One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on June 13, 2021, 10:33:57 PM
-
Hopefully we get Prestia back. Not sure about Nank.
Fire away with your changes ...?
-
Out : Lazy Cotchin
IN : Cotchin with effort.
-
Castagna Caddy Aartz
Prestia Miller Collier-Dawkins
-
Caddy
Chol
Out
Nank
Prestia
In
-
Too early and raw right now but hopefully Nank & Prestia are right.
-
INS: Prestia, Nank, RCD
OUTS: Caddy, Rioli, Chol
-
INS: Prestia, Nank, RCD
OUTS: Caddy, Rioli, Chol
I understand this but I really think that if we care using Pickett as a relief ruck then we are running a tall less than we should (or a coaching error). We were running with only one ruck, have had Atbury, Lynch and Nank go out and have only bought CCJ and Chol in. Seems unbalanced to me.
-
Outs: Rioli (please!). Castagna (please!). Chol.
Ins: Prestia. Nankervis. Parker (can’t be worse than Rioli or Castagna)
Caddy - very lucky to keep his spot.
McIntosh - needs to clean up his delivery (terrible).
Cotchin - needs to find some of his leadership magic.
B: Nathan Broad Noah Balta Dylan Grimes
HB: Bachar Houli Jayden Short Nick Vlastuin
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Shai Bolton Marlion Pickett
HF: Trent Cotchin Shane Edwards Kane Lambert
F: Callum Coleman-Jones Dustin Martin Jack Riewoldt
R: Toby Nankervis Dion Prestia Jack Graham
Int: Jake Aarts. Josh Caddy. Liam Baker (forward if centre only). Matthew Parker.
Emerg: Mabior Chol. Ben Miller. Daniel Rioli. Jason Castagna. Will Martyn. Hugo Ralphsmith
-
I would be extremely happy to never see caddy and chol ever again. They are both rubbish and Rioli not far behind.
Out: Caddy Chol Rioli
In: Stack, Prestia , Nank
-
OUTS: Caddy, Castagna, Aarts, Rioli, McIntosh,
INS: Miller, Parker, RCD, Prestia, Nankervis,
B: Vlastuin - Milller - Grimes
HB: Broad - Balta - Houli/Short
C: Lambert - Cotchin - Pickett
R: Nankervis - Martin - Prestia
HF: Bolton - Riewoldt - Baker
F: Edwards - CC-J - Parker
Int: Graham - RC-D - Chol - Stack - Dow - Short.
-
OUTS: Caddy, Castagna, Aarts, Rioli, McIntosh,
INS: Miller, Parker, RCD, Prestia, Nankervis,
Something like this & throw Baker forward.... :shh
-
Balmey said he'd be surprised if Prestia and Lynch don't play against St Kilda.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/959101/talking-tigers-episode-15-2021
-
Pickett and Rioli 'dropped' to the ressies this week.
-
Pickett and Rioli 'dropped' to the ressies this week.
Pickett has already had his break due to suspension. Rioli needs another full game after being sub two weeks in a row. Good decision
-
Prestia and Astbury are available to return according to the RFC website.
-
Hope they leave Astbury out.
-
We're is Nank I thought it was a 2 week injury.
-
Out: Castagna, Rioli, Pickett, Ralpsmith (sub)
In Lynch, Prestia, RCD
B Grimes Balta Short
HB Baker Broad Vlastuin
C Graham Prestia McIntosh
HF Edwards Riewoldt Lambert
F CCJ Lynch Martin
R Chol Cotchin Bolton
Int Aarts, RCD, Houli, Caddy
Sub: Who cares (stupid rule)
-
Tigers premiership pair poised to return for clash with Saints
Daniel Cherny
The Age
June 22, 2021
Richmond are likely to regain triple-premiership pair David Astbury and Dion Prestia for Friday night’s MCG clash against St Kilda as the Tigers seek to keep alive their flagging top-four chances.
However Tiger pillars Toby Nankervis and Tom Lynch have been ruled out of contention for the date with the Saints, despite closing in on returns from their respective knee injuries.
Astbury (Achilles) hasn’t played since the round 10 loss to the Brisbane Lions but the Tigers listed him on Monday as “probable” for this week, as they have with injury-prone midfielder Prestia (hamstring), who is in line to return less than three weeks after being hurt in Richmond’s win against Essendon at Optus Stadium.
The Tigers gave away a hint of their impending selection moves this week when Marlion Pickett and Daniel Rioli played in Richmond’s drawn VFL game against Williamstown on Sunday.
Pickett and Rioli are both senior incumbents, playing in the round 13 loss to West Coast in Perth, but appear likely to be squeezed out of the AFL 22 this week given they played at the lower level over the weekend of Richmond’s senior bye.
Hugo Ralphsmith, who was the Tigers’ unused medical substitute against the Eagles, also played in the thriller against the Seagulls.
Backman Astbury could in-effect take Pickett’s role as backup ruckman behind Mabior Chol, who has been holding down the no.1 role in the absence of the injured Nankervis and Ivan Soldo.
While they have a relatively favourable fixture in the back half of the season, Richmond will begin round 15 two wins and 23 per cent outside the top four. Only one side - the Western Bulldogs in 2016 - has won the premiership from positions 5-8 since the advent of the current finals system.
Lynch is listed as a “short-term” proposition on the Tigers’ website, while Nankervis is out for the “medium-term.”
https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/tigers-premiership-pair-poised-to-return-for-clash-with-saints-20210621-p582xx.html
-
Team Tips: The premiers keep gaining reinforcements with David Astbury and Dion Prestia likely to return for Friday night. Based on VFL selection, Marlion Pickett, Daniel Rioli and unused medical sub Hugo Ralphsmith are on the fringes of the 23, since the AFL team had a bye on the weekend but all three played against Williamstown. Astbury could back up Mabior Chol in the ruck - which Pickett has been doing.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2021-afl-teams-round-15-team-tips-predicted-lineups-squads-games-injuries-ins-and-outs-supercoach-news/news-story/0ad70394dd485410ccdac607ed2ea357
-
:banghead Astbury in the ruck
-
:banghead Astbury in the ruck
Astbury or Pickett in the Ruck are a mistake IMHO.
-
In the Mix: Round 15
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
22 June 2021
RICHMOND
The Tigers are set for a selection crunch, with Dion Prestia (hamstring) and David Astbury (Achilles) ready to return, bar any mishaps. Marlion Pickett played VFL last weekend while the AFL side had a bye, as did Daniel Rioli – the pair both played against the Eagles in round 13. Josh Caddy may also be an option to come out of the side. We're unlikely to see a defender come out due to Liam Baker's versatility allowing room for Astbury to return.
Verdict: Pickett and Rioli out for Prestia and Astbury
https://www.afl.com.au/news/634821/in-the-mix-r15-big-names-returning-who-makes-way
-
Prestia is a lock for Friday night.
Astbury could miss another week.
Source: 7news
-
Samson Ryan is an in
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/963154/samson-ryan-to-debut-against-the-saints
-
Samson Ryan is an in
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/963154/samson-ryan-to-debut-against-the-saints
Like it. We have been playing 1 short in the big guy department for a while now. Chol, Ryan are the main rucks and will rotate up forward with CCJ so we will always have two talls down there. Well that is at least how I picture it.
-
Are we seeing a change in selection philosophy? It feels to me like the 3 amigo small forward era is coming to an end...
-
Clearly we're worried about Marshall & Ryder. Both sides going in tall in the wet will be interesting.
-
Dimma said Astbury has been ruled out.
-
From the training pics: Ryan (who we know is playing), RCD, Mansell & Parker took part in the captain's run today of those who didn't play against the Eagles.