One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: wayne on March 23, 2011, 05:20:51 PM
-
newman rance mcguane
deledio astbury conca
cotchin martin edwards
morton vickery grigg
white riewoldt helbig
graham jackson foley
houli batchelor nahas connors
-
Richmond
B: Newman Rance McGuane
HB: Deledio Astbury Conca
C: Cotchin Martin Edwards
HF: Morton Vickery Grigg
F: White Riewoldt Helbig
R: Graham Jackson Foley
Int: Houli Batchelor Nahas Connors
Emg: Post Dea Nason
Edit: Subs not named until 90 mins before the game according to SEN.
-
few surprises! ;). Good luck HELLBOY
-
Carlton
B: Christopher Yarran, Bret Thornton, Nick Duigan
HB: Jordan Russell, Simon White, Kane Lucas
C: Heath Scotland, Bryce Gibbs, Jeremy Laidler
HF: Kade Simpson, Jarrad Waite, Andrew Walker
F: Jeffrey Garlett, Shaun Hampson, Eddie Betts
R: Robert Warnock, Marc Murphy, Chris Judd
I/C: Andrew Carrazzo,Dennis Armfield,Mitch Robinson,Edward Curnow
ps. Andy Collins is an emergency.
-
fairly happy with the team named.
though it would be nice if post was in the 22 rather than an emergency. perhaps take one of white or nahas out?
does anyone know if tuck has any niggles?? tucky is fairly important to our engine room but with the depth in there now it's difficult to fit everyone in.
-
Hopefully the sub is Donkey Nahas
-
10 changes from last year and 13 changes since round 1 2009. Only survivors are Lids, Edwards, Foley, Jacko, McGuane, Morton, Newy, Jack and Whitey.
-
Good to see Rance step up and push Thursfield out.
Great effort from Helbig to earn a spot too.
-
Good to see Helbig in the bloke deserves.
Don't know why we persist with Mr de plane de plane Nahas
The guy is useless
Bower out there goes a bit of run
I don't rate the Blues with this team, which us what makes the loss hurt more
-
I don't rate the Blues with this team, which us what makes the loss hurt more
Agree, pretty ordinary looking Blues side.
White at CHB, Hampson at FF
-
though it would be nice if post was in the 22 rather than an emergency.
I reckon he was lucky to get named there :rollin ;D
Disappointing Derickx didn't get a run ahead of Gus
Gus desperatley needs to step up
-
I don't rate the Blues with this team, which us what makes the loss hurt more
Agree, pretty ordinary looking Blues side.
White at CHB, Hampson at FF
Yep and an injury interrupted pre season for the football mercenary.
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
-
Richmond
B: Newman Rance McGuane
HB: Deledio Astbury Conca
C: Cotchin Martin Edwards
HF: Morton Vickery Grigg
F: White Riewoldt Helbig
R: Graham Jackson Foley
Int: Houli Batchelor Nahas Connors
Emg: Post Dea Nason
Edit: Subs not named until 90 mins before the game according to SEN.
Like the look of our centre line and half forward line. :thumbsup
Good luck to the new boys tomorrow representing our footy club for the first time. :thumbsup
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
If Nahas is the sub then that limits the damage we will cop, If White plays in a forward pocket then maybe he can pinch 1 or 2 himself and Edwards - well it depends, it depends on which Edwards rocks up tomorrow night. The good one or the comedy caper one.
-
Good to see plenty of new names in the side, as well as Rance and Vickery claiming a spot.
Lets get into them boys!!! :gotigers
-
Like the look of our centre line and half forward line. :thumbsup
HB line looks good too
-
It looks like we are going with 3 runners on the bench as part of the rotation so that would leave Batchelor as sub.
No Tucky. Is he injured or not in Dimma's future plans again? Jacko probably got the not ahead of him as a potential tagger.
Obviously Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Simpson and Waite are they keys to Carlton but Betts and Garlett are the ones that make me nervous as we usually struggle to hold nippy small forwards.
-
Like the look of our centre line and half forward line. :thumbsup
HB line looks good too
It does too GG. Hope Conca tears it apart.
-
Obviously Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Simpson and Waite are they keys to Carlton but Betts and Garlett are the ones that make me nervous as we usually struggle to hold nippy small forwards.
It has been the same old story in the past that a teams second and third tier players have a day out against us. Seems Betts Garlett Yarran Scotland Robinson Carazzo Simpson Thornton or most of these guys anyway seem to step up in the same game against us and take us to the sword and its not just Carlskata its other clubs as well.
I would like to see our boys deliver these mentioned blokes and a few others a really vigorous message that we are going to give this match a real sustained effort and make the RFC proud. :gotigers
-
Obviously Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Simpson and Waite are they keys to Carlton but Betts and Garlett are the ones that make me nervous as we usually struggle to hold nippy small forwards.
It has been the same old story in the past that a teams second and third tier players have a day out against us. Seems Betts Garlett Yarran Scotland Robinson Carazzo Simpson Thornton or most of these guys anyway seem to step up in the same game against us and take us to the sword and its not just Carlskata its other clubs as well.
I would like to see our boys deliver these mentioned blokes and a few others a really vigorous message that we are going to give this match a real sustained effort and make the RFC proud. :gotigers
I think its a depth thing, Tucker. The cream of our crop is pretty good, so we are able to hold the better players fairly well. But our second and third tear players are often inferior to those of the opposition, so they gain the upper-hand in those match-ups.
-
Obviously Judd, Murphy, Gibbs, Simpson and Waite are they keys to Carlton but Betts and Garlett are the ones that make me nervous as we usually struggle to hold nippy small forwards.
It has been the same old story in the past that a teams second and third tier players have a day out against us. Seems Betts Garlett Yarran Scotland Robinson Carazzo Simpson Thornton or most of these guys anyway seem to step up in the same game against us and take us to the sword and its not just Carlskata its other clubs as well.
I would like to see our boys deliver these mentioned blokes and a few others a really vigorous message that we are going to give this match a real sustained effort and make the RFC proud. :gotigers
I think its a depth thing, Tucker. The cream of our crop is pretty good, so we are able to hold the better players fairly well. But our second and third tear players are often inferior to those of the opposition, so they gain the upper-hand in those match-ups.
It has been a problem Willy but I would like to see the tide turn and am hoping that the kids development has been sufficient enough to avert the dangers or for want of a better term lessen the impact on the game of these opposition B and C graders.
-
And our 2nd and 3rd tier players are of better quality now than they have been in recent years.
-
And our 2nd and 3rd tier players are of better quality now than they have been in recent years.
I think so too Smokey. :thumbsup
I just want to walk out tomorrow night win draw or whatever with a sense of pride.
I know we are on a long journey and there may be some passion in my blood due to the repugnance of our
opposition tomorrow and hence the result in two years in a much more clearer picture may or may not mean much but I just don't want to go down without a yelp or be physically manhandled.
In so many ways for me and for alot of us the result tomorrow is everything and what will be in round 2 round 22 or two years down the track will be.
-
And our 2nd and 3rd tier players are of better quality now than they have been in recent years.
I think so too Smokey. :thumbsup
I just want to walk out tomorrow night win draw or whatever with a sense of pride.
I know we are on a long journey and there may be some passion in my blood due to the repugnance of our
opposition tomorrow and hence the result in two years in a much more clearer picture may or may not mean much but I just don't want to go down without a yelp or be physically manhandled.
In so many ways for me and for alot of us the result tomorrow is everything and what will be in round 2 round 22 or two years down the track will be.
well said Tucker. Nothing annoys me more when we get thrown to the ground against duds like Scotland and Robinson
For me personally a win tomorrow and i couldnt really care less if we lose the next 5, such is my hatred for the Blues.
Everything about that club make me sick starting from Robert Walls
-
And our 2nd and 3rd tier players are of better quality now than they have been in recent years.
I think so too Smokey. :thumbsup
I just want to walk out tomorrow night win draw or whatever with a sense of pride.
I know we are on a long journey and there may be some passion in my blood due to the repugnance of our
opposition tomorrow and hence the result in two years in a much more clearer picture may or may not mean much but I just don't want to go down without a yelp or be physically manhandled.
In so many ways for me and for alot of us the result tomorrow is everything and what will be in round 2 round 22 or two years down the track will be.
well said Tucker. Nothing annoys me more when we get thrown to the ground against duds like Scotland and Robinson
For me personally a win tomorrow and i couldnt really care less if we lose the next 5, such is my hatred for the Blues.
Everything about that club make me sick starting from Robert Walls
:bow :cheers :thumbsup :clapping :clapping :clapping
-
A win tomorrow night would knock a rusty mail in the rattan coffin. Like 2009 for Wallace.
I'm not confident but the roar from the tiger army after a win would sure bring music to my ears.
-
Disappointed Tuck and Derrickx are not in side. Believe Thursfield should also been in side. Question why Nahas is in side. Wish Helbig, Batchelor and Conca luck in their first game for the club and wish them long and successful careers at Richmond.
-
What the stuff happened to Tuck? Why the stuff is stuffing McGawn playing? :banghead Thursfield had a better pre-season.
Graham :banghead Nahas :banghead
:lol
Good to see ConcaTruck. Jack needs a big game :police:
Soooos
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
I think White might play a defensive role on Yarran. If we can shut him down they won't get any drive from the backline.
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
I think White might play a defensive role on Yarran. If we can shut him down they won't get any drive from the backline.
Yep very important role for White tonight.
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
I think White might play a defensive role on Yarran. If we can shut him down they won't get any drive from the backline.
Yep very important role for White tonight.
Good call wayne, spot on. Whitey did very well on him too
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
I think White might play a defensive role on Yarran. If we can shut him down they won't get any drive from the backline.
Yep very important role for White tonight.
Good call wayne, spot on. Whitey did very well on him too
he did, that was a collingwood-esque type role. If he can keep on offering that there is a spot for him. Add Kingy and Tuck into that lineup and we'll balance up a bit better
-
Nahas, White and Edwards named means we are giving them a 6 goal start (goals from turnovers).
I really don't understand how these guys are getting a game on form, and how the first two are getting a game on ability.
I think White might play a defensive role on Yarran. If we can shut him down they won't get any drive from the backline.
well done Wayne :thumbsup. Too good. :bow