowden just as a future prospect replacing an old timer.

Rance if fit must play with either Pettifer making way, Polo if he is sighted on the Peake garbage and outed. Polo was a gun yesterday by the way. Brilliant.

Dogs are a quick side so no Cogs as he is no road runner. Beep Beep.
I know Schulz kicked 8 but how many chances does he need? I am of the mindset let him excel at Coburg rather than fail at Richmond which he has time and time again. He might attract some sniffing from some opposition club performing well for Coburg as opposed to poorly performing for Richmond. Keep him at the Burgers please.......
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Jackstar is back on May 31, 2009, 07:46:25 PM

Tempted to suggest Schulz gets a game next week.

 :outtahere

dont go there
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Rex on May 31, 2009, 08:00:16 PM
glad white got injured , he was costing us badly and when he went off , we started winning

anyway, out white, foley snake  petts

in cogs vickery edwards and gourdis(if thats possible)
Foley??????? TT get real mate!!!! Snake? Who is gunna ruck with Patto? Petts maybe, Sarge in White out thats it.
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Go Richo 12 on May 31, 2009, 08:14:37 PM
I think Simmo's time is up! The only reason he is still in imo is a lack of a quality replacement!
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: WilliamPowell on May 31, 2009, 09:44:53 PM
Outs: White (inj), Pettifer, Bowden. Simmonds

Ins: Thomson (for White), Rance (for Bowden), Gus (for Simmonds). Vickery (for Pettifer)

No room for Cogs against the speedy Bullies,
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: TigerTime on May 31, 2009, 09:48:32 PM
after today i say post schulz edwards and cogs  and one of browne/gus/vickery must come in

out white simmonds foley petts thursty
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: torch on May 31, 2009, 10:00:18 PM
Out (In):

Pettifer (Schulz), Simmonds (Graham), White (Inj) (Coughlan), Brown (Inj) (Post), Bowden (Rance).

*time to play Schulz and Post as key "tall" Forwards.

*Brown, drop him if he isn't injured!

*If Graham is not right, play Vickery! Pattison and Vickery!

*Pettifer is useless! lazy, soft, selfish, useless!

--------------------------

Nahas, Post, Morton

Riewoldt, Schulz, Deledio

--------------------------

*forward line!
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Tigermonk on June 01, 2009, 10:17:42 AM
Out: Simmonds, Bowden, White (inj)
In: Rance, Graham, Coughlan/Thomson

Obviously I'd revise this after the Coburg match but the old guys were stuffing useless tonight, time to get rid of them
Hard to make that many changes to a winning side, but Simmo was a liability, Bowden did nothing and White is a clearly forced change

Wouldn't surprise me if they bring back McMahon to replace White unfortunately

FW always wanting to drop Bowden when he was the one who setup the win again
when are you going to wake up from your dream tosser
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: gtig on June 01, 2009, 10:18:53 AM
crazy talk maybe but mcguane seems to be developing a healthy taste for kicking goals and he's taking a lot of marks - i'd love to see what he might do up forward for a game, & bring in silverster to fill his spot down back.  :juggle  :outtahere
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: TigerTime on June 01, 2009, 10:39:23 AM
crazy talk maybe but mcguane seems to be developing a healthy taste for kicking goals and he's taking a lot of marks - i'd love to see what he might do up forward for a game, & bring in silverster to fill his spot down back.  :juggle  :outtahere

mguane was recruited and came to us as a fwd :thumbsup
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Judge Roughneck on June 01, 2009, 08:10:29 PM
crazy talk maybe but mcguane seems to be developing a healthy taste for kicking goals and he's taking a lot of marks - i'd love to see what he might do up forward for a game, & bring in silverster to fill his spot down back.  :juggle  :outtahere

mguane was recruited and came to us as a fwd :thumbsup

i do not agree
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Infamy on June 01, 2009, 08:33:10 PM
crazy talk maybe but mcguane seems to be developing a healthy taste for kicking goals and he's taking a lot of marks - i'd love to see what he might do up forward for a game, & bring in silverster to fill his spot down back.  :juggle  :outtahere

mguane was recruited and came to us as a fwd :thumbsup

i do not agree
How can you not agree, that's a fact?
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Hes My Hero on June 01, 2009, 08:43:20 PM
crazy talk maybe but mcguane seems to be developing a healthy taste for kicking goals and he's taking a lot of marks - i'd love to see what he might do up forward for a game, & bring in silverster to fill his spot down back.  :juggle  :outtahere

mguane was recruited and came to us as a fwd :thumbsup

i do not agree


How can you not agree, that's a fact?

Very true. :thumbsup
McGuane was playing as a forward when recruited. Maybe his was noted as having a kicking deficientcy, that looks as if it is well on it's way to being rectified. Playing forward may be an option not yet explored ala Richo to the wing. :)
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: Infamy on June 01, 2009, 09:07:11 PM
He had 100% disposal efficiency against Freo and they were quite damaging too
Looks like he is well over those groin issues and his disposal has come on in leaps and bounds.
Title: Re: Changes for Round 11 Vs Bulldogs
Post by: mightytiges on June 04, 2009, 12:54:20 PM
I got to training near the end but Thomson, Rance and JON from memory were with the squad as was Cogs who went off near the end with a trainer. Jordie was there too. I believe Gus is ready to go as well. Kingy came out after everyone had left to do some laps. Browny apparently missed yesterday's training.