One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 22, 2010, 05:39:35 PM
-
Richmond
B: Edwards, McGuane, Dea
HB: Tambling, Moore, Newman
C: Martin, Deledio, Cotchin
HF: Taylor, Riewoldt, Foley
F: Nason, Astbury, Cousins
Foll: Vickery, Rance, Tuck
I/C (from): Simmonds, Collins, Morton, Farmer, Polo, White, Nahas.
In: Newman, McGuane, Foley, Cousins, Polo, Nahas.
Out: Jackson (inj - leg), Hislop (inj - leg), Post.
-
Fremantle
B: Jay van Berlo, Chris Tarrant, Adam McPhee
HB: Greg Broughton, Luke McPharlin, Roger Hayden
C: Matthew de Boer, David Mundy, Paul Hasleby
HF: Michael Johnson, Matthew Pavlich, Stephen Hill
F: Des Headland, Chris Mayne, Anthony Morabito
Foll: Aaron Sandilands, Michael Barlow, Paul Duffield
I/C (from): Hayden Ballantyne, Rhys Palmer, Nat Fyfe, Clancee Pearce, Kepler Bradley, Ryan Crowley, Alex Silvagni
In: Fyfe, Palmer, Bradley
Out: -
New: Nat Fyfe (Claremont)
-
side is looking better
i reckon blingers is wher he should be finally
deledio isnt dirty enough to play centre, would rather have foley in there or martin
and have lids either on the wing or hff
collins white and naha shoul dbe the 3 ommitted
-
80 point lose with this line up
-
Rance - Ruck Rover???
???
-
Still persisting with Simmonds I see :banghead
-
At least Hislop out. Need Will back. Good news Foley and Newman back. We are going to get thumped in the ruck need to be able to rover Sandliands taps otherwise we are stuffed
-
rance as a big bodied mid may be a surprise
remember we unleashed richo on the wing v freo at subi
ok im dreaming
-
i wouldnt be taking any notice of the positions. meaningless
-
Newman is of interest,quick recovery from a hammy ::).
Strong mail he wasnt injured at all ;)
-
Some pretty good ins. Side looks a little more balanced.
Would have liked to have seen Webberley promoted.
-
80 point lose with this line up
That's what you will hope to see when you look for the result in Mondays paper 8)
-
Edwards still in... ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'(
-
I also think we will really really miss Jacksons hardness at the ball, while I know he has his critics for his disposal he is one of the hardest at the ball in the team. He will be missed IMO.
-
Richmond
B: Edwards, McGuane, Dea
HB: Tambling, Moore, Newman
C: Martin, Deledio, Cotchin
HF: Taylor, Riewoldt, Foley
F: Nason, Astbury, Cousins
Foll: Vickery, Rance, Tuck
I/C (from): Simmonds, Collins, Morton, Farmer, Polo, White, Nahas.
In: Newman, McGuane, Foley, Cousins, Polo, Nahas.
Out: Jackson (inj - leg), Hislop (inj - leg), Post.
this would be my team v Fremantle.
B: Dea, Moore, Newman
HB: Rance, McGuane, Tuck
C: Cousins, Cotchin, Collins
HF: Tambling, Riewoldt, Deledio
F: Taylor, Astbury, Morton
Foll: Vickery, Foley, Martin
I/C: Simmonds, White, Polo, Nason
:)
-
Richmond
B: Edwards, McGuane, Dea
HB: Tambling, Moore, Newman
C: Martin, Deledio, Cotchin
HF: Taylor, Riewoldt, Foley
F: Nason, Astbury, Cousins
Foll: Vickery, Rance, Tuck
I/C (from): Simmonds, Collins, Morton, Farmer, Polo, White, Nahas.
In: Newman, McGuane, Foley, Cousins, Polo, Nahas.
Out: Jackson (inj - leg), Hislop (inj - leg), Post.
this would be my team v Fremantle.
B: Dea, Moore, Newman
HB: Rance, McGuane, Tuck
C: Cousins, Cotchin, Collins
HF: Tambling, Riewoldt, Deledio
F: Taylor, Astbury, Morton
Foll: Vickery, Foley, Martin
I/C: Simmonds, Nason, Polo, Nason
:)
Nason will get sick of sitting on the bench twice..... ;D
-
I also think we will really really miss Jacksons hardness at the ball, while I know he has his critics for his disposal he is one of the hardest at the ball in the team. He will be missed IMO.
miss jackson , and u bag edwards!!!! fanta pants is a bigger clanger king than edwards
-
Edwards still in... ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'(
Ever thought the coaches might see him differently to you
I think you'll be "ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'("ing a lot this season
-
edwards is having a go, breaking the lines , not his fault he is in a team which cant get it right
anyway we match up well v freo, we may surprise a few this week
-
Edwards still in... ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'(
Ever thought the coaches might see him differently to you
I think you'll be "ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'("ing a lot this season
Really Infamy and here I was thinking that a forum is the place to have your say. Many spend time here bagging each other e.g. you and Jack,,,, and others bag the club. I don't think Edwards should be in the team and against every side so far this year he has done very little to sway me otherwise.
I can't control the coaching staff or who they pick and that will never change, but I can still have my say.. :thumbsup
-
Edwards still in... ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'(
Ever thought the coaches might see him differently to you
I think you'll be "ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'("ing a lot this season
Really Infamy and here I was thinking that a forum is the place to have your say. Many spend time here bagging each other e.g. you and Jack and many bag the club. I don't think Edwards should be in the team and against every side so far this year he has done very little to sway me otherwise.
I can't control the coaching staff or who they pick and that will never change, but I can still have my say.. :thumbsup
When on earth have you seen me bag the club?
-
Edwards still in... ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'(
Ever thought the coaches might see him differently to you
I think you'll be "ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'("ing a lot this season
Really Infamy and here I was thinking that a forum is the place to have your say. Many spend time here bagging each other e.g. you and Jack and many bag the club. I don't think Edwards should be in the team and against every side so far this year he has done very little to sway me otherwise.
I can't control the coaching staff or who they pick and that will never change, but I can still have my say.. :thumbsup
When on earth have you seen me bag the club?
Please re-read the post I said "Many spend time here bagging each other e.g. you and Jack and many bag the club".
-
Please re-read the post I said "Many spend time here bagging each other e.g. you and Jack and many bag the club".
Needed a comma to make your point correctly WAT - I read it the same way Infamy did but I get what you were saying now.
-
Please re-read the post I said "Many spend time here bagging each other e.g. you and Jack and many bag the club".
Needed a comma to make your point correctly WAT - I read it the same way Infamy did but I get what you were saying now.
F me, now I am getting nailed for gramatical errors, , , , anyway it's fixed sorry for the crossed wires... ;D
-
If you are going to play Edwards try him up forward. If Foley plays his toughness at the ball is similar if not better than Jackson's. So the loss of Jackson hopefully will not hurt us too much plus Foley is a much better kick for goal. Really need Thursfield in Defence. Agree with comments may surprise Freo.
-
we wont miss jackson, just like we didnt miss newman last wee
thursty will be missed, he was missed last week
want a hard player on the ball, through polo in the mix, hard as nails
freo will be in for a surprise this week
-
freo will be in for a surprise this week
Yeah can't wait to see their faces when our players run out stark bollocks naked.
-
:lol
we'd probably pick up a few thousand extra female members overnight
-
freo will be in for a surprise this week
Yeah can't wait to see their faces when our players run out stark bollocks naked.
:clapping
-
Richmond $10
Freo $1.03
-
I also think we will really really miss Jacksons hardness at the ball, while I know he has his critics for his disposal he is one of the hardest at the ball in the team. He will be missed IMO.
miss jackson , and u bag edwards!!!! fanta pants is a bigger clanger king than edwards
Such eloquence! ::)
-
:lol
we'd probably pick up a few thousand extra female members overnight
They might be a bit shy on tackling too with the blokes all watching :lol We might win a lot of hard ball.
-
Headcase is out for Freo.
Fremantle
B: Jay van Berlo, Chris Tarrant, Adam McPhee
HB: Greg Broughton, Luke McPharlin, Roger Hayden
C: Matthew de Boer, David Mundy, Paul Hasleby
HF: Michael Johnson, Matthew Pavlich, Stephen Hill
F: Nat Fyfe, Chris Mayne, Anthony Morabito
Foll: Aaron Sandilands, Michael Barlow, Paul Duffield
I/C: Hayden Ballantyne, Alex Silvagni, Clancee Pearce, Ryan Crowley
Emg: Kepler Bradley, Rhys Palmer, Dylan Roberton
In: Fyfe
Out: Des Headland (knee)
-
thats good as headland always hurts us
-
Richmond ------- Final 22
B: Shane Edwards, Luke McGuane, Matt Dea
HB: Richard Tambling, Kelvin Moore, Chris Newman
C: Dustin Martin, Brett Deledio, Trent Cotchin
HF: Troy Taylor, Jack Riewoldt, Nathan Foley
F: Ben Nason, David Astbury, Ben Cousins
Foll: Tyrone Vickery, Alex Rance, Shane Tuck
I/C: Troy Simmonds, Andrew Collins, Robin Nahas, Mitch Farmer
Emg: Dean Polo, Mitch Morton, Matt White
In: Newman, McGuane, Foley, Cousins, Nahas
Out: Daniel Jackson (leg), Tom Hislop (leg), Jayden Post, Mitch Morton, Matt White
-
Something wrong down at Punt Rd.
Collins , Nahas and Farmer get games in front of Morton ::) :banghead
-
Maybe he didnt follow team rules again...who knows?
-
Richmond ------- Final 22
B: Shane Edwards, Luke McGuane, Matt Dea
HB: Richard Tambling, Kelvin Moore, Chris Newman
C: Dustin Martin, Brett Deledio, Trent Cotchin
HF: Troy Taylor, Jack Riewoldt, Nathan Foley
F: Ben Nason, David Astbury, Ben Cousins
Foll: Tyrone Vickery, Alex Rance, Shane Tuck
I/C: Troy Simmonds, Andrew Collins, Robin Nahas, Mitch FarmerEmg: Dean Polo, Mitch Morton, Matt White
In: Newman, McGuane, Foley, Cousins, Nahas
Out: Daniel Jackson (leg), Tom Hislop (leg), Jayden Post, Mitch Morton, Matt White
Close to our best 22?
what players left out would be in our best side?
-
Thursfeild, Morton, Roberts, Connors, Post, Griffiths
^
the only players i can think of who would be close to our best side not playing this week
-
It is strange. As was Morton starting games on the bench despite being our 2nd highest goalkicker. Is he carrying some niggle? His defensive pressure not up to scratch for the coaching staff? Will there be a late omission? Makes no sense to me otherwise ???.
Simmo on the bench behind Vickery although it's hard to take the way the team's been named seriously with Rance as ruck rover ???.
Hardwick is sticking with the young debutants so he's sticking to his blueprint. Astbury and Jack in the KPP is getting closer to our future line-up. Add Griffiths eventually and move Jack to the 3rd tall forward role is the final piece.
-
Close to our best 22?
what players left out would be in our best side?
I don't think so
Too early to say that a bloke playing his 2nd game (in this case Dea) is in our best 22
Staggered Nahas got a game
-
ant believe collins and nahas ar in over polo
wtf
-
Dea had a shocker last game but i think he is in hardwick long term
plan and not too far away from his best side.
maybe more so in 12-18-24 months instead of now but he hopfully will continue to blood the kid
-
why is "Double M" (Mitch Morton) out?
???
Farmer, Nahas, Edwards, Nason, Foley - all under 180cm ???
glad to have Axel Foley back, spoke to a friend who is at Coburg and he said "Foley was a star last week, before he was benched for the rest of the final quarter." something like, Foley played the first 3 minutes of the last and that was it!
i think Polo and Morton are in the gun with Hardwick! when are their contracts up?
:(
-
why the hell would hardwick get rid of morton ???
-
Something wrong down at Punt Rd.
Collins , Nahas and Farmer get games in front of Morton ::) :banghead
so you reckon a forward having 1 shot on goal a week is doing enough to hold their spot ::)...not in my books partner
-
Something wrong down at Punt Rd.
Collins , Nahas and Farmer get games in front of Morton ::) :banghead
so you reckon a forward having 1 shot on goal a week is doing enough to hold their spot ::)...not in my books partner
And you think Collins , Farmer and Nahas can play AFL ?? Your on drugs partner ::)
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
-
why is "Double M" (Mitch Morton) out?
Been playing like crap would be a good start.
-
I don't think that's the reason, I think he is getting groomed to play a different role funnily enough. He has been playing further up the ground hence you havn't seen him near the goals nearly as much in the last few games. Looks like they want to test out the younger forwards a bit and perhaps see how flexible Morton can be. He is a good footballer so I don't think he will be missing long.
-
I'm tending to think along the the same lines as Owl. I think Hardwick is doing a lot of experimenting. Trying different structures and different players just to have a look-see.
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
Biggest problem at punt road has been holding on to players who CANNOT play.
Other clubs just keeping turning them over early.
Example of this would be the disgracefull and farcical decision to delist/rookie/promote Cam Howat 3 years in a row,
Its obvious to all except RFC that all 3 wont make it. Collins should be playing netball is way too timid, Likewise Nahas who is way too small, and Farmer tries but isnt up to it, Add White, Rance , King ,Polak, McMahon,Hislop and Graham and there is the receipe for the Wooden Spoon, HARSH BUT TRUE !
There is 10 players ( a quarter of the list ) who wouldnt get a game at another club
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
Biggest problem at punt road has been holding on to players who CANNOT play.
Other clubs just keeping turning them over early.
Example of this would be the disgracefull and farcical decision to delist/rookie/promote Cam Howat 3 years in a row,
Its obvious to all except RFC that all 3 wont make it. Collins should be playing netball is way too timid, Likewise Nahas who is way too small, and Farmer tries but isnt up to it, Add White, Rance , King ,Polak, McMahon,Hislop and Graham and there is the receipe for the Wooden Spoon, HARSH BUT TRUE !
There is 10 players ( a quarter of the list ) who wouldnt get a game at another club
Hey Mods !!!!
Is there a Block posts from a specific user function?
If not then this constant crap should motivate you to investigate adding it to the forums. I know I wouldnt be the only one using it for this user
-
Well the Morton for Nahas move IMO may wark, Morton doesn't even look like he is interested these days to be honest. Yeah sure he runs around the mark and kicks one maybe two goals a game but does he work as hard as Nahas, not IMO. nahas is aslo a much better tackler and applies 100% more forward pressure than Morton. This may free some space up for Nahas to work in the forward line and up the ground a bit like he normally does. Don't write Nahas off totally because he hasn't had a great start to the year, not many players have. Remember least year, we all couldn't get enough of Nahas.
Don't bag this move until after the game.. :thumbsup
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
Biggest problem at punt road has been holding on to players who CANNOT play.
Other clubs just keeping turning them over early.
Example of this would be the disgracefull and farcical decision to delist/rookie/promote Cam Howat 3 years in a row,
Its obvious to all except RFC that all 3 wont make it. Collins should be playing netball is way too timid, Likewise Nahas who is way too small, and Farmer tries but isnt up to it, Add White, Rance , King ,Polak, McMahon,Hislop and Graham and there is the receipe for the Wooden Spoon, HARSH BUT TRUE !
There is 10 players ( a quarter of the list ) who wouldnt get a game at another club
Hey Mods !!!!
Is there a Block posts from a specific user function?
If not then this constant crap should motivate you to investigate adding it to the forums. I know I wouldnt be the only one using it for this user
Don't be silly FT, like that will happen.... :whistle :whistle :whistle :whistle ::) ::) ::) ::) We need people like that on the forum otherwise one of us decent people will turn into idiots... :lol
-
White who is an emergency didn't play today for Coburg.
Either a spare 23rd man to take over to Subi in case of a late injury to someone or a late change?
-
Thursfeild, Morton, Roberts, Connors, Post, Griffiths
^
the only players i can think of who would be close to our best side not playing this week
Thursty, Morton and Connors yes. The other three need to do more at VFL level before being promoted or in Griffs case is unknown at AFL level. Even a number of those in our current 22 are still questionable/unproven.
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
Biggest problem at punt road has been holding on to players who CANNOT play.
Other clubs just keeping turning them over early.
Example of this would be the disgracefull and farcical decision to delist/rookie/promote Cam Howat 3 years in a row,
Its obvious to all except RFC that all 3 wont make it. Collins should be playing netball is way too timid, Likewise Nahas who is way too small, and Farmer tries but isnt up to it, Add White, Rance , King ,Polak, McMahon,Hislop and Graham and there is the receipe for the Wooden Spoon, HARSH BUT TRUE !
There is 10 players ( a quarter of the list ) who wouldnt get a game at another club
Hey Mods !!!!
Is there a Block posts from a specific user function?
If not then this constant crap should motivate you to investigate adding it to the forums. I know I wouldnt be the only one using it for this user
Don't be silly FT, like that will happen.... :whistle :whistle :whistle :whistle ::) ::) ::) ::) We need people like that on the forum otherwise one of us decent people will turn into idiots... :lol
Look who is talking :birthday
-
Something wrong down at Punt Rd.
Collins , Nahas and Farmer get games in front of Morton ::) :banghead
so you reckon a forward having 1 shot on goal a week is doing enough to hold their spot ::)...not in my books partner
And you think Collins , Farmer and Nahas can play AFL ?? Your on drugs partner ::)
collins looks every bit a league footballer, jury ourt on the the others, there was queue from punt rd to flinders st at trade time enquiring about collins, that would indicate the potential of the lad...he is a proigious talent :o
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
Biggest problem at punt road has been holding on to players who CANNOT play.
Other clubs just keeping turning them over early.
Example of this would be the disgracefull and farcical decision to delist/rookie/promote Cam Howat 3 years in a row,
Its obvious to all except RFC that all 3 wont make it. Collins should be playing netball is way too timid, Likewise Nahas who is way too small, and Farmer tries but isnt up to it, Add White, Rance , King ,Polak, McMahon,Hislop and Graham and there is the receipe for the Wooden Spoon, HARSH BUT TRUE !
There is 10 players ( a quarter of the list ) who wouldnt get a game at another club
Hey Mods !!!!
Is there a Block posts from a specific user function?
If not then this constant crap should motivate you to investigate adding it to the forums. I know I wouldnt be the only one using it for this user
Don't be silly FT, like that will happen.... :whistle :whistle :whistle :whistle ::) ::) ::) ::) We need people like that on the forum otherwise one of us decent people will turn into idiots... :lol
Look who is talking :birthday
And to think I wasn't even talking about you..... :cheers
-
Geez dude
they are all 21 yoa or younger
why right them off?? ??? ???
if this was geelong or collingwood or bulldogs they would not get a game at this stage
Biggest problem at punt road has been holding on to players who CANNOT play.
Other clubs just keeping turning them over early.
Example of this would be the disgracefull and farcical decision to delist/rookie/promote Cam Howat 3 years in a row,
Its obvious to all except RFC that all 3 wont make it. Collins should be playing netball is way too timid, Likewise Nahas who is way too small, and Farmer tries but isnt up to it, Add White, Rance , King ,Polak, McMahon,Hislop and Graham and there is the receipe for the Wooden Spoon, HARSH BUT TRUE !
There is 10 players ( a quarter of the list ) who wouldnt get a game at another club
Hey Mods !!!!
Is there a Block posts from a specific user function?
If not then this constant crap should motivate you to investigate adding it to the forums. I know I wouldnt be the only one using it for this user
I'd like one too
-
Hey Mods !!!!
Is there a Block posts from a specific user function?
If not then this constant crap should motivate you to investigate adding it to the forums. I know I wouldnt be the only one using it for this user
I'd like one too
I have one and it works a treat. It works like this - just stop replying to the posts of idiots. After a while you do get over the initial desire to reply and point out the rampant stupidity of their comments, and it makes a big difference knowing that you no longer validate their 'thinking' (and I use that term very, very, very loosely) or waste your precious time by responding. Applied mine a while ago now and it is working a treat. ;)
-
;)
-
Hey Smokey,
You will reply. You are the typical internet nuffer, LOL
-
Hey Smokey,
You will reply. You are the typical internet nuffer, LOL
No need to bait me Jack, you are obviously not astute enough to realise that on occasion I do reply to your posts. Or does your ego need a little helping hand by knowing that you're not on my 'ignore' list?
;D
-
Well the Morton for Nahas move IMO may wark, Morton doesn't even look like he is interested these days to be honest. Yeah sure he runs around the mark and kicks one maybe two goals a game but does he work as hard as Nahas, not IMO. Nahas is aslo a much better tackler and applies 100% more forward pressure than Morton. This may free some space up for Nahas to work in the forward line and up the ground a bit like he normally does. Don't write Nahas off totally because he hasn't had a great start to the year, not many players have. Remember least year, we all couldn't get enough of Nahas.
Don't bag this move until after the game.. :thumbsup
So do I get a gold star for this... ;D ;D, pretty well summed his night up before he even played.. :thumbsup
-
Edwards still in... ffs.... :scream........ :lol............ :rollin............ :'(
And do I get a black star for this.... :shh
Credit where it's due, best game in over 2 years, now to keep it up.
-
i also have huge question marks over Morton....i tend to think he doesnt work any where near hard enough,and throws the ball onto his boot like its park footy.
in mitches case i think its all upstairs
-
i also have huge question marks over Morton....i tend to think he doesnt work any where near hard enough,and throws the ball onto his boot like its park footy.
in mitches case i think its all upstairs
Totally agree, to me sometimes Morton doesn't look like he is enjoying his football, I am probably wrong but that might explain why he was dropped to Coburg.
-
If Morton is in and out of the side this year he might have some trade value.
Maybe he'd like to join his brother at the Dees. With all their young guys, the Dees might look to offload some picks this year :shh
-
If Morton is in and out of the side this year he might have some trade value.
Maybe he'd like to join his brother at the Dees. With all their young guys, the Dees might look to offload some picks this year :shh
Not such a bad idea actually.. :thumbsup
-
Or the hawks, could be a good foil for buddy & roughead
-
Something wrong down at Punt Rd.
Collins , Nahas and Farmer get games in front of Morton ::) :banghead
so you reckon a forward having 1 shot on goal a week is doing enough to hold their spot ::)...not in my books partner
And you think Collins , Farmer and Nahas can play AFL ?? Your on drugs partner ::)
Hmmmmmm based on the Freo game the answer would be yes for Collins and Nahas.