One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Phil Mrakov on February 15, 2014, 12:44:53 PM
-
Sick of his 'Alex Rance moments'...... We won't win a flag with him in our backline, falls over way too much and is just an all round goose.
:banghead
-
I don't think trading Race is the go, our backline was disfunctional all night and they were all caught out.
Get Frawley yes, he was very composed!
-
Didn't think Rance could improve on his moments.But after last night he took it to another level.
-
I'll reserve judgement till the real stuff starts....
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
What would you know ? You liked Post
-
If we want to get Frawley we do not need to trade anyone nor give up any draft picks.
-
Post was never up to the standard. Rance has shown that he can play to a decent standard.
-
If we want to get Frawley we do not need to trade anyone nor give up any draft picks.
We don't have the cap space. Newman retires and we get rid of Rance = we can afford Frawley
-
If we want to get Frawley we do not need to trade anyone nor give up any draft picks.
We don't have the cap space. Newman retires and we get rid of Rance = we can afford Frawley
Id rather keep rance and get a star midfielder.
-
Rance is good enuff for us to win a flag :thumbsup
-
get spud and keep Rance. Played like scoobydo on skates at times, but hes a good player. V quick! he gave that Melbourne fwd goal sneak 15 metres and caught him
-
Post was never up to the standard. Rance has shown that he can play to a decent standard.
Rance is a very good player IMO and yes he has a few moments but every player who plays the game has those same moments...clangers, etc. Clearly in the top bracket of defenders. Frawley is also a very good player but his kicking lets him down too much, but he is a great defender just like Rance. I am very happy with Rance as his last few years have been fantastic.
-
If we want to get Frawley we do not need to trade anyone nor give up any draft picks.
We don't have the cap space. Newman retires and we get rid of Rance = we can afford Frawley
Id rather keep rance and get a star midfielder.
X2
Any ideas of elite midfielders who will be free agents at the end of the season?
-
1. Get the fyfe. 2. Get the fyfe
-
Rance 2011 edition returned last night. Easily the most overrated player on our list.
-
Easily the most overrated player on our list.
Grimes is way out in front in his wheelchair
-
Easily the most overrated player on our list.
Grimes is way out in front in his wheelchair
...addendum to my post - "that regularly plays."
-
Rance 2011 edition returned last night. Easily the most overrated player on our list.
NAB Challenge dude. Start hanging it on Rance if he doesn't perform during the H&A season. At least Rance takes a gun most week....Melbourne's best dressed gardener runs around like a fairy and is hailed as saviour.
-
Dietician not sure what your smoking but No rance and we are royally screwed in 2014. Great player
That number 12 arsebury is useless and grimes well I've given up on him
-
people seemed to have forgotten the struggle we have had as a club over the last 30 years to have decent full backs. Turner was ok after he came to Richmond, Gaspar we had to recruit from Sydney and was good. Rance is the first one weve had in 30 years whose any good who we have brought through after drafting him.
-
people seemed to have forgotten the struggle we have had as a club over the last 30 years to have decent full backs. Turner was ok after he came to Richmond, Gaspar we had to recruit from Sydney and was good. Rance is the first one weve had in 30 years whose any good who we have brought through after drafting him.
:clapping Spot on.
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
Agreed Bachelor the prolific goal sneak can attest to that.
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
What would you know ? You liked Post
poos on petterd
-
1980 - Michael Roach aka Disco
2014 - Alex Rance aka Roller Disco
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
What would you know ? You liked Post
poos on petterd
Lol at you if you actually believe that. Petterd is poo but he's not as poo as Jayden Post
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
What would you know ? You liked Post
poos on petterd
Lol at you if you actually believe that. Petterd is poo but he's not as poo as Jayden Post
Post actually could mark and kick on either foot. Had good height and leap too and was cut too early. Petterd can't do anything, is short, no composure, no skill lol
-
people seemed to have forgotten the struggle we have had as a club over the last 30 years to have decent full backs. Turner was ok after he came to Richmond, Gaspar we had to recruit from Sydney and was good. Rance is the first one weve had in 30 years whose any good who we have brought through after drafting him.
Yes and we need backmen.
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
What would you know ? You liked Post
poos on petterd
Lol at you if you actually believe that. Petterd is poo but he's not as poo as Jayden Post
Post actually could mark and kick on either foot. Had good height and leap too and was cut too early. Petterd can't do anything, is short, no composure, no skill lol
:whistle
-
Dumb thread. Nice turnovers by Frawley last night
What would you know ? You liked Post
poos on petterd
Lol at you if you actually believe that. Petterd is poo but he's not as poo as Jayden Post
Post actually could mark and kick on either foot. Had good height and leap too and was cut too early. Petterd can't do anything, is short, no composure, no skill lol
Petterd can do a few things ok BUT he 9 irons the ball to our disadvantage far too often. Not in our best 22 for mine
-
Oh...and Rance's kicking efficiency was 80% last year. Hardly a turnover king
-
I dont think there was anybody in our side that broke into a sweat on Friday night. Rance was just as bad as anybody else. No player gave a rats clacker about that game, it was obvious.
-
I dont think there was anybody in our side that broke into a sweat on Friday night. Rance was just as bad as anybody else. No player gave a rats clacker about that game, it was obvious.
morris and Edwards say hi. Sheds got dragged for trying too hard I reckon.
-
i voted no. we should keep rance and get frawley. its not as if we have depth in the area yet alone a current replacement for rance. i keep on saying it third tall role for rance.
atm we are two big bodied kpds shy of what we need on the LIST. i say list opposed to in the best 22.
i still think when looking where we are at as far as development and capable players goes we should have
2 more ruckmen 1/ junior 21 and under, and 1/ development. 22 thru 24. making a total of 5. imo maric 29, hampson 26, orren 31, are the only real ruckmen we have capable of holding down first ruck now or in the future. ask yourselves what should be the aim be in 3 or 4 yrs time as far as this area is concerned.
2 kpd both with the potential to play on the big blokes. one junior one development or early mature. these two go with chaplin whos 28 this yr , rance, grimes and possibly astbury and darrou.
what we have atm is hardly inspiring overall.
2 key forwards. 1/ in the gunston mould. 1/ in the cloke mould. could do with one at around 22 24 yrs and the other a junior.
how do we go down this path as far as type goes. easy just cut the excess flankers of which we have far too many.
-
Are we sacking Rance based on a practice match, oh you guys
-
Ridiculous thread, nfi of the rules, free agency means ummm errrrr players don't traded.....they walk ::)