Who was it WP?Kaleb Smith.
So has anything come out about Prestia being injured or should we just chalk it down to a standard big footy bs rumour?Hopefully, it was just minor and is short-term. Prestia didn't do the wrestling drills at the Camp but he seemed to do most other things such as the bike ride.
So has anything come out about Prestia being injured or should we just chalk it down to a standard big footy bs rumour?
And why why we still need a few spares like Graham and Ross
So I’m just gonna assume all those other guys that have been doing running drills only and/or missing match sim are just being managed rather than nursing any specific injury.Yep. Like a more definitive response that just "hoping" :-\.
I don’t like that last sentence on Lynchys report at all. Wish the guy could just play a full season for once - would easily kick 80+ goals.
List seems to keep getting bigger and bigger.
7 all up - Tarrant, Graham, Pickett, Gibcus, Bauer, Smith, Colina.List seems to keep getting bigger and bigger.
There’s only 3 unavailable to play this weekend.
List seems to keep getting bigger and bigger.
There’s only 3 unavailable to play this weekend.
7 all up - Tarrant, Graham, Pickett, Gibcus, Bauer, Smith, Colina.List seems to keep getting bigger and bigger.
There’s only 3 unavailable to play this weekend.
Is it worth just amputating that toe of Graham's at this point? Wasn't that the little piggy that kept him grounded last season?It's not that simple. Losing a toe would affect his balance.
Robbie Tarrant, hipIf Tarrant misses round 1 then who replaces him?
"Robbie is managing some hip symptoms and is unavailable in the short term."
If Lynch, Tarrant and Gibcus are all injured for R1 I'd be quite worried tbh.Lynch will play round 1 unless he picks up an injury on Saturday. Tarrant is the worry if the hip isn't just some minor thing that will clear up in a week. As we know from past experience, the Club saying it's a "short-term" thing doesn't necessarily mean it is :-\.
Jack will get a back from the Carlton backline at his age and we would be left with an undersized backline ourselves against McKay.
If Lynch, Tarrant and Gibcus are all injured for R1 I'd be quite worried tbh.
Jack will get a bath from the Carlton backline at his age and we would be left with an undersized backline ourselves against McKay.
If Lynch, Tarrant and Gibcus are all injured for R1 I'd be quite worried tbh.
Jack will get a bath from the Carlton backline at his age and we would be left with an undersized backline ourselves against McKay.
Broad is the same height and weight as Curnow.
Miller can pinch hit back there if need be.
I don’t think playing without Tarrant is catastrophic
It was a arse decision to appoint the 2IC of a team that had a woeful record in 2021 and 2022. You pay peanuts you get monkeys.
Oh wow. A lot more available than anticipated. Will be close to best 23 for Thursday then apart from Tarrant.
Oh wow. A lot more available than anticipated. Will be close to best 23 for Thursday then apart from Tarrant.
And I thought our S&C team had completely stuffed up
Josh Gibcus looking like having the longest ever time off for a hamstring?
For the umpteenth season, we are being destroyed by injuries. Tarrant isn't a big loss IMO, but Lynch going down is huge. And I'm waiting for the Prestia news, I reckon he is shot as well. Just isn't moving well at all.Prestia had an issue at last Tuesday's training session. Did some testing with the rehab trainers then left the track early. He trained fully on Thursday though.
'Spy' says Prestia left the main training group and after speaking to the rehab trainers and doing some testing, he then went inside :-\. Graham, Cumberland and Campbell also spent time with the rehab group but perhaps just midweek management.
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum/index.php?topic=2565.msg742117#msg742117
Robbie Tarrant, hip (indefinite)Sounds like Lambert 2022 :(.
"Unfortunately for Robbie, he's battling away with his hip. At the moment, we're going to say this is more of an indefinite injury and we're going to take some time to assess where it's at, get him going again and hopefully we'll see him later in the year."
(https://i.makeagif.com/media/6-24-2016/r7yXun.gif)Robbie Tarrant, hip (indefinite)Sounds like Lambert 2022 :(.
"Unfortunately for Robbie, he's battling away with his hip. At the moment, we're going to say this is more of an indefinite injury and we're going to take some time to assess where it's at, get him going again and hopefully we'll see him later in the year."
Remember Prestia also injured his pectoral muscle two weeks before the start of the season. While it may only have been a mild(?) strain, it would've affected his start to the season proper.
https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/8108604/prestia-injured-as-demons-rucks-help-down-tigers/
Tarrant will retire before the mid-season draft also
Is Rance still fit?Tarrant will retire before the mid-season draft also
If he does, will we get an extra pick?
Tarrant will retire before the mid-season draft also
If he does, will we get an extra pick?
Tarrant will retire before the mid-season draft also
If he does, will we get an extra pick?
Yep
Id love a real update on Gibcus, havent heard anything.'Spy' says Gibbo is finally on the way back to returning now. Did some kicking drills with the main group at training today. The rest was running as part of his rehab. So positive signs.
Id love a real update on Gibcus, havent heard anything.'Spy' says Gibbo is finally on the way back to returning now. Did some kicking drills with the main group at training today. The rest was running as part of his rehab. So positive signs.
(https://resources.richmondfc.com.au/photo-resources/2023/04/28/724e7a8f-2406-4da8-9bd6-0aef84b55374/230428_RD7_Training-9850-Josh-Gibcus.jpg?width=1240)
The club hasn't said yet if it's a reoccurrence of the plantar fasciitis, but it sounds as though Soldo has re-injured that foot after just one game back :P.
The club hasn't said yet if it's a reoccurrence of the plantar fasciitis, but it sounds as though Soldo has re-injured that foot after just one game back :P.
The club hasn't said yet if it's a reoccurrence of the plantar fasciitis, but it sounds as though Soldo has re-injured that foot after just one game back :P.
Ryan and Miller are not up to rucking out a full game against senior-bodied ruckmen. Losing Nank and Soldo is a huge blow and nullifies much of our contested ball strength
The club hasn't said yet if it's a reoccurrence of the plantar fasciitis, but it sounds as though Soldo has re-injured that foot after just one game back :P.
Ryan and Miller are not up to rucking out a full game against senior-bodied ruckmen. Losing Nank and Soldo is a huge blow and nullifies much of our contested ball strength
The Pies are on top of the ladder and the best clearance team in the league, despite using Grigg-style rucks.
The club hasn't said yet if it's a reoccurrence of the plantar fasciitis, but it sounds as though Soldo has re-injured that foot after just one game back :P.
Typical been the same scenario last 3 year fitness and injury has been mess.
So is Bradtke available??
Tom Brown the longest broken wrist in history it feels like.
Tom Brown the longest broken wrist in history it feels like.
Gibcus has had a setback :(. According to Dimma, Gibbo has had "a bit of discomfort in his hamstring". So, he won't be making his comeback in the VFL this week and we are going to hold him off for a while to see how it progresses.Gez our fitness and injury program is a mess how many reoccurrences.
Gibcus has had a setback :(. According to Dimma, Gibbo has had "a bit of discomfort in his hamstring". So, he won't be making his comeback in the VFL this week and we are going to hold him off for a while to see how it progresses.
Gibcus has had a setback :(. According to Dimma, Gibbo has had "a bit of discomfort in his hamstring". So, he won't be making his comeback in the VFL this week and we are going to hold him off for a while to see how it progresses.
A 6mth hamstring - FMD. I could find a meth addict with more idea on how to manage our injured players than our team does
Gibcus has had a setback :(. According to Dimma, Gibbo has had "a bit of discomfort in his hamstring". So, he won't be making his comeback in the VFL this week and we are going to hold him off for a while to see how it progresses.
A 6mth hamstring - FMD. I could find a meth addict with more idea on how to manage our injured players than our team does
He tore his hamstring off the bone
This type of injury can take anywhere between 4 months to 12 months to get right. It depends on how the reattached heals.
He had problems with infections in the wound
That has nothing to do with our fitness people.
Everything would have been done via the specialist who did the surgery via our team doctors
Gibcus has had a setback :(. According to Dimma, Gibbo has had "a bit of discomfort in his hamstring". So, he won't be making his comeback in the VFL this week and we are going to hold him off for a while to see how it progresses.
A 6mth hamstring - FMD. I could find a meth addict with more idea on how to manage our injured players than our team does
He tore his hamstring off the bone
This type of injury can take anywhere between 4 months to 12 months to get right. It depends on how the reattached heals.
He had problems with infections in the wound
That has nothing to do with our fitness people.
Everything would have been done via the specialist who did the surgery via our team doctors
Tom Lynch
The forever 6-11 man it seems
Tom Lynch
The forever 6-11 man it seems
6 weeks if the visit surgeon this week and he says all is good after surgery and Lynch can commence running again
longer if things aren't healing the way they should
I think (hope) our medical team have learnt the extra cautious approach is the way to go. they did it with Graham's hammie, gave him a extra week and seems to have worked. Looks like they are doing the same with MJ, 21 days only clicked over this week, taking an extra week few days to get him right
He was 6-11 three weeks ago
If the current 6-11 is accurate then there is only two explanations
1- the initial estimate was wrong
2- he’s had a setback
Granted it can still fall into the initial 6-11, but I would have thought it would currently be 3-8
Lynch is back on long term lol gez we botched this appointment of Luke Meehan.
Lynch is back on long term lol gez we botched this appointment of Luke Meehan.
Hopper a 4-6 week calf that he did a week ago. What calf takes 7 weeks to heal?
Lynch is back on long term lol gez we botched this appointment of Luke Meehan.
Lynch has been long term since he broke his foot. It has not changed. Only thing that has changed is 8-13 weeks has dropped back to 6-11.
A broken foot caused by copping a nasty knock by an opposition player in the first few minutes of the Bulldogs game as TFL said nothing to do with S&C
Whack the S&C for the things they can control but they certainly don't deserve any whacks for broken bones
Hopper a 4-6 week calf that he did a week ago. What calf takes 7 weeks to heal?
How long has he been 6 to 11 weeks now lol ? Wasn't he supposed to see the doctor this week so he can hit the track no update at all.Lynch wasn't well all p5reseason and rd 1 you could see it with his foot issue and rushed back let's not blanket the incompetence of this department.
:yep Dont mention training without the footys or you will get eaten alive.
Someone a while back mentioned Burge was doing the training without footys' in "December" . Funny thing with that is Burg was at the hawks, so it appears he was at 2 places at the same time :shh :shh
well is that even true, as i just checked and saw footy drills in December 2021.
Perhaps it was drills for most of December but not all :shh
Lynch back in a moonboot according to 'Spy' :P.
Lynch back in a moonboot according to 'Spy' :P.
Lynch back in a moonboot according to 'Spy' :P.
Stuffen Meehan strikes again! :help
Lynch back in a moonboot according to 'Spy' :P.
Stuffen Meehan strikes again! :help
I will repeat the Lynch injury, that is badly broken bone in his foot was not caused by anything the S&C did. It was caused by a Bulldogs player. It happened in the 1st fre minutes of that game. It required surgery. Everything post surgery has been dictated by the surgeon and our medical team. S&C rightly follow those instructions
To be back in a moon boot means the repaired bone is not healing the way they had hoped.
Will also repeat again whack the S&C team for the things they should be held accountable for = soft tissue injuries but to whack them for Lynch being back in a moonboot is one helluva stretch
Mate Lynch wasn't right preseason with his foot injury and was rushed back wouldn't surprise me the injury is related.
Mate Lynch wasn't right preseason with his foot injury and was rushed back wouldn't surprise me the injury is related.
I have had 3 people tell me the same thing about his broken foot, how it happened and that it was not related to the injury/surgery he had in the pre-season. 3 people I might add that I trust and believe
People will believe what they want, I get that but I have only posted what I've been told
I'll leave it at that
ANd at the same time keep to myself the discussion I had with my physio about soleus calf injuries
Richmond is yet to officially update its injury list...How hard can it be? Just chuck "short term," "4-6 weeks," and "7-11" weeks next to everyone's names and put your feet up.
Umm....
Only thing I will say is that outside of the obvious ones, the others are last week's timelines. As the players are on break the Club hasn't released any updates this week
As for the serious foot and hammy ones I've given my views and what I know about those a number of times but because it doesn't suit narratives people ignore the ..er...ummm facts around the seriousness of those 2 injuries
Whatever
Stand to be corrected but it’s not simply a hamstring, it required surgery then got infected. I would imagine that would blow recovery time well and truly off the ball park.
Stand to be corrected but it’s not simply a hamstring, it required surgery then got infected. I would imagine that would blow recovery time well and truly off the ball park.
Really?
Been saying this for weeks now and everyone won't acknowledge it
And the other thing I've been saying if you've want to whack S&C then go ahead for the things they should be whacked for and there's plenty to whack them for
But to whack them for the Lynch and Gibcus isn't realistic
The injury report is just a bluff report. Gibcus will probably play VFL after the bye.
Probably not a bad out with Hopper returning - I'd say it at least guarantees Cotchin stays on ball. Certainly not as crucial as it would've been last year anyway. :shh
Was meatball injured against Freo or was this during the break ?. Puzzling they mentioned it this week.
Was meatball injured against Freo or was this during the break ?. Puzzling they mentioned it this week.McQaulter said Dion injured it right at the end of the game against St Kilda. They are hoping he will miss just the one week.
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=952)
PLAYER INJURY ESTIMATED RETURN
Jacob Bauer Hamstring 1-3 weeks
Seth Campbell Adductor 1-3 weeks
Toby Nankervis Suspension Round 21
Josh Gibcus Hamstring 4-6 weeks
Jayden Short Hamstring 4-6 weeks
Mate Colina Back 7-12 weeks
Tom Lynch Foot 7-12 weeks
Robbie Tarrant Hip Indefinite
Kaleb Smith Ankle Season
Updated: July 11, 2023
Early prognosis
Richmond has said Short is running, is progressing well and will be "back pretty soon", but the club's timeline is still "medium-term". Bauer's debut ended after only a few minutes, but in a rare bit of good news, it's at the minor end of the scale. Colina's long-term back issue is resolving, and his focus for the remainder of the season will be building fitness, rather than VFL matches. Rhyan Mansell is now available for selection after serving a three-match suspension for rough conduct, while Nankervis heads to his own three-week break. – Sarah Black
https://www.afl.com.au/news/969092/medical-room-the-full-afl-injury-list-r18
How stuffen unprofessional can we be? Short running but still listed as 4-7wks. Embarrassing
Set back due to infection after minor surgery :help
Lynch? Gibcus?Set back due to infection after minor surgery :help
Sorry I must have missed something
Who had minor surgery that got infected?
Tom Brown wasn't it?Set back due to infection after minor surgery :help
Sorry I must have missed something
Who had minor surgery that got infected?
Lynch? Gibcus?Set back due to infection after minor surgery :help
Sorry I must have missed something
Who had minor surgery that got infected?
Mini's presser indicates Jayden Short will miss a further 4-6 weeks with a hamstring. WTF.
What is with these type of injuries and the length our players miss with seemingly innocuous injuries.
Lynch? Gibcus?Set back due to infection after minor surgery :help
Sorry I must have missed something
Who had minor surgery that got infected?
Both of those were anything but minor surgeries
Mini's presser indicates Jayden Short will miss a further 4-6 weeks with a hamstring. WTF.
What is with these type of injuries and the length our players miss with seemingly innocuous injuries.
Mini's presser indicates Jayden Short will miss a further 4-6 weeks with a hamstring. WTF.
What is with these type of injuries and the length our players miss with seemingly innocuous injuries.
WTF is right .. the following was said by the club only a few days ago ...
Jayden Short, hamstring
"Shorty's jumping out of his skin to get back, as everyone would expect. He's running, things are progressing really well.... We'll see Jayden back pretty soon."
How does that turn into 4-6???????????
Mini's presser indicates Jayden Short will miss a further 4-6 weeks with a hamstring. WTF.
What is with these type of injuries and the length our players miss with seemingly innocuous injuries.
WTF is right .. the following was said by the club only a few days ago ...
Jayden Short, hamstring
"Shorty's jumping out of his skin to get back, as everyone would expect. He's running, things are progressing really well.... We'll see Jayden back pretty soon."
How does that turn into 4-6???????????
What the hell is going on with Gibcus, wishy washy reporting, no clear concise reports, poor bugger, I bet he wish he never let the choppers get hold of him
When is Jayden back ??The Club website said 4-6 weeks last week. So, another 3-5 weeks now based on that.
When is Jayden back ??The Club website said 4-6 weeks last week. So, another 3-5 weeks now based on that.
Fingers crossed you're right, TK. AFL website now saying 1-3 weeks so it's possible.When is Jayden back ??The Club website said 4-6 weeks last week. So, another 3-5 weeks now based on that.
That’s the afl website who are just guessing based on the short/medium/long term that the club list them at. I see the clubs not downgraded him to short term. I reckon he’ll be back next week.
Fingers crossed you're right, TK. AFL website now saying 1-3 weeks so it's possible.When is Jayden back ??The Club website said 4-6 weeks last week. So, another 3-5 weeks now based on that.
That’s the afl website who are just guessing based on the short/medium/long term that the club list them at. I see the clubs not downgraded him to short term. I reckon he’ll be back next week.
I’ve heard we are icing Gibcus and getting him ready for next year
Gibcus ruled out for the year.Thanks pmac.
You can say what you want how does a bad hamstring keep player out for the year even if it was off the bone at his young age to much bs all year we herd from the injury front time to be accountable.
You can say what you want how does a bad hamstring keep player out for the year even if it was off the bone at his young age to much bs all year we herd from the injury front time to be accountable.
Off the bone, with serious infection after surgery not caused by anything done by S&C but just bad luck. Muscle wastes due to infection. No surprise
Club takes a super conservative approach despite the kid wanting to play and folks still complain
I can only imagine the reaction if they had played him when he wasn't right and he did long term damage
Seems people want a bob each way
You can say what you want how does a bad hamstring keep player out for the year even if it was off the bone at his young age to much bs all year we herd from the injury front time to be accountable.
Off the bone, with serious infection after surgery not caused by anything done by S&C but just bad luck. Muscle wastes due to infection. No surprise
Club takes a super conservative approach despite the kid wanting to play and folks still complain
I can only imagine the reaction if they had played him when he wasn't right and he did long term damage
Seems people want a bob each way
Mate Treloar ripped 2 hammies off the bone and returned in the same season something dearly wrong for all the relapses to happen.
Mate Treloar ripped 2 hammies off the bone and returned in the same season something dearly wrong for all the relapses to happen.
Mate Treloar ripped 2 hammies off the bone and returned in the same season something dearly wrong for all the relapses to happen.
And has been popping his hammy every season since.
Also he didn't have any infection the infection this is significant. Any chance you can acknowledge that? You that maybe just maybe it has had a bearing on the seriousness of his injury
BTW a Richmond legend had to retire because after ripping his hammy off the bone it never healed enough for him to get back no matter how hard he tried
I can acknowledge it mate , but seems we have had way to much bad luck on the injury front to much sugar coating. About time you acknowledge that standards have dropped 💯 in our football department since our flag years bigtime don't give us this covid rubbish because most clubs running full capacity now. Very simple we took a short cut with this appointment hiring within the bloke who worked under Burge who was basically sacked .
WP is like the head of Luke’s PR department. :rollin
Has anyone told the club there is only 1 game to go in the Season!