One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on January 17, 2024, 07:39:38 PM
-
Injury Report: January 17, 2023
Pre-season injury update from Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan.
Tom Lynch, foot
"He's going really, really well. He's had four sessions outside now. Things are progressing as we planned. It's going to be a little bit of a slow build. Tom's very impatient of course, and we all want to get Tom out there and into the footy drills as soon as possible, but we need to understand that he had a really long period off, he had eight months without running. He's going to work his tail off to get back as soon as he can, but we need to be really smart and have Tom available for as long as possible this year."
Josh Gibcus, hamstring
"He's completing about 90 per cent of our drills. There's a couple more things we need to do before we throw him full into training. In saying that though, he's pretty much doing all of training. It's just one or two drills that we keep him out of. He worked so hard in his off-season and went away with physio Anthony Schache, who has also worked really hard with Josh. It's great to see him out there and he's going to continue to build up to practice games."
Shai Bolton, ankle
"He hurt his ankle with a minute to go of the Port Adelaide game (Round 24) last year, with a minute to go of the season. The surgery was really successful, it went really well. He slowly worked into some training just before Christmas, and since we got back from the break, he's pretty much been in everything. He's looking fantastic."
Jack Ross, big toe
"Jack's been carrying a sore big toe for pretty much all of last year. It was bugging him to the point where we decided on surgical intervention to help him. It's been a bit of a slow pre-season for Jack so far. But, in January we'll slowly build him up and have him ready for the start of the year."
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1481345/injury-report-january-17-2023
-
Richmond
Community Series: v Collingwood, February 27, Ikon Park
Dustin Martin (ankle): Took some steps back into training on Wednesday after being sent off to the rehab group after a minor ankle tweak. Should recover in time to face Collingwood.
Tom Lynch (foot): Unlikely for pre-season matches but the big forward has been running on grass and is still hopeful of playing in opening round.
Josh Gibcus (hamstring): The youngster has lifted to be included in almost all of training after a slow build to nurse through his worrisome hamstring. Should be cherry ripe for some pre-season action.
Jack Ross (toe): Off-season toe surgery has put the brakes on the winger’s pre-season, he is still building up fitness so is touch and go for a pre-season meeting with Collingwood.
Shai Bolton (ankle): No worries for Bolton, he had ankle surgery post-season but is back in full training.
Dylan Grimes (calf): The veteran is taking it easy and among the rehab group at the Tigers but club CEO Brendon Gale reckons he will play in opening round. Whether he faces Collingwood on February 27 is yet to be seen.
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/afl-preseason-injury-watch-for-all-18-clubs-ahead-of-februarys-trial-games/news-story/fe2a35abc3802853a89a33392a5488d1
-
Need to pee off Butcher Louie and get the bloke who fixed Shamar Joseph's toe.... :shh
-
Need to pee off Butcher Louie and get the bloke who fixed Shamar Joseph's toe.... :shh
Stitches and a painkilling jab. Yep just what we need ::)
-
Your mate Meehan would've amputated his foot... :shh
-
Your mate Meehan would've amputated his foot... :shh
Going a bit far their Dio
But he would definitely have been in the rehab group till after the July series in England
With an eye to getting him right for 2025
-
RICHMOND
Jack Graham (quad, three-to-five weeks) was the key casualty to come out of Richmond’s pre-season, brutally succumbing to the ailment very late in the Tigers’ final tune-up against Collingwood last Tuesday. Spearhead forward Tom Lynch (foot) has already been rubbed out of Richmond’s season-opener against the Suns, but the club is aiming for the gun goalkicker to suit up for its traditional early-season clash with Carlton. Premiership stalwarts Dion Prestia (hamstring) and Dylan Grimes (calf) overcame complaints to play against the Magpies, while improved utility Rhyan Mansell (syndesmosis, TBC) suffered an unfortunate setback in Richmond’s match simulation against Melbourne after an impressive pre-season. Emerging flanker Sam Banks (calf, test) is also under a cloud.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2024-injury-list-at-every-club-state-of-play-latest-news-casualty-ward-suspension-players-unavailable-for-round-1-opening-round-updates/news-story/ffef563d5a265e530c00d1257f86b938
-
Jacob Bauer ???
-
Dusty???
-
Nank out for R0.
Dusty in doubt.
-
Richmond Injury List:
Available
Nick Vlastuin, managed
Sam Banks, calf soreness
Test
Dustin Martin, corky
Unavailable
Rhyan Mansell, ankle (1-2 weeks)
Tom Lynch, foot (1-2 weeks)
Toby Nankervis, foot (1-2 weeks)
Jack Graham, quad (4 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC- Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC- Long Term)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/afl/injury-list
-
Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan gives an injury update:
Watch here: https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1500191/injury-report-martin-lynch-nankervis
---------------------------
Dustin Martin, corky
"Dustin received a knock towards the end of (Tuesday's) session. He was sent for precautionary scans which have cleared him of major damage, and we're going to monitor him over the next couple of days."
Toby Nankervis, foot
"Toby's been building his workloads over the last couple of weeks. Everything's going really well, really happy with how he's progressing. Toby will be unavailable this week and he's looking likely to play against Carlton."
Nick Vlastuin, managed
"Nick's trained fully since (missing the Charity Shield match). He'll be available this week."
Tom Lynch, foot
"Tom's put in an amount of work over the last six weeks. He's done a couple of main sessions now and he's got another really important session this Thursday. A few things to get through there and we're hopeful that he'll be available next week."
Rhyan Mansell, ankle
"Things have been really positive with Rhyan. He completed a really important session yesterday. He's going to get involved in some training on Thursday this week, and things are looking likely for a return to play in the next week or two."
Jack Graham, quad
"Jack was really unlucky in the last minute against Collingwood, he hurt himself. He escaped major damage and has been training, been back running since then. We're looking at around about a month out of footy."
Sam Banks, calf soreness
"Sam's been training fully the last two weeks. He'll be available this week."
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1500096/injury-report-opening-round-2024
-
Injury Report: Round 1, 2024
Available
Dustin Martin
Tom Lynch
Toby Nankervis
Rhyan Mansell
Unavailable
Jack Graham, quad (2-3 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1504184/injury-report-round-1-2024
-
Richmond Injury List:
Unavailable
Tylar Young, concussion protocols (1 week)
Jack Graham, quad (2-3 weeks)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (TBC)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/afl/injury-list
-
What’s actually happened to Fawcett ?
-
What’s actually happened to Fawcett ?
Someone turned him off.
-
What’s actually happened to Fawcett ?
Someone turned him off.
:snidegrin
-
Where is Bauer?
-
What’s actually happened to Fawcett ?
Someone turned him off.
Good god that is shocking !
-
What’s actually happened to Fawcett ?
Someone turned him off.
Time to tap out mate
-
What’s actually happened to Fawcett ?
Someone turned him off.
Time to tap out mate
They are going to slowly drip feed him back in
-
Hope he's not in hot water
-
Injury Report: Round 2, 2024
By Richmond Media
1 hr ago
This Injury Report is brought to you by nib. Live Health First with nib.
Scans have confirmed that midfielder Dion Prestia suffered a significant hamstring strain in Thursday night’s loss to Carlton.
Prestia felt the injury to his right leg late in the opening term and was subsequently substituted out of the game.
The Club anticipates Prestia will miss the next 8-10 weeks due to the injury.
Dion Prestia, hamstring
"Dion was going for a ground ball late in the first quarter and hurt his hamstring. Follow up scans have unfortunately showed significant damage. It's looking like a long-term injury for Dion, we're looking at an 8-10 week period of him being out."
Josh Gibcus, knee
"Terrible luck for Josh. He had to learn a lot of lessons last year of mental toughness and resilience. Josh is going to have surgery tomorrow (Thursday) to repair his ACL and he's going to miss the rest of this season. We're really confident that Josh will get a full preparation going in the next year, so the timing is not bad from that point of view. Josh is going to need a lot of support from his family and the Club, which he'll get. We're looking forward to seeing him again next year."
Tylar Young, concussion protocols
"Tylar was in a contest late in the second quarter and knocked his head. He was consequently checked and was given the all clear, and then over the half-time period developed symptoms. He's gone into concussion protocols and he'll miss this week. We'll make an assessment later in the week to see how he is for the following week."
Jack Graham, quad
"(He's going) really well. Jack's now completed some top-end sprinting and has almost completed his kicking progressions. He'll drip-feed back into some group skills next week and we're looking at another week or two before he's back available."
Liam Fawcett, back
"Liam had a scan a couple of days ago which showed some really good progress with his back oedema. We're looking at around about a month's time having another follow up scan to hopefully progress him back into running."
(**oedema = Oedema is a build-up of fluid in the body which causes the affected tissue to become swollen from https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/conditions/oedema#:~:text=Oedema%20is%20a%20build%2Dup,general%2C%20depending%20on%20the%20cause.)
Mate Colina, back
"(He's) on a pretty similar timeline (to Fawcett). He had a follow up scan the other day and things are progressing well. He's probably in similar boat to Liam, in around about a month looking to get going again."
Richmond Injury List:
Unavailable
Tylar Young, concussion protocols (1 week)
Jack Graham, quad (2-3 weeks)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (8-10 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1510705/injury-report-round-2-2024
-
Is Colina ever not injured? Swear the bloke has been on the injury list for 5 years.
They'll keep listing him when he's back playing basketball after he's delisted
-
Still no mention of Bauer....have to start asking questions if he's not named on the VFL side again either.... :shh
-
Still no mention of Bauer....have to start asking questions if he's not named on the VFL side again either.... :shh
He trained fully yesterday. Apparently was "managed" due to hamstring awareness and missed the 2 VFL praccy matches.
-
Still no mention of Bauer....have to start asking questions if he's not named on the VFL side again either.... :shh
He trained fully yesterday. Apparently was "managed" due to hamstring awareness and missed the 2 VFL praccy matches.
thanks!
best news of this thread
-
Still no mention of Bauer....have to start asking questions if he's not named on the VFL side again either.... :shh
He trained fully yesterday. Apparently was "managed" due to hamstring awareness and missed the 2 VFL praccy matches.
Cheers...good to see at least somebody knows and cares to inform us.... :shh
-
INJURY REPORT
Injury Report: Round 3, 2024
Get the latest injury update from Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan ahead of Sunday's Round 3 clash with Sydney at the MCG.
By Richmond Media
1 hr ago
Get the latest injury update from Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan ahead of Sunday's Round 3 clash with Sydney at the MCG
Jacob Hopper, knee
"(Hopper) pulled up quite sore after the Carlton game (Round 1). We thought we would give him every chance to be available for Port Adelaide, but as the week progressed, it became clear after a scan that he needed an arthroscope on his knee. He's looking like missing around about four weeks."
Nathan Broad, calf soreness
"Similar to (Hopper), Nathan was a little bit sore post-game against Carlton and as the week progressed, it just became too risky to play him. We're really confident he'll be available this week."
Maurice Rioli, back
"'MJ' hurt his back during the first warm up. It's on the minor side, we're pretty confident he will be available this week."
Tylar Young, concussion protocols
"Tylar's feeling really good. He's going to train fully this week and be available (for the Sydney game)."
James Trezise, ankle
"(The incident happened) halfway through the third quarter. James is actually quite lucky he didn't snap his leg. He's suffered a moderate syndesmosis injury. He's in a moon boot now and he'll progress into running in a couple of weeks' time and be available in around about a month."
Jack Graham, quad
"Jack's going to join in some drills this week, and it's looking like Gather Round back in Adelaide will be when Jack returns."
Josh Gibcus, knee
"From all reports (his ACL surgery went) really well. He's already starting to set goals, and he's looking forward to getting back into the Club and attacking his rehab."
Dion Prestia, hamstring
"Dion's going really well. He's running, he's actually as determined as I've ever seen him to return. Things are looking good and we can't wait to see him back out there."
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Tylar Young, concussion protocols
Nathan Broad, calf soreness
Mathew Coulthard, illness
Maurice Rioli, back
Unavailable
Jack Graham, quad (1-2 weeks)
James Trezise, ankle (4-6 weeks)
Jacob Hopper, knee (4-6 weeks)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (8 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1515439/injury-report-round-3-2024
-
Hopper is officially a disaster.
Young and broad ready to come back… for who? The only one who deserves to
Be dropped Is grimes and obviously trezise is out
-
tried to tell a few on here but they defended the decision and also the man himself. Crickets at the moment from a few of them :shh
the bloke is a very average footballer and was not required. He was also average at gws, and his numbers and body prove that.
GWS made out like they gaf but in reality never gave a flying stuff about hopper and i suspect TT. The main guy they loved is in brownlow medal form and he was the one they wanted all along.
-
I’ll defend hopper because he is getting criticism for a deal that should be directed at the club.
He is better than an average footballer for sure but the constant injuries aren’t helping him to prove that. Again another thing I would criticise the club for as while I’m sure it isn’t the case, it’s hard to believe a full examination on his knee didn’t pick up anything that would have raised some concerns over handing the bloke a 7 year contract.
GWS’ were handed a treasure chest of first round picks which unlike GC they managed to mainly get right. They have willingly lost their early draft picks who have requested moves and replaced them with 2 new ones that they get in the trades. It’s a cycle that doesn’t seem to end unless they start being able to retain their players or missing on their early picks. Steele, shiel, Taranto, adams, hopper, Cameron, patton, treloar, the list goes on and on…..
-
I thought/think he's a good footballer but maybe his body is just going to let him down prematurely.
If that's the case then the club has to answer for the ridiculous 7 year contract he was enticed with.
-
In other news, under parliamentary privilege, MP Andrew Wilkie has alleged that he has been told by a former MFC doctor that the club (and all/most other clubs) are doing their own illicit drug testing and dropping players from their side under injury clouds such as 'hamstring soreness' so that they don't play when testing positive to performance enhancing drugs like amphetamine.
Wouldn't put it beyond the realm of possible myself.
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/mar/27/andrew-wilkie-tells-parliament-of-alleged-secret-drug-tests-on-afl-players-ntwnfb
-
Its %100 true and has been going on for years. Every club has players that do drugs
-
Its %100 true and has been going on for years. Every club has players that do drugs
Yep.
The COVID hubs were apparently rampant with female visitors and coke being thrown over the fences for the players. Heard it direct from a former RFC player who was there.
And they all knew about Dimma's new Mrs and largely didn't GAF, maybe bar Cotchin or players who were similarly close to him and his family.
-
tried to tell a few on here but they defended the decision and also the man himself. Crickets at the moment from a few of them :shh
the bloke is a very average footballer and was not required. He was also average at gws, and his numbers and body prove that.
GWS made out like they gaf but in reality never gave a flying stuff about hopper and i suspect TT. The main guy they loved is in brownlow medal form and he was the one they wanted all along.
So..when our starting midfield of Dow, Baker and Taranto walked out to start the game against Butters, Wines and Rose last Sunday, you didn't think we might miss this very average footballer?
-
tried to tell a few on here but they defended the decision and also the man himself. Crickets at the moment from a few of them :shh
the bloke is a very average footballer and was not required. He was also average at gws, and his numbers and body prove that.
GWS made out like they gaf but in reality never gave a flying stuff about hopper and i suspect TT. The main guy they loved is in brownlow medal form and he was the one they wanted all along.
So..when our starting midfield of Dow, Baker and Taranto walked out to start the game against Butters, Wines and Rose last Sunday, you didn't think we might miss this very average footballer?
at absolutely no stage during that game did i think gee we need hopper out there.
Did you when we were 2 goals up?
How were our mids including hopper going last year and against the suns in round 1?
IMO he makes no difference to where we are at as a club though what we gave up for him may.
a non goal kicking injury riddled mid that barely gets over 21 possys in a game is nothing to get excited about.
He may prove me wrong, but at 27 years of age he wont be around so i hope we get his body right which is unlikely with meehan and trade him.
-
Its %100 true and has been going on for years. Every club has players that do drugs
Yep.
The COVID hubs were apparently rampant with female visitors and coke being thrown over the fences for the players. Heard it direct from a former RFC player who was there.
And they all knew about Dimma's new Mrs and largely didn't GAF, maybe bar Cotchin or players who were similarly close to him and his family.
Yeah the cheating is pretty bad. I know multiple current and former players who said most of the guys will cheat on their partners
-
tried to tell a few on here but they defended the decision and also the man himself. Crickets at the moment from a few of them :shh
the bloke is a very average footballer and was not required. He was also average at gws, and his numbers and body prove that.
GWS made out like they gaf but in reality never gave a flying stuff about hopper and i suspect TT. The main guy they loved is in brownlow medal form and he was the one they wanted all along.
So..when our starting midfield of Dow, Baker and Taranto walked out to start the game against Butters, Wines and Rose last Sunday, you didn't think we might miss this very average footballer?
at absolutely no stage during that game did i think gee we need hopper out there.
Did you when we were 2 goals up?
How were our mids including hopper going last year and against the suns in round 1?
IMO he makes no difference to where we are at as a club though what we gave up for him may.
a non goal kicking injury riddled mid that barely gets over 21 possys in a game is nothing to get excited about.
He may prove me wrong, but at 27 years of age he wont be around so i hope we get his body right which is unlikely with meehan and trade him.
I thought we got absolutely comprehensively pulverised in the midfield all day, just not on the scoreboard until the second half. We missed a bigger bodied inside mid - Dow was pushed around like a little doll, Bakes did his utmost, Taranto did his thing, Ross was better, but there was nobody to get their hands dirty the way Hopper would have. We still would have lost, but blind freddie could see we missed him, and we'll continue to miss him until he's back.
Having said that, I'm not saying it was the best trade we've ever done, but, boy, did we need some inside presence then and we still need it.
-
Hopper was best on ground with 20 possessions to half time against Carlton.
Played the second half like a gimp and hasn’t played since.
I’ll read between the lines
-
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Dustin Martin, calf
Dylan Grimes, wrist
Jack Graham, quad
Unavailable
James Trezise, ankle (3-5 weeks)
Jacob Hopper, knee (3-4 weeks)
Noah Balta, knee (4-6 weeks)
Jacob Bauer, hamstring (4-6 weeks)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (6 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (10-12 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1520907/richmond-gather-round-injury-update
-
Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan has updates on Tom Lynch, Noah Balta, Dustin Martin, Jack Graham and Jacob Bauer ahead of Gather Round v St.Kilda.
Tom Lynch, hamstring
"Tom's going in for surgery tomorrow to repair the tendon at the back of his knee. The incident occurred really late in the game on Sunday, he was turning and got pushed and landed awkwardly. It's actually a really rare injury, for what has occurred, we've got a really experienced medical team here who haven't seen anything like it before. So, he goes into surgery tomorrow and we're looking at about a three-month layoff. Tom did a mountain of work to get back, he was in great condition, and unfortunately, these things happen. But, Tom's looking forward to getting stuck back into it, and we'll see him later in the year."
Noah Balta, knee
"I think it was in the last 20 seconds, a really critical contest that Noah was involved in. His right knee clashed with (Swan) Brodie Grundy, and unfortunately, he suffered a MCL sprain. We're looking at about a month out, he's in a brace at the moment and hopefully gets going in about two weeks."
Dustin Martin, calf
"Dustin suffered a pretty severe corked calf just prior to Opening Round. He's sort of been spluttering ever since, and we made the decision to pull him out of last week (Round 3). Since then, he's put together multiple sessions. He's looking really good, and we're looking forward to seeing him return this week."
Jack Graham, quad
"He is (on track to return for Gather Round). He's been working really hard the last month. He's done a mountain of work and I'm looking forward to seeing him on Sunday."
Dylan Grimes, wrist
"It's still pretty sore. In the third quarter against Port Adelaide (Round 2), he had an incident and hurt his wrist. Initially, we thought he may have broken it. Scans cleared him of any major damage, but he's still in a lot of pain. We thought we'd give him all of last week to get up, and unfortunately, he couldn't quite get through the main session. At this stage, we've still got another session to go, and we'll see how he is later in the week."
Jacob Bauer, hamstring
"Jacob hurt himself on our first or second session back from Christmas earlier this year. Since then, he's had a really interrupted training block. He put together a couple of weeks of training and we were looking to play him last week, but unfortunately, in the last session, he hurt his hamstring again. This in isolation is not a major issue, but we've listed him as medium-term to allow for him to bank some good training continuity before he returns."
Dion Prestia, hamstring
"He's tracking really well, he's putting together some good weeks of training. He's just starting to hit some intensity, we want him to get through a really strong block of work before we return him, and at this stage, it's still a few weeks away."
Jacob Hopper, knee
"He's going really well, he's starting to get function back in his knee. We're looking to start running next week, and hopefully we'll see him very soon."
James Trezise, ankle
"He's going well as well. He's out of his moon boot now, he's walking around. We're looking to start running soon, and he's on track for around about a month until he returns."
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1521476/injury-report-gather-round-2024
-
"We've got a really unprofessional medical team led by me"
Efa
-
"We've got a really unprofessional medical team led by me"
Efa
See this is where I get frustrated
He doesn't lead the medical team, that would be the head doctor, which he isn’t. So ridiculous statement
The constant soft tissue injuries are a disgrace and either he needs to look at his and his teams (that’s the S&C team) methods and adjust accordingly or the Club needs to look at him and his team and tell them to start getting it right or make a change
-
"We've got a really unprofessional medical team led by me"
Efa
See this is where I get frustrated
He doesn't lead the medical team, that would be the head doctor, which he isn’t. So ridiculous statement
The constant soft tissue injuries are a disgrace and either he needs to look at his and his teams (that’s the S&C team) methods and adjust accordingly or the Club needs to look at him and his team and tell them to start getting it right or make a change
Agreed it’s become a massive problem
-
4 soft tissue injuries (not including Dusty's cork) looking at significant lay offs. Every hamstring seems to be at least 6 weeks, up to 10-12 for the older blokes.
How does this stack up in the industry?
-
Surely the club will seriously look at this department.
I know luck is a factor but surely something isn’t right here.
-
"We've got a really unprofessional medical team led by me"
Efa
See this is where I get frustrated
He doesn't lead the medical team, that would be the head doctor, which he isn’t. So ridiculous statement
The constant soft tissue injuries are a disgrace and either he needs to look at his and his teams (that’s the S&C team) methods and adjust accordingly or the Club needs to look at him and his team and tell them to start getting it right or make a change
So when burge was in charge the plaudits came from everywhere. Our fitness levels, ability to overcome injuries and not have repeated injuries, peak at the right time etc
Well done burge what a legend.
Now he has left and there is virtually zero accountability.
Wake up. He took the job end of story. Had the job handed to him on a silver platter.
who knows why but we have loads of cash now so why are we not splashing it out and searching for the best in the country not some Kmart version
-
So many here we're defending him last year the same is happening this season in his department very poor. We're is the accountability ? .Tim Livingstone is head of Gale runs the club there accountable to.
-
Burge is back at Hawthorn. Check out their soft tissue injury list. Worse than ours
-
Burge is back at Hawthorn. Check out their soft tissue injury list. Worse than ours
matters little. I was referring to Burge at Richmond and believe me he would be crucified if he was still here.
During his time he served us well" is what i was referring to.
-
It's that bloke we had but couldn't afford because of the scarey monster SOFTCAP but Sydney could afford him no problem. :rollin
We are now stuck with the third string assistant that keeps using the same dodgy surgeon with the dirty scalpel.
-
keeps using the same dodgy surgeon with the dirty scalpel.
Hi Doctor Nick!!!!
-
Updated - April 9, 2024
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Dylan Grimes, wrist
Thomson Dow, ankle
Kane McAuliffe, ankle
Unavailable
Jacob Hopper, knee (2-3 weeks)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (3 weeks)
James Trezise, ankle (3-5 weeks)
Noah Balta, knee (4-6 weeks)
Jacob Bauer, hamstring (4-6 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (10-12 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/afl/injury-list
-
I see Prestia has dropped from the initial 8-10 weeks down to about half that.
Balta has blown out from initial 3-5 to 6-8 given time already served.
Bauer another kid with a long-term soft tissue - wtf.
Time to move on Colina immediately and also very concerning re: Fawcett - what's his deal? Had glandular over the pre-season now a long-term back issue at his age?
-
Fawcett was in the Club XIII room at halftime of the Port clash and said he would be running by end of April and full training at end of May.
-
Now Ross with a foot injury....are our blokes running laps barefoot on concrete at training or something? :huh :shh >:(
-
Now Ross with a foot injury....are our blokes running laps barefoot on concrete at training or something? :huh :shh >:(
all of them except Cumberland who is refusing to do so. This is why Mansell is better than him
-
Now Ross with a foot injury....are our blokes running laps barefoot on concrete at training or something? :huh :shh >:(
all of them except Cumberland who is refusing to do so. This is why Mansell is better than him
Has to learn to do the team things.... :shh
-
TT has busted his wrist now… :lol
-
TT has busted his wrist now… :lol
Yes RFC twitter saying Taranto has been sent for scans on his wrist
-
Omg this can’t be happening.
-
Lol
Waiting for the responses to this piece of news
-
Another one bites the dust #luketheripper :facepalm
-
Clearly S & C haven't scheduled enough wrist-strengthening sessions.
-
Has a team ever had such critical injuries like this before ? Arguably our whole midfield and our two best key forwards.
We are gonna find out about sonsie and McC now !
-
No 1 pick here we come
-
Can't do anything about that wrist injury but tell me which foot has Ross hurt. His second surgery this year on a foot or toe.
Yze said this “Unfortunately for Rossy they’ve found a bit of a stress fracture in his foot or his toe and he’ll go in for surgery,” Yze said.
-
Has a team ever had such critical injuries like this before ? Arguably our whole midfield and our two best key forwards.
We are gonna find out about sonsie and McC now !
I’m sure they’ll find a way to get injured next week 😂
-
Scans have confirmed that Richmond midfielder Tim Taranto suffered a fractured radius at training today.
The injury occurred late in the Club’s main training session, after an innocuous mishap.
Taranto will have surgery today to repair his wrist and is expected to miss an extended period.
Richmond General Manager- Football Performance, Tim Livingstone said the Club would have a clearer picture of the injury’s timeline after today’s surgery.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1527962/tim-taranto-injury-update
-
Yze today talking about our long injury list:
"It's not about me, you just feel for the players that are unavailable," Yze said.
"Irrelevant of where we sit and how we're going win-loss, we just want to see the kids play.
"So when you see some of your players walking around injured, frustrated, flat, that's worse than win-loss."
Lynch was back at Punt Road on Friday after his successful hamstring tendon surgery, and Yze confirmed he was in good spirits and would soon return to running.
Balta is out of a knee brace and was walking laps at training.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1106295/double-midfield-blow-adds-to-richmond-tigers-mounting-injury-toll
-
Yze today talking about our long injury list:
"It's not about me, you just feel for the players that are unavailable," Yze said.
"Irrelevant of where we sit and how we're going win-loss, we just want to see the kids play.
"So when you see some of your players walking around injured, frustrated, flat, that's worse than win-loss."
Lynch was back at Punt Road on Friday after his successful hamstring tendon surgery, and Yze confirmed he was in good spirits and would soon return to running.
Balta is out of a knee brace and was walking laps at training.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1106295/double-midfield-blow-adds-to-richmond-tigers-mounting-injury-toll
The group must be pretty flat with this many injuries
-
Either that or they're having a huge bender on the coke
-
Now Ross with a foot injury....are our blokes running laps barefoot on concrete at training or something? :huh :shh >:(
all of them except Cumberland who is refusing to do so. This is why Mansell is better than him
:lol :rollin
-
We’re down to 6 players left outside of the game day team. Pretty dire straits. You’d have to think these 6 players are extremely out of favour if they’re not playing
-
We’re down to 6 players left outside of the game day team. Pretty dire straits. You’d have to think these 6 players are extremely out of favour if they’re not playing
Think Grimes at the very least will be available for our next game. Given we’ve got the bye next weekend there might be a couple more who are available against the dees.
-
https://twitter.com/SamCohen81/status/1779366651592622565?s=19
Says it all
-
Tim Livingstone is head of football everything under him needs to take responsibility and accountability. Our last 2 seasons has been a shambles and it started hiring within.
-
Add another one to the list.
-
https://twitter.com/SamCohen81/status/1779366651592622565?s=19
Says it all
Omg yes please fmd
-
Toranto out for 8 weeks due to an injury he sustained at training. :help
-
From the AFL website:
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=1511)
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GLRPb8qaYAIux_g?format=png&name=900x900)
https://www.afl.com.au/matches/injury-list
-
From the RFC website:
Updated - April 16, 2024
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Dylan Grimes, wrist
Jacob Hopper, knee
Unavailable
Jayden Short, soleus (TBC)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (3 weeks)
James Trezise, ankle (3-4 weeks)
Noah Balta, knee (3-4 weeks)
Jacob Bauer, hamstring (3-4 weeks)
Jack Ross, foot (8 weeks)
Tim Taranto, wrist (8 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (10-12 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
Judson Clarke, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/afl/injury-list
-
Jayden Short, soleus (TBC)
Hmm
Soleus - same calf complaint Hopper had last year and it kept him out for at least 6 weeks
Soleus isnt a standard calf :whistle :shh
-
Latest injury update from Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan ahead of next Wednesday night's Anzac Day Eve clash with Melbourne at the MCG.
Jacob Hopper, knee
"'Hops' has been working really hard over the bye and has a couple of important training sessions to go. But at this stage, he is expected to play on Wednesday."
Dylan Grimes, wrist
"Same boat (as Hopper). Dylan's looking good to play next week, as long as he gets through the next couple of training sessions."
Tim Taranto, wrist
"Tim's actually ok. It was a pretty unfortunate accident at the end of training last week on Friday, in the last play of the last drill. He had surgery that day, we were lucky enough to get him in, and he actually went home that night. He has pulled up really well, hopefully he won't be out for too long, but at this stage, we're looking at a six to eight week period."
Judson Clarke, knee
"Unfortunate news for 'Juddy', he unfortunately ruptured his right ACL. It's actually the same ACL he hurt while he was an under 18 player. He's going to have surgery on Monday and is going to be out for the rest of the season."
Jayden Short, soleus
"It's a pretty minor soleus injury. He's going to be back running tomorrow and we're hoping he'll only miss one, maybe two games max."
Jack Ross, foot
"(His) foot surgery went really well. It's his fifth metatarsal, which can be a really tricky bone to heal. It was a really tiny crack that appeared in the scan shortly after the St Kilda game. We debated whether to treat it conservatively but in the end, given the nature of that bone, the decision was made to have a screw put in and we'll give Jack the best chance to have a strong finish to the year."
Tom Lynch, hamstring
"'Lynchy' pulled up well from his surgery. He's going to check up with his specialist today and we're hoping to get him running very soon, in the next couple of days, and we'll update you further."
Dion Prestia, hamstring
"Dion's going really well, he's really attacked his rehab hard. (We're) hoping to get him involved in some skills this week and he's a couple of weeks away at this stage."
Noah Balta, knee
"Noah's finally running, it's taken his knee a little bit to get over the initial injury. He's up and running now and we're hoping to get him going pretty soon. It's not going be the Melbourne game (his return), but hopefully it won't be too long after."
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1533177/injury-report-anzac-day-eve-2024
-
Tom Lynch's recovery time has dropped from 10-12 weeks to 8-10.
Noah Balta, Jayden Short and James Trezise chances to return next week.
https://twitter.com/_sjblack/status/1782666133377843227
-
I hope they don’t rush them back when they are not close to100% , a reoccurrence in the hope of winning a game and getting re injured would be counter productive.
-
I hope they don’t rush them back when they are not close to100% , a reoccurrence in the hope of winning a game and getting re injured would be counter productive.
Might be exactly what has happened with hopper
-
Put Hopper on the permanent injury list
Can keep meatballs company there
-
Luke "Plan B" Meehan working wonders at Punt road.
I really like how he has handled Jacob Hopper. :rollin
-
Luke "Plan B" Meehan working wonders at Punt road.
I really like how he has handled Jacob Hopper. :rollin
How did he handle him?
-
Where is WP??? What bs is WP going to spin tonight?
Ooh yeah I know. Meehan only looks after the VFL and not the seniors.
He should be sacked immediately.
-
Simply has to go....must go.... :thumbsdown
-
Simply has to go....must go.... :thumbsdown
Albo?
-
Where is WP??? What bs is WP going to spin tonight?
Ooh yeah I know. Meehan only looks after the VFL and not the seniors.
He should be sacked immediately.
I've just got home from the Dawn Service at the Shrine paying my respects to our Diggers
Getting a bit tired of your constant baiting Frankie. Fortunate for you I'm a mod so I let the constant baiting and cheap shots pass without issuing you with a strike
But anyways...
I will repeat this for the final time. Hopefully, you will actually read what I write in full, not grab the bits that allow you to ridicule and bait :banghead
I have no issue with you or anyone wracking Meehan for the things he is responsible for.. but to whack someone for things outside of their control simply because it suits an argument is foolish. That has been my position all along...Clear enough?
But...
I have posted a number of times that the number of soft tissue injuries is totally unacceptable and the entire S&C department, plus the medical team need to be reviewed and the Club needs to do it and act ASAP. It is embarrassing what is going on and Meehan and his team, need to be held accountable for the mess. And to hear the coach in his weekly pre-game presser make excuses for it was quite frankly pathetic and disgraceful
Can I make that any clearer for you?
-
Where is WP??? What bs is WP going to spin tonight?
Ooh yeah I know. Meehan only looks after the VFL and not the seniors.
He should be sacked immediately.
I've just got home from the Dawn Service at the Shrine paying my respects to our Diggers
Getting a bit tired of your constant baiting Frankie. Fortunate for you I'm a mod so I let the constant baiting and cheap shots pass without issuing you with a strike
But anyways...
I will repeat this for the final time. Hopefully, you will actually read what I write in full, not grab the bits that allow you to ridicule and bait :banghead
I have no issue with you or anyone wracking Meehan for the things he is responsible for.. but to whack someone for things outside of their control simply because it suits an argument is foolish. That has been my position all along...Clear enough?
But...
I have posted a number of times that the number of soft tissue injuries is totally unacceptable and the entire S&C department, plus the medical team need to be reviewed and the Club needs to do it and act ASAP. It is embarrassing what is going on and Meehan and his team, need to be held accountable for the mess. And to hear the coach in his weekly pre-game presser make excuses for it was quite frankly pathetic and disgraceful
Can I make that any clearer for you?
This is not on Yze for me his in a catch 22 can't co e out and criticise the department. Don't you think Tim Livingstone head of football should be accountable to his dead silent.
-
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2024-odd-hamstring-injury-for-jacob-hopper-knee-taped-too-tight-might-have-caused-injury-richmond-tigers-loss-to-melbourne-demons-adem-yze-comments-reactions-latest-news/news-story/71e88d1b2dc96b96de09006f1eafbe1d
-
Lol taped too tight, please.
-
Simply has to go....must go.... :thumbsdown
Albo?
Yes him too.... :shh
-
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2024-odd-hamstring-injury-for-jacob-hopper-knee-taped-too-tight-might-have-caused-injury-richmond-tigers-loss-to-melbourne-demons-adem-yze-comments-reactions-latest-news/news-story/71e88d1b2dc96b96de09006f1eafbe1d
Lmao ...runs a tight ship does Lukey Pookey.......#mustgo :shh
-
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2024-odd-hamstring-injury-for-jacob-hopper-knee-taped-too-tight-might-have-caused-injury-richmond-tigers-loss-to-melbourne-demons-adem-yze-comments-reactions-latest-news/news-story/71e88d1b2dc96b96de09006f1eafbe1d
Lmao ...runs a tight ship does Lukey Pookey.......#mustgo :shh
Amateur hour. Its like everyone's thought stuff it we won 3 flags, so lets just put the cue in the rack for our off field stuff for the next 5 years.
-
I don't subscribe to The Code
But from thier X feed
@codeafl
Will Marlion Pickett join Jacob Hopper on the sidelines next week?
@ralphyheraldsun has MRO details, plus news of Richmond's investigation into its horror injury run: bit.ly/4baI4ut
#AFLTigesDees
https://twitter.com/codeaflau/status/1783355276621733901?t=rNiWiBw5fctO2DBeup7X6w&s=19
-
Updated - April 29, 2024
Richmond Injury List:
Test
James Trezise, ankle
Jayden Short, calf
Unavailable
Noah Balta, knee (1 week)
Dion Prestia, hamstring (1 week)
Jacob Bauer, hamstring (1 week)
Jacob Hopper, hamstring (3 weeks)
Tim Taranto, wrist (6 weeks)
Jack Ross, foot (8 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (7-9 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBC - Long Term)
Mate Colina, back (TBC - Long Term)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
Judson Clarke, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/football/afl/injury-list
-
Ross 8 weeks looks like the season, Wasn't Fawcett supposed to return in May ?.
-
Who needs an injury update list when you were at a player sponsor function the night before ;D
Amazing what you find out when you ask players directly about their injuries, how they got 'em and how they are tracking comeback wise
I always have a giggle whe I think of what some post on here and wonder would people have the courage to say face to face what the post on here :rollin
And just on Jack Ross, wasn't there last night currently in a moon boot for at least another couple of weeks
-
If Balta, Bauer and Prestia are legitimately fit in one week we need to play them all.
Desperate for Balta at either end.
Need to see if Bauer will make a player.
Prestia to do another soft tissue before MSD.
-
Who needs an injury update list when you were at a player sponsor function the night before ;D
Amazing what you find out when you ask players directly about their injuries, how they got 'em and how they are tracking comeback wise
I always have a giggle whe I think of what some post on here and wonder would people have the courage to say face to face what the post on here :rollin
And just on Jack Ross, wasn't there last night currently in a moon boot for at least another couple of weeks
as if they will tell a nutter fan the truth and start bagging the staff in front of them. :lol
-
as if they will tell a nutter fan the truth and start bagging the staff in front of them. :lol
You calling me a "nutter fan" >:(
Hope for your sake you're not
-
Who needs an injury update list when you were at a player sponsor function the night before ;D
Amazing what you find out when you ask players directly about their injuries, how they got 'em and how they are tracking comeback wise
I always have a giggle whe I think of what some post on here and wonder would people have the courage to say face to face what the post on here :rollin
And just on Jack Ross, wasn't there last night currently in a moon boot for at least another couple of weeks
as if they will tell a nutter fan the truth and start bagging the staff in front of them. :lol
You would be suprised how open players are when they trust you :shh
-
Spell check, he meant nuther fan as in another
-
Who needs an injury update list when you were at a player sponsor function the night before ;D
Amazing what you find out when you ask players directly about their injuries, how they got 'em and how they are tracking comeback wise
I always have a giggle when I think of what some post on here and wonder would people have the courage to say face to face what the post on here :rollin
And just on Jack Ross, wasn't there last night currently in a moon boot for at least another couple of weeks
I wouldn't have any issue asking Colina how he managed to get free rehab from an AFL club and how has he convinced them to keep him around for so long considering how hopelessly unskilled he is
-
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GMiF-l8aIAAmKpi?format=jpg&name=large)
https://twitter.com/FOXFOOTY/status/1785824584174105023
-
Who needs an injury update list when you were at a player sponsor function the night before ;D
Amazing what you find out when you ask players directly about their injuries, how they got 'em and how they are tracking comeback wise
I always have a giggle when I think of what some post on here and wonder would people have the courage to say face to face what the post on here :rollin
And just on Jack Ross, wasn't there last night currently in a moon boot for at least another couple of weeks
I wouldn't have any issue asking Colina how he managed to get free rehab from an AFL club and how has he convinced them to keep him around for so long considering how hopelessly unskilled he is
And he’d most likely tell you to eff off and smack you in the nose.
-
Who needs an injury update list when you were at a player sponsor function the night before ;D
Amazing what you find out when you ask players directly about their injuries, how they got 'em and how they are tracking comeback wise
I always have a giggle when I think of what some post on here and wonder would people have the courage to say face to face what the post on here :rollin
And just on Jack Ross, wasn't there last night currently in a moon boot for at least another couple of weeks
I wouldn't have any issue asking Colina how he managed to get free rehab from an AFL club and how has he convinced them to keep him around for so long considering how hopelessly unskilled he is
And he’d most likely tell you to eff off and smack you in the nose.
I doubt it as he has a debilitating back injury since he arrived and he is very uncoordinated :rollin
-
Slow, unco, high centre of gravity ...duck and foot sweep..... :shh
-
If he misses you then I’m sure his cousin Noah will be able to mop up….
-
The Tigers are putting Prestia through an extensive training block while Balta pushed for selection this week, but Richmond took a "no-risk" approach with both.
"To have those guys close to selection, hopefully being available next week, is exciting," he said.
Yze noted the Tigers couldn't help some of their injuries, while small soft-tissue injuries made the situation look worse.
"The majority of our injuries have just been unlucky and ... it's a no-risk policy," he said.
"So yeah, little one-week injuries here and there are going to make it look worse.
"But ... we're going to support our players and make sure their welfare is the most important thing."
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1120543/light-at-end-of-injury-tunnel-for-richmond-tigers-gun-defender-jayden-short-set-to-return
-
If he misses you then I’m sure his cousin Noah will be able to mop up….
..his tears... :shh
-
Injury Report: Round 9, 2024
Noah Balta, Dion Prestia and Jack Graham will all face fitness tests ahead of potential returns weekend.
Key Richmond trio Noah Balta, Dion Prestia and Jack Graham are all a test to return to action for Saturday night's clash with the Western Bulldogs at the MCG.
Important midfielder Prestia suffered a significant hamstring strain back in Round 1, while athletic swingman Balta has been on the sidelines since the Tigers' Round 3 win over the Sydney with an MCL injury.
Hard-tackling midfielder Graham missed Sunday's Round 8 clash with Fremantle due to a hamstring complaint.
Meanwhile, developing forward Jacob Bauer is also a test to be available for the first time this season after recovering from a hamstring injury.
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Noah Balta, knee
Dion Prestia, hamstring
Jack Graham, hamstring
Jacob Bauer, hamstring
Unavailable
Jacob Hopper, hamstring (2 weeks)
Tim Taranto, wrist (4-6 weeks)
Jack Ross, foot (6-8 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (6-8 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBA)
Mate Colina, back (TBA)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
Judson Clarke, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1548477/injury-report-round-9-2024
-
“Hard tackling midfielder “ so by the clubs own admission he’s basically useless
-
“Hard tackling midfielder “ so by the clubs own admission he’s basically useless
Was a strange thing to say by the club. Must be there to increase his trade value. That being said I feel like he has generally always had good tackling numbers (not hard tackles) compared to his teammates. Could be wrong though.
-
To me that hardly boosts his trade value
-
What is going on with Fawcett?
-
What is going on with Fawcett?
Still waiting for the plumber..... :shh
-
Meehan Magic.... :shh
-
Four Tigers from the Dogs loss in for scans today:
- Maurice Rioli - syndesmosis, 8+
- Jack Graham - hamstring, 2+
- Seth Campbell - knee, in doubt
- Tyler Sonsie - wrist, should be OK
+ Sam Banks knocked out
Only 6 Tigers have played every game in 2024. Demons have 16, Swans 17
https://twitter.com/cleary_mitch/status/1789597410173558845
7news report here: https://twitter.com/TroutWoodend/status/1789581442705666149
-
Prestia got through though! Yay Meehan
-
Prestia got through though! Yay Meehan
I must say Prestia looked pretty fit
-
Prestia got through though! Yay Meehan
I must say Prestia looked pretty fit
Funny you say that, I thought he looked slimmer than usual too. Not his normal meatball look??!!
-
I struggled to watch it so can't comment much tbh.
I see he got a bit of ball though.
Still needs to retire this year.
-
Instead of an injury update maybe we should have a non injured update? It would be a shorter list 😂😂😂😰😰😰
-
Instead of an injury update maybe we should have a non injured update? It would be a shorter list 😂😂😂😰😰😰
:thatsgold
-
Oh wow, when I had the audacity to suggest the kids would get a run in the seniors , due to injury I wasn’t thinking every single one of them
-
Instead of an injury update maybe we should have a non injured update? It would be a shorter list 😂😂😂😰😰😰
:thatsgold
#meehanmagic :clapping
-
Horrible news regarding Rioli. Sums up this season. Suspect Graham will be out for at least 4 weeks.
-
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Liam Baker, soreness
Dylan Grimes, back
Unavailable
James Trezise, concussion Protocols (1 week)
Sam Banks, concussion Protocols (1 week)
Seth Campbell, knee (1-2 weeks)
Jack Graham, hamstring (1-2 weeks)
Jacob Hopper, hamstring (2-3 weeks)
Tim Taranto, wrist (3-4 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (4-6 weeks)
Jack Ross, foot (6-8 weeks)
Maurice Rioli, ankle (8-10 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBA)
Mate Colina, back (TBA)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
Judson Clarke, knee (season)
-----------------
Richmond youngster Maurice Rioli Jnr will miss 8-10 weeks as he recovers from the syndesmosis injury that he suffered late in Saturday’s match against the Western Bulldogs.
Rioli Jnr, 21, had surgery today to repair his ankle. The youngster had been a strong contributor across eight games this season.
This Injury Report is brought to you by nib. Live Health First with nib.
Sam Banks remains in good spirits and is being monitored closely by Club Medicos after suffering a concussion in a heavy collision on the weekend.
Banks is unavailable for selection this week as part of the concussion protocols.
Jack Graham, who was substituted out of the game early in the third quarter, is expected to miss 1-2 weeks.
Graham felt tightness in his hamstring, with scans showing a minor strain, that he will rehabilitate before returning to action.
Youngster Seth Campbell will also miss the next 1-2 weeks due to bone bruising on his knee. The 19-year-old has featured in every game this season since debuting in the Opening Round.
In other injury news, Jack Dyer Medallist Tim Taranto is only 3-4 weeks away from playing as he progresses through his return from a broken wrist.
Rebounding defender James Trezise is also unavailable for selection this weekend after suffering a concussion in the final quarter of the VFL match.
Liam Baker (corked leg/soreness) and Dylan Grimes, who was managed last week due to a niggling back issue, are both listed as a test for this week.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1554776/
-
Last week Hopper was 2 weeks, this week it’s 2-3 weeks. Someone strap his knee and he redid it?
-
Ross was 8 weeks for how long it hasn't moved.
-
Graham with another potential 1 week hammy lmao
Let's give him a week off and see how he goes, straight back into the side :D
-
Graham with another potential 1 week hammy lmao
Let's give him a week off and see how he goes, straight back into the side :D
It wont be 1 week this time :shh :whistle
Ross was 8 weeks for how long it hasn't moved.
Saw him on Tuesday night at the Player Sponsors dinner wasn't in the moonboot
All up to the specialist to determine the whens
-
Graham with another potential 1 week hammy lmao
Let's give him a week off and see how he goes, straight back into the side :D
It wont be 1 week this time :shh :whistle
Ross was 8 weeks for how long it hasn't moved.
Saw him on Tuesday night at the Player Sponsors dinner wasn't in the moonboot
All up to the specialist to determine the whens
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
-
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
Get your point
But...
The majority of Clubs use the same surgeons, specialists in sports injuries
I'll be honest I don't get what it is people want.
Folks complain if we rush players back and they re-injure but then also complain if they are held back because the recovery takes takes longer
-
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
Get your point
But...
The majority of Clubs use the same surgeons, specialists in sports injuries
I'll be honest I don't get what it is people want.
Folks complain if we rush players back and they re-injure but then also complain if they are held back because the recovery takes takes longer
Want more accurate assessments on return to full fitness
-
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
Get your point
But...
The majority of Clubs use the same surgeons, specialists in sports injuries
I'll be honest I don't get what it is people want.
Folks complain if we rush players back and they re-injure but then also complain if they are held back because the recovery takes takes longer
It’s a tricky situation. It’s close to home for me as I have a high profile friend in the afl who’s career was nearly derailed by the surgeon stuffing up multiple times. Ending up sourcing a different surgeon privately.
Also I’m not sure anyone at this stage is against a recovery taking a little longer
-
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
Get your point
But...
The majority of Clubs use the same surgeons, specialists in sports injuries
I'll be honest I don't get what it is people want.
Folks complain if we rush players back and they re-injure but then also complain if they are held back because the recovery takes takes longer
Come on mate all we ask for is a bit of transparency the whole the department has been a mess last 2 seasons. Miatake after mistake we never learn just look at the Graham incident over the weekend. This is we're standards have dropped from our premiership years we take short cuts. Before we herd the exuse because of covid spending had to be cut what's the issue now. The first person I'm looking at is Livingstone as Blair is more on the contracts and recruitment side.
-
It's not supposed to be explained - that's why it's #meehanmagic..... :shh
-
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
Get your point
But...
:shh :shh
The majority of Clubs use the same surgeons, specialists in sports injuries
I'll be honest I don't get what it is people want.
Folks complain if we rush players back and they re-injure but then also complain if they are held back because the recovery takes takes longer
Thanks for proving our point then. If they all use the same surgeons then it must be the fault of your main man magic Meehan.
:shh
WP I think it's fair to say you are compromised in this discussion. How anyone can defend what has transpired this year is wild. Actually this dates back to his actual recruitment.
-
WP I think it's fair to say you are compromised in this discussion. How anyone can defend what has transpired this year is wild. Actually this dates back to his actual recruitment.
How am I compromised? Because I dont see an issue with a bloke after surgery being eased back into things when they healing process is taking longer than 1st thought. Seriously?
If you have surgery and your initially told the recovery period is x amount of weeks all going well and then you have a follow up scan and find things haven't healed to point it needs to be at to resume your job are you suggesting that you just ignore the medical advice and go back to work to more damage?
Is that what you are saying. Last time I checked that's not allowed to happen in the workplace so why should a footy club be any different. It is a workplace.
And what are you on about "his actual recruitment"? Sim and I were talking more about Jack Ross, not you fav Hopper.
-
Specialists and surgeons get things wrong and it’s up
To the club to learn from their mistakes by using the same surgeons and specialists (if they are)
Get your point
But...
:shh :shh
The majority of Clubs use the same surgeons, specialists in sports injuries
I'll be honest I don't get what it is people want.
Folks complain if we rush players back and they re-injure but then also complain if they are held back because the recovery takes takes longer
Thanks for proving our point then. If they all use the same surgeons then it must be the fault of your main man magic Meehan.
:shh
WP I think it's fair to say you are compromised in this discussion. How anyone can defend what has transpired this year is wild. Actually this dates back to his actual recruitment.
Might stop getting invited to the cocktail nights..... :shh
-
I don’t think our injury management was good through the dynasty years either. Difference being we were a great side that could absorb the injuries and most importantly we had everyone fit and firing in September when it mattered.
His whole appointment was suspect. Just another one of those where instead of hiring externally they promoted internally. Again don’t know if he was the best man for the job, although injury history in his reign would suggest otherwise, although it did reek then and still does now as a cost saving hire which I’d argue was the case with Steve Morris becoming VFL coach after Fly left as well as X being promoted to assistant coach in the seniors.
-
We had a great run in 2017 for injuries. Some oppos have suggested we were kissed on the willy by fate.
2019 less so, but managed to get most players fit and firing after the bye.
Regardless there has been a severe drop in fitness and durability over the last few years. The clear link is Meehan.
-
Yeah I do remember 2017 being almost essentially injury free, 2018 may have been pretty much the same. But 2019, 2020 and 2021 were certainly on similar levels to what we are experiencing now. I believe they were all years under the previous regime although I could be wrong about 2021.
-
According to Ch7 just now.
Lefau - suspected fractured jaw.
Mansell - concussion. Out for a week under the protocol.
-
stuffen Taking the pee now
-
(https://i.makeagif.com/media/8-24-2015/FgKYim.gif)
-
...and now looks like Naishyte's done his ACL aagain .....
(https://i.makeagif.com/media/9-16-2019/ueTeTo.gif)
-
When is the mid-season draft?
-
...and now looks like Naishyte's done his ACL aagain .....
(https://i.makeagif.com/media/9-16-2019/ueTeTo.gif)
Maybe not the best time to use your juvenile nicknames on a dude that’s just done his ACL for the 4th time most likely ending his career.
-
When is the mid-season draft?
Wednesday, May 29.
-
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GN2s-M1akAAaOrp?format=jpg&name=medium)
https://x.com/TroutWoodend/status/1791778417899446634/photo/1
And add:
Lefau (possible fractured jaw)
Mansell (concussion)
Naismith (ACL)
-
Mate Colina seems to have been injured forever
-
Mate Colina seems to have been injured forever
This one is surely a definite de-list.
-
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
-
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Wasn't it a stress fracture or oedema?
-
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Wasn't it a stress fracture or oedema?
Unsure
-
Bauer out with quaddy.
Oh boy, if we don’t start getting anyone back in the next 1-2 weeks were legitimately going to struggle to field a full side.
-
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Maybe he’s tapped out?
-
There is something odd about the Fawcett situation...
-
There is something odd about the Fawcett situation...
No there isn't
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Wasn't it a stress fracture or oedema?
Unsure
Read it somewhere in this thread it is oedema
Found it
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum/index.php?topic=33233.msg765695#msg765695
-
There is something odd about the Fawcett situation...
No there isn't
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Wasn't it a stress fracture or oedema?
Unsure
Read it somewhere in this thread it is oedema
Found it
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum/index.php?topic=33233.msg765695#msg765695
That was March 20, now we are 2 months on ….
-
Tigers could have 20 players unavailable as injury crisis worsens
The Tigers' injury nightmare continues to worsen
By Sarah Black
5 hrs ago
RICHMOND is once again facing severely limited numbers as the Tigers' injury crisis intensifies, the unavailability list now a chance to hit an astonishing 20 players.
The Tigers have suffered yet another round of injuries, with Rhyan Mansell (concussion) definitely ruled out of Dreamtime at the 'G, while Sam Naismith tore his ACL in the VFL and is set to undergo his fourth knee reconstruction.
Richmond is now down to one fit ruck, captain Toby Nankervis.
Subbed out key forward Mykelti Lefau has been cleared of a broken jaw, but it remains to be seen if he will be declared fit to play.
Jacob Bauer – who has battled a hamstring injury this year – was also a late withdrawal from the VFL side, this time with a quad issue.
Teams must name a squad of 26 players (23 and three emergencies), and only Jacob Koschitzke, Samson Ryan and Kaleb Smith – who were emergencies for the Brisbane defeat – were left standing by the end of the VFL game.
If a fit three emergencies cannot be reached, there's a chance injured players will be named in order to make the minimum.
But Richmond will be hoping to regain Liam Baker (corked leg) and Dylan Grimes (back), who have both been sidelined for two weeks.
The Tigers will release their official injury list on Tuesday, but last week listed concussed pair Sam Banks and James Trezise as set to miss only one match, while Seth Campbell (knee bone bruising) and Jack Graham (hamstring) are outside chances to face the Bombers.
Richmond has used 39 players this year, comfortably the most of any side. The only Tigers yet to take to the field are long-term injured pair Liam Fawcett and Mate Colina (back), Bauer (who has been sidelined most of this season), second-year Kaleb Smith and category B rookie Oliver Hayes-Brown, who is currently playing in the VAFA, the level below the VFL.
RICHMOND UNAVAILABILITY
Approximate timelines, to be officially confirmed on Tuesday
Mykelti Lefau (jaw), TBC
Jacob Bauer (quad), TBC
Sam Naismith (suspected ACL), season
Rhyan Mansell (concussion), TBC
Liam Baker (corked leg), test
Dylan Grimes (back), test
James Trezise (concussion), test
Sam Banks (concussion), test
Seth Campbell (knee), 1 week
Jack Graham (hamstring), 1 week
Jacob Hopper (hamstring), 1-2 weeks
Tim Taranto (wrist), 2-3 weeks
Tom Lynch (hamstring), 3-5 weeks
Jack Ross (foot), 5-7 weeks
Maurice Rioli jnr (ankle), 7-9 weeks
Liam Fawcett (back), TBC/long-term
Mate Colina (back, TBC/long-term
Josh Gibcus (ACL), season
Judson Clarke (ACL), season
Oliver Hayes-Brown, playing VAFA
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1135054/richmond-tigers-could-have-20-players-unavailable-as-injury-crisis-worsens
-
There is something odd about the Fawcett situation...
No there isn't
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Wasn't it a stress fracture or oedema?
Unsure
Read it somewhere in this thread it is oedema
Found it
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum/index.php?topic=33233.msg765695#msg765695
That was March 20, now we are 2 months on ….
Yes and?
It is a condition that can take a very long time to correct, recover from. Get it wrong, rush him back before fully recovered ...well let's not go there ::)
-
There is something odd about the Fawcett situation...
No there isn't
Would like to know what is going on with Fawcett
Back, indefinite, really concise and insightful …NOT
Wasn't it a stress fracture or oedema?
Unsure
Read it somewhere in this thread it is oedema
Found it
http://oneeyed-richmond.com/forum/index.php?topic=33233.msg765695#msg765695
That was March 20, now we are 2 months on ….
Yes and?
It is a condition that can take a very long time to correct, recover from. Get it wrong, rush him back before fully recovered ...well let's not go there ::)
Ty 👌
-
So has Bauer actually done a quad ? stuffen unbelievable if so
-
the meehan curse strikes again. No problems with him though according to some. :lol
-
the meehan curse strikes again. No problems with him though according to some. :lol
Another clear bait at posters who don't agree with you. And this :lol doesn't make it OK it's still baiting
Final warning Frankie, keep it up and you will receive a strike
-
the meehan curse strikes again. No problems with him though according to some. :lol
Another clear bait at posters who don't agree with you. And this :lol doesn't make it OK it's still baiting
Final warning Frankie, keep it up and you will receive a strike
i should go back at some of your posts and issue you with a warning then?
You need to harden up. There was nothing wrong with my comment.
Be nice to obtain a reply?
-
Gez what a mess it is the department. Bauer hamstring how long it has taken to get right nearly 1 year pathetic now a quad related to it. How could people defend this rubbish. Where is our joint football department bosses Livingstone and Hartley ?. Say it again standards have dropped bigtime. Tim the club start investing in the footy department.
-
i should go back at some of your posts and issue you with a warning then?
You need to harden up. There was nothing wrong with my comment.
Be nice to obtain a reply?
Here's your reply >:(
When I realise I've crossed a line I do one of 2 things
1/ post an apology or..
2/ take myself off line for a time
Guarantee you'd never notice and you'll accuse me of lying
I don't need to "harden up".
Your constant snide remarks directed at those that heaven forbid don't agree with you is baiting and against site rules. It is disrespectful.
If we are being totally honest it borders on bullying but no doubt you'll disagree, make some comment about me being a lefty, woke and whatever else
Don't think it's asking too much for you to show your fellow posters the odd bit respect rather than your constant belittling of them
-
Hey WP, not trying to be a wise guy or anything but what does issuing strikes actually accomplish? Assume there is a 3 strike policy where a user is banned afterwards but couldn’t someone in theory just create a new account and keep posting away under the illusion of being someone else?
I see posts from time to time of people accusing other posters of being older posters under a new name so assume someone who is banned could just do the same thing if they so pleased?
-
I see posts from time to time of people accusing other posters of being older posters under a new name so assume someone who is banned could just do the same thing if they so pleased?
There are ones doing that currently
Formally known as TTII
-
Old mate Bents is the record holder for alt. accounts...is long overdue for another crack... :shh
-
nitro tiger is the record holder. use to post when he'd had a few!
-
Injury Report: Round 11, 2024
By Richmond Media
4 hrs ago
Get the latest injury update from Physical Performance Manager Luke Meehan ahead of Dreamtime at the 'G against Essendon on Saturday night at the MCG.
Injury Update: Round 11
Find out who is available to face the Bombers this Saturday night at the MCG.
Liam Baker, soreness
"'Bakes' is back full training, he'll be available on Saturday."
James Trezise, concussion and Sam Banks, concussion
"They're both feeling a lot better, will train all week and be available on the weekend."
Seth Campbell, knee
"He is (set to be available) as well. He's going really well, we'll see him on Saturday."
Sam Naismith, knee
"It's heartbreaking, isn't it? He's so important to be around the group though as a quality guy, and we saw that on Sunday when he got hurt, he was back out on the bench supporting the boys. It's going to be really important to have him around for the rest of the year and hopefully his rehab goes really well."
Ryan Mansell, concussion
"He's got a few headaches and not sleeping, all the usual concussion symptoms. We'll have an update early next week to see how he's going for the Geelong game."
Jacob Bauer, quad
"He was just a little bit sore coming off his first game back for a while, and we just took the cautious approach, given how much he's missed. He trained mostly today (Tuesday), and if he gets through training on Thursday, he'll be available again on the weekend."
Dylan Grimes, back
"Dylan's coming in and out of training, he hasn't completed a session yet. His back's sort of on and off sore. We'll just assess him as he goes over the next week or so. But at the moment, he's unavailable until he can complete training."
Maurice Rioli, ankle
"Surgery went really well, Maurice is back at the club, and he's attacking his rehab. We'll see Maurice later in the year."
Jack Graham, hamstring
"Jack's now in the same situation as pre the Bulldogs game (Round 9), he's flat out sprinting and involved in training. But, given that he did have a recurrence during that game, we're going to hold on for another week and have another week of training and see him against Geelong."
Jacob Hopper, hamstring
"(He's tracking) really well. He's just introduced himself back into some skills today, and, we're going to get a couple of weeks of footy into him before we see him again. So, it's looking likely the Adelaide game."
Tim Taranto, wrist
"Tim's going really well. He's been working really hard on his non-contact skills while he's had his broken wrist. He's also been working really hard with our speed coach Dan Bailey on his acceleration technique. He's doing as much footy as he can without contact at the moment. We're just waiting for a final tick off, but we're thinking likely the Adelaide game at this stage for his return."
Tom Lynch, hamstring
"Good news with Tom, his surgeon was really happy with where he's at. He was introduced today back into some skills. It's going to be really important to get a good block of football into Tom before we see him, and we're aiming for him to be returning before the bye."
Richmond Injury List:
Test
Liam Baker, soreness
James Trezise, concussion
Sam Banks, concussion
Seth Campbell, knee
Jacob Bauer, quad
Unavailable
Dylan Grimes, back (TBA)
Rhyan Mansell, concussion (1 week)
Jack Graham, hamstring (1 week)
Jacob Hopper, hamstring (1-2 weeks)
Tim Taranto, wrist (2-3 weeks)
Tom Lynch, hamstring (3-4 weeks)
Jack Ross, foot (6-8 weeks)
Maurice Rioli, ankle (8-10 weeks)
Liam Fawcett, back (TBA)
Mate Colina, back (TBA)
Sam Naismith, knee (season)
Josh Gibcus, knee (season)
Judson Clarke, knee (season)
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1559933/injury-report-round-11-2024
-
Grimes may as well retire
-
Grimes may as well retire
All that farm work has stuffed his back
-
Would be easier to nominate who’s fit
😁