One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 29, 2010, 05:01:55 PM
-
Richmond
B: Chris Newman, Luke McGuane, Will Thursfield
HB: Brett Deledio, Kelvin Moore, Daniel Connors
C: Mitch Morton, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Ben Nason, Andrew Collins, Jake King
F: Matt White, Jack Riewoldt, David Astbury
Foll: Angus Graham, Shane Tuck, Daniel Jackson
I/C (from): Ben Cousins, Andrew Browne, Mitch Farmer, Jeromey Webberley, Alex Rance, Robbie Hicks, Troy Taylor
In: Moore, White, Jackson, Thursfield, Taylor, Hicks
Out: Dean Polo, Robin Nahas, Jayden Post
New: Robbie Hicks (Calder Cannons/Rookie list)
-
some good ins there, would like to see taylor playing and rance should keep his spot
-
At least 4 changes as Moore, Thursty, Jacko and Whitey are straight into the starting 18.
With two tall backmen coming in will Rance keep his spot?
-
like the ins. Would like it if either taylor or hicks played
-
At least 4 changes as Moore, Thursty, Jacko and Whitey are straight into the starting 18.
With two tall backmen coming in will Rance keep his spot?
He should but so should Webberley
-
lets hope Nahas never plays seniors again. I would say Farmer will be out on form. Dimma has seen the light i think.
Good ins lets see what you got Taylor and good to see Tambling not in again.
One good game at Coburg aint going to win a downhill skier an immediate recall.
-
Here's the Adelaide side.....
B: Michael Doughty, Ben Rutten, Scott Stevens
HB: Brent Reilly, Nathan Bock, Nathan van Berlo
C: Rory Sloane, Scott Thompson, David Mackay
HF: Ricky Henderson, Taylor Walker, Matthew Jaensch
F: Jason Porplyzia, Kurt Tippett, Richard Douglas
Foll: Ivan Maric, Bernie Vince, Patrick Dangerfield
I/C (from): Tony Armstrong, Phil Davis, Jonathon Griffin, Jack Gunston, Chris Schmidt, James Sellar, Brad Symes
In: Sellar, Schmidt, Davis, Gunston
Out: Graham Johncock (suspension)
-
Nahas will be very lucky if his contract saves him. His deficiencies (too small) have been exposed this year.
At least 4 changes as Moore, Thursty, Jacko and Whitey are straight into the starting 18.
With two tall backmen coming in will Rance keep his spot?
He should but so should Webberley
I agree Suffered. That would then leave Farmer to be dropped.
-
Nahas will be very lucky if his contract saves him. His deficiencies (too small) have been exposed this year.
At least 4 changes as Moore, Thursty, Jacko and Whitey are straight into the starting 18.
With two tall backmen coming in will Rance keep his spot?
He should but so should Webberley
I agree Suffered. That would then leave Farmer to be dropped.
Nahas falls over too much.
rance dispite the possesions of last week could be out
-
then aagin they might drop webberley
-
then aagin they might drop webberley
They might Jack but I would be very disappointed if they did. I reckon he is a real keeper - shows plenty already and has the potential/scope to improve a fair bit next season.
-
then aagin they might drop webberley
A bit stiff if he is. I didn't think his first half was too bad. He ent missing in the 2nd half but hey there were plenty of his teammates who didn't show up at all.
I can only see Rance getting dropped due to team balance with both Moore and Thursty back in defence.
I agree about Nahas. Too easily falls over when there's a contest (lacks size). A cardinal sin in footy.
-
Who plays on Tippett? He's a fair bit taller than any of our three 'talls'
-
then aagin they might drop webberley
A bit stiff if he is. I didn't think his first half was too bad. He ent missing in the 2nd half but hey there were plenty of his teammates who didn't show up at all.
I can only see Rance getting dropped due to team balance with both Moore and Thursty back in defence.
I agree about Nahas. Too easily falls over when there's a contest (lacks size). A cardinal sin in footy.
Rance got really cheap possesions last week, A certain poster will disagree on this, but he has to go.
I cant see who else they can drop
-
Good Outs, Ins it doesnt matter, what counts is that Hardwick has worked out who cant play and we are being given hints almost weekly now. Hardwick will get rid of alot again at years end, and thats how it should be. DUDS=OUT!
-
Ramps, it isnt too hard to work out who cant play,
-
not sure that half forward line is going to win flags!
-
why drop Post after one match?
drop Edwards and Farmer for Taylor and Hicks.
give Rance another match.
Tambling should be a midfielder, leave him at Coburg untill Round 20.
like Morton's match against Collingwood as that skillful, strong marking, attacking wingman.
-
good to see Troy Taylor & Wiliam Thursfeild
Hicks is small but i dont think you lose much changig im wth nahas
-
why drop Post after one match?
drop Edwards and Farmer for Taylor and Hicks.
give Rance another match.
Tambling should be a midfielder, leave him at Coburg untill Round 20.
like Morton's match against Collingwood as that skillful, strong marking, attacking wingman.
Will say this
I never seen a worse performance from an AFL player last week what Post produced.
Rance was on the end of so many uncontested possesions last week it wasnt even funny
Agree with Morton, but he needs to back up again this week.
Edwards was one of the reasons we have been competitive over the past 8 weeks.
As for Hicks, the horse races are at Caulfield this weeknd. :banghead
-
The only reason I can see Hicks coming in is if he is a direct swap for Nahas as a small forward. That would mean five changes though which is a lot and it affects the stability of the side as everyone will need to re-adjust to all the changes in personnel. It would be back to the first 6 rounds of the season where we also had many changes to the side each and every week trying to find a combo that works.
-
Adelaide has recalled rookie Chris Schmidt and first-year player Jack Gunston for the match at the MCG. Schmidt will replace the suspended Graham Johncock, while Gunston comes in at the expense of Tony Armstrong, who has been omitted. Rising Star Phil Davis misses out again.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/99340/default.aspx
-
why drop Post after one match?
drop Edwards and Farmer for Taylor and Hicks.
give Rance another match.
Tambling should be a midfielder, leave him at Coburg untill Round 20.
like Morton's match against Collingwood as that skillful, strong marking, attacking wingman.
Will say this
I never seen a worse performance from an AFL player last week what Post produced.
Rance was on the end of so many uncontested possesions last week it wasnt even funny
Agree with Morton, but he needs to back up again this week.
Edwards was one of the reasons we have been competitive over the past 8 weeks.
As for Hicks, the horse races are at Caulfield this weeknd. :banghead
So he ran hard to make space. Sounds like a good thing to me.
-
Richmond
B: Chris Newman, Luke McGuane, Will Thursfield
HB: Brett Deledio, Kelvin Moore, Daniel Connors
C: Mitch Morton, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Ben Nason, Andrew Collins, Jake King
F: Matt White, Jack Riewoldt, David Astbury
Foll: Angus Graham, Shane Tuck, Daniel Jackson
I/C: Ben Cousins, Andrew Browne, Mitch Farmer, Jeromey Webberley
Emg: Troy Taylor, Robbie Hicks, Alex Rance
In: Moore, White, Jackson, Thursfield
Out: Dean Polo, Robin Nahas, Alex Rance, Jayden Post
Adelaide
B: Michael Doughty, Ben Rutten, Scott Stevens
HB: Brent Reilly, Nathan Bock, Nathan van Berlo
C: Rory Sloane, Scott Thompson, David Mackay
HF: Ricky Henderson, Taylor Walker, Matthew Jaensch
F: Jason Porplyzia, Kurt Tippett, Richard Douglas
Foll: Ivan Maric, Bernie Vince, Patrick Dangerfield
I/C: Jonathon Griffin, Jack Gunston, Chris Schmidt, Brad Symes
Emg: Tony Armstrong, Phil Davis, James Sellar
In: Schmidt, Gunston
Out: Graham Johncock (suspension), Tony Armstrong
-
polo gawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwn
-
No real surprises or giving more young guys a go. Rance a fraction stiff as he wasn't our worst last week. Looks like we are going all out to win.
I wonder if there'll be a late to bring in another small given it's forecasted to be just 12 degrees and rain on Sunday.
-
Would have liked to see Gourdis in the big league. I heard Jackson have good words about him on SEN this week.
Still can't get a game though.
-
Hey Infamy, Rance dropped. :lol
That just shows you know absolute ZIP you clown.
Forget about abusing me pal
Please refer my previous post re Rance
-
why drop Post after one match?
drop Edwards and Farmer for Taylor and Hicks.
give Rance another match.
Tambling should be a midfielder, leave him at Coburg untill Round 20.
like Morton's match against Collingwood as that skillful, strong marking, attacking wingman.
Will say this
I never seen a worse performance from an AFL player last week what Post produced.
Rance was on the end of so many uncontested possesions last week it wasnt even funny
Agree with Morton, but he needs to back up again this week.
Edwards was one of the reasons we have been competitive over the past 8 weeks.
As for Hicks, the horse races are at Caulfield this weeknd. :banghead
So he ran hard to make space. Sounds like a good thing to me.
He got dropped, I rest my case,
You posters should start going to a game or 2,
Rance cannot play
-
Hey Infamy, Rance dropped. :lol
That just shows you know absolute ZIP you clown.
Forget about abusing me pal
Please refer my previous post re Rance
It doesnt show he knows zip, it shows he has a different opinion to you!
-
Hey Infamy, Rance dropped. :lol
That just shows you know absolute ZIP you clown.
Forget about abusing me pal
Please refer my previous post re Rance
It doesnt show he knows zip, it shows he has a different opinion to you!
yep, he enjoys seeing Richmond being a failure all these years, I dont :gotigers
-
Hey Infamy, Rance dropped. :lol
That just shows you know absolute ZIP you clown.
Forget about abusing me pal
Please refer my previous post re Rance
It doesnt show he knows zip, it shows he has a different opinion to you!
yep, he enjoys seeing Richmond being a failure all these years, I dont :gotigers
Surely not!?
Although I would not be surprised if we have the largest Emo supporter base in the land! Barracking for Richmond is a form of self harm!
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
I dont disagree with your list at all! However, there have been a few players;notably King, Graham and Edwards, who are just finding their feet now! Some players need longer, or at least need a good team, to show their wares!
Rance being dropped shows what our plans are for him! Not sure we will delist Sloppy, why would we send him in for an op? Are we obligated to or are we hanging on to him? Same question for the others sent in for ops!
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?
You miss the point, whats the use
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?
You miss the point, whats the use
Agree with you Jack, there is no use. If I was you I would just throw my hands in the air, walk away and give up.
-
I still laugh at some supporters wanted to get rid of a new draftee after two matches, talk about armchair experts.
He may not make it or he may but at least he will go through the development stage and I have confidence that Hardwick will get the most out of draftees
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?
You miss the point, whats the use
Agree with you Jack, there is no use. If I was you I would just throw my hands in the air, walk away and give up.
I actually go every week, unlike some on here
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?
You miss the point, whats the use
Agree with you Jack, there is no use. If I was you I would just throw my hands in the air, walk away and give up.
I actually go every week, unlike some on here
Well I supose thats one big plus of Internet football forums, poeple who can not attend games etc (for what ever reason) can still have a say. Good isnt it.
-
I actually go every week, unlike some on here
Congratulations Jack but your point is?
-
My point is there a number of people who want to abuse me but dont even watch the games, thats my point
-
The only comments I made about Rance was that his game last week showed that he'd been working on his deficiencies at VFL level
I understand that he still has work to do on other areas of his game, but he is a kpp in his 3rd year, many don't even get to debut by this stage in his career.
With Moore & Thursfield returning to the squad he was always going to pushed out of the side, or made to play in another position that he hadn't been training for.
I have no interest in seeing Richmond fail, however I also have no interest in just writing off kids before they've properly developed. Just because a player has deficiencies doesn't mean they can't be overcome or at least reduced due to hard work and training, all players have weaknesses, even GAJ, Judd & Franklin. Rance shows a great work ethic, has admitted his deficiencies on public television and showed improvement last week in many of those areas. He kept his feet well, got plenty of the ball, disposed of it well and even contested better in the air, the only blemish was his dropped sitter of a mark, which he still collected and disposed of it without turning it over.
To give up on him now is a little ridiculous. If the right trade came up then I wouldn't complain if we moved him on, but it would want to be for a pick similar to what we took him with or a good young player.
-
The only comments I made about Rance was that his game last week showed that he'd been working on his deficiencies at VFL level
I understand that he still has work to do on other areas of his game, but he is a kpp in his 3rd year, many don't even get to debut by this stage in his career.
With Moore & Thursfield returning to the squad he was always going to pushed out of the side, or made to play in another position that he hadn't been training for.
I have no interest in seeing Richmond fail, however I also have no interest in just writing off kids before they've properly developed. Just because a player has deficiencies doesn't mean they can't be overcome or at least reduced due to hard work and training, all players have weaknesses, even GAJ, Judd & Franklin. Rance shows a great work ethic, has admitted his deficiencies on public television and showed improvement last week in many of those areas. He kept his feet well, got plenty of the ball, disposed of it well and even contested better in the air, the only blemish was his dropped sitter of a mark, which he still collected and disposed of it without turning it over.
To give up on him now is a little ridiculous. If the right trade came up then I wouldn't complain if we moved him on, but it would want to be for a pick similar to what we took him with or a good young player.
To have any credibility you need to get rid of that signature.
Otherwise you are just proving what a petulant twerp you are.
:wallywink
-
My point is there a number of people who want to abuse me but dont even watch the games, thats my point
How do you know they don't watch the games? I would guess that the very large majority of people who visit and post here watch almost every one of our games.
-
mate, i hate losing with a passion.
Major issue with most Richmond supporters that we fall in love with players who just arent up to it.
We hold on to them for too long in the hope they will improve. You cant improve if you have no ability.
Nahas is a perfect example, he used to fall over all the time when he played at Port Melbourne, 3 years later he still falls over :banghead
Rance, just aint going to make.
Hislop and Thomson like wise
Since when do the supporters have a say in list management?
You miss the point, whats the use
Actually I don't believe I missed the point at all. Your post reads like we hold to players to long because of the supporters views,(Your not the only one to do this either), which is just silliness that distracts from the point you were trying to make.
You make some pretty outrageous statements at times Jack, yet want to call people idiots when they disagree with you. If you had a 100% strike rate with your opinions and then perhaps this may be justified, but no one is 100% right all the time, not even you!
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
-
:P :rollin
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
jack considering you were the same bloke that said that JR8 should be traded because he would never be good enough I dont think your opinion counts for much.
Dea is the youngest player on the playing list and has great afl athletic qualities, lets give him a fair go he is 18 yrs old for gods sake.
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
jack considering you were the same bloke that said that JR8 should be traded because he would never be good enough I dont think your opinion counts for much.
Dea is the youngest player on the playing list and has great afl athletic qualities, lets give him a fair go he is 18 yrs old for gods sake.
JR8 has improved heaps off and on the field
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
If you got your FACTS :banghead right, maybe, just maybe, people would give your views a little more credence.
Making stuff up or exaggerating is not how you convince people of something.
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
jack considering you were the same bloke that said that JR8 should be traded because he would never be good enough I dont think your opinion counts for much.
Dea is the youngest player on the playing list and has great afl athletic qualities, lets give him a fair go he is 18 yrs old for gods sake.
JR8 has improved heaps off and on the field
So what's to say Dea can't? From my experiences talking to him, he's a great guy.
-
Rance is well ahead of Dea from what I saw. Dea didnt have a clue in his first 2 games. Hopefully he improves, Rance, I would keep because I think he would be good to have around a footy club, he's a young kid, always does his best, doesnt cause trouble, got dropped after getting 20 odd possessions and went and got 2nd best on ground in the VFL today. Rance you keep hopefully he comes good over the next 12 months.
-
Late change tomorrow, Robbie Hicks to make his debut for the tiges! That should get you excited JJ.
-
Late change tomorrow, Robbie Hicks to make his debut for the tiges! That should get you excited JJ.
All the Hicks clan will be there then, who is out ??? White ?
-
Late change tomorrow, Robbie Hicks to make his debut for the tiges! That should get you excited JJ.
Who is coming out then? I assume it is due to the weather conditions that are forecast?
-
would have to better than Nahas as he is hopeless
Did Hicks ride any winners at Caulfield today ??????? ;)
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
He's played 3 games for 7 kicks 24 handballs 5 marks & 10 tackles
Stop making stuff up
-
Hey Infamy, hows Rance going ????
Your a goose, he was your best player last week :lol
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
He's played 3 games for 7 kicks 24 handballs 5 marks & 10 tackles
Stop making stuff up
10.33333 average possies per game not too bad!
I dont think his effeciencies are too good though!
Still early days
yet though!
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
He's played 3 games for 7 kicks 24 handballs 5 marks & 10 tackles
Stop making stuff up
10.33333 average possies per game not too bad!
I dont think his effeciencies are too good though!
Still early days
yet though!
70.97%, which isn't too bad for a kid in his first 3 games
-
Hey Al
Are u saying the delist Dea after two games wasn't a good call
Well he has played 6 games and hasnt had a kick :banghead
He's played 3 games for 7 kicks 24 handballs 5 marks & 10 tackles
Stop making stuff up
10.33333 average possies per game not too bad!
I dont think his effeciencies are too good though!
Still early days
yet though!
70.97%, which isn't too bad for a kid in his first 3 games
Cheers mate!
-
Infamy, you dont want to talk about Rance this week ?? :lol
-
Infamy, you dont want to talk about Rance this week ?? :lol
I've already commented and you haven't responded
-
Infamy, you dont want to talk about Rance this week ?? :lol
I've already commented and you haven't responded
Well i have spent the last 10 minutes looking for your views on Rance being dropped after you said he was our best last week. ::)
I CANT FIND your response :lol :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
-
Infamy, you dont want to talk about Rance this week ?? :lol
I've already commented and you haven't responded
Well i have spent the last 10 minutes looking for your views on Rance being dropped after you said he was our best last week. ::)
I CANT FIND your response :lol :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
-
Daniel, still no response
-
Well i have spent the last 10 minutes looking for your views on Rance being dropped after you said he was our best last week. ::)
I CANT FIND your response :lol :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
And I've been back in interstate for 3 days and spent 5 minutes reading this thread and found this
Shows me you see only what you ant to see to suit your purpose ;D
The only comments I made about Rance was that his game last week showed that he'd been working on his deficiencies at VFL level
I understand that he still has work to do on other areas of his game, but he is a kpp in his 3rd year, many don't even get to debut by this stage in his career.
With Moore & Thursfield returning to the squad he was always going to pushed out of the side, or made to play in another position that he hadn't been training for.
I have no interest in seeing Richmond fail, however I also have no interest in just writing off kids before they've properly developed. Just because a player has deficiencies doesn't mean they can't be overcome or at least reduced due to hard work and training, all players have weaknesses, even GAJ, Judd & Franklin. Rance shows a great work ethic, has admitted his deficiencies on public television and showed improvement last week in many of those areas. He kept his feet well, got plenty of the ball, disposed of it well and even contested better in the air, the only blemish was his dropped sitter of a mark, which he still collected and disposed of it without turning it over.
To give up on him now is a little ridiculous. If the right trade came up then I wouldn't complain if we moved him on, but it would want to be for a pick similar to what we took him with or a good young player.
Is that not a response.... ::)
-
Hicks in for Collins (leg)
-
Hicks in for Collins (leg)
:cheers
-
Good luck to hicks hopes he plays well but I reckon he's too small.
Would have loved to see Gourdis play. Apparently he's super quick, tall and athletic. Looks like the tigers are grooming him as a key defender.
Good luck to the jockey anyway.
-
Well Hicks rode a winner today
-
:lol :rollin
-
dea has a solid build for a young boy and is a baby. Worth a few seasons at least, hardwick must see something in him to draft him as of of our higher picks in the last draft.
Rance is still a young for s tall
Rance is well ahead of Dea from what I saw. Dea didnt have a clue in his first 2 games. Hopefully he improves, Rance, I would keep because I think he would be good to have around a footy club, he's a young kid, always does his best, doesnt cause trouble, got dropped after getting 20 odd possessions and went and got 2nd best on ground in the VFL today. Rance you keep hopefully he comes good over the next 12 months.
-
Well Hicks rode a winner today
Was given goal of the day by SEN
-
Well i have spent the last 10 minutes looking for your views on Rance being dropped after you said he was our best last week. ::)
I CANT FIND your response :lol :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
And I've been back in interstate for 3 days and spent 5 minutes reading this thread and found this
Shows me you see only what you ant to see to suit your purpose ;D
The only comments I made about Rance was that his game last week showed that he'd been working on his deficiencies at VFL level
I understand that he still has work to do on other areas of his game, but he is a kpp in his 3rd year, many don't even get to debut by this stage in his career.
With Moore & Thursfield returning to the squad he was always going to pushed out of the side, or made to play in another position that he hadn't been training for.
I have no interest in seeing Richmond fail, however I also have no interest in just writing off kids before they've properly developed. Just because a player has deficiencies doesn't mean they can't be overcome or at least reduced due to hard work and training, all players have weaknesses, even GAJ, Judd & Franklin. Rance shows a great work ethic, has admitted his deficiencies on public television and showed improvement last week in many of those areas. He kept his feet well, got plenty of the ball, disposed of it well and even contested better in the air, the only blemish was his dropped sitter of a mark, which he still collected and disposed of it without turning it over.
To give up on him now is a little ridiculous. If the right trade came up then I wouldn't complain if we moved him on, but it would want to be for a pick similar to what we took him with or a good young player.
Is that not a response.... ::)
No wonder you grunted at me when I said hello today
-
No wonder you grunted at me when I said hello today
was that you ;D
-
yes, dont look my age these days, lol
-
yes, dont look my age these days, lol
botox?
:rollin
-
yes, dont look my age these days, lol
botox?
:rollin
no, hair dye, lol
-
Well i have spent the last 10 minutes looking for your views on Rance being dropped after you said he was our best last week. ::)
I CANT FIND your response :lol :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin :rollin
And I've been back in interstate for 3 days and spent 5 minutes reading this thread and found this
Shows me you see only what you ant to see to suit your purpose ;D
The only comments I made about Rance was that his game last week showed that he'd been working on his deficiencies at VFL level
I understand that he still has work to do on other areas of his game, but he is a kpp in his 3rd year, many don't even get to debut by this stage in his career.
With Moore & Thursfield returning to the squad he was always going to pushed out of the side, or made to play in another position that he hadn't been training for.
I have no interest in seeing Richmond fail, however I also have no interest in just writing off kids before they've properly developed. Just because a player has deficiencies doesn't mean they can't be overcome or at least reduced due to hard work and training, all players have weaknesses, even GAJ, Judd & Franklin. Rance shows a great work ethic, has admitted his deficiencies on public television and showed improvement last week in many of those areas. He kept his feet well, got plenty of the ball, disposed of it well and even contested better in the air, the only blemish was his dropped sitter of a mark, which he still collected and disposed of it without turning it over.
To give up on him now is a little ridiculous. If the right trade came up then I wouldn't complain if we moved him on, but it would want to be for a pick similar to what we took him with or a good young player.
Is that not a response.... ::)
No wonder you grunted at me when I said hello today
So after all that fuss about me not wanting to discuss Rance being dropped you don't even come up with a response?
What stats can you make up this time? Or are you just going to call me an internet nuffer who knows nothing about football for a change?
I know it's too much for you to respond to points on their merits, so I don't exactly expect much, just surprised there was nothing at all.
-
you dont even go to games. :lol
Who did you give best too today you clown ?????
Rance ?? :lol :lol :lol.
No Collins ?? He was a late withdrawl,
-
you dont even go to games. :lol
Who did you give best too today you clown ?????
Rance ?? :lol :lol :lol.
No Collins ?? He was a late withdrawl,
In case you haven't noticed, I haven't made any comment on who was our best today and don't intend to
Also I go to plenty of games, but I didn't today, never said that I did and have made no comment to even suggest I did
I know you don't like me because I call you out on your bullsh!t. Hopefully one day you will argue my points on its merits rather than change the subject to something else because you have nothing to say that isn't more bullsh!t. You are like a compulsive liar, except its more a compulsive bullsh!t artist.
-
yeah, because you have been found out from last weeks pathetic assesment.
You should trying attending a game or two..
Pointless discussing anythings with idiots
-
yeah, because you have been found out from last weeks pathetic assesment.
You should trying attending a game or two..
Pointless discussing anythings with idiots
I haven't been found out on anything, I have explained my comments from last week yet you won't respond despite giving me a hard time for not responding.
As I said, just becasuse I didn't go today, doesn't mean I don't go to games
Funny how you say it's pointless discussing anything with idiots when you are posting childish bullsh!t on here demanding a response from my on Rance. So make up your mind, do you want my comment or not, because on one hand you're demanding them, on the other hand you say it's pointless discussing it with me.
From what I can see, I am providing opinions with evidence to back up why I have come to such conclusions and all you do is proclaim how amazing you are and avoid any response when you have been proven wrong.
Just delete your account again and get it over with you wanker.
-
... hair .....
What's that? Or in the immortal words of Pauline - please explain? ;D
-
yeah, because you have been found out from last weeks pathetic assesment.
You should trying attending a game or two..
Pointless discussing anythings with idiots
I haven't been found out on anything, I have explained my comments from last week yet you won't respond despite giving me a hard time for not responding.
As I said, just becasuse I didn't go today, doesn't mean I don't go to games
Funny how you say it's pointless discussing anything with idiots when you are posting childish bullsh!t on here demanding a response from my on Rance. So make up your mind, do you want my comment or not, because on one hand you're demanding them, on the other hand you say it's pointless discussing it with me.
From what I can see, I am providing opinions with evidence to back up why I have come to such conclusions and all you do is proclaim how amazing you are and avoid any response when you have been proven wrong.
Just delete your account again and get it over with you wanker.
Get over it.
Rance got dropped after you said he was our best player, you must be watching a differerent game on TV ::)
-
yeah, because you have been found out from last weeks pathetic assesment.
You should trying attending a game or two..
Pointless discussing anythings with idiots
I haven't been found out on anything, I have explained my comments from last week yet you won't respond despite giving me a hard time for not responding.
As I said, just becasuse I didn't go today, doesn't mean I don't go to games
Funny how you say it's pointless discussing anything with idiots when you are posting childish bullsh!t on here demanding a response from my on Rance. So make up your mind, do you want my comment or not, because on one hand you're demanding them, on the other hand you say it's pointless discussing it with me.
From what I can see, I am providing opinions with evidence to back up why I have come to such conclusions and all you do is proclaim how amazing you are and avoid any response when you have been proven wrong.
Just delete your account again and get it over with you wanker.
Get over it.
Rance got dropped after you said he was our best player, you must be watching a differerent game on TV ::)
I never said he was Richmond's best