One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on March 17, 2012, 06:29:44 PM
-
The team for round 1 will mostly come from today's squad plus Reece Conca. So what's your final 22?
B:
HB:
C:
HF:
F:
R:
Int:
Sub:
Emg:
-
FB ellis rance houli
HB grimes post batchelor
C edwards cotchin conca
HF newman vickery maric
FF miller reiwoldt nahas
FOLL maric martin deledio
INT foley jackson helbig grigg
Don't think we should play Tuck with Jacko and Grigg in there. Need as much skill and composure as possible in the middle. We have enough ball winners. Would rather stick with the young up and coming Helbig. No Morris either. Need experience and skill down back. He'll get a few games soon. Hope to see Derricks and Griffiths forcing Miller out very soon too
-
Conca's in our best 22 but I've just got a feeling the more I think about that because Reece hasn't played for a month the coaching staff will give him a run at Coburg first and then bring him back into the side in round 2.
B: Grimes Rance Morris
HB: Houli Post Batchelor
C: Deledio Cotchin Newman
HF: Edwards Riewoldt A.Maric
F: Miller Vickery Nahas
R: I.Maric Martin Foley
Int: Grigg, Tuck, Ellis
Sub: Jackson
Emg: Browne, Helbig, Arnot
If Conca did play then one of Jacko, Tuck or Grigg would need to make way. On form this preseason then out of the three Jacko misses out.
-
B Post Rance Newman
HB Batchelor Grimes Houli
C Deledio Cotchin Grigg
HF Edwards Vickery Mini Maric
F Miller Riewoldt Nahas
Foll Maric Martin Foley
Int Jackson Tuck Ellis Conca (sub)
Conca is important to structure he'll play. Its just a question whether Mini Maric plays as the sub or Conca does. Alot of the VFL sides are having runs next week I am sure Conca will have a run for them if Coburg is playing just to sweep away the cobwebs.
-
B Post Rance Newman
HB Batchelor Grimes Houli
C Deledio Cotchin Grigg
HF Edwards Vickery Mini Maric
F Miller Riewoldt Nahas
Foll Maric Martin Foley
Int Jackson Tuck Ellis Conca (sub)
Conca is important to structure he'll play. Its just a question whether Mini Maric plays as the sub or Conca does. Alot of the VFL sides are having runs next week I am sure Conca will have a run for them if Coburg is playing just to sweep away the cobwebs.
Totally agree.
Conca will be sub
-
You wouldn't have Morris in for anybody, jack? Edwards? Jackson? Grigg?
-
You wouldn't have Morris in for anybody, jack? Edwards? Jackson? Grigg?
Would think its either Morris or Ellis.
Either one, although Ellis slighty ahead.
Or they dont go with Conca as the sub and play both Morris and Ellis
-
I would have thought Morris was necessary to shut down Betts or Garlett.
-
B: Newman Rance Grimes
HB: Ellis Post Houli
C: Grigg Foley Conca
HF: A Maric Vickery Deledio
F: Nahas Reiwoldt Miller
R: I Maric Cotchin Martin
Int: Tuck, Edwards, Jackson
Sub: Batchelor
Emg: Browne, Helbig, Arnot
-
You wouldn't have Morris in for anybody, jack? Edwards? Jackson? Grigg?
Would think its either Morris or Ellis.
Either one, although Ellis slighty ahead.
Or they dont go with Conca as the sub and play both Morris and Ellis
I think whether conca plays may be determined by how the coaching staff view the incident that saw him get reported.
If they see the whole thing as him being stiff, he will probably play.
If they reckon he clearly and stupidly crossed the line, then they may take the attitude he has to earn his spot once again.
-
Tend to agree with Tucker but have Nahas on the bench, Mini Maric in the pocket and and Tuck in the starting 18 on the HFF
B Post Rance Newman
HB Batchelor Grimes Houli
C Deledio Cotchin Grigg
HF Edwards Vickery Tuck
F Miller Riewoldt Mini Maric
Foll Maric Martin Foley
Int Jackson Nahas Ellis Conca (sub)
Conca sub only because he hasn't played for 4 weeks
-
i reckon conca may be left out in favour of playing both ellis and morris given his extended layoff
-
First time in long time that the team seems to be pretty much the same for everybody. I dont know if thats a good thing or bad. Normally the fight for places would have us scratching our heads as to who will get a game but this years preseason has been different with basically the same team being played for the last two weeks.
I will wait to make a call on Conca untill I see what happens this weekend. He is easy best 22 but is he ready with missing the games he has ??
-
B: Post Rance Newman
HB: Batchelor Grimes Grigg
C: Deledio Foley Houli
HF: A. Maric Vickery Conca
F: Nahas Riewoldt Miller
R: I. Maric Cotchin Martin
Int: Jackson, Tuck, Edwards
Sub: Ellis
Emg: White, Helbig, Morris
-
B: Morris Rance Grimes
HB: Houli Post Batchelor
C: Newman Cotchin Deledio
HF: Edwards Riewoldt Nahas
F: A Maric Vickery Miller
R: I Maric Martin Foley
Int: Ellis Tuck Grigg
Sub: Conca
Emg: Webberley Arnott Dea
-
I'd be tempted to have White in to do another number on Yarran;)
-
B: Post Rance Newman
HB: Batchelor Grimes Grigg
C: Deledio Foley Houli
HF: A. Maric Vickery Conca
F: Nahas Riewoldt Miller
R: I. Maric Cotchin Martin
Int: Jackson, Tuck, Foley
Sub: Ellis
Emg: White, Helbig, Morris
stuff I forgot all about my Brownlow fancy... Edwards!!
-
B: Post Rance Newman
HB: Batchelor Grimes Grigg
C: Deledio Foley Houli
HF: A. Maric Vickery Conca
F: Nahas Riewoldt Miller
R: I. Maric Cotchin Martin
Int: Jackson, Tuck, Foley
Sub: Ellis
Emg: White, Helbig, Morris
stuff I forgot all about my Brownlow fancy... Edwards!!
swap him for one of your Foleys
-
swap him for one of your Foleys
Good thinking. ;D
-
B: Grimes Rance Morris
HB: Houli Post Batchelor
C: Conca Cotchin Newman
HF: Edwards Riewoldt Deledio
F: Miller Vickery Nahas
R: I.Maric Martin Foley
Int: Grigg, Tuck, Ellis
Sub: A Maric
I know they will play Jackson because they will put him on Judd. So I accept it is unrealistic of me not to include him in squad. Would have liked to put in Helbig but want to see how Morris goes in the big time
-
For mine, Morris and Tuck will be our weak links skills/desposal wise but will win plenty of the ball with their strength of will and size. Jackson could fall in the same bracket. Very few other players in the team now that are excellent kicks :thumbsup
-
In light of Batchy playing at the Burgers and assuming he won't be AFL ready with just 5 days cool down, I'll take a punt at it looking some like
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Pretty vanilla and includes pets. Swap around Jack and TV, and Conca and Ellis possibly. Ellis would be good sub material this match IMO. I'd bet on Carlton playing a quick sub and Ellis would be a good option late in the game to apply pressure on tired opponents and break lines.
-
From the Herald-Sun...
A long list of players with interrupted pre-seasons have been given permission to play in Round 1 of the VFL, which starts tomorrow.
The names give an indication of players pushing for a Round 1 spot - but VFL selection could be bad news for Carlton and Richmond players.
The Coburg Tigers and the Northern Blues face off tomorrow afternoon, giving players in that match just five days to prepare for the AFL clash next Thursday.
That means Tigers Jake Batchelor, Luke McGuane, Matt White, Jeromey Webberley and Andrew Browne seem out of contention for the MCG blockbuster.
Promoted rookies Brad Miller and Addam Maric have not been named which makes them likely starters next Thursday, along with defenders Brandon Ellis and Steve Morris.
Among the Carlton-listed players lining up for the Northern Blues are Sam Rowe, Aaron Joseph, Matthew Watson and Brock McLean.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/more-news/vfl-hitout-for-jarryd-roughead-jack-watts/story-e6frf9jf-1226308370752
-
In light of Batchy playing at the Burgers and assuming he won't be AFL ready with just 5 days cool down, I'll take a punt at it looking some like
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Pretty vanilla and includes pets. Swap around Jack and TV, and Conca and Ellis possibly. Ellis would be good sub material this match IMO. I'd bet on Carlton playing a quick sub and Ellis would be a good option late in the game to apply pressure on tired opponents and break lines.
I would agree with your team, reckon Conca will be sub
-
I'd be tempted to have White in to do another number on Yarran;)
agree :thumbsup
I think they will include him just for this reason
-
million to one Matt White will play, he is no chance
-
Yep
-
Footy Barometer - Round 1
Sam Landsberger
From: Herald Sun
March 26, 2012 1:30PM
RICHMOND
SAM LANDSBERGER’S FORECAST: Thursday night is looming as Tiger Time with many giving Richmond a huge chance to topple the injury-ravaged Blues. Brandon Ellis and Steve Morris are likely to debut after being spared Coburg duties, forcing Jake Batchelor out of the side. A win against Carlton and a crunch Round 3 showdown against Melbourne will be crucial for any finals designs Richmond harbours. David Astbury is likely to return in May.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/footy-barometer-round-1/story-fncufbo5-1226310294049
-
Going by the coburg side and current injury it looks fair clear this is current best 22.
King will force out little maric. I reckon moore is in trouble and.its a bit odd he bot dekisted hope a fit.asrbury is ahead of miller.
I would love to see griffiths batchelor and maybe derickx helbig elton aarnot oushing for our first finals side..
In light of Batchy playing at the Burgers and assuming he won't be AFL ready with just 5 days cool down, I'll take a punt at it looking some like
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Pretty vanilla and includes pets. Swap around Jack and TV, and Conca and Ellis possibly. Ellis would be good sub material this match IMO. I'd bet on Carlton playing a quick sub and Ellis would be a good option late in the game to apply pressure on tired opponents and break lines.
-
Going by the coburg side and current injury it looks fair clear this is current best 22.
King will force out little maric. I reckon moore is in trouble and.its a bit odd he bot dekisted hope a fit.asrbury is ahead of miller.
I would love to see griffiths batchelor and maybe derickx helbig elton aarnot oushing for our first finals side..
In light of Batchy playing at the Burgers and assuming he won't be AFL ready with just 5 days cool down, I'll take a punt at it looking some like
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Pretty vanilla and includes pets. Swap around Jack and TV, and Conca and Ellis possibly. Ellis would be good sub material this match IMO. I'd bet on Carlton playing a quick sub and Ellis would be a good option late in the game to apply pressure on tired opponents and break lines.
tell me you posted this from a phone or something bents?
-
Going by the coburg side and current injury it looks fair clear this is current best 22.
King will force out little maric. I reckon moore is in trouble and.its a bit odd he bot dekisted hope a fit.asrbury is ahead of miller.
I would love to see griffiths batchelor and maybe derickx helbig elton aarnot oushing for our first finals side..
In light of Batchy playing at the Burgers and assuming he won't be AFL ready with just 5 days cool down, I'll take a punt at it looking some like
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Pretty vanilla and includes pets. Swap around Jack and TV, and Conca and Ellis possibly. Ellis would be good sub material this match IMO. I'd bet on Carlton playing a quick sub and Ellis would be a good option late in the game to apply pressure on tired opponents and break lines.
:cheers
-
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Have to agree with you on your lineup dwanio. Though I would prefer to see Ellis in our backline over Morris. Morris will be harder at the ball but Ellis better at moving the ball out of defence and through the zone. I worry Morris may turn the ball over at crucial times.
Tuck will obvious be in the team for similar reasons as Morris and have many of the same flaws.
Should be interesting how everyone plays their roles.
-
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Newman, Post, Houli
C: Deledio, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Martin, Vickory, Nahas
F: Miller, Riewoldt, A.Maric
R: iMaric, Foley, Tuck
I/C: Conca, Jackson, Edwards
SUB: Ellis
Have to agree with you on your lineup dwanio. Though I would prefer to see Ellis in our backline over Morris. Morris will be harder at the ball but Ellis better at moving the ball out of defence and through the zone. I worry Morris may turn the ball over at crucial times.
Tuck will obvious be in the team for similar reasons as Morris and have many of the same flaws.
Should be interesting how everyone plays their roles.
After watching Dimma on EMT I would agree with you re: Ellis. At first I thought either or, but Dimma stated Ellis looks to play back pocket on Thursday. Morris will be near necessary down back to outweigh Carlton in sheer kegs.
-
We need someone to lock down Betts, maybe Morris can worry him off his game.
Matt White might be a smoky, did a job last year on Yarren who is a very dangerous and quick playmaker off their d50.
-
White seemed to play a full game Saturday i reckon he would be out of calculations
-
If Ellis and Morris are penciled into the starting lineup then could Edwards be the sub? Perhaps Conca?
-
If Ellis and Moore are penciled into the starting lineup then could Edwards be the sub? Perhaps Conca?
Morris, Stripes. Morris!!
-
Perhaps Conca?
If it weren't Ellis, then I'd guess Conca. Not for any reason other than the trend of quick line breakers typically being the sub. I can see Morris getting subbed off but not subbed on late in the game to fill this role. Could be completely wrong though as I've only seen him play a couple Nob Cup matches. I assumed Ellis being the newbie, but Ellis + Morris starting down back gives that size, rebound, and unlocks others into the midfield. Using my completely uneducated formula, Conca could also fit this role as he is quick and can go back and forward, and he has missed 3 games of pre-season footy.
-
If Conca plays I'd expect him to either be the sub or start and be the one subbed off. Hard to see him lasting through a whole game after not playing a competitive match for a month.
-
Reckon you might be right there mt
-
I reckon Concs might be subbed off for A. Maric.
-
. Hard to see him lasting through a whole game after not playing a competitive match for a month.
This makes me laugh a little, Lids had a whole month off with an injury and still managed 30 possessions and a couple of goals in his return game! the down time didn't seem to affect his match fitness. With Conc's he hasn't had the injury to contend with and I'm sure the fitness staff has tailored his program to be cherry ripe for this game ;)
-
. Hard to see him lasting through a whole game after not playing a competitive match for a month.
This makes me laugh a little, Lids had a whole month off with an injury and still managed 30 possessions and a couple of goals in his return game! the down time didn't seem to affect his match fitness. With Conc's he hasn't had the injury to contend with and I'm sure the fitness staff has tailored his program to be cherry ripe for this game ;)
Spot on. No different from any player returning from suspension.
-
You cannot attain match fitness by training. The game will be played at a frenetic pace. Conca will be one of the first to tier.
-
If Ellis and Moore are penciled into the starting lineup then could Edwards be the sub? Perhaps Conca?
Morris, Stripes. Morris!!
Fixed! How funny. I was just reading how on SEN they referred to Morris as Moore and thought what idiots! :P ;D
-
You cannot attain match fitness by training. The game will be played at a frenetic pace. Conca will be one of the first to tier.
So Carlton will rest Judd? Should we rest King another week or two?
We've got the luxury of just coming off rigorous pre-season training. Every team would be fielding sides this weekend where at least a handful only spent minutes in the Nob Cup.
-
The official teams will be announced at 6.25pm tonight.
Source: RFC twitter.
-
I reckon Concs might be subbed off for A. Maric.
Willy knows :shh
A.Maric or Nahas sub
-
I reckon Concs might be subbed off for A. Maric.
Willy knows :shh
A.Maric or Nahas sub
Ellis for me ;)
-
The official teams will be announced at 6.25pm tonight.
Source: RFC twitter.
On chan 7 sport news first right?
-
The official teams will be announced at 6.25pm tonight.
Source: RFC twitter.
On chan 7 sport news first right?
Correct around 6.20pm ;D
-
The official teams will be announced at 6.25pm tonight.
Source: RFC twitter.
On chan 7 sport news first right?
Correct around 6.20pm ;D
Will 9 still show the teams or has 7 got exclusive rights to show them?
-
I reckon Ellis or Morris a certs for the green Lantern costume.
-
Will 9 still show the teams or has 7 got exclusive rights to show them?
Ch7 has an exculsive deal to name all the teams first during their news service
Means neither Chs 9 or 10 can name the teams until after Ch7 have.
Seriosuly I have no idea when Ch 7 plan to announce the teams but would think it would during sport which usually comes on around 6.20
-
Which means that here in NSW we will get them around 11pm. I'll keep an eye out here on OER. I wonder who will post the scoop first out of wayne, OE, WP or Coach Davey. ;D
The race is on!!
(http://i41.tinypic.com/2ugjbev.jpg)
-
Tiga,u look like a good bloke :thumbsup
-
Which means that here in NSW we will get them around 11pm. I'll keep an eye out here on OER. I wonder who will post the scoop first out of wayne, OE, WP or Coach Davey. ;D
The race is on!!
(http://i41.tinypic.com/2ugjbev.jpg)
Not sure why you've put me in with that group of freaks, guy. However, The Coach doesn't back down from a challenge.
-
Tiga,u look like a good bloke :thumbsup
I'd like Tiga more if he looked like the bloke in his avatar. :lol :rollin :lol
-
Tiga is a nerd, he looks more like a midget Bill Gates :-*