One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 22, 2013, 06:23:32 PM
-
In: A.Edwards, White, King, Dea, S.Edwards
Out: McGuane, Astbury
-
According to the AFL website, both McGuane and Astbury are out injured (leg) rather than dropped.
-
With those outs it would suggest its Dea and A. Edwards as replacements, am guessing some late changes.
-
Richmond
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Houli, Chaplin, Petterd
C: Grigg, Cotchin, Jackson
HF: Vlastuin, Martin, Ellis
F: King, Riewoldt, Vickery
R: Maric, Deledio, S. Edwards
IC from: Tuck, Conca, White, McDonough, Dea, Foley, A. Edwards
In: S. Edwards, King, White, A. Edwards
Out: Astbury (inj – soreness), McGuane (inj – leg soreness)
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2013-08-22/round-22-tiger-squad
-
Hmmm soreness?
IMO 2 weeks out from the finals and those blokes have only just come into the AFL side , need exposure at that level so I don't think you'd be resting them because of soreness
-
GWS Giants
B: Zachary Williams, Tim Mohr, Nicholas Haynes
HB: Curtly Hampton, Phil Davis, Tomas Bugg
C: Adam Treloar, Tom Scully, Stephen Coniglio
HF: Adam Tomlinson, Jonathan Giles, Nathan Wilson
F: Kristian Jaksch, Jeremy Cameron, Liam Sumner
Foll: Dean Brogan, Callan Ward, Taylor Adams
I/C: Mark Whiley, Toby Greene, Dylan Shiel, Dom Tyson, Sam Darley, Lachie Whitfield, Adam Kennedy (Three to be omitted)
In: Taylor Adams, Dom Tyson, Sam Darley, Kristian Jaksch
Out: Stephen Gilham (Omitted)
New: Kristian Jaksch
http://www.gwsgiants.com.au/team/team-announcement#sthash.FVAUakie.dpuf
-
Obviously Petterd's hamstring is OK.
Surely Riewoldt will not play and A.Edwards will come in.
-
Obvisuolu Petterd's hamstring is OK.
No probably not, extended benches for Sunday game means they can play games until 5pm tomorrow ;D
-
According to the AFL website, both McGuane and Astbury are out injured (leg) rather than dropped.
Nudge nudge wink wink
-
Hmmm soreness?
IMO 2 weeks out from the finals and those blokes have only just come into the AFL side , need exposure at that level so I don't think you'd be resting them because of soreness
Don't plan to go into finals with them perhaps?
-
Good to see King, White and S Edwards back in. Is this Dea's last game to prove himself?
-
Hmmm soreness?
IMO 2 weeks out from the finals and those blokes have only just come into the AFL side , need exposure at that level so I don't think you'd be resting them because of soreness
Don't plan to go into finals with them perhaps?
Bingo :thumbsup
IMHO now that Grimes is back Astbury drops out of calculations. Dont' think we can have Chaplin, Rance, Grimes and Astbury down back together makes us too big. Only need three tall back IMHO
-
Is this Dea's last game to prove himself?
No
-
Hmmm soreness?
IMO 2 weeks out from the finals and those blokes have only just come into the AFL side , need exposure at that level so I don't think you'd be resting them because of soreness
Don't plan to go into finals with them perhaps?
Bingo :thumbsup
IMHO now that Grimes is back Astbury drops out of calculations. Dont' think we can have Chaplin, Rance, Grimes and Astbury down back together makes us too big. Only need three tall back IMHO
Yeah agree what that but a bit staggered if we don't go with McGuane in finals :-\
-
Finalised 22
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Houli, Chaplin, Petterd
C: Grigg, Cotchin, Jackson
HF: Vlastuin, Martin, Ellis
F: King, Riewoldt, Vickery
R: Maric, Deledio, S. Edwards
IC: Foley, Conca, White, A. Edwards
Emerg: Tuck, Dea, McDonough
In: S. Edwards, King, White, A. Edwards
Out: Astbury (inj – leg soreness), McGuane (inj – leg soreness), Tuck, McDonough
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2013-08-23/four-tiger-changes
-
Greater Western Sydney
B: Zachary Williams, Tim Mohr, Nicholas Haynes
HB: Curtly Hampton, Phil Davis, Tomas Bugg
C: Adam Treloar, Tom Scully, Stephen Coniglio
HF: Adam Tomlinson, Jonathan Giles, Nathan Wilson
F: Kristian Jaksch, Jeremy Cameron, Liam Sumner
Foll: Dean Brogan, Callan Ward, Taylor Adams
I/C: Toby Greene, Dylan Shiel, Dom Tyson, Adam Kennedy
Emg: Mark Whiley, Sam Darley, Matthew Buntine
In: Taylor Adams, Dom Tyson, Kristian Jaksch
Out: Mark Whiley (Omitted), Stephen Gilham (Omitted), Lachie Whitfield (Back)
New: Kristian Jaksch
http://www.gwsgiants.com.au/team/team-announcement#sthash.MSHZAKgl.dpuf
-
Finalised 22
B: Morris, Rance, Grimes
HB: Houli, Chaplin, Petterd
C: Grigg, Cotchin, Jackson
HF: Vlastuin, Martin, Ellis
F: King, Riewoldt, Vickery
R: Maric, Deledio, S. Edwards
IC: Foley, Conca, White, A. Edwards
Emerg: Tuck, Dea, McDonough
In: S. Edwards, King, White, A. Edwards
Out: Astbury (inj – leg soreness), McGuane (inj – leg soreness), Tuck, McDonough
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2013-08-23/four-tiger-changes
A better team balance (3 tall defenders as opposed to 4) this week and more linebreakers into the side that we missed big time last week.
No talls in the emergencies so Jack must be playing.
-
Near on full strength :cheers
-
Dont think Petterd will play so if he doesn't they'd bring in Dea or Tuck I suppose
-
I have watched matty dea several times in the magoos this year and although he seems above that level,i have some serious questions,not sure if he can cut the mustard at this point in time.
-
I have watched matty dea several times in the magoos this year and although he seems above that level,i have some serious questions,not sure if he can cut the mustard at this point in time.
Agree but just think if Petterd doesn't play like for like means Dea gets the gig
-
I wonder why batch doesn't get the gig
-
I wonder why batch doesn't get the gig
Going by Clarke's review of RFC players at Coburg last week Batch wasnt good, Dea was
-
I wonder why batch doesn't get the gig
Going by Clarke's review of RFC players at Coburg last week Batch wasnt good, Dea was
Rewarding form :clapping
-
Batch really hasn't responded to being dropped back to Coburg has he.....what's happened to Helbig to?
-
Hopefully Tyson and Adams put on a full dress rehearsal for us :clapping
-
Hopefully Tyson and Adams put on a full dress rehearsal for us :clapping
Was hoping just to leave the plane's engines running and pick them up on the way back :shh
-
Batch, Dea, Helbig Petterd.....simply can't hit a target often enough, so don't expect them to be part of the future
cheers!
-
i dont think helbig is a bad kick
-
If we have given Astbury and Griffiths 4 years surely we can afford Batch the same time given he is not injured regularly like the other two blokes and many on here have agreed that he has played some really good footy for us. I still have the belief Batch will be a very good player for us. Right now he is a forgotten man. :thumbsup
Astbury and Griff are at the crossroads and possibly Helbig given his injuries too.
-
If we have given Astbury and Griffiths 4 years surely we can afford Batch the same time given he is not injured regularly like the other two blokes and many on here have agreed that he has played some really good footy for us. I still have the belief Batch will be a very good player for us. Right now he is a forgotten man. :thumbsup
Astbury and Griff are at the crossroads and possibly Helbig given his injuries too.
Agree definitely deserves more time
-
Batch needs to show something in the two's first because he has shown bugger all in the firsts when given the opportunity.
-
Batch needs to show something in the two's first because he has shown bugger all in the firsts when given the opportunity.
This season in what is left of it WAT. He has been very good in his first two seasons. Has shown more than Astbury and Griff TBH in his 3 seasons at the club.
-
Batch needs to show something in the two's first because he has shown bugger all in the firsts when given the opportunity.
This season in what is left of it WAT. He has been very good in his first two seasons. Has shown more than Astbury and Griff TBH in his 3 seasons at the club.
Yep, don't have a problem keeping him, just cant play him now that's all, I don't think he has deserved it...they may even trade him..who knows.
-
Hopefully Tyson and Adams put on a full dress rehearsal for us :clapping
Yep stink it up, and get them on the cheap.
-
Hope Flossy has a good game! :gotigers