One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 04, 2010, 07:05:32 PM
-
Any?
Is Lids' elbow okay?
-
McGuane-in if Lids is injured, if Lids is not injured then Tambling!
Leave Griff in as he is our lucky charm!
-
I'm a realist, but good times coming up u tiger fatefull - I'll be there with bells on as per usual - Did I mention that was FFFARKEN AWESOME today :cheers
-
Outs Tambling (Enough is enough)
Ins Gourdis
-
Out Tambling
In Foley( if ready )
-
I'd probably not make a change unless injury demanded so, but if I did it would be to give Griffiths a rest and see if Gourdis can make it this season. Gourdis and Astbury could then float forward and back as needed.
Be tempted to bring Webberley in for Tambling too - thought the bronx cheers for Tambo were ordinary today tho.
-
The bronx cheers were warranted
-
The bronx cheers were warranted
Agreed was poor for the most part. Is becoming the supporters bunny this season and has taken over from Jordy.
-
Tambling was very good at the end of the game
-
Tambling had a shocker today until the last quarter, then I don't think anybody played that last quarter badly. Griffiths needs to stay in the side and should try and play every game for the rest of the season, he's getting better with each outing and today was his best game so far, he needs as many games under his belt as he can possibly get. Possibly Tambling out and Foley in, they should at least look at it.
-
The bronx cheers were warranted
Agreed was poor for the most part. Is becoming the supporters bunny this season and has taken over from Jordy.
Its not the point really. In some cases there are players like Jordy who are soft and don't do anything for the team. The cheers went up for Tambling because he wasn't getting his hands on the footy enough - its a problem for him. But unlike Jordy he never shirks the dirty work and for a time this season his tackling stats were fantastic.
By all means drop him as he's not getting hold of it enough, but better to get behind him than put more pressure on him
-
Yes enough is enough!
Tambling -out
Foley or Gourdis -in
-
Yes enough is enough!
Tambling -out
Foley or Gourdis -in
Welcome to OER, aer(blah blah)
:thumbsup
-
The bronx cheers were warranted
Agreed was poor for the most part. Is becoming the supporters bunny this season and has taken over from Jordy.
Its not the point really. In some cases there are players like Jordy who are soft and don't do anything for the team. The cheers went up for Tambling because he wasn't getting his hands on the footy enough - its a problem for him. But unlike Jordy he never shirks the dirty work and for a time this season his tackling stats were fantastic.
By all means drop him as he's not getting hold of it enough, but better to get behind him than put more pressure on him
Not disagreeing with what you are saying TBJ, merely that is where the fans it seems are at with Tambling.
Injured or not he needs either some time at Coburg or if his inury is giving him too much grief some time resting up. He just seems slow and reactive and that's the way he has been all season for the most part and unfortuantely he is in year 6 of his career. Consistency is obviously lacking.
-
Injured or not he needs either some time at Coburg or if his inury is giving him too much grief some time resting up. He just seems slow and reactive and that's the way he has been all season for the most part and unfortuantely he is in year 6 of his career. Consistency is obviously lacking.
Agree with that. Going back to Coburg and getting 30 touches would do the trick
-
Injured or not he needs either some time at Coburg or if his inury is giving him too much grief some time resting up. He just seems slow and reactive and that's the way he has been all season for the most part and unfortuantely he is in year 6 of his career. Consistency is obviously lacking.
Agree with that. Going back to Coburg and getting 30 touches would do the trick
Yep but not just for a week. It's not about sending him back to Coburg for a week to teach him a lesson keep him there for a few weeks let him regain some form there and see how he reacts in his head to that challenge.
-
Out Tambling
In Foley( if ready )
Would be very surprsied to see Foley again this year. Actually cannot see the point. Why play him? Just let him get ready for next year - I am sure all good pro-tankers would agree ;D
Out: Astbury (needs a rest struggling a bit at the minute), Tambling (I'm a Richie fan but he needs a break to get some confidence), Vickery (struggled today)
Ins: Gourdis, BrownE, Webberley or Polo (just to upset people) ;D
-
Out: Astbury (needs a rest struggling a bit at the minute)
William, Hardwick has suggested that Astbury get the rising star nomination this week in his press conference, so I'm pretty sure he's going to get another gig this week.
-
Out: Astbury (needs a rest struggling a bit at the minute)
William, Hardwick has suggested that Astbury get the rising star nomination this week in his press conference, so I'm pretty sure he's going to get another gig this week.
Yeah I know Rodger but I just thought today at times (especially against the big bodies) he struggled
He going to be a very good player no doubt and as I posted soemwhere else I think he has already bolted past Jayden Post
-
if he puts up rubbish like that what do you expect.
those cheers were warranted
he is taken the spot of someone who deserves a game..
I personally think he is as bad as JON.
he lets the team down with his fairy slow paced crap. dud of the highest order.
-
I personally think he is as bad as JON.
Talk about an over exageration
-
I personally think he is as bad as JON.
Talk about an over exageration
x2 :gobdrop
-
I personally think he is as bad as JON.
Talk about an over exageration
x2 :gobdrop
x3
But he does need to be dropped, give him a week or two out, after that if he does not preform trade.
-
tambling is safe, he is copping from everyone left right and centre, but he has been given specific roles each qtr mainle defensive ones by dimma, blingers is sacrificing his game for teh team and is always putting his body in, his last quarter was very important and there is no way he willl be dropped
dimma knows whats going on and he is happy
if mguanes ankle is still stuffed there will be no change
-
Would be good if Foley was right but not confident. Thought Farmer played his best game for the club. I know he is only a rookie but was glad to see Hicks was in the best for Coburg. Unless there are injuries would not change the side
-
those cheers were warranted
Richmond "SUPPORTERS" rubbishing Richmond players in never warranted in any circumstances.
It makes us look like Collingwood morons.
The match committee will makes correct decisions without input from morons.
-
Agree Ekto.
Like with the spitter (who wasn't even a Richmond supporter) crap like what Tambling copped from a minority taints all Richmond supporters.
-
Looks like Cousins will be out, would also rest Deledio if his arm is not right. He wont want to miss as he is looking at 3 B&F's in a row.
Temptation would be to rest Griffiths but as he is 4-0 this year so cant see it.
Out Cousins, Vickery (rested)
In Gourdis, Browne
Possibly a little tall but the Goo can play small. Like this back 6.
B Newman Gourdis Thursfield
HB Deledio Moore Connors
Would love to see Post & Rance get a run in the coming weeks.
-
Also agrees with Ekto
That sort of behaviour is FERAL not warranted or wanted in the outer.
-
Agree Ekto.
Like with the spitter (who wasn't even a Richmond supporter) crap like what Tambling copped from a minority taints all Richmond supporters.
Yes he was FF and still is. Very much regrets it and is very ashamed of it. I know him through long time family friends and although I couldn't stand him at first because of what he did, I must say his contrition since has been sincere. Lives in Qld but has always followed Richmond.
-
if he puts up rubbish like that what do you expect.
those cheers were warranted
he is taken the spot of someone who deserves a game..
I personally think he is as bad as JON.
he lets the team down with his fairy slow paced crap. dud of the highest order.
pal, my friend, mate, cobber.....that's a dud post of the highest order.
-
Cousins is going to be a massive loss next week.
When the tigers were hanging by a thread last Sunday....Bennys experience was holding the team together (only just).
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
Ben Cousins is likely to miss this weekend's clash with Fremantle after being hospitalised early in the week - Cousins says he wants to play, but is likely to be rested. Robin Nahas (31 disposals) and Jeromey Webberley (23) were both excellent for Coburg in the midfield, with Webberley appealing as a direct replacement for the Brownlow Medallist. Defender Alex Rance is still pushing for a spot after being Coburg's best.
FREMANTLE
With a key defender crisis developing at Freo, Chris Tarrant will have to return this week after struggling with an achilles complaint. The stuff, who was a late withdrawal against Port Adelaide, could be joined by Nick Suban after the young midfielder returned from an elbow injury through the WAFL. Des Headland is on the verge of playing again after 10 matches sidelined with a knee injury, while Greg Broughton (hamstring) will be tested.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/97630/default.aspx
-
Yes he was FF and still is. Very much regrets it and is very ashamed of it. I know him through long time family friends and although I couldn't stand him at first because of what he did, I must say his contrition since has been sincere. Lives in Qld but has always followed Richmond.
Thanks for clearing that up smokey, although I was happier believing what I was told about him being from Brisbane on a junket.
A tiges supporter. >:(
You're a forgiving person. He's a filthy, low scumbag.
-
Out - Cousins
In - Nahas
:)
-
Has anyone really been standing up at Coburg that would deserve a shot at replacing Cousins? Or has Nahas been consistent enough to get a recall??
-
Has anyone really been standing up at Coburg that would deserve a shot at replacing Cousins? Or has Nahas been consistent enough to get a recall??
One really good game shouldn't mean a recall
Consistent performances over a number of weeks should
I'd go for Webberely before Nahas
-
COUSINS IN.
Freo lose.
-
I'd go for Webberely before Nahas
Ken Oath.
I thought Webberley was quite good for us and like Collins put his body on the line a couple of times and maybe in light of this should be top of the pecking order....
-
COUSINS IN.
Freo lose.
Ken Oath
-
Cousins out
Morton or Webberly in
I would love it if Cousins played because apparently the media (that fw Quartermaine) had him pegged for never playing again.
PS: Apparently recoveringdrugaddict is a middle name as is adulterer and beatup man - LOL
-
Thanks for clearing that up smokey, although I was happier believing what I was told about him being from Brisbane on a junket.
A tiges supporter. >:(
You're a forgiving person. He's a filthy, low scumbag.
I get that FF - it took me a while, a long while!
-
I'd go for Webberely before Nahas
Ken Oath.
I thought Webberley was quite good for us and like Collins put his body on the line a couple of times and maybe in light of this should be top of the pecking order....
Agree WP and Jake about Webbs coming in if Cuz misses. Unlucky to be dropped when he was, been consistent at Coburg and we don't really have anyone else playing at Coburg who can come in play 4 quarters in the midfield.
If McGuane's over his ankle injury he could come back in also. Hard to drop anyone though from a winning side.
-
If McGuane's over his ankle injury he could come back in also. Hard to drop anyone though from a winning side.
I am starting to wonder if that is the right balance. Most teams are shorter in the front 6 than they used to be and have 1-2 genuine marking talls, and having three 'short talls' as we do in McGuane, Moore and Thursty means that one of the opposition shorter forwards is often picked up by one of these. Plus it means we carry 3 blokes down back who aren't much of a kick. It was great on the weekend rebounding with Deledio, Newman, Farmer, Astbury, Connors. All better kicks and really set us up going forward. Would rather we looked at two of Moore, McGuane and Thursfield.
-
No Change!
-
The media this arvo are saying the ins will come from Webberley, Nahas and Morton.
-
They were saying on Fox sport news that Cotchin was also in doubt