One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Tiger Spirit on March 10, 2005, 03:14:46 PM

Title: Player Rankings and Best 22
Post by: Tiger Spirit on March 10, 2005, 03:14:46 PM

This is our best 22 and player rankings for 2005, according to this week’s Inside Footy.

B: Hartigan, Gaspar, Newman
HB: Bowden Hall Chaffey
C: Hyde, Campbell, Tivendale
HF: Krakouer, Richardson, Brown
F: Tambling, Simmonds, Deledio
R: Stafford, Johnson, Coughlan
Inter: Kellaway, Knobel, Roach, Hilton

1. Matthew Richardson
2. Nathan Brown
3. Kane Johnson
4. Greg Stafford
5. Joel Bowden
6. Darren Gaspar
7. Mark Coughlan
8. Ray Hall
9. Troy Simmonds
10. Andrew Krakouer
11. Chris Newman
12. Trent Knobel
13. Brent Hartigan
14. Andrew Kellaway
15. Mark Chaffey
16. Greg Tivendale
17. Chris Hyde
18. Wayne Campbell
19. Rory Hilton
20. Daniel Jackson
21. Jay Schulz
22. Tom Roach
23. Mark Graham
24. Kelvin Moore
25. Kayne Pettifer
26. Andrew Raines
27. Shane Tuck
28. Shane Morrison
29. David Rodan

Title: Re: Player Rankings and Best 22
Post by: Tiger Spirit on March 10, 2005, 03:40:04 PM

Staff at 4. ??  Don't know if we can expect he will play enough games to be ranked that high.  If he plays anywhere near 15 games this year, we should be happy with that.

Hard to work out Hall at 8.  Maybe they were thinking of Barry Hall or Jerry Hall.

Not sure what Knobel’s done to be at 12.

Cambo at 18 and Hilton at 19?  JohnF will be ROFL that they reckon Hilton should be ranked one place below Cambo.

Rodan at 29 would be due to injury.

Title: Re: Player Rankings and Best 22
Post by: WilliamPowell on March 10, 2005, 03:56:10 PM

Makes a person wonder why they subscribe to this magazine when you read this ;D

Goodness, gracious me :o :o

Quote from: Tiger Spirit on March 10, 2005, 03:14:46 PM

4. Greg Stafford

No offence to Staffy but what the!!!!!!! ::)

Quote

19. Rory Hilton

 :gobdrop :gobdrop in your dreams - thanks goodness Adam Houlihan's no longer on our list he would have been in the top 3  :banghead :rollin :banghead :rollin :banghead :rollin

Title: Re: Player Rankings and Best 22
Post by: mightytiges on March 10, 2005, 05:45:51 PM

Like to know what stuff these guys are on! What did they base their rankings on - a dart board  ???

Staff at 4 when he only played 11 games and was 20th in overall posessions. Bowden had 400 more possies yet is below him ???. Even Tim Fleming was 10th in possessions last year. Cambo was 4th btw for John.

Add to that having Gas at 6th, Cogs at 7th and Razor at 8th. Didn't these guys watch us last year  - lucky them  ;D.

Title: Re: Player Rankings and Best 22
Post by: JohnF on March 10, 2005, 10:30:47 PM

I suggest the person from Inside Footy that compiled that list be sacked.

There are so many absurdities in that list it's not even woth analysing or critiquing.