One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 14, 2025, 06:29:26 PM
-
No outs yet. Extended squad.
IN: Gibcus, Koschitzke, Trainor.
Source: RFC twitter/X.
-
RICHMOND
B: Nick Vlastuin Ben Miller Tylar Young
HB: Nathan Broad Sam Banks Jayden Short
C: Tyler Sonsie Dion Prestia James Trezise
HF: Maurice Rioli Seth Campbell Jack Ross
F: Noah Balta Tom Lynch Rhyan Mansell
R: Toby Nankervis Tim Taranto Jacob Hopper
Int: Tom Brown Taj Hotton Kamdyn McIntosh Harry Armstrong
Steely Green Luke Trainor Josh Gibcus Jacob Koschitzke
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1860556/three-additions-to-round-23-squad
-
Would be nice to see gibcus and Trainor together
-
Would be nice to see gibcus and Trainor together
As a couple? Progressive.
-
Would be nice to see gibcus and Trainor together
As a couple? Progressive.
In the same 22 more so than sexually. Especially with Miller and young. If the 4 can fit in the eyes of the coaches.
Give balta a run at ruck or wing.
Seems unlikely however, game trying to win
-
Don’t think those 4 can fit in the backline. That’s not even including Balta too. If gibcus can stay healthy we’re gonna have a pretty good problem.
-
Would be nice to see gibcus and Trainor together
Trainor had been poor for weeks prior to being "managed" last week
Although I reckon he will be straight back in, he shouldn't be and should go back to the VFL
-
Don’t think those 4 can fit in the backline. That’s not even including Balta too. If gibcus can stay healthy we’re gonna have a pretty good problem.
I rekn they could. Just in terms of number of talls we did run all of Astbury, Grimes, Broad and Rance/Balta together pretty successfully.
Let’s see how Gibcus is after the long lay off but he was pretty nimble and agile in his debut year. Reckon out of the 4, young would be the worst below his knees and at ground level but then again Astbury wasn’t great at that either.
Not comparing the groups skill wise obviously but just in terms of playing them all together, i think it could work.
-
North Melbourne's team for those interested:
In: - P.Curtis, J.Simpkin, T.Goad, W.Phillips, M.Whitlock
Out: - R.Hardeman (Injured), B.Teakle (Omitted)
---------------------
B: C.Comben, T.Pink, G.Logue
HB: T.Powell, C.Daniel, F.O’Sullivan
C: D.Stephens, L.Davies-Uniacke, C.McKercher
HF: P.Curtis, C.Trembath, J.Simpkin
F: L.Parker, J.Darling, C.Zurhaar
FOLL: T.Xerri, H.Sheezel, G.Wardlaw
I/C: Z.Duursma, B.Scott, T.Goad, G.Payne, W.Phillips, M.Whitlock, C.Harvey, J.Konstanty
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-teams-round-23-2025-team-news-and-lineups-for-round-23-full-squads-ins-and-outs-injury-list-team-changes-selection-latest/news-story/81535523496d637f39d090deb368e53e
-
Lol nice.
We'll get to see the bloke Norf traded pick 3 for :D
-
Apparently gibcus needs 1 more vfl game for finals
-
One change.
Trainor in for Green.
Source: RFC twitter/X.
-
RICHMOND
B: Nick Vlastuin Ben Miller Tylar Young
HB: Nathan Broad Sam Banks Jayden Short
C: Tyler Sonsie Dion Prestia James Trezise
HF: Maurice Rioli Seth Campbell Jack Ross
F: Noah Balta Tom Lynch Rhyan Mansell
R: Toby Nankervis Tim Taranto Jacob Hopper
Int: Tom Brown Taj Hotton Kamdyn McIntosh Harry Armstrong Luke Trainor
Emg: Steely Green Josh Gibcus Jacob Koschitzke
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1862172/youngster-returns-for-tasmania-trip
-
Fair call. Hotton is keeping green out
-
One change.
Trainor in for Green.
Source: RFC twitter/X.
What a surprise not >:(
Further proof that young Luke is one of the coach's favourites >:(
-
One change.
Trainor in for Green.
Source: RFC twitter/X.
What a surprise not >:(
Further proof that young Luke is one of the coach's favourites >:(
All the draftees have been given games, like Armstrong coming back in so soon too.
I’m all for it at this stage
-
One change.
Trainor in for Green.
Source: RFC twitter/X.
What a surprise not >:(
Further proof that young Luke is one of the coach's favourites >:(
All the draftees have been given games, like Armstrong coming back in so soon too.
I’m all for it at this stage
I am supportive of playing the kids. We have to I get that
But Trainor has even horribly out of form. His efforts a fortnight ago against the Suns were to be blunt at times pathetic. Refused to chase, zero 2nd efforts. If a senior player dished it up people would be demanding they be dropped.
If they drop Sims for poor form, then that rule applies to all of the kids
-
I agree Trainor has been poor but worth persisting with, just needs the experience. Next year should be a bit more even re: who gets games. Especially if gibcus can stay healthy. Hard backline to break into
-
Really disappointed that Gibcus not included. Believe would have been an excellent opportunity for him to build confidence. Wasted chance.
-
RICHMOND
B: Nick Vlastuin Ben Miller Tylar Young
HB: Nathan Broad Sam Banks Jayden Short
C: Tyler Sonsie Dion Prestia James Trezise
HF: Maurice Rioli Seth Campbell Jack Ross
F: Noah Balta Tom Lynch Rhyan Mansell
R: Toby Nankervis Tim Taranto Jacob Hopper
Int: Tom Brown Taj Hotton Kamdyn McIntosh Harry Armstrong Luke Trainor
Emg: Steely Green Josh Gibcus Jacob Koschitzke
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1862172/youngster-returns-for-tasmania-trip
Its irrelevant what teams we pick now with just this and next week to go.
Things like giving McIntosh and others send of games is the go.
The truth is if half that side doesnt change for next year then development will totally stall. Injuries seriously curtailed development of kids this year we don't want that to happen again.
As should have been the case this year minimal older blokes just because they have experience and play our most talented kids as much as possible with just enough experience around them.
Would like them to think outside the box a bit more and find ways to ensure as many of our kids are playing as possible. Things like trying Brown and Campbell on the wing. Lefau as a mid, Smillie across hb and Hotton and lalor as mid forwards and Balta as a second ruck/utility.
Next year we need to play sides along these lines.
Vlastuin - Miller - Trainor
Smillie - Gibcus - Banks#
Campbell - Taranto - Brown
Nankervis - McAuliffe - Lalor
Hotton - Faull - Algar
Mansell - Lynch - Armstrong
Sharpe #2 hopefully at this stage. - Hopper - Broad - Balta - Pick #3 highly skilled quick more outside than in. - Lefau as a mid/utility.
Outside of some younger blokes not named imo the majority of the rest are superfluous to needs and are the ones we need to improve on.
Can put up with lots of losses if its with good kids but not if its with ordinary players like we constantly have played.
-
RICHMOND
B: Nick Vlastuin Ben Miller Tylar Young
HB: Nathan Broad Sam Banks Jayden Short
C: Tyler Sonsie Dion Prestia James Trezise
HF: Maurice Rioli Seth Campbell Jack Ross
F: Noah Balta Tom Lynch Rhyan Mansell
R: Toby Nankervis Tim Taranto Jacob Hopper
Int: Tom Brown Taj Hotton Kamdyn McIntosh Harry Armstrong Luke Trainor
Emg: Steely Green Josh Gibcus Jacob Koschitzke
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1862172/youngster-returns-for-tasmania-trip
Its irrelevant what teams we pick now with just this and next week to go.
Things like giving McIntosh and others send of games is the go.
The truth is if half that side doesnt change for next year then development will totally stall. Injuries seriously curtailed development of kids this year we don't want that to happen again.
As should have been the case this year minimal older blokes just because they have experience and play our most talented kids as much as possible with just enough experience around them.
Would like them to think outside the box a bit more and find ways to ensure as many of our kids are playing as possible. Things like trying Brown and Campbell on the wing. Lefau as a mid, Smillie across hb and Hotton and lalor as mid forwards and Balta as a second ruck/utility.
Next year we need to play sides along these lines.
Vlastuin - Miller - Trainor
Smillie - Gibcus - Banks#
Campbell - Taranto - Brown
Nankervis - McAuliffe - Lalor
Hotton - Faull - Algar
Mansell - Lynch - Armstrong
Sharpe #2 hopefully at this stage. - Hopper - Broad - Balta - Pick #3 highly skilled quick more outside than in. - Lefau as a mid/utility.
Outside of some younger blokes not named imo the majority of the rest are superfluous to needs and are the ones we need to improve on.
Can put up with lots of losses if its with good kids but not if its with ordinary players like we constantly have played.
Largely agree.
Tigers fielding a side almost two years older and more experienced than norf tomorrow.
Not ideal at this stage of the rebuild.
The entire starting midfield. Half the back 6 and Lynch is far too old for a best 22.
-
Kmac is the sub.
-
Kmac is the sub.
And strangely Whitlock