One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 15, 2024, 07:37:47 PM
-
Only slightly underdogs :help.
AFL Round 23
Hawthorn vs RICHMOND
Sunday, 18th August @ the M.C.G.
Start time: 3:20 PM
Odds: (Sportsbet)
Richmond $8.00
Hawthorn $1.08
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/6088
-
Kmac is the sub.
NO LATE CHANGES
SUBSTITUTES
Hawthorn: Luke Breust
Richmond: Kamdyn McIntosh
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1195688/roos-out-to-spoil-dogs-day-in-sunday-cracker-live-from-110pm-aest
-
Just got to the game, gee the Hawks supporters have jumped on their train
-
Why wouldn't they
-
Why wouldn't they
Agree but you have to be there for the good and the bad
Like the majority of Tiger fans have been
-
Why wouldn't they
Agree but you have to be there for the good and the bad
Like the majority of Tiger fans have been
Dunno if we’ve really been there for the bad this year….
All fan bases are fair weather, really.
-
Mansell goal. Blow the siren :snidegrin.
Leigh Fisher the anti-Richmond ump ::). Clear free for too high on Broad not paid :thumbsdown.
-
Seen enough of Balta forward already
Time to move him back, he ain't a forward
-
Dumb Noah. Agree pmac, he's not a forward.
Just got to the game, gee the Hawks supporters have jumped on their train
Their home game with them expecting a 10 goal plus win :help to seal their first finals spot in 6 years.
-
Senior players balta and prestia mistakes resulting in goals. Same old
Story !
-
Disposal woeful
-
Hopper poor disposal. Our senior players are so bad… and no defensive pressure from Prestia on that goal
-
Why wouldn't they
Agree but you have to be there for the good and the bad
Like the majority of Tiger fans have been
Dunno if we’ve really been there for the bad this year….
All fan bases are fair weather, really.
Yep
Though we did still get decent crowds in the Spud and Wallet era
-
So far it's the Hawks of 2024 vs us imitating the Hawks of 2-3 years ago. Remember when they use to always try to go through the corridor even when it wasn't on and would turn it over gifting easy goals to the opposition.
Add being smashed at the stoppages. This will be 100 pts if this continues :help.
-
Nank is being trashed.
-
We're in trouble here
-
Can we pull a 2016 and request a mercy rule at 3/4 time?
-
Wtf are you doing nank ? So dumb out of the ruck. FMD
-
Amazing tap Nank, you are a bloody star
-
Our vfl standard backline are in for a smacking today. Doesn't help the so called senior mids are also being destroyed
-
Game over 14 mins into the 1st qtr
Nank's ability to hit straight to opposition at centre bounces is quite extraordinary
-
Stuffen disgraceful. This whole midfield group is completely useless. Every single one of them can be moved on. Taranto and Graham starting at the centre bounce ??? Seriously ??? The hawks can jog away from them
-
We need Shaun Grigg back
-
When a teammate is streaming towards F50 you lead up at the ballcarrier; not sit and allow your opponent to win front position and rebound with ease :facepalm.
Getting destroyed all over the park.
Mercy rule time already :help.
-
Are you all starting to wake up about everything I have been saying about Bank.. he is useless.. always has been.. just was fortunate in the past to be part of a great midfield
-
This is already becoming an embarrassment..
STARTS WITH YZE!!!! HE IS A FRAUD
BALTA WILL NEVER EVER EVER BE A FORWARD.. FFS
-
Stuffen disgraceful. This whole midfield group is completely useless. Every single one of them can be moved on. Taranto and Graham starting at the centre bounce ??? Seriously ??? The hawks can jog away from them
But Sim, that's not the players issue, that's a coaching issue pitting them in there.
Got know issue with whacking players for their efforts but is totally on the coaches, in particular Newy as mid field coach
-
Are you all starting to wake up about everything I have been saying about Bank.. he is useless.. always has been.. just was fortunate in the past to be part of a great midfield
Yes, he's been horrifically bad at times. No, he wasn't always useless.
-
Stuffen disgraceful. This whole midfield group is completely useless. Every single one of them can be moved on. Taranto and Graham starting at the centre bounce ??? Seriously ??? The hawks can jog away from them
But Sim, that's not the players issue, that's a coaching issue pitting them in there.
We have no coach.. we have UM ARR STUTTERING FRAUD
-
Stuffen disgraceful. This whole midfield group is completely useless. Every single one of them can be moved on. Taranto and Graham starting at the centre bounce ??? Seriously ??? The hawks can jog away from them
But Sim, that's not the players issue, that's a coaching issue pitting them in there.
No I accept that, they’re two seperate issues. This our full strength midfield so there are no excuses. It’s coaching and personnel
-
Wonder what rubbish Yze will spin after this game. I’ve held and still hold faith in yze but just come out and say you’re angry at how bad we are. Say we need a full rebuild.
-
Don't protect the defensive side of contests then you get what you deserve.
Geez our forward line is a joke.
Young hungry connected team with leg speed vs a disconnected rabble that just wants the season to end and needs to hit the draft to find young A-grade talent.
-
Get Balta in the backline now.
-
Are you all starting to wake up about everything I have been saying about Bank.. he is useless.. always has been.. just was fortunate in the past to be part of a great midfield
Yes, he's been horrifically bad at times. No, he wasn't always useless.
Nank was always useless.. he was masked by a great midfield.. it's not my problem most of you were blinded by our success to see this..
SYDNEY KNEW!!!!!
I TOLD YOU SO!!!
been on this for ages and ridiculed.. but I never sway..
-
Trezise is like a robot.
Kicking action so slow. Can't be like that at afl level.
-
Dear in the headlights stuff :help.
Reminds of the 2007 game at the Dome against Geelong :help.
-
Dear in the highlights stuff :help.
Reminds of the 2007 game at the Dome against Geelong :help.
This is worse!!! We have multiple premiership players out there
And allegedly a great captain ruckman LMAO
-
No defensive pressure at all. Would love to see a good old fashioned spray from yze. Stop being the nice guy and demand more. This group is absolutely gutless with no leadership at all, atleast get angry and show you care
-
Are you all starting to wake up about everything I have been saying about Bank.. he is useless.. always has been.. just was fortunate in the past to be part of a great midfield
Yes, he's been horrifically bad at times. No, he wasn't always useless.
Nank was always useless.. he was masked by a great midfield.. it's not my problem most of you were blinded by our success to see this..
SYDNEY KNEW!!!!!
I TOLD YOU SO!!!
been on this for ages and ridiculed.. but I never sway..
Prestia was never any good!!! Always been average, just had Dusty and Cotch (who everyone hated) around him!!!
!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
Ah well, on track for a 200 point loss at this rate. That's impressive
-
Boys against men , the men playing for something the kids for self preservation and it will be worse next year , I just hope some of kids show something to give a little hope but at this rate a 20 goal belting is coming.
-
Leaders have been pathetic. Vlastuin is having a shocker. Mansell and Ralphsmith are the only ones who appear to be trying
-
What a pathetic bunch of spuds led by a coach who has no idea. Embarrassing.
Nank, Hopper, TT, Shai, Short, Vlas. Not exactly kids on peanuts.
Just rolling over and letting Hawthorn waltz out of the center.
-
By the way, Prestia was a club reject!!!!
Nank was !!!!! Why!!! SYDNEY knew
-
Nank tackling awesome again
-
By the way, Prestia was a club reject!!!!
Nank was !!!!! Why!!! SYDNEY knew
7
-
Nank tackling awesome again
8
This game is fun
-
Dear in the highlights stuff :help.
Reminds of the 2007 game at the Dome against Geelong :help.
This is worse!!! We have multiple premiership players out there
They were 4-7 years ago when they were in their prime. Most of the side today aren't premiership players. We have mostly oldies and fringe cubs and not much in between. I was there in 1987 too when we had Roach, Lee, Maurice snr and a premiership coach too in Tony Jewell (literally ripping his hair out). Won the spoon then too. Means diddly squat when most of the side are below standard and the team itself just wants the season to end. It's a team sport requiring all 22 to succeed. Even a few not up to it destroys the connection required defensively and offensively. We currently have more than a few not up to standard and not caring.
-
Just admit it, bank was never that great . He has now been exposed..
-
Just admit it, bank was never that great . He has now been exposed..
11
-
Just admit it, bank was never that great . He has now been exposed..
Ask Dusty how he won his Brownlow and Norm Smiths, ask him how many times it was Brandon Ellis coming off the square and protecting him.... :shh
Let's reveal all the club secrets. Lambert????!!!
-
Just admit it, bank was never that great . He has now been exposed..
11
12
13
....
157
Wgaf
-
I don’t recall ever seeing such poor defensive pressure. This carralling business is just crazy, no one wants to tackle just let them execute a kick with no pressure. It’s bizarre.
-
77 - 13
Led by a great captain and coach
-
77 - 13
Led by a great captain and coach
13
-
I don’t recall ever seeing such poor defensive pressure. This carralling business is just crazy, no one wants to tackle just let them execute a kick with no pressure. It’s bizarre.
YZE
-
X you are a crack up
-
I don’t recall ever seeing such poor defensive pressure. This carralling business is just crazy, no one wants to tackle just let them execute a kick with no pressure. It’s bizarre.
YZE
14
-
How come our players are all slipping over??
-
Mansell just never ever keeps his feet. He looks so silly jumping and rolling around out there. Just keep your feet son
-
And if we get it out of the centre and get it into the forward line who’s going to hit the scoreboard , I have no confidence and I’m thinking even our senior players are hoping for the season to end .
-
By the way, Prestia was a club reject!!!!
Nank was !!!!! Why!!! SYDNEY knew
Bagging 3-time premiership greats who are now in their 30s and can't do what they once did in their prime 4-7 years ago ::).
It's round 23 and the bottom side with nothing to play for is playing the most inform team in the comp. Remember we lost the last game of 2016 by around 113 pts and that was with a list that would win a flag 12 months later. Players are human. Today was going to be a minimum 10 goal loss if the Hawks turned up to play which they did until the last 10 mins. Welcome to reality!
If you hate it now, then you're going to hate it even more over the next 5 years when we'll be a regular bottom 4 side like the Hawks were from 2019-2023. It's not going to turn until we hit multiple drafts and grab and develop multiple mostly A-grade talent as we did between 2006-2009 - Jack, Sheds, Cotch, Rance, Dusty, Grimes, Astbury. Rebuilds are long and painful even when you get it mostly right.
-
Hopper is a turnover machine
-
The only positive in this game so far is that it's been all our younger brigade showing something.
When it should have been our leaders and experienced group.
Bauer and HRS have lead the way and the young group have followed.
But the game was over at QTR time.
-
Taranto must be captain next year
-
At least there was some effort that qtr
And it would appear when I get home tonight I'm going to busy. Fair bit of editing will be happening :banghead :banghead
-
I don’t recall ever seeing such poor defensive pressure. This carralling business is just crazy, no one wants to tackle just let them execute a kick with no pressure. It’s bizarre.
It's the exact opposite of a premiership winning football philosophy.
What do we call this game style?
-
At least there was some effort that qtr
And it would appear when I get home tonight I'm going to busy. Fair bit of editing will be happening :banghead :banghead
Not really much editing needed
Just pointing out the repetitive nonsense being posted
Wouldn’t think that doing that via counting would need editing ???
-
When a teammate is streaming towards F50 you lead up at the ballcarrier; not sit and allow your opponent to win front position and rebound with ease :facepalm.
Getting destroyed all over the park.
Mercy rule time already :help.
The commentators had a go at Ralphsmith for that, when it was Balta's fault
Balta doubled down on his mistake by not even trying to spoil it once he knew he was out of position.
-
How was that not HTB against Sicily? ::)
Second non-HTB call this qtr ::)
-
We are the worst tackling team by a mile.
How on earth have we forgotten what made us a powerhouse.
Why haven't we employed a tackling coach to improve this?
Are we going to do this?
You'd think we should. Or are we terrified of the soft cap monster?
-
Hopper is such a poor footballer.
-
Treszise is rubbish and Ross needs a haircut
-
I have question marks on Tresise not because of the stupid mistakes or losing one on one but his apparent lack of mongrel to win the next context.
You can be ok footy player but what makes you a quality isn't quitting because you lose or the ball isn't delivered to you correctly.
Pull out the digit and fight!
-
That F50 entry where Mansell got the quick bouncing kick in and everyone ran past the contest wanting the cheapy out the back and left the defensive side wide open is what does my head in with the way we play.
ps. that was a mark to Miller not paid ::)
-
Stuffen dumbass nank. Dumbest captain in the league. Time and time again dumb and undisciplined free kicks and 50’s. So over it
-
Nank. Captain cannot be doing that.
-
So sick of Nankervis being a momentum killer.. does it week in week out
-
Are you all starting to wake up about everything I have been saying about Bank.. he is useless.. always has been.. just was fortunate in the past to be part of a great midfield
Yes, he's been horrifically bad at times. No, he wasn't always useless.
Nank was always useless.. he was masked by a great midfield.. it's not my problem most of you were blinded by our success to see this..
SYDNEY KNEW!!!!!
I TOLD YOU SO!!!
been on this for ages and ridiculed.. but I never sway..
Please point to some of your posts from 2017-2020 where you were saying nank is useless. Will even take some bigfooty references……
Also still waiting for your clarification regarding Rowan Marshall being a kid.
-
What is great about our captain :banghead
He loves not only to give away an unnecessarily stupid free kick but give an even more ridiculously stupid 50 metres penalty and a goal. :rollin :help
-
Now that was something stupid Nank deserves criticism for let alone as captain :facepalm.
-
Any chance we had and it was minuscule Nank just killed it
Hang your head in shame Captain
-
Pathetic tackle from short steps
-
Blights level is VFL
-
Hopper wants possessions at any cost. He doesn't care where they go. Just wants the stat.
-
Hopper wants possessions at any cost. He doesn't care where they go. Just wants the stat.
Agreed. The amount of blind handballs is ridiculous. No class or damage. Such a poor decision acquiring him
-
Blights level is VFL
3rd game
Least of our problems today.
Should be more concerned with how far Miller has regressed in the last 6 weeks
-
At least there was some effort that qtr
And it would appear when I get home tonight I'm going to busy. Fair bit of editing will be happening :banghead :banghead
Not really much editing needed
Just pointing out the repetitive nonsense being posted
Wouldn’t think that doing that via counting would need editing ???
Was talking more about avoiding swear filter and some of the insults
-
The Tigers have now conceded 90 or more points in nine consecutive matches – their longest stretch since a streak of 12 games spanning late 2010 and early 2011.
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/6088#timeline
-
Yeah massive concerns over miller. Doesn’t look like a backmen the second half of this year.
Trezise very very poor too.
-
Should be more concerned with how far Miller has regressed in the last 6 weeks
Exhibit A: A short 15m pass to a contest in D50 :help.
-
Short :thumbsdown
-
Again a Tiger player running towards F50 and no forward is leading hard up towards him :facepalm.
-
Hopper :thumbsdown :banghead
-
Our desperate need to handball as first option is beyond stupid now :facepalm.
-
Do any of our defenders ever stop opponents from a free run and jump at the ball.
-
Aside from the poor defensive pressure, structure and complete disorganisation ( that is extremely concerning ) our disposal really sticks out. Not of afl standard. Tells me we have a good 3-4 years of recruiting to bring in elite ball users until we can start to turn things around
-
Miller .. my god wow :thumbsdown :banghead
-
The schoolboy errors with and without the ball :facepalm :help
-
Just weed out the lazy 1-way runners. They are everywhere.
-
Well we got to 10 goals. That's about our limit these days :P.
-
Once again 3 Tigers run past the ball/contest when the ball ends up 5m defensive side. Hello being front and square that you learn when you're a little kid :banghead.
-
I want the club to come out and tell the supporters their plan. What are we working on. What kind of game style are we trying to create and play? What kind of personnel do we need ? There’s just no communication. Surely the club can’t think we can still compete and re build on the run.
We need to see wtf the plan is
-
Seriously, what do we do at training during the week? Another kick inside an open 50 that goes nowhere near our forwards. Where's the freaking connection? Where's the hit up forward?
-
I want the club to come out and tell the supporters their plan. What are we working on. What kind of game style are we trying to create and play? What kind of personnel do we need ? There’s just no communication. Surely the club can’t think we can still compete and re build on the run.
We need to see wtf the plan is
It doesn't help that we have a Prez that is MIA and rarely publicly speaks. We had Benny do most of the communication as CEO but he's leaving in a few weeks and not leading the rebuild. It's all been left to rookie coach Yze.
I remember back in 2009-10 when Benny came in, the Club had members' forums inviting ppl from fan forums like OER. It was direct communication in what the Club was planning both on and off-field.
-
The President as far as I'm aware has done one radio interview this season. Not good enough.
They are wanting people to contribute to redevelopment but we keep dishing up pathetic efforts like today.
But anyways the player I'm most peeved with today is the Captain. That stupid free and then the 50 in the third killed any chance, momentum we had. He should step down from the captaincy immediately after that
Unforgivable
-
The President as far as I'm aware has done one radio interview this season. Not good enough.
Sounds like Kamala.
-
Just weed out the lazy 1-way runners. They are everywhere.
So you want us to delist 37 players and just be left with Rioli & half a dozen or so duds? :shh
-
The President as far as I'm aware has done one radio interview this season. Not good enough.
Sounds like Kamala.
'65 actually bagging a leftist politician - frame this post. :o
-
Why do so many of players either slip over or just go to ground far too easily? :banghead
-
I thought Coultard did a few nice things, Mansell had a RHG, Taranto and Rioli good, Bolton was our most exciting player, Miller actually had one good passage of play when he went for an intercept and a run, Nankervis, well he didn’t know who to give the ball to in that 50 m moment, give it to the wrong person and it’s a 50.
All in all a few positives but really a slow moving train wreck.
Our List management department needs a massive shake up.
-
Pre game - I expected a 100 point loss .
So to fight back after such a calamitous first quarter was an unexpected surprise.
It’s hard to fathom that expectations have fallen away so quickly that a 10 goal loss feels under par .
-
I thought Coultard did a few nice things, Mansell had a RHG, Taranto and Rioli good, Bolton was our most exciting player, Miller actually had one good passage of play when he went for an intercept and a run, Nankervis, well he didn’t know who to give the ball to in that 50 m moment, give it to the wrong person and it’s a 50.
All in all a few positives but really a slow moving train wreck.
Our List management department needs a massive shake up.
sorry i would have to disagree here. TT was rubbish and Hopper not far behind. Nank average despite some positive momets.