One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Chuck17 on July 16, 2009, 04:57:33 PM
-
RICHMOND v NORTH MELBOURNE
Richmond
B: Jake King, Will Thursfield, Chris Newman
HB: Dean Polo, Luke McGuane, Matthew White
C: Trent Cotchin, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio
HF: Robin Nahas, Jack Riewoldt, Jayden Post
F: Tyrone Vickery, Mitch Morton, Ben Cousins
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Richard Tambling
I/C (from): Adam Pattison, Alex Rance, Jordan McMahon, Jarrod Silvester, Tom Hislop, Mark Coughlan, Shane Edwards
In: Pattison, Coughlan, Silvester, McMahon
Out: Kelvin Moore (calf)
North Melbourne
B: Brady Rawlings, Scott Thompson, Nathan Grima
HB: Scott McMahon, Josh Gibson, Michael Firrito
C: Levi Greenwood, Liam Anthony, Drew Petrie
HF: Leigh Harding, Lachie Hansen, Lindsay Thomas
F: Brent Harvey, David Hale, Corey Jones
Foll: Hamish McIntosh, Adam Simpson, Andrew Swallow
I/C (from): Daniel Harris, Sam Power, Leigh Adams, Ben Ross, Todd Goldstein, Aaron Edwards, Daniel Pratt
In: Ross, Goldstein, Edwards, Pratt
Out: Gavin Urquhart (groin)
-
Edit: Cheers Chucky :thumbsup.
-
No probs OE.
Oh No; McMuppet/McLovin etc may be back in. Always topical when that happens.
Probably think Hislop/Edwards/McMahon will miss out but who knows.
Like some others here I am not sold on Cogs being done and gone, his inside work is very good.
-
In: Pattison, Coughlan, Silvester, McMahon
Not the players to bring in to impress the fans Jade especially Jordie lol.
Silvester will be straight swap for Moore you would think.
I hope Blingers is okay and we don't bring in Jordie as his replacement :help
-
Moore out, Coughlan and McMahon in
richmondfc.com.au
By Mic Cullen Thu 16 July, 2009
FOR THE second week in a row, Richmond won’t have a debutant in the side at the MCG this weekend.
Jayden Post, Jarrod Silvester and Ty Vickery played their first AFL games in caretaker coach Jade Rawlings first three weeks. But the trend stopped there.
Tall defender Kel Moore is out of the side with a corked calf picked up in the loss to Carlton last weekend.
But given the Tigers face North Melbourne on Sunday that is the only change so far. Richmond named an extended 25-man squad that will be culled to 22 on Friday night.
Four players were added to last week's team – midfielder Mark Coughlan, ruckman Adam Pattison, tall defender Silvester and running half-back Jordie McMahon.
"They've all shown good form at VFL level," Tigers football manager Ross Monaghan told richmondfc.com.au.
"They've all be there about for a number of weeks – Jarrod's probably the anomaly, where he went up and then went back for one."
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/80794/default.aspx
-
In: Pattison, Coughlan, Silvester, McMahon
Not the players to bring in to impress the fans Jade especially Jordie lol.
You got that right MT, JON would have tipped that list off quiet nicely.
-
It would be great to see Jacko put Harvey out of his misery early in the game.....AGAIN. :cheers
-
RICHMOND v NORTH MELBOURNE
Richmond
B: Jake King, Will Thursfield, Chris Newman
HB: Dean Polo, Luke McGuane, Matthew White
C: Trent Cotchin, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio
HF: Robin Nahas, Jack Riewoldt, Jayden Post
F: Tyrone Vickery, Mitch Morton, Ben Cousins
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Richard Tambling
I/C (from): Adam Pattison, Alex Rance, Jordan McMahon, Jarrod Silvester, Tom Hislop, Mark Coughlan, Shane Edwards
In: Pattison, Coughlan, Silvester, McMahon
Out: Kelvin Moore (calf)
North Melbourne
B: Brady Rawlings, Scott Thompson, Nathan Grima
HB: Scott McMahon, Josh Gibson, Michael Firrito
C: Levi Greenwood, Liam Anthony, Drew Petrie
HF: Leigh Harding, Lachie Hansen, Lindsay Thomas
F: Brent Harvey, David Hale, Corey Jones
Foll: Hamish McIntosh, Adam Simpson, Andrew Swallow
I/C (from): Daniel Harris, Sam Power, Leigh Adams, Ben Ross, Todd Goldstein, Aaron Edwards, Daniel Pratt
In: Ross, Goldstein, Edwards, Pratt
Out: Gavin Urquhart (groin)
:P
-
No probs OE.
Oh No; McMuppet/McLovin etc may be back in. Always topical when that happens.
Probably think Hislop/Edwards/McMahon will miss out but who knows.
Like some others here I am not sold on Cogs being done and gone, his inside work is very good.
lol
-
It would be great to see Jacko put Harvey out of his misery early in the game.....AGAIN. :cheers
The way harvey has been playing we want him in, hang on, we run players into form from the opposition dont we?
-
In: Pattison, Coughlan, Silvester, McMahon
Not the players to bring in to impress the fans Jade especially Jordie lol.
You got that right MT, JON would have tipped that list off quiet nicely.
We are tanking JON would have been a welcome addition and come to think of it so would Pettifer. For goodness sakes. How can we expect to win the rat race? What is Jade on? :rollin
Next week I guess.
-
In: Pattison, Coughlan, Silvester, McMahon
Not the players to bring in to impress the fans Jade especially Jordie lol.
You got that right MT, JON would have tipped that list off quiet nicely.
lol I don't think Jade the Blade is that cruel to supporters ;D
-
Cogs in for foley ?
Its a week too late .
-
Jade isn't on the selection committee...
-
LMAO at Thompson still not being able to get a game
How poo must this guy actually be.
Mclovin will get a game. Now thats a step in the right direction if ever ive seen one
Edit: swear filter avoidance
-
Jade isn't on the selection committee...
Surely as senior coach he must be? ???
-
From last weeks Footy Record page 45
RFC Match Committee: Jade Rawlings, Brian Royal, David King, Wayne Campbell, Gordon Casey, Ross Monaghan, Craig Cameron
-
Sylvestor and King on Jones and Harding please ;D
-
We are tanking JON would have been a welcome addition and come to think of it so would Pettifer. For goodness sakes. How can we expect to win the rat race? What is Jade on? :rollin
Next week I guess.
That's right Tucker, we are probably saving our "guns" in Petts and JON for the Melbourne, WC and Freo games. Cant have them injured when we will really need them to "perform".
-
That's right Tucker, we are probably saving our "guns" in Petts and JON for the Melbourne, WC and Freo games. Cant have them injured when we will really need them to "perform".
How funny if they brought them in for 'that' purpose and both starred kicking 10 between and being individually responsible for snatching victory from the jaws of defeat. Image OER if that happened! :rollin :lol
-
How also funny it is that Wallace was bagged for picking bad sides well people Jade has certainly trumped him here. Really athoer than Post and Vickery coming in which in my opinion would have happened anyway I can't see a lot thats changed, don't expect Jade to get the top job!
-
How funny if they brought them in for 'that' purpose and both starred kicking 10 between and being individually responsible for snatching victory from the jaws of defeat. Image OER if that happened! :rollin :lol
With JON as long as his rs points downwards there is no chance of that happening. With Petts well if he looks like he is getting a roll on put him CHB or FB and let him show the AFL world his defensive side.
Although you are right and it would be a good laugh if it happened
-
How also funny it is that Wallace was bagged for picking bad sides well people Jade has certainly trumped him here. Really athoer than Post and Vickery coming in which in my opinion would have happened anyway I can't see a lot thats changed, don't expect Jade to get the top job!
Who else should we be picking?? ??? ???
No one else warrants it.
If plough was still here we'd still have Petts, McMahon, an injured Brown and an injured Simmo all in the 22 while 4 kids would miss out.
The sides named since Wallace left are far better.
-
How also funny it is that Wallace was bagged for picking bad sides well people Jade has certainly trumped him here. Really athoer than Post and Vickery coming in which in my opinion would have happened anyway I can't see a lot thats changed, don't expect Jade to get the top job!
Who else should we be picking?? ??? ???
No one else warrants it.
If plough was still here we'd still have Petts, McMahon, an injured Brown and an injured Simmo all in the 22 while 4 kids would miss out.
The sides named since Wallace left are far better.
Agreed Wallace would still be picking sides that he felt would save his job and playing injured players to boot.
Jade in 4 matches has done heaps more than Wallace did for 11 matches. Some would argue for the previous four years of his tenure too.
-
In: Silvester
Out: Kelvin Moore (calf)
-
In: Silvester
Out: Kelvin Moore (calf)
Absolutely no surprise there
And no Jordie either :rollin
How also funny it is that Wallace was bagged for picking bad sides well people Jade has certainly trumped him here. Really athoer than Post and Vickery coming in which in my opinion would have happened anyway I can't see a lot thats changed, don't expect Jade to get the top job!
I would think by actually playing Vickery & Post as well putting a few players in decent positions (eg throwing Nahas in the midfield for patches) he has made some significant changes.
And IMHO if Wallace was still in the job I would doubt that Post or Vickery would have got a game and no way in hell would Nahas played inthe midfield
-
RICHMOND v NORTH MELBOURNE
Richmond
B: Jake King, Will Thursfield, Chris Newman
HB: Dean Polo, Luke McGuane, Matthew White
C: Trent Cotchin, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio
HF: Robin Nahas, Jack Riewoldt, Jayden Post
F: Tyrone Vickery, Mitch Morton, Ben Cousins
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Richard Tambling
I/C: Tom hislop, Alex Rance, Shane Edwards, Jarrod Silvester
Emg: Adam Pattison, Jordan McMahon, Mark Coughlan
In: Silvester
Out: Kelvin Moore (calf)
North Melbourne
B: Brady Rawlings, Scott Thompson, Nathan Grima
HB: Scott McMahon, Josh Gibson, Michael Firrito
C: Levi Greenwood, Liam Anthony, Drew Petrie
HF: Leigh Harding, Lachie Hansen, Lindsay Thomas
F: Brent Harvey, David Hale, Corey Jones
Foll: Hamish McIntosh, Adam Simpson, Andrew Swallow
I/C: Sam Power, Leigh Adams, Todd Goldstein, Daniel Pratt
Emg: Daniel Harris, Ben Ross Aaron Edwards
In: Goldstein, Pratt
Out: Gavin Urquhart (groin), Daniel Harris
-
Well good luck with this side, does Edwards have a photo of Rawlings with a goat or something?? Why he is still in the side is beyond me, sureley Cogs with the bigger body would have to come in for him???
-
In: Silvester
Out: Kelvin Moore (calf)
Absolutely no surprise there
And no Jordie either :rollin
How also funny it is that Wallace was bagged for picking bad sides well people Jade has certainly trumped him here. Really athoer than Post and Vickery coming in which in my opinion would have happened anyway I can't see a lot thats changed, don't expect Jade to get the top job!
I would think by actually playing Vickery & Post as well putting a few players in decent positions (eg throwing Nahas in the midfield for patches) he has made some significant changes.
And IMHO if Wallace was still in the job I would doubt that Post or Vickery would have got a game and no way in hell would Nahas played inthe midfield
Also Silvester would not have got a gig- right or not at least the RFC will know one way or another if he is worth a spot on the list next year. It sure beats hanging onto players just for the sake of it. Jade has been teriffic so far in picking our side. :clapping
-
Well good luck with this side, does Edwards have a photo of Rawlings with a goat or something?? Why he is still in the side is beyond me, sureley Cogs with the bigger body would have to come in for him???
Is that more a statement by the Club about Cogs' future than Edwards?!
No surprise by the only change. It seems you only get a game now if you're 23 or under.
-
Well good luck with this side, does Edwards have a photo of Rawlings with a goat or something?? Why he is still in the side is beyond me, sureley Cogs with the bigger body would have to come in for him???
Or maybe you just have something against Edwards? :shh
I watched the Carlton game again today and was left with no doubt that Edwards deserved to hold his spot. He won't learn anything more in the VFL. Let him get more experience.
-
Well good luck with this side, does Edwards have a photo of Rawlings with a goat or something?? Why he is still in the side is beyond me, sureley Cogs with the bigger body would have to come in for him???
Or maybe you just have something against Edwards? :shh
I watched the Carlton game again today and was left with no doubt that Edwards deserved to hold his spot. He won't learn anything more in the VFL. Let him get more experience.
I agree, it seemed that he was instructed to move the move the ball forward at all costs and seemed to play better for it.
-
Cuz out
Cogs in
According to Anduril on Y&B
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=262479&postcount=152
-
Cuz out
Cogs in
According to Anduril on Y&B
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=262479&postcount=152
Why? How? Thats not fair! I not believe! Maybe they are holding Cogs back for someone else? Whats his source?
-
Does that mean the tank is on?
Bucks may make a decision on his coaching future on this game depending on who wins or loses.
-
Cuz out
Cogs in
According to Anduril on Y&B
http://www.yellowandblack.com.au/forum/showpost.php?p=262479&postcount=152
Why? How? Thats not fair! I not believe! Maybe they are holding Cogs back for someone else? Whats his source?
Don't know GR. Just passing on what was posted. Muscles said Cuz didn't do much today at training and he didn't fully train on Thursday.
-
Ive had a look on the other forums and there is no mention of it yet!
-
Didn't see Cogs at training this morning. But neither Cuz nor Cotch joined in training out on the ground. Jordie was out there.
-
Cuz has the flu I think, was crook last week too and probably shouldn't have played.
-
OK that maybe answered my ? :thumbsup
I was coming down with what seemed like a really nasty one just 48 hours ago - still worked the nights slept heaps and it seems to of just dissapeared.
I have a pig tail tho ???
-
Cuz has the flu I think, was crook last week too and probably shouldn't have played.
Yep, he had cold & flu symptoms against Carlton and then missed his radio segment on Nova Monday morning as he was crook
Not surprised that he missed and I think I even called it in my team changes for the week
-
If he has what I had ...you start off thinking OK I have a cold but I can keep going. Then all of a sudden after a day or 2 'bang' you hit the wall.
-
So if Cuz is out it will mean that all our 30+ players will be sitting in the stands(or in bed with the flu)
I dont think Victory will be that meaningless
-
what is the team?
were there some players that played today that are playing tomorrow?
-
Whats his source?
What's HER source GR12, what's her source. ;)
Andy sees almost every RFC and Coburg match and has some good sources. She doesn't say things without good reason. You can normally trust her info.
-
If Cuz has the lurgy then why have him down at training so he can pass it onto everyone else :P.
-
Whats his source?
What's HER source GR12, what's her source. ;)
Andy sees almost every RFC and Coburg match and has some good sources. She doesn't say things without good reason. You can normally trust her info.
Thanks for the heads up up RROFO :thumbsup, potentially dangerous situation that :-[
-
Foley, Cuz out and Cotch no guarantee of playing either if he didn't train today plus Jacko feeling his calf. Our midfield is looking pretty thin is they all miss :-\. If Jordie comes in for Cotch we are definitely tanking lol.
-
Does that mean the tank is on?
Bucks may make a decision on his coaching future on this game depending on who wins or loses.
if bucks makes a decision from the result of a pointless game then he's a knob and i dun want him as coach
-
Foley, Cuz out and Cotch no guarantee of playing either if he didn't train today plus Jacko feeling his calf. Our midfield is looking pretty thin is they all miss :-\. If Jordie comes in for Cotch we are definitely tanking lol.
if we have to tank, so be it. i can tolerate it.
-
if we have to tank, so be it. i can tolerate it.
Well it definitely helps on the tanking front but we don't want to be thrashed on the scoreboard either. Yes I'm being fussy ;D.
-
Does that mean the tank is on?
Bucks may make a decision on his coaching future on this game depending on who wins or loses.
if bucks makes a decision from the result of a pointless game then he's a knob and i dun want him as coach
I was referring to the fact that he has already made comments about both teams lists and perhaps if he were to lose and tank the rest of the year it would mean a few more draft picks of young players. Given his work with the U16's and the fact that our young list he sees as more advanced than Norths as well as possibly an inside knowledge to these kids he may choose us over North on those grounds.
-
Foley, Cuz out and Cotch no guarantee of playing either if he didn't train today plus Jacko feeling his calf. Our midfield is looking pretty thin is they all miss :-\. If Jordie comes in for Cotch we are definitely tanking lol.
we are not tanking. our players are sick. you need to show some consideration for the shocking plight of our players health, especially if this lurgy is still around when we are playing Melbourne. Im very disappointed in you MT. I expected better from you ;D :lol
-
RICHMOND v NORTH MELBOURNE
Richmond
B: Jake King, Will Thursfield, Chris Newman
HB: Dean Polo, Luke McGuane, Shane Edwards
C: Jarrod Silvester, Shane Tuck, Brett Deledio
HF: Robin Nahas, Jack Riewoldt, Jayden Post
F: Tyrone Vickery, Mitch Morton, Tom Hislop,
Foll: Angus Graham, Daniel Jackson, Richard Tambling
I/C: Alex Rance, Jordan McMahon, Mark Coughlan, Matthew White
Changes to the selected side
In: Jordan McMahon, Mark Coughlan
Out: Ben Cousins, Trent Cotchin
-
hahahahaha
another meaningless win for the RFC...yay yay we beat NORTH yay
effin usless idiots NFI
-
hahahahaha
another meaningless win for the RFC...yay yay we beat NORTH yay
effin usless idiots NFI
And yet if we were losing you would still be calling them "effin usless idiots NFI" so its irrelevant what you say.
-
hahahahaha
another meaningless win for the RFC...yay yay we beat NORTH yay
effin usless idiots NFI
Have you been drinking daniel?
-
hahahahaha
another meaningless win for the RFC...yay yay we beat NORTH yay
effin usless idiots NFI
Have you been drinking daniel?
actually i have had a few
its just on 7am here in Germany pal and im listening to the game live on the net.
-
Germany? Im off to sweden for 6 months in a few weeks
-
Rexy is already singing.
-
And the winner of todays game is .... drumroll .....
North Melbourne.
Another idiotic, useless win, that will cost us a star player at the end of the year. But thats alright, those who are against tanking - well i imagine there happy at the moment. Theyll talk about a "winning culture"
North, WCE, Freo and Melb will all get a fantastic player, a couple of these will get 2 ... we will get Jack Schizen because we want a winning culture.
Come talk to us in 10 years when we will have only won 1 flag in 40 years and made the finals only twice.
-
hahahahaha
another meaningless win for the RFC...yay yay we beat NORTH yay
effin usless idiots NFI
And yet if we were losing you would still be calling them "effin usless idiots NFI" so its irrelevant what you say.
look back at my posts the past 2 weeks when we just lost and then come back to me.
Edit: enough with the swearing >:(
-
And the winner of todays game is .... drumroll .....
North Melbourne.
Another idiotic, useless win, that will cost us a star player at the end of the year. But thats alright, those who are against tanking - well i imagine there happy at the moment. Theyll talk about a "winning culture"
North, WCE, Freo and Melb will all get a fantastic player, a couple of these will get 2 ... we will get Jack Schizen because we want a winning culture.
Come talk to us in 10 years when we will have only won 1 flag in 40 years and made the finals only twice.
We are a shambolic football club. We really are.
Some supporters Ramps just have NFi when it comes to this club.
For the first time we have the chance to right so many wrongs but no doubt we will screw this draft up yet again with another mid table finish.
These same supporters jumped for joy when we beat the HAWKS last year..
hahahahaha what a joke we r
-
It is an indictment to most memebrs and most supporters that we are winning a meaningless game of footy today. Other wins in subsequent weeks against Melbourne Sydney and West Coast will only highlight how far behind we are as a club and how much substance we have when we need to take the next step.
From pick 1 to pick 8 with 5 wins for the year. :banghead
-
you might get your wish boys!
-
You two must be aroused barracking for North right now.
-
there is still hope that we will get our very early pick and that would be a fantastic result indeed. there is no point in beating a club like North, they are in worse shape than us on the field.
-
You two must be aroused barracking for North right now.
I hope you are not putting me in the tanking crew, TA!
-
No GR12, not you.
I can't stand us seeing play this crap and I can't see how any supporter can.
-
Two points are better than 4. :rollin
We can still finish below Melbourne and Fremantle. :thumbsup
Got North over the four wins.
-
Not sure if want...
-
Two points are better than 4. :rollin
We can still finish below Melbourne and Fremantle. :thumbsup
Got North over the four wins.
spot on mate
great result :thumbsup
-
Two points are better than 4. :rollin
We can still finish below Melbourne and Fremantle. :thumbsup
Got North over the four wins.
spot on mate
great result :thumbsup
losing would have been better but atleast we didnt win.
So is 16 1//2 points the maximum you can get when you get a priority or do you lose it at 16 1/2.
-
I think you're confusing the 'half' with a draw, Ramps. If we won 1 more, we'd be on 18. Therefore, we wouldn't be eligible for a draft pick.
-
yep ... so a draw was as bad as a win today. pretty senseless result i reckon. we have no room to manouvre with melbourne west coast etc.
-
No GR12, not you.
I can't stand us seeing play this crap and I can't see how any supporter can.
Here here TA. McUseless and turnoverKING should never play in the Tiger Jumper again. Gus has to go back to the two's (got nothin) If we were serious about winning JB and Browny would be straight in to the side. Oh and well done Umpies well played NOTTTTT!!!!!
-
Two points are better than 4. :rollin
We can still finish below Melbourne and Fremantle. :thumbsup
Got North over the four wins.
spot on mate
great result :thumbsup
losing would have been better but atleast we didnt win.
So is 16 1//2 points the maximum you can get when you get a priority or do you lose it at 16 1/2.
I think Melbourne can still win 5 games and get a priority pick ahead of us regardless of even if we finish on the bottom. This is so as they won 3 games last year and they do not exceed 8 wins over two years. Much like the Carlton scenarion in 2007.
-
Huh? If Melbourne win 2 more games, they lose their priority pick. It's not counted over 2 years. You have to have 4 or fewer wins each year to get the priority pick before the first round.
-
Okay Danog. As I wrote "I think" in my post. Was not 100% sure. :thumbsup
-
Bucks will stick with the Pies after watching that. Talk about showing your best and worst in the space of 120 minutes :-X.
Today looked like young bodies running out of puff after half-time. First half our pressure was terrific even though we were making mistakes and not getting full return on the scoreboard for our total dominance. After half-time we just stopped running and struggled to get the ball out of our backline from kick-ins and our delivery inside forward 50 was awful.
Actually today's game reminded me of Richmond vs Hawthorn towards the end of 2005 but with the roles reversed today. We came from 7 goals down at half-time in that game to pinch it and Hawthorn kept hold of their priority pick.
As for umps - they deserve their own thread after today ::).
-
Whoever is responsible for our match fitness needs to be looked at very very closely. We have been woefully underdone in most games this year, getting run down in the 2nd half with monotonous regularity. It has happened too often now to be a coincidence.
-
Agree smoke, goes back to the reason why we were so unprepared for Round 1. Horrible Pre Season mentally and physically.
The one thing the coach can 100% control is training/pre season and preperation.
Thanks Terry.
-
Yep we've played no more than 2 quarters per game all year. We either start well then fall away badly or we start slowly and then try to play catch up. I'm guessing the fitness and conditioning at the club will have been heavily reviewed in this review of the footy department.
-
Given the amount of kids in the side, I'm hardly surprised that they ran out of legs
It's effectively our VFL side from Round 1 who is now playing as the Richmond seniors
-
Given the amount of kids in the side, I'm hardly surprised that they ran out of legs
It's effectively our VFL side from Round 1 who is now playing as the Richmond seniors
And that should appease all the pro-tankers because I can't see us growing any stronger or fitter in the last few weeks - even if we are trying our hardest to win!