One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 05, 2016, 06:23:15 PM
-
In: Griffiths, McIntosh, Vlastuin, Short
Out: Maric, Cotchin (inj), Lambert (inj), Astbury.
https://twitter.com/AFL_PKeane
-
Ok with that
-
Happy with the team
Couldn't possibly play Ivan after what I seen this year
-
Ivan isn't injured. He's been dropped.
Round 7 Tigers team
B: Vlastuin, Chaplin, Batchelor
HB: Deledio, Houli, B. Ellis
C: Grigg, McIntosh, Menadue
HF: Short, Martin, Rioli
F: Riewoldt, Lloyd, Vickery
R: Griffiths, Edwards, Miles
IC: C. Ellis, Hampson, Castagna, Morris
Em: Astbury, A. Moore, Hunt
In: Vlastuin, Griffiths, McIntosh, Short
Out: Cotchin (cheekbone), Lambert (ribs), Astbury, Maric
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2016-05-05/round-7-team-announcement
-
Not enough changes. They drop Astbury but retain Chaplin and Vickery who were both atrocious against Port. Having said that glad brought Short in.
-
.... :yawn
-
Depth. I see depth everywhere.
-
Astbury???
and Chaplin playing???
JOKE!
SACK HARDWICK NOW!
-
No Hodge and Frawley for the Hawks.
HAWTHORN
B: Kaiden Brand, Tim O’Brien, Josh Gibson
HB: Sam Mitchell, Ben Stratton, Grant Brchall
C: Bradley Hill, Jordan Lewis, Isaac Smith
HF: Luke Breust, Jack Gunston, Liam Shiels
F: Paul Puopolo, Jonathon Ceglar, Cyril Rioli
Foll: Ben McEvoy, Will Langford, Shaun Burgoyne
Int: Billy Hartung, James Sicily, Taylor Duryea, Daniel Howe
Emer: Angus Litherland, Dallas Willsmore, Kieran Lovell
In: Kaiden Brand, Will Langford, Billy Hartung
Out: Luke Hodge (knee), James Frawley (concussion), Kieran Lovell (omitted)
New: Kaiden Brand
http://www.hawthornfc.com.au/news/2016-05-05/team-selection-round-7
-
Ok with that
Thought you said that Ivan would be our saviour, not verbatim of course. :snidegrin
-
Astbury???
and Chaplin playing???
JOKE!
SACK HARDWICK NOW!
Groundhog Day
-
Not exactly a fearsome hawks team...
-
Would rather have seen Elton get a go ahead of Chaplin.
-
Ok with that
Thought you said that Ivan would be our saviour, not verbatim of course. :snidegrin
Would rather Hampson dropped
But very pleased to see they've dropped Astbury
Bought back short and not dropped Castagna
-
So hopefully next week both Grimes and Rance are added. And with a bit of luck Chaplin and Batchelor go out.
That's 2 less duds.
Hopefully when Yarran is fit Houli goes out. That will be a good day for me.
Cotch back for Grigg at about the same time and the side looks a lot quicker and tougher.
And if Griff can can make that ruck spot his own, maybe we could see the end of Hampson too.
-
Bigger and tougher?
Lolz.
-
Bought back short and not dropped Castagna
Best part of the team selection..
-
Ok with that
Thought you said that Ivan would be our saviour, not verbatim of course. :snidegrin
Would rather Hampson dropped
But very pleased to see they've dropped Astbury
Bought back short and not dropped Castagna
Maric?? Didn't you say he would be the difference.. :snidegrin
-
Griffiths to play backline ? Vickery and Hampson to ruck. Geez we are in trouble
-
At least it looks like DH has picked a couple of guys that can play on Hawthorns 3 very good smalls.
Castagna, Morris and Short are all super quick and at least it seems like Dimma has thought about it.
I hope they throw Vlastuin into the midfield even if just for short stints now that Cotch is out.
Let him have a crack in the middle.
-
Ivan isn't injured. He's been dropped.
Round 7 Tigers team
B: Vlastuin, Chaplin, Batchelor
HB: Deledio, Houli, B. Ellis
C: Grigg, McIntosh, Menadue
HF: Short, Martin, Rioli
F: Riewoldt, Lloyd, Vickery
R: Griffiths, Edwards, Miles
IC: C. Ellis, Hampson, Castagna, Morris
Em: Astbury, A. Moore, Hunt
In: Vlastuin, Griffiths, McIntosh, Short
Out: Cotchin (cheekbone), Lambert (ribs), Astbury, Maric
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2016-05-05/round-7-team-announcement
Win lose or draw that is one crap side.
-
Ivan isn't injured. He's been dropped.
Round 7 Tigers team
B: Vlastuin, Chaplin, Batchelor
HB: Deledio, Houli, B. Ellis
C: Grigg, McIntosh, Menadue
HF: Short, Martin, Rioli
F: Riewoldt, Lloyd, Vickery
R: Griffiths, Edwards, Miles
IC: C. Ellis, Hampson, Castagna, Morris
Em: Astbury, A. Moore, Hunt
In: Vlastuin, Griffiths, McIntosh, Short
Out: Cotchin (cheekbone), Lambert (ribs), Astbury, Maric
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2016-05-05/round-7-team-announcement
Win lose or draw that is one crap side.
Can't be too bad if it wins (which I highly doubt).
-
Ok with that
Thought you said that Ivan would be our saviour, not verbatim of course. :snidegrin
Would rather Hampson dropped
But very pleased to see they've dropped Astbury
Bought back short and not dropped Castagna
Agree with you about Castagna not being dropped. Disagree that Astbury should have been dropped. I accept Astbury did not play a good game against Port but how earth did Chaplin keep his place.
-
Morris super quick lol
Heard it all
-
Ok with that
Thought you said that Ivan would be our saviour, not verbatim of course. :snidegrin
Would rather Hampson dropped
But very pleased to see they've dropped Astbury
Bought back short and not dropped Castagna
Agree with you about Castagna not being dropped. Disagree that Astbury should have been dropped. I accept Astbury did not play a good game against Port but how earth did Chaplin keep his place.
Do you notice Astbury doesn't really spoil that much, he just runs into the back of his opponent. :lol
He hasent been our worst but we need to upgrade him at some stage.
-
Astbury mixes good with bad.
He can take a good saving mark but often lets his opponent off the leash too easily. He also doesn't rebound well as he makes poor choices coming out of the back line.
-
Astbury mixes good with bad.
He can take a good saving mark but often lets his opponent off the leash too easily. He also doesn't rebound well as he makes poor choices coming out of the back line.
Another FJ special selection :clapping
-
Bloody hell, how is hampson still getting a game
-
People bagging astbury while Chaplin still being selected
Remarkable
-
Not exactly a fearsome hawks team...
So what does that make this Richmond team?
-
Astbury mixes good with bad.
He can take a good saving mark but often lets his opponent off the leash too easily. He also doesn't rebound well as he makes poor choices coming out of the back line.
Another FJ special selection :clapping
The guy will soon be up for an Order of Australia the way he's going! ;D
-
Astbury originally recruited as a forward if my memory serves me correctly. Here's an idea, why dont we plonk him inside forward 50 for a couple of weeks and see how he goes in the VFL. Think with the limited depth we have we need to look at other options and the VFL is the place to try these things.
-
Astbury originally recruited as a forward if my memory serves me correctly. Here's an idea, why dont we plonk him inside forward 50 for a couple of weeks and see how he goes in the VFL. Think with the limited depth we have we need to look at other options and the VFL is the place to try these things.
Chf from memory
-
Not exactly a fearsome hawks team...
So what does that make this Richmond team?
Fearful....
-
Batchelor, Chaplin and Morris - FMFD - Hardwick is clueless!
Should play Moore in back pocket instead of Batchelor. Elton instead of Chaplin and someone that can get more than 4 touches in a game to replace Morris
-
Astbury problem is he as slow as treacle and a liability when the ball hits the ground. Unfortunately for us Chaplin is even worse
-
Astbury problem is he as slow as treacle and a liability when the ball hits the ground. Unfortunately for us Chaplin is even worse
More slow
More of a liability ...
-
How could Elton possibly still be worse than either of them?
-
How could Elton possibly still be worse than either of them?
I can tell you , he is
-
Are you a reliable source?
-
Are you a reliable source?
Rhetorical question?
-
:lol
-
Chaplin is not the future yet Hardwick continually selects him(regardless of how poorly he plays). This is yet another example of Hardwick's inability to take chances and of his stubborn resistance to drop his favoured players. Agree with earlier comments that Hardwick will probably play Griffiths in backline. I suspect that Houli will be given the kicking out duties and wonder how long he will last at it this time.
-
Are you a reliable source?
Very 😉
-
I actually agree, in the complete opposite way to what you think
-
How could Elton possibly still be worse than either of them?
I can tell you , he is
That's because the club has developed him poorly.
The guy is 197cm, mobile for his size and can take a grab. That gives him a great platform to be a KPP. The rest is development.....
-
How could Elton possibly still be worse than either of them?
I can tell you , he is
That's because the club has developed him poorly.
The guy is 197cm, mobile for his size and can take a grab. That gives him a great platform to be a KPP. The rest is development.....
Unless he is a spud
-
How could Elton possibly still be worse than either of them?
I can tell you , he is
That's because the club has developed him poorly.
The guy is 197cm, mobile for his size and can take a grab. That gives him a great platform to be a KPP. The rest is development.....
Unless he is a spud
True to a point. He was rated as a junior though. We picked him at pick 26 in the draft IIRC.
We do turn them into spuds pretty quickly at Punt road though.... :whistle
-
Both Astbury and Maric wernt good last week but were they worse than Hampson and Chaplin? I didnt think so. Cant remember seeing Maric turn it over like Hampson did thats for sure.
Dont like those two changes but after last week there were probably 12 you could make. Good that the younger ones are getting a exteneded run though from what I saw last week that is part of the problem. These guys are just getting pushed around by bigger bodies. Supose you cant have it both ways (playing the kids and bigger bodies) but some teams seem to do it.
Dont like the Griffith backline idea much. That has also been part of the problem, trying to turn guys into something they are not and playing them out of position.
-
How could Elton possibly still be worse than either of them?
I can tell you , he is
That's because the club has developed him poorly.
The guy is 197cm, mobile for his size and can take a grab. That gives him a great platform to be a KPP. The rest is development.....
Unless he is a spud
The clubs development of elton has been unbelievably poor
-
Both Astbury and Maric wernt good last week but were they worse than Hampson and Chaplin? I didnt think so. Cant remember seeing Maric turn it over like Hampson did thats for sure.
Dont like those two changes but after last week there were probably 12 you could make. Good that the younger ones are getting a exteneded run though from what I saw last week that is part of the problem. These guys are just getting pushed around by bigger bodies. Supose you cant have it both ways (playing the kids and bigger bodies) but some teams seem to do it.
Dont like the Griffith backline idea much. That has also been part of the problem, trying to turn guys into something they are not and playing them out of position.
As a KPF I haven't seen BBBG do a lot.
-
I actually agree, in the complete opposite way to what you think
Reliably unreliable
Dont like the Griffith backline idea much. That has also been part of the problem, trying to turn guys into something they are not and playing them out of position.
As a KPF I haven't seen BBBG do a lot.
Griff in the backline is the sole reason we have Hampson in our team so I never want to see it happen again
-
Ivan isn't injured. He's been dropped.
Round 7 Tigers team
B: Vlastuin, Chaplin, Batchelor
HB: Deledio, Houli, B. Ellis
C: Grigg, McIntosh, Menadue
HF: Short, Martin, Rioli
F: Riewoldt, Lloyd, Vickery
R: Griffiths, Edwards, Miles
IC: C. Ellis, Hampson, Castagna, Morris
Em: Astbury, A. Moore, Hunt
In: Vlastuin, Griffiths, McIntosh, Short
Out: Cotchin (cheekbone), Lambert (ribs), Astbury, Maric
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2016-05-05/round-7-team-announcement
Unsure about: Lloyd. Short. Bachelor.
Looks for draft picks: Griffiths. Vickery. Bellis
List blocker: grigg. Chaplin. Houli. Morris. Hampson.
Best 22: martin. Miles. Deledio. Vlastuin. Jack. Edwards.
Should continue getting games into: Mcintosh. Rioli. Menadue. Castagna. C Ellis.
#SackHardwick
-
What's wrong with Short?
-
What's wrong with Short?
He seems pretty good
Do you find a spot for him when Cotchin. Grimes. Lambert. Lennon. Yarren are fit and we he a non insane coach?
Hopefully butler. Chol. McBean. Put on pressure
-
What's wrong with Short?
He seems pretty good
Do you find a spot for him when Cotchin. Grimes. Lambert. Lennon. Yarren are fit and we he a non insane coach?
Hopefully butler. Chol. McBean. Put on pressure
But you're unsure about him and in another thread you listed the players we should keep playing but omitted him. So obviously you don't rate him as one of the kids we should keep playing? Why is that?