One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: WA Tiger on June 30, 2015, 08:38:20 PM
-
So we now have the option to upgrade a rookie.
Anyone?
Thomas
Short
What re people's thoughts?
-
Why do we?
I don't mind either, i know people have a crack at Thomas for being slow but he gets alot of inside ball. With that being said, we upgraded on him with Miles and don't think we need to upgrade.
I do not know much about Short but looking at results, I think Thomas is the one if we need too!!
-
I like Short as a player. Just has something. Would be good on a hff. Id select Short.
-
y does everyone like short?
-
Leave it till George comes back form injury. He was scintillating at times before he was injured.
-
Castanga or Short
-
Leave it till George comes back form injury. He was scintillating at times before he was injured.
Agree
He was close to promotion before injury, worth waiting for :yep
-
Who is George??
-
Who is George??
Jason Castagna
-
Who is George??
Jason Castagna
Thanks
-
Short, simply because I think the injection of youth into our side is paying big dividends.
Thomas as much as I think he's an honest footballer doesn't have a place in our firsts...
-
I watched one of the games Castagna played in against the Cats I think, his disposal let him down but his play, determination and gut running was brilliant. Wouldn't we spend the rest of the season getting those skills up a bit before promoting him?
-
Castagna has a lot going for him but I want him to spend the next 6 to 12 months getting his kicking right. His disposal on the run is poor. Get his kicking up to speed and he will be a player too. Short has a touch of class IMHO.
-
Thomarse is a slow hack who'll hopefully be delisted - unless half the side goes down, surely we're now past playing these kind of rejects.
Castagna - I dunno - he has a go, is fit, quick and tackles well but his kicking makes Taylor Hunt look like Nathan Buckley.
Short doesn't defend at all, but until Butler is fit & ready or Dan the Man delivers us one of Motlop, Yarran or Matera, is exacty the attacking option we desperately need up forward.
Short it is for me.
-
with Knights set to return from the LTI list, do we still have the option to upgrade?
-
We upgraded Arnot for Knights I think but no-one was upgraded after Drummond was ruled out for the season and you can upgrade another rookie after round 11 or 12.
-
I noticed Castagna is now on the injury list,where he has not been before, does this mean anything?
-
I think Bikkie came on for Ricky Bobby
-
I noticed Castagna is now on the injury list,where he has not been before, does this mean anything?
It means as I've previously said, the injury list issued by the club is a joke
Castagna hasnt played for about 3-4 weeks now but the club in its wisdom has only listed him for the first time this week