Football > Richmond Rant

Mike Sheahan's top 50

(1/3) > >>

mightytiges:
Only two tigers got into Mike's potential top 50 for 2005

39. Richo
41. Browny

Actually was surprised we had that many  :-\. Joel and Johnson didn't make it even though they were the top two in our B&F. Cogs is on Mike's injury and don't know what to do with list.

froars:
Well, as much as i like Richo, there has been nothing in his form that would rate him above Johnno or Bowden last year, so why he would be picked instead of them i wouldn't have a clue.
But either does Mike, so i'm not even going to bother to ask to see the full list if anyone's got it lol

JohnF:
Mike Sheethead's top 50:

1 N. RIEWOLDT St Kilda (31 in 2004)
2 C. JUDD West Coast (28 in 2004)
3 W. TREDRA Port Adel (7 in 2004)
4 B. HALL Sydney (10)
5 M. VOSS Brisbane Lions (inj)
6 J. HIRD Essendon (5)
7 N. LAPPIN Brisbane Lions (12)
8 C. CORNES Port Adelaide (48)
9 S. BLACK Brisbane Lions (6)
10 J. BROWN Brisbane Lions (4)
11 M. MICHAEL Brisbane Lions (25)
12 M. LLOYD Essendon (3)
13 M. SCARLETT Geelong (24)
14 M. RICCIUTO Adelaide (13)
15 J. AKERMANIS Brisbane Lions (16)
16 N. BUCKLEY Collingwood (1)
17 F. GEHRIG St Kilda (-)
18 B. COUSINS West Coast (14)
19 L. POWER Brisbane Lions (27)
20 P. BURGOYNE Port Adelaide (-)
21 A. GOODES Sydney (2)
22 S. CRAWFORD Hawthorn (8)
23 B. FEVOLA Carlton (42)
24 P. EVERITT Hawthorn (29)
25 A. McLEOD Adelaide (22)
26 J. WHITE Melbourne (-)
27 J. LEPPITSCH Brisbane Lions (18)
28 M. LAPPIN Carlton (-)
29 D. KERR West Coast (-)
30 L. BALL St Kilda (-)
31 C. JOHNSON Brisbane Lions (20)
32 C. LING Geelong (37)
33 A. McPHEE Essendon (-)
34 B. KIRK Sydney (41)
35 B. HARVEY Kangaroos (-)
36 J. CLEMENT Collingwood (-)
37 N. STEVENS Carlton (-)
38 D. WELLS Kangaroos (-)
39 M. RICHARDSON Richmond (49)
40 M. PAVLICH Fremantle (9)
41 N. BROWN Richmond (35)
42 A. EMBLEY West Coast (-)
43 C. BRUCE Melbourne (-)
44 B. JOHNSON W. Bulldogs (19)
45 D. COX West Coast (-)
46 C. FLETCHER West Coast (-)
47 L. HAYES St Kilda (17)
48 L. BARRY Sydney (50)
49 K. CORNES Port Adelaide (-)
50 G. ABLETT Geelong (-)


------------------------------------------------------
Barry Hall the 4th best player? lmfao
James Hird only the 6th best player? LMFAO
Nigel Lappin the 7th best? ROFLFMAOO
Scott West not in the top 50 players? ROOOOOOOOOFLMAOOOOOOOO


If he is judging players purely on their last season, then Bowden should be on that list before Richo and Brown.

If its judging players in the background of a flow on from previous years then its understandable that he's not there, but it's incomprehensible that guys like Hird should be outside the top 5 and buckley outside the top 15.

Bulluss:
I agree regarding Hird, should be atleast number 3 in my opinion.

Also think that Scarlett should be much higher than 13 and possibly at around number 5/6 as he wins many games for the Cats and is one of my favorite players outside of Richmond.

julzqld:
Does anyone really give a toss to what Mike Sheahan thinks?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page