One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 24, 2024, 10:52:02 PM
-
Hopper (hammy) will be a forced out as he rejoins our long injury list after only one game back :P.
Fire away with your changes?
-
Jon Ralph on Fox Footy said Short may be back next week but Balta and Prestia are at least 2 weeks away.
-
Sonsie & KMac2 for Hopper & Slowham surely.... :shh
-
Sonsie for Hopper surely.... :shh
Will he play he midfield though????
-
Sonsie for Hopper surely.... :shh
Will he play he midfield though????
Well yes that's the rub..... :banghead
-
Bring in Smith.
-
INS: Sonsie, Smith, Ryan****
OUTS: Hopper (inj), Pickett (susp), Naismith
**** I'd bring in Ryan but can see them bringing in Kosi.
I'd also bring back McAuliffe for Banks but they shot themselves in the foot by not playing McAuliffe in the VFL yesterday
-
Out Banks. Cannot stand soft players. Needs to spend weeks at VFL working on hardness, intensity etc. If he Cannot improve those parts of his game then delist. Makes early Hugo look tough.
-
Hopper (inj) -> Sonsie
Kmac -> McAuliffe
Banks -> Short
Naismith -> Ryan
However, I fear they will drop a cub like Campbell after one poor game.
-
Campbell's been ordinary for weeks #PolomkII#1gamewonder :shh
-
INS: Sonsie, Smith, Ryan****
OUTS: Hopper (inj), Pickett (susp), Naismith
**** I'd bring in Ryan but can see them bringing in Kosi.
I'd also bring back McAuliffe for Banks but they shot themselves in the foot by not playing McAuliffe in the VFL yesterday
Well seeing Marlion didn't get suspended he won't be and out. So no debut for Smith this week
And BTW I wouldn't bring in Short either. Calf injuries can be tricky, come back to early do it again and it's another 4-6 weeks. Besides he's been horribly out of form
-
In - Smith, Sonsie, McAuliffe, Kosi, Ryan.
Out- Banks , Graham, Hopper, McIntosh - Naismith.
-
We just need to play the like of McAuliffe, Smith, Green and Ryan. What have we got to lose. Give them match experience for next year. No point wasting time picking Naismith, McIntosh, Grimes and others etc etc. Our season is cooked. I want to enjoy watching the youth for the remainder of 2024. Having said that these kids have to compete and be hard in the contest. That's all we ask. You want to play AFL. Get tough immediately.
-
We just need to play the like of McAuliffe, Smith, Green and Ryan. What have we got to lose. Give them match experience for next year. No point wasting time picking Naismith, McIntosh, Grimes and others etc etc. Our season is cooked. I want to enjoy watching the youth for the remainder of 2024. Having said that these kids have to compete and be hard in the contest. That's all we ask. You want to play AFL. Get tough immediately.
Kind of agree, to an extent. It's been proven over the years that it's better to bring young players through in competitive teams, rather than expose them to constant demoralising defeats. You learn faster in competitive games and situations. So you need a good mix of experienced players and young players, rotate them through in blocks of games if possible.
-
No way drop banks for short . Short isn't our future and gas been poor all year.
Campbell needs a spell. Been ordinary since his first 3 weeks
-
INS: Sonsie, Smith, Ryan****
OUTS: Hopper (inj), Pickett (susp), Naismith
**** I'd bring in Ryan but can see them bringing in Kosi.
I'd also bring back McAuliffe for Banks but they shot themselves in the foot by not playing McAuliffe in the VFL yesterday
Well seeing Marlion didn't get suspended he won't be and out. So no debut for Smith this week
And BTW I wouldn't bring in Short either. Calf injuries can be tricky, come back to early do it again and it's another 4-6 weeks. Besides he's been horribly out of form
Regardless of whether Marlion is playing Smith needs to be brought in. His form merits selection. Would be good to give him experience.
-
Out
Hopper (inj)
Campbell (rest)
Naismith (omit)
Kmac (omit)
Mansell (omit)
In
McAuliffe
Sonsie
Ryan
Smith
Kosi
-
Team Tips:
The Tigers were average at best on Anzac Eve, and will benefit greatly from the potential inclusions of Jayden Short and Noah Balta this Sunday, should they prove their fitness during the week. Rhyan Mansell was quiet, and may come under a selection cloud with their impending inclusions. Emergencies from last Wednesday Jacob Koschitzke and Tyler Sonsie performed well, with Koschitzke kicking four goals straight in the reserves’ 20-point win over Casey. Sonsie was best on ground with his 32 disposals, 10 clearances, seven inside 50’s and a goal. Matthew Coulthard also kicked three goals in his second VFL game for the season.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2024-round-8-team-tips-predicted-sides-squads-ins-and-outs-team-changes-injury-news-latest-supercoach/news-story/03d1a5433477678799b35aacebb6dd0e
--------------------
Jayden Short (calf) and James Trezise (ankle) are available for selection this week, with Balta, Prestia and Bauer likely to be in the mix to face the Western Bulldogs next round. – Sarah Black
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1119507/medical-room-the-full-afl-injury-list-r8
-
Would like to see Sonsie in the guts and Coultard forward
-
Would like to see Sonsie in the guts and Coultard forward
Watch the VFL and you will...... :shh
-
Would like to see Sonsie in the guts and Coultard forward
Watch the VFL and you will...... :shh
😂😂
-
Won't happen but you could make 7 realistic changes.
-
No way drop banks for short . Short isn't our future and gas been poor all year.
Campbell needs a spell. Been ordinary since his first 3 weeks
Reckon Sam has struggled all four games he has played and needs to go back again. Give me a kid in great form in Smith.
Campbell has struggled his last couple, my concern is he has not kicked a goal for five weeks. kicking goals is killing us as a whole.
A spell wont hurt him atm give me the extra tall fwd Kossie please who just bagged four in the two's..
Mansell has been poor in his last three games and has not managed a goal in that time. Give me Coulthard a goal kicker..
McIntosh imo has been ordinary in all seven games and as a winger has not kicked a goal all year. Ralphsmith stays. :o
Graham has played three games and has been average to poor and not managed a goal. Sonsie please.
Hopper is injured logical replacement is McAuliffe nice big body for a big body onball.
Naismith well i like him but we need a goalkicking ruck and Ryan has been doing that so Ryan please.
Would be very tempted to make Trezise the sub but maybe some game time in the two,s first.
Big no to Short has done nothing to warrant automatic selection and like others needs to play reserves and earn his spot back.
-
In the Mix: Round 8
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
1 May 2024
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=1511)
Jayden Short (calf) will be a welcome return, while Jacob Hopper (hamstring) will come out of the side. Draftee Kane McAuliffe was held out of the VFL game as an emergency for the seniors, while Tyler Sonsie (rarely used as a midfielder at AFL level) dominated Casey with 32 disposals and 10 clearances. The winger permutations are interesting, with Adem Yze last week opting to deploy Marlion Pickett as a tagger and shunting Kamdyn McIntosh to the sub. Hugo Ralphsmith played one of his better games on the wing, so if space on the outside is needed for Short, one of McIntosh or Sam Banks could make way. Given Fremantle plays two genuine rucks, it'd be surprising if Yze swapped out Sam Naismith for Jacob Koschitzke, despite the latter kicking four goals in the VFL.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1119512/in-the-mix-r8-whos-under-the-pump-pushing-for-selection