One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 05, 2009, 03:16:47 PM
-
VFL Round 17
Coburg Tigers (10th, 6-9) vs Bendigo Bombers (14th, 0-14)
Saturday 8th August @ ABD Stadium
Ressies: 11:10 AM
Seniors: 2:00 PM
nb. No broadcast this weekend to my knowledge.
-
Surely we'll win this one.
-
Surely we'll win this one.
After losing 6 of the last 7 don't hold your breath :-\
-
Coburg Tigers senior squad
B: Polak Rance Thomson
HB: Caruso Bowden Raines
C: White Coughlan Carrick
HF: Clarke Pattison Brown
F: Carnell Schulz Graham
R: Simmonds Tuck A. Horne
Int (from): Allan, Morris, Clifton, Hughes, J. Hislop, Gilligan, Liddle, Cattapan, Thompson*, Putt, Oakley-Nicholls, Browne, Rayson
-
Coburg ressies squad
B: Considine Morgan Houli
HB: McQuilken Keogh Groves
C: Wood Ambrose Jordon
HF: Bassi Oakley-Nicholls Abdallah
F: Gilligan Hughes Browne
R: Putt Cattapan Kandilakis
Int: Smith, Temel, Koroneos, Lawton, De Cesare, J. Horne, J. Hislop, Corry, Kellett, Meroli, Fulton, Bramich
-
Coburg Tigers senior squad
B: Polak Thomson
HB: Caruso Bowden Raines
C: Coughlan Carrick
HF: Clarke Pattison
F: Carnell Schulz
R: Simmonds Tuck A. Horne
Int (from): Allan, Morris, Clifton, Hughes, Gilligan, Liddle, Thompson*, Putt, Oakley-Nicholls, Browne, Rayson
Looks like Putt and JON to miss out on the final 23 and play ressies.
-
WP said Cleve and Browne played in the ressies
-
Quarter time
Coburg 4.2-26
Bendigo 5.3-33
-
Thanks to WP again
Clarke has 2 goals.
Tucky has been good.
-
2nd qtr underway
Coburg 5.2-32
Bendigo 6.3-39
Goal to Gilligan :thumbsup
Polak been very good at CHB
-
Coburg now up by 4
15 mins Q2
Thanks to WP :)
-
Keep em comin and thanks ....
-
Half-time
Coburg 4.2 9.3-57
Bendigo 5.3 9.5-59
Clarke has 3 goals
WP said Polak has been very good
Tuck and Bowden good also
-
A bit more from WP at the ground.....
Thomson not playing.
Cogs average. Too slow.
Gilligan okay. Physically not strong enough.
-
Any reason for Thomson not playing? Late change for the Tigers?
-
Bendigo are winless for the year and we're trailing them :P.
WP said Cleve and Browne played in the ressies
No surprise but surely thay means we've given up on Cleve and he's gone.
Cogs gone too sadly. His body is stuffed.
-
Any reason for Thomson not playing? Late change for the Tigers?
Thomson wasn't listed as an emergency. Polly, Tucky and Patto all playing at Coburg as far as I know. I'll ask WP to be sure.
-
WP said no idea about why Thomo isn't playing.
Bendigo up by 5 points. 17 min Q3
-
Any reason for Thomson not playing? Late change for the Tigers?
Thomson wasn't listed as an emergency. Polly, Tucky and Patto all playing at Coburg as far as I know. I'll ask WP to be sure.
I remember Geelong changing around the emergencies a few weeks ago when Ablett and Stevie J were late outs.
-
Thomson's been carrying an odd sternum injury all year. Just a guess but maybe they have told him to forget about the rest of 2009.
WP on the game - "The way they're going at the moment they won't win today" :P
-
Simmo kicks a goal. Coburg up by 1 point.
-
LOL they must have heard WP.
Patto goal. Coburg by 8.
-
JON kicks a goal on the siren
3/4 time
Coburg 4.2 9.3 14.5-89
Bendigo 5.3 9.5 11.9-75
-
WP - "Yep amazing what happens when Cogs, Raines and Simmo start playing team footy"
-
WP hasn't seen Polak on the ground since half-time. Not sure why.
Coburg gets the first goal of the last quarter. 20 points up.
-
10 mins Q4
Coburg up by 31. Last 6 goals kicked by Coburg.
-
what was the ressies score?
and anyone know how conners and schulz are going. havnt had a game in ages.
-
25 mins Q4
Cob 20.6-126
Ben 11.11-77
Running all over them in the last qtr.
-
what was the ressies score?
Don't know. There's no coverage or scores on the VFL site.
and anyone know how conners and schulz are going. havnt had a game in ages.
Connors is injured (hammy) and hasn't played the last two weeks IIRC.
WP hasn't noticed Schulz at all out there.
-
Final Score
Coburg 4.2 9.3 14.5 21.6-132
Bendigo 5.3 9.5 11.9 13.11-89
:gotigers
-
WP hasn't seen Polak on the ground since half-time. Not sure why.
Coburg gets the first goal of the last quarter. 20 points up.
may very well be the emergency for tomorrows big game :shh
-
Final Score
Coburg 4.2 9.3 14.5 21.6-132
Bendigo 5.3 9.5 11.9 13.11-89
:gotigers
WP bests: Tuck, Bowden, Clarke and add in the 2nd half - Simmo, Raines
Thanks again to WP for the updates :cheers :bow :clapping
-
Polly has a leg injury which is why he went off. An ankle or knee :(
-
Bowden played well again keeping his good form going for his new club 2010
-
Was worried during the first 3 quarters that this would be another embarrassing loss but good on the Burgers to kick away and win easily. Finals chances remain alive ... just.
Polly has a leg injury which is why he went off. An ankle or knee :(
Poor Polly. Just when he was on the cusp on playing AFL footy. Hopefully the injury isn't too serious and he can still make his AFL comeback dream come true before the season ends.
-
was at the Casey vs Ballarat game, spoke to Disco watching his son Tom what a hack he sat mostly on the bench ;D
glad we delisted him ;D
-
2009 VFL Seniors
Coburg Tigers 4.2 9.3 14.5 21.6 (132)
Bendigo Bombers 5.3 9.5 11.9 13.11 (89)
GOALS:
Coburg Tigers: Hislop 5 Clarke 4 Pattison 2 Simmonds 2 GILLIGAN 2 Liddle Raines Allan Tuck Horne Oakley-Nicholls
Bendigo Bombers: Daniher 5 Delahunty 2 Holmes Jetta Magin Scanlon Stroobants Hulme
BEST:
Coburg Tigers: Clarke Simmonds Liddle Bowden Pattison Coughlan
Bendigo Bombers: Slattery Daniher Crameri Scanlon Jetta Magin
2009 VFL Reserves
Coburg Tigers 4.5 9.10 15.11 21.20 (146)
Bendigo Bombers 5.2 6.4 7.6 11.8 (74)
GOALS:
Coburg Tigers: Temel 5 Abdallah 4 Hughes 3 Meroli 2 Smith 2 Bassi Horne Kandilakis Ambrose Wood
Bendigo Bombers: Taylor 2 Bowe 2 Hackett 2 Messis Tamaroudis Harrison Crameri Byrne
BEST:
Coburg Tigers: Cattapan Browne Temel Keogh Abdallah Wood
Bendigo Bombers: Harrison Mason Richards Messis Crameri Stringer
https://reg.sportingpulse.com/olr_v3/rpt_progressive.cgi?aID=8&pg=1&a=MR_
-
Hislops brother doing well in the Coburg seniors, eh?
-
I went to Coburg today. Just a few observations:
-Believe it or not JON played a blinder. Feeding temmates all day, running to support, 2nd and 3rd efforts, looked clean and composed. Even did a beautiful
blind turn and spin out of the pack.
-Even more unbelievably, Patto's skills were very clean today. He took some strong overhead marks, and even did a one-handed gather of a bouncing ball, spun, turned his opponent inside-out, and ran into an open goal and converted. P.S. I was not hallucinating.
-Simmonds was very useful, marked strongly across half-forward all day.
-Schulz started back, but was moved forward. Didn't really have much impact on the game.
-Despite the good reports on Raines, I thought he had a poor game. Continues to try and take on the whole team for some reason, and just runs himself into trouble. One stuff-up pass in the forward line that should have resulted in a certain goal for us was intercepted and run the length of the field for a Bendigo goal.
-Hislop's brother had a day out kicking 5 goals I believe, four of them in the last qtr.
-My mate had a very interesting conversation with Shane Tuck's mother. Apparently his demotion is down to Wayne Campbell, who doesn't rate him. She thinks Jade Rawlings is too much of a "yes" man to the committee, and would like to see Hardwick get the job, who she considers a straight shooter.
-
Cheers for the report RR :cheers
In fairness to Jade, as caretaker he would be answerable to match committee in them wanting to have a look at everyone on the list. Craig Cameron was in the box last week next to him and they were hardly overjoyed after Jordie kicked the winning goal lol. As far as Cambo not rating Tucky I can understand that. Tucky wins a lot of footy but doesn't really hurt the opposition with it so the opposition never tag him. In McRae's EOTT report he said they were a lot happier with Tucky getting 26 possies but being more constructive with it rather than racking up a massive 40 so-so disposals.
How did you think Gilly and Putty went today?
-
temel from the calder cannons playing for coburg reserves on the TAC cup's bye week. looks like he did well with 5 goals too. big strapping forward. we may look at him later in the draft i imagine.
-
Hi MT.
When Tucky was dropped, I assumed it was because he's neither quick, nor a damaging kick (40% efficiency rate the week he was demoted.) But apparently the gripe on him was for a lack of accountability,which surprised me.
His mum said that Frawley told him he didn't rate him either, which is no surprise. But she said at least he got a big tick off her for telling him to his face.The implication seemed to be that Campbo is a bit more duplicitous. Apparently he sent Tucky a text message on the week of his demotion wishing him luck.
She said Travis seems to be in a similar position at Hawthorn atm, because Clarko is currently favouring a lot of outside running players over "at the coalface" types.
Putt showed a bit.Took some good marks through the middle without setting the world on fire. Gilligan was getting to the fall of the ball, and didn't have any brain fades like the dying minute of last weeks game where he kicked straight to the unmarked Box Hill ruckman, instead of icing the clock.
-
temel from the calder cannons playing for coburg reserves on the TAC cup's bye week. looks like he did well with 5 goals too. big strapping forward. we may look at him later in the draft i imagine.
Bomber fans mentioned Temel too on BB so we're not the only Club who has noticed him.
-
Hi MT.
When Tucky was dropped, I assumed it was because he's neither quick, nor a damaging kick (40% efficiency rate the week he was demoted.) But apparently the gripe on him was for a lack of accountability,which surprised me.
His mum said that Frawley told him he didn't rate him either, which is no surprise. But she said at least he got a big tick off her for telling him to his face.The implication seemed to be that Campbo is a bit more duplicitous. Apparently he sent Tucky a text message on the week of his demotion wishing him luck.
She said Travis seems to be in a similar position at Hawthorn atm, because Clarko is currently favouring a lot of outside running players over "at the coalface" types.
Putt showed a bit.Took some good marks through the middle without setting the world on fire. Gilligan was getting to the fall of the ball, and didn't have any brain fades like the dying minute of last weeks game where he kicked straight to the unmarked Box Hill ruckman, instead of icing the clock.
Cheers RR. I think Tucky's lack of accountability at times is more due to him not being overtly quick. Match him up on a quicker mid at stoppages or centre bounces and he can get left behind at times. Tucky's more a resilient workhorse like his dad rather than a gamebreaker. We could probably carry him off the bench if our midfield depth was 10-12 deep and he was used as a 2nd/3rd tier midfielder while an A-grader midfielder rested. However for us he plays as a first tierer and lacks the class to be leading a midfield. At almost 28 year olds (in december) he's unlikely to be around or at least near his peak when our current young list matures.
In fairness to the current coaches we've seen 5 years of Tucky playing AFL so we know what he can and can't do. Spud on the other hand just refused to play him at all as a younger 22 year old despite us being last on the ladder and getting flogged most weeks with older mids while Tucky was a standout at Coburg. The only reason Tucky survived was due to Wallace seeing him training in the gym when he arrived and Fleming was the last one flicked instead.
-
I went to Coburg today. Just a few observations:
-Believe it or not JON played a blinder. Feeding temmates all day, running to support, 2nd and 3rd efforts, looked clean and composed. Even did a beautiful
blind turn and spin out of the pack.
-Even more unbelievably, Patto's skills were very clean today. He took some strong overhead marks, and even did a one-handed gather of a bouncing ball, spun, turned his opponent inside-out, and ran into an open goal and converted. P.S. I was not hallucinating.
-Simmonds was very useful, marked strongly across half-forward all day.
-Schulz started back, but was moved forward. Didn't really have much impact on the game.
-Despite the good reports on Raines, I thought he had a poor game. Continues to try and take on the whole team for some reason, and just runs himself into trouble. One stuff-up pass in the forward line that should have resulted in a certain goal for us was intercepted and run the length of the field for a Bendigo goal.
-Hislop's brother had a day out kicking 5 goals I believe, four of them in the last qtr.
Have to say I agree with that report! :clapping
-
I agree about Raines but will say his 2nd half was much better than his first which was terrible/selfish
I thought JON was OK compared to his last few weeks
Putt played alot down back and I must say it was close to the best game I've seen him play at VFL senior level
Hislop's brother - not as angry as Tommy ;D
-
I agree about Raines but will say his 2nd half was much better than his first which was terrible/selfish
I thought JON was OK compared to his last few weeks
Putt played alot down back and I must say it was close to the best game I've seen him play at VFL senior level
Hislop's brother - not as angry as Tommy ;D
what was highlight of Putts game, did he take any contested marks?
-
what was highlight of Putts game, did he take any contested marks?
Yeah he took a couple of contersted marks but the most pleasing thing was he actually was up with the tempo of the game which is something he has really struggled with
And before anyone asks ...NO I wouldn't give him a senior gig
-
Round 17 Match Report
coburgtigers.com.au
By Glenn Robertson
COBURG TIGERS v BENDIGO BOMBERS
ABD GROUP STADIUM
SATURDAY 8th AUGUST
With three games remaining in the 2009 season Coburg need to win at least two to make the finals. This week they were up against the winless Bendigo Bombers at ABD Group Stadium and were clear favourites to take the four points. A fairly sizeable crowd turned up to watch the home side overturn a two point halftime deficit to run away with a relatively easy victory.
In an entertaining first term both sides played attacking football, this was illustrated on the scoreboard with nine goals kicked for the term. Neither side could get the break on each other with the Bombers ending the term seven points ahead. Troy Simmons was instrumental in the ruck giving the Burger on-ballers first use of the ball all day and as a bonus he also slotted through two majors. Adam Pattison gave him great support in the ruck and finished with two goals also.
Coburg Tigers 4.2 (26) Bendigo Bombers 5.3 (33)
Coburg started the second term with two quick goals, but the Bombers replied with a couple of their own. The experienced players in Joel Bowden and Mark Coughlan won plenty of the ball through the middle of the ground and also worked back hard to help out their defence. Coburg played solid football for the term but couldn’t break open any type of lead, trailing by two points at half time.
Coburg Tigers 9.3 (57) Bendigo Bombers 9.5 (59)
After an even first half the Burgers were revved up at the main break by coach Craig McRae and the boys new if they wanted to have any chance of playing finals this year their work rate had to lift in the second half. And that’s exactly what happened.
Tim Clarke was once again outstanding for the Tigers. He dominated the stoppages and pin pointed his leading forwards. Clarke also booted through a season high four goals in a clear best on ground display. The Burgers kept the Bombers to just two majors for the term and booted through five themselves to take a fifteen point margin into the final change.
Coburg Tigers 14.5 (89) Bendigo Bombers 11.9 (75)
The flood gates opened in the final term as Coburg piled on seven goals for the quarter. Jacob Hislop made a brilliant debut for the Burger seniors and had his kicking boots on up forward finishing with a match high five majors. In the end the Burgers had too many options up forward and finished up winners by forty three points. A highlight to the Burgers win was their accuracy at goal as they kicked over twenty goals and only registered six behinds. Nic Liddle continued on his extremely consistent season and was again a pivotal member of the Burgers victory. Coburg’s next ‘must win’ game is on Sunday against the Werribee Tigers at Chirnside Park starting at 2pm, with the reserves at 11.10am.
Coburg Tigers 4.2 9.3 14.5 21.6 (132)
Bendigo Bombers 5.3 9.5 11.9 13.11 (89)
Goal Kickers: J. Hislop 5, T. Clarke 4, A. Pattison 2, T. Simmonds 2, A. Gilligan 2, R. Allan, S. Tuck, A. Horne, A. Raines, J. Oakley-Nicholls, N. Liddle
Best Players: T. Clarke, T. Simmonds, N. Liddle, J. Bowden, A. Pattison, M. Coughlan
RESERVES
The Burger reserves recorded their tenth win of the season defeating the Bendigo Bombers by a whopping seventy two points. After a slow start the Burgers stormed home in the second half, similar to the seniors. Youngster Nic Cattapan and Andrew Browne were best for the Burgers, while Tamer Abdallah and Serhat Temel both played great games sharing nine goals between them. The Burgers are a game clear in third spot on the ladder.
Coburg Tigers 4.5 9.10 15.11 21.20 (146)
Bendigo Bombers 5.2 6.4 7.6 11.8 (74)
Goal Kickers: S. Temel 5, T. Abdallah 4, C. Hughes 3, A. Meroli 2, C. Smith 2, J. Bassi, J. Kandilakis, M. Ambrose, J. Horne, N. Wood
Best Players: N. Cattapan, A. Browne, S. Temel, J. Keogh, T. Abdallah, N. Wood
http://www.sportingpulse.com/club_info.cgi?client=1-118-10471-0-0&sID=56260&&news_task=DETAIL&articleID=9712343§ionID=56260