One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 04, 2011, 05:06:25 PM
-
Richmond
B: Bachar Houli, Alex Rance, Luke McGuane
HB: Brett Deledio, Will Thursfield, Matt Dea
C: Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Daniel Jackson, Tyrone Vickery, Reece Conca
F: Robin Nahas, Jack Riewoldt, Jake King
Foll: Angus Graham, Shane Tuck, Nathan Foley
I/C: Matthew White, Mitch Morton, Mitchell Farmer, Ben Griffiths, Jeromey Webberley, Shaun Grigg, Brad Miller
In: Mitchell Farmer, Matt Dea, Jeromey Webberley, Shaun Grigg, Brad Miller
Out: Chris Newman (Knee), Jake Batchelor (Shoulder)
-
No Post ???
-
Miller????????
Where the hell is Post?
-
No Post ???
What a joke. Post ripped off. Club stuffing his development and our back 6 development. Miller lmao
-
At least we are upping McGuane and Thirsty's trade value.
:thumbsup
-
This could play out a few ways. It could be experience for experience swap with Grigg in for Newy. That would mean perhaps Dea in for Batchelor in the backline. Alternatively either Farmer/Webberley will come in for Newy and then Grigg in for Batchelor.
I'm hoping we don't do something stupid and shortsighted and drop Griffiths for Miller :help.
-
peeed off. I want to see Post given a run and see what he can do. The hole is there at CHB and he is the friggen answer. :banghead
-
peeed off. I want to see Post given a run and see what he can do. The hole is there at CHB and he is the friggen answer. :banghead
Postie was equal b.o.g. with BrownE for Coburg last week and both can't even make the squad yet Miller who missed the game is included in the 25. Just weird! ???
-
Here's the West Coast squad:
B: Shannon Hurn, Darren Glass, Will Schofield
HB: Ashley Smith, Eric Mackenzie, Scott Selwood
C: Matthew Rosa, Matthew Priddis, Andrew Embley
HF: Luke Shuey, Jack Darling, Andrew Gaff
F: Mark Nicoski, Quinten Lynch, Mark LeCras
Foll: Dean Cox, Daniel Kerr, Adam Selwood
I/C: Mitch Brown, Chris Masten, Bradley Ebert, Nic Naitanui, Patrick McGinnity, Bradd Dalziell, Brad Sheppard
In: Daniel Kerr, Mitch Brown, Chris Masten, Nic Naitanui, Bradd Dalziell, Brad Sheppard
Out: Beau Waters (elbow), Thomas Swift, Scott Lycett
-
Agree with comments that Post should be included. Will be angry if drop Griffiths for Miller
-
Grigg and Dea are both playing this week according to the RFC site:
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/6301/newsid/120209/default.aspx
-
peeed off. I want to see Post given a run and see what he can do. The hole is there at CHB and he is the friggen answer. :banghead
Postie was equal b.o.g. with BrownE for Coburg last week and both can't even make the squad yet Miller who missed the game is included in the 25. Just weird! ???
It's a disgrace. I pay to see the best future team out there. You have to give all players a fair run of weeks at afl level. Why are we playing Miller? Backwards crap
-
We are tanking!
-
peeed off. I want to see Post given a run and see what he can do. The hole is there at CHB and he is the friggen answer. :banghead
Postie was equal b.o.g. with BrownE for Coburg last week and both can't even make the squad yet Miller who missed the game is included in the 25. Just weird! ???
It's a disgrace. I pay to see the best future team out there. You have to give all players a fair run of weeks at afl level. Why are we playing Miller? Backwards crap
Miller may still not be playing (fingers crossed) but no Post is just perplexing. It's not as though he needs to break into a winning side. We've lost 7 of our past 8 games.
-
How does Dea get a game is beyond belief .was useless at Coburg last week.Post plays good and doesn't get a game.someone at punt road is digging a grave for tbemselves .initials DH
-
Hardwick said the Tigers were 'hamstrung' to an extent by a burgeoning injury list that's left them with just 28 players to choose from this week.
http://www.sportal.com.au/afl-news-display/tigers-to-make-statement-132733
-
would love to know what is going on with post.
Is there anyone in the media with an inkling of knowledge who may put the question to Hardwick?
Millers inclusion without a tall ommited perhaps suggests one of our talls is under an injury cloud?
-
Obviously Post is on the outer. No other way to look at it. If he can't get a game with 28 players to choose from then his papers are probably signed or if he is still contracted next year he may be put as trade bait.
-
I'm over the team selections, I sick of our club being the playthings of people who treat our jumper like a roll of sorbent.
They can go and eff themselves, the lot of them.
-
Nason and Post hard done buy
-
Obviously Post is on the outer. No other way to look at it. If he can't get a game with 28 players to choose from then his papers are probably signed or if he is still contracted next year he may be put as trade bait.
He's exactly the player we need to pesist with. Would be very shocked if didn't have him in our future plans
-
Nason and Post hard done buy
Do not understand why Post isn't getting games. The season will be over soon and we will have wasted the last 12 weeks not trying to get him comfortable in our back 6. We want something to look forward too, not a piece of poo like Miller getting a game
-
Obviously Post is on the outer. No other way to look at it. If he can't get a game with 28 players to choose from then his papers are probably signed or if he is still contracted next year he may be put as trade bait.
either that or he has some flaws that really need ironing out.
I remember naught supporting mate lamenting how tough pagen was being on a young bloke by the name of david king. he said that pagan would drag him for the smallest indiscretion while other would do worse and not get dragged. I hadnt really seen him play at that stage and and only reply i had was that perhaps pagan thought he was worth the effort.
hopefully it's the same with post.
-
How does Dea get a game is beyond belief .was useless at Coburg last week.Post plays good and doesn't get a game.someone at punt road is digging a grave for tbemselves .initials DH
Are you ready to step up mate, we need YOU :bow :bow :bow
-
Dea looked completely lost at times last week.
Farmer what a disgrace
Miller see Farmer
Graham oh boy prepare yourselves for a benny hill debacle
-
This is why some players underperform at Coburg because whatever they do they don't get rewarded. Post will probably play like a depressed man. I'm so annoyed I might go and stab Miller at the airport 8)
-
this treatment perhaps will make or break him?
-
this treatment perhaps will make or break him?
I'm almost certain he's part of the future. This is just hardwicks way of making him as hungry as possible. If this is not the case then Hardwick is in trouble 8)
-
Dea looked completely lost at times last week.
Farmer what a disgrace
Miller see Farmer
Graham oh boy prepare yourselves for a benny hill debacle
Post of the week
-
Oh well, might as well play the lot and see what they have.
-
Dea looked completely lost at times last week.
Farmer what a disgrace
Miller see Farmer
Graham oh boy prepare yourselves for a benny hill debacle
Understand people's frsutrations with Dea getting a game ahead of others but he is coming off contract and TBH the only real way of seeing if he has anything to offer is play him
Decision time is coming up regarding the list need to see who's worth keeping and who needs to be shown the door.
-
It might be a chance to get some trade value in him!
-
I dont understand why people are so upset about the selections.
Ever heard of a club throwing a player in to see how they go???
I am far from a Matty Dea fan, but he hasnt had a great run in regards to being on the park. Give him a chance.
Dimma's comments about not gifting games was a while ago, the whole context of the season has change significantly since then.
Hope i am not talking too much sense here......... :P
-
Hope i am not talking too much sense here......... :P
You are
Shame on you ;D :thumbsup ;D
-
if you cant get a kick at coburg, you certainly wont get a kick in the AFL.
Feel really sorry for one J.Post
-
heres a thought
WGAF
Im over who we select now. Another year outside the 8, thats all i know
-
if you cant get a kick at coburg, you certainly wont get a kick in the AFL.
Feel really sorry for one J.Post
Jack I agree Post should have gotten the nod but he hasn't
I think they need to play Dea to see if he offers anything for the future as I said he's out of contract years end - need to see if he has improve at all on last year
-
It might be a chance to get some trade value in him!
No
Deais a nice prospect , good to see him back in..
Will probably struggle but another game at the top level competing is good..
-
Batch better get a game. It will eff my dreamteam if he's out. I have so many out of my backline.
-
what i know is this, most other clubs laugh at Richmond and there list,
We have players they are clearly not up to it.
As Daniel posted , yet another year outside the 8.
Only way we will get any better is automatically clean out the bottom 12 players and then try and trade 1 or 2 of your best 8 .
Very simple process.
But will keep rubbish players,
Keep rubbish players as Rookies Ala Hislop and Hicks who are clearly not up to it.
One last mention on Tuck, reason they havent played him is that there is a condition of his contract if he plays 15 games or more, he automatically gets a contract in 2012.
Pretty sad that his career was determined before the start of round 1.
Thats why we are a bottom team, with little vision and purpose
How J.Post doesnt get a game is a total disgrace. especially when Matt Dea will be remembered as one of the worst footbalers to pull on a RFC , Oh hold on, I forget about Gourdis, who most here throught he was the next start.
NEITHER CAN PLAY !
-
what i know is this, most other clubs laugh at Richmond and there list,
We have players they are clearly not up to it.
As Daniel posted , yet another year outside the 8.
Only way we will get any better is automatically clean out the bottom 12 players and then try and trade 1 or 2 of your best 8 .
Very simple process.
But will keep rubbish players,
Keep rubbish players as Rookies Ala Hislop and Hicks who are clearly not up to it.
One last mention on Tuck, reason they havent played him is that there is a condition of his contract if he plays 15 games or more, he automatically gets a contract in 2012.
Pretty sad that his career was determined before the start of round 1.
Thats why we are a bottom team, with little vision and purpose
How J.Post doesnt get a game is a total disgrace. especially when Matt Dea will be remembered as one of the worst footbalers to pull on a RFC , Oh hold on, I forget about
, who most here throught he was the next start.
NEITHER CAN PLAY !
Cottonelle man, you must keep Kleenex in business, it would take ten rolls a day to clean the crap from around your mouth! Half that post us stating the freaking obvious the other half sounds like part an exaggerated wet dream that you seem keep having over and over :sleep
As I said before, it shocks me that Brendan Gale hasn't tracked
you down to fix the club, you are our savior, you are "The Chosen One" :bow That is why the club is so up the creek :P
-
I wouldnt be surprised if Postie has told the club that he wants out. Hardwick would then not pick him so he could develop/ look at other players instead. Just a thought, can't see any other logical reason why he is not in the team over some of the others.
-
what i know is this, most other clubs laugh at Richmond and there list,
We have players they are clearly not up to it.
As Daniel posted , yet another year outside the 8.
Only way we will get any better is automatically clean out the bottom 12 players and then try and trade 1 or 2 of your best 8 .
Very simple process.
But will keep rubbish players,
Keep rubbish players as Rookies Ala Hislop and Hicks who are clearly not up to it.
One last mention on Tuck, reason they havent played him is that there is a condition of his contract if he plays 15 games or more, he automatically gets a contract in 2012.
Pretty sad that his career was determined before the start of round 1.
Thats why we are a bottom team, with little vision and purpose
How J.Post doesnt get a game is a total disgrace. especially when Matt Dea will be remembered as one of the worst footbalers to pull on a RFC , Oh hold on, I forget about
, who most here throught he was the next start.
NEITHER CAN PLAY !
Cottonelle man, you must keep Kleenex in business, it would take ten rolls a day to clean the crap from around your mouth! Half that post us stating the freaking obvious the other half sounds like part an exaggerated wet dream that you seem keep having over and over :sleep
As I said before, it shocks me that Brendan Gale hasn't tracked
you down to fix the club, you are our savior, you are "The Chosen One" :bow That is why the club is so up the creek :P
truth hurts
-
the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1
-
would think Hislop and Hicks are a total waste of space
What else do you think is garbage ?
Our list is poor, Recruiting been ordinary
-
the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1
That was part of my "captain obvious" stament...fact ;D
-
the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1
That was part of my "captain obvious" stament...fact ;D
For football club to do that, I would beleive that is a complete lack of vision. considering of his output against Geelong
Also he had broken ribs when he played round 4 and missed the next 3 weeks
Unfortunately not a level playing field for some players at punt rd
-
would think Hislop and Hicks are a total waste of space
What else do you think is garbage ?
Our list is poor, Recruiting been ordinary
It's all after the fact, it's easy to pot players and recruiting when it dosent work out but we never hear from you prior to the draft? Why? With all your knowledge you should be head of recruiting! What are your thought for this years draft? Who should we look at rookieing? You must of scouted plenty of players by now to have a good feel as to who we should be targeting?
Why don't you show your hand now so in a couple of years time you can actually say I told you so with some credibility.
-
mate , read my posts from 4-5 years ago :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
-
the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1
That was part of my "captain obvious" stament...fact ;D
For football club to do that, I would
beleive that is a complete lack of vision. considering of his output against Geelong
Also he had broken ribs when he played round 4 and missed the next 3 weeks
Unfortunately not a level playing field for some players at punt rd
So we are the only club on earth to do somthing like this to our players?
I can think of a dozen separate instances where a club has thought a player will not be a part of there plans going forward hence they are left to rot in the VFL. Some have even gone on to play in a premiership :o
-
"its all after the fact"
hahahaha
Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.
Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.
Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.
Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.
-
mate , read my posts from 4-5 years ago :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
I have waded back through the crap before, I couldn't find much that made any sence? Please feel free to enlighten me of your oricle ways :bow
-
mate , read my posts from 4-5 years ago :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
I have waded back through the crap before, I couldn't find much that made any sence? Please feel free to enlighten me of your oricle ways :bow
::) ::)
-
"its all after the fact"
hahahaha
Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.
Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.
Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.
Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.
thank you
-
"its all after the fact"
hahahaha
Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.
Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.
Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.
Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.
Dude, I'm not saying we havnt made some monumental stuff ups regarding our drafting just saying Jstar has a habit of bringing up the obvious but is never willing to put his money where his mouth is before the drafts!
-
Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.
Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects
-
Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.
Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects
Mate, I agree with you 100%, IMO the 2005 draft has hurt us more than any, that was a compleat eff up :banghead
-
"its all after the fact"
hahahaha
Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.
Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.
Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.
Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.
Dude, I'm not saying we havnt made some monumental stuff ups regarding our drafting just saying Jstar has a habit of bringing up the obvious but is never willing to put his money where his mouth is before the drafts!
i cant speak for him for Jack, what i can see is the RFC is not in a position to take risks and IMO we still make stupid risky decisions.
Why rookie Hislop again. Rookie draft is a powerful draft if used correctly yet we screw it up every year.
I was also dead against the Conca move and still am. I think he will be a serviceable player but not A grade.
Now its my opinion and i may be wrong
All i want is the best for the club and thats get rid of rubbish. Now we hold onto your mcguane/Edwards type till they are worthless.
-
Conca was playing 2,s footy in Perth last year I might add
-
Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.
Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects
McMahon played close to 20 senior games for the Dogs that year despite popular belief. Still wouldn't have traded for him but he wasn't in the twos all year
-
Put your vendetta against the RFC away for a sec and look at the FACTS. Jordan McMahon played 18 senior games for the Dogs in 07. He also played the last game of the home & away season, so obviously he was mostly a senior player in 2007. He didn't play in the twos all year.
STFU and move on from it. everybody else has
-
Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.
Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects
McMahon played close to 20 senior games for the Dogs that year despite popular belief. Still wouldn't have traded for him but he wasn't in the twos all year
the fact he was in the two's was enough for most richmond people. It was a disgraceful decision that cost us.
When has recruiting players from another club worked apart from this year which i would say its ahead.
Will say this. IMO Dimma's coaching role will be decided by December. If the same duds with limited currency are kept on board and not shopped around and he opts for Trengrove then i expect him gone by end of 2012.
-
The fact McMahon has overrated skills and doesn't win hardball was enough to put me off him but Jack said he played twos (which he did for a few games) was incorrect as he played 18 seniors game and the last game of the season.
-
Here's the West Coast squad:
B: Shannon Hurn, Darren Glass, Will Schofield
HB: Ashley Smith, Eric Mackenzie Mitch Brown, Scott Selwood
C: Matthew Rosa, Matthew Priddis, Andrew Embley
HF: Luke Shuey, Jack Darling, Andrew Gaff
F: Mark Nicoski, Quinten Lynch, Mark LeCras
Foll: Dean Cox, Daniel Kerr, Adam Selwood
I/C: Brett Jones, Chris Masten, Bradley Ebert, Nic Naitanui, Patrick McGinnity, Bradd Dalziell, Brad Sheppard
Mackenzie injured himself at Eagles' training tonight and will now miss the game on Sunday.
http://au.news.yahoo.com/thewest/a/-/breaking/9976290/training-mishap-forces-out-eagles-mackenzie/
-
He was in the 2,s actually .watched him for a month at Werribee
What a crock again! He only played 2 games that season in the two's rd 11 and 19 he missed 2 other games with injury...Fact! Exactly what month were you watching him? Maybe that was the problem, you were actualy watching someone you "thought" was McMahon :lol
-
:lol
-
Match committee is weak as pee and have made poor decisions this year.How the hell does Farmer get in the side while Posty has been playing really well for the burgers last month.Farmer and Hislop got a run of 4 or 5 games and did bugger all while Post plays one and he is not given a chance to string a couple together :banghead.God help us if Thursfield ,Mcgaune and Miller are our future!!! ahead of Post.Hardwick looses me at times.
-
Would believe 4 twos games equals a month.otherwise the guy I seen at werribee was an impostor .what an absolute disgrace that the RFC game him a million dollar contract for 3 years
-
Laughable .posters sticking up for Jordy
-
Laughable .posters sticking up for Jotdy
Who is Jotdy?
:lol
-
Although listed in the best Farmer was average last week. Post can feel hard done by but needs to keep performing well at Coburg level to prove how wrong the selectors are
-
Although listed in the best Farmer was average last week. Post can feel hard done by but needs to keep performing well at Coburg level to prove how wrong the selectors are
Wouldn't blame him if asked for a transfer.
>:(
-
Laughable .posters sticking up for Jotdy
What is Laughable is you think we are sticking up for him! I'm just picking holes in all you story's to prove your full of crap :lol
4 weeks in the ressies = a month :lol he only played 2 weeks in the ressies and had 2 off with injury you twit :lol :lol
-
How does Dea get a game is beyond belief
Woohoo ! Go Matty Dea ! A well deserved game in the seniors and anyone who says otherwise is a moron. Good luck kiddo
-
That's another thing, why would the club send you down to watch him play at VFL level when he played 18 games at AFL level that season? Did the club not want to pay the entrance fee for the AFL matches? it was cheaper for them to get you into a VFL game! or maybe the club really wanted to know about his VFL form knowing full well that's where he would end up :lol :lol
-
Laughable .posters sticking up for Jotdy
Who is Jotdy?
:lol
:lol
Laughable .posters sticking up for Jordy
No one is sticking up for him, we're just saying you've got a vendetta and you don't know the FACTS. The FACTS are that Jordy Mac played two games in the twos and was in the seniors for the rest of the season. FACT. We didn't offer someone who played twos all year a contract. That's a FACT. He played nearly all year in the ones.
FWIW I thought he was an average player and didn't want a bar of him. That's another FACT ;D
-
Go Dea! Give em hell! :thumbsup
-
No one is sticking up for him, we're just saying you've got a vendetta and you don't know the FACTS. The FACTS are that Jordy Mac played two games in the twos and was in the seniors for the rest of the season. FACT. We didn't offer someone who played twos all year a contract. That's a FACT. He played nearly all year in the ones.
FWIW I thought he was an average player and didn't want a bar of him. That's another FACT ;D
Jackstar spent a whole month wasting his time watching an impostor...FACT :lol
-
Woah!!
Shaun Grigg, Brad Miller and Mitch Farmer have joined Matt Dea as inclusions in the finalised Richmond side for Sunday’s Round 20 clash with the West Coast Eagles at Subiaco.
They replace captain, Chris Newman, who has been sidelined with a knee injury, 2011 NAB Rising Star nominee, Jake Batchelor, who will miss due to a shoulder injury, plus Matt White and Ben Griffiths, who have both been omitted.
The three Tiger emergencies for Sunday’s match are White, Griffiths and Jeromey Webberley.
Trent Cotchin will captain the team in the absence of Newman, while Daniel Jackson will play his 100th AFL game.
http://www.richmondfc.com.au/tabid/6301/default.aspx?newsid=120292
-
Must be Miller and Farmers farewell match.
-
I think I like it when we are winning better, for the obvious reasons offcourse but for one very important reason for the good people of the OER forum.
You don't have to scroll though page after page or repetitive crap from some sour idiot. He goes quiet when we are winning.
BTW I think Postie should of got a go but is there anybody here that actually knows what they are saying to him and are asking him to do? I don't think so.
Im also a bit perplexed on Griffiths missing out, we just have to trust the people that the Club have employed to do the job know what they are doing. I still see the light, just some of the selections seem a bit baffling to those not in the inner sanctum
-
Here's the finalised line-up:
Richmond
B: Bachar Houli, Alex Rance, Luke McGuane
HB: Brett Deledio, Will Thursfield, Matt Dea
C: Trent Cotchin, Dustin Martin, Shane Edwards
HF: Daniel Jackson, Tyrone Vickery, Reece Conca
F: Robin Nahas, Jack Riewoldt, Jake King
Foll: Angus Graham, Shane Tuck, Nathan Foley
I/C: Mitch Morton, Mitchell Farmer, Shaun Grigg, Brad Miller
Emg: Matthew White, Ben Griffiths, Jeromey Webberley
In: Mitchell Farmer, Matt Dea, Shaun Grigg, Brad Miller
Out: Chris Newman (Knee), Matthew White, Ben Griffiths, Jake Batchelor (Shoulder)
-
Miller ::)
Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago that Dimma said we need to get games into Griffiths and Post yet Miller is back getting a game ahead of both :banghead.
So much for needing to earn your spot at VFL level either when Miller didn't play last week ???.
-
Miller ::)
Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago that Dimma said we need to get games into Griffiths and Post yet Miller is back getting a game ahead of both :banghead.
So much for needing to earn your spot at VFL level either when Miller didn't play last week ???.
Anybody else think (or hope) a late change ?
-
Am certainly hoping for one, FT.
-
Miller ::)
Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago that Dimma said we need to get games into Griffiths and Post yet Miller is back getting a game ahead of both :banghead.
So much for needing to earn your spot at VFL level either when Miller didn't play last week ???.
Anybody else think (or hope) a late change ?
The Club normally takes 23 interstate just in case of a late injury. So unless Griffiths is the 23rd spare then Miller is definitely playing :scream.
-
Here's the West Coast final 22:
B: Shannon Hurn, Darren Glass, Will Schofield
HB: Ashley Smith, Mitch Brown, Scott Selwood
C: Matthew Rosa, Matthew Priddis, Andrew Embley
HF: Luke Shuey, Jack Darling, Andrew Gaff
F: Mark Nicoski, Quinten Lynch, Mark LeCras
Foll: Dean Cox, Daniel Kerr, Adam Selwood
I/C: Chris Masten, Bradley Ebert, Nic Naitanui, Patrick McGinnity
In: Daniel Kerr, Mitch Brown, Chris Masten, Nic Naitanui
Out: Beau Waters (elbow), Eric Mackenzie (Injured), Thomas Swift, Scott Lycett
-
Nothing would surprise me.
Miller could even stay on the list for 2012 :-\
-
Miller ::)
Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago that Dimma said we need to get games into Griffiths and Post yet Miller is back getting a game ahead of both :banghead.
So much for needing to earn your spot at VFL level either when Miller didn't play last week ???.
mate, the joint is a disgrace, still trying to work out why Griffiths and Post arent playing
-
Miller ::)
Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago that Dimma said we need to get games into Griffiths and Post yet Miller is back getting a game ahead of both :banghead.
So much for needing to earn your spot at VFL level either when Miller didn't play last week ???.
mate, the joint is a disgrace, still trying to work out why Griffiths and Post arent playing
Do they need to play a number of games at Coburg to play finals?
-
Miller ::)
Wasn't it only a couple of weeks ago that Dimma said we need to get games into Griffiths and Post yet Miller is back getting a game ahead of both :banghead.
So much for needing to earn your spot at VFL level either when Miller didn't play last week ???.
mate, the joint is a disgrace, still trying to work out why Griffiths and Post arent playing
Do they need to play a number of games at Coburg to play finals?
Coburg are as close to playing finals as the seniors are!
-
Must be Miller and Farmers farewell match.
You'd hope so. De ja vu roll back the clock to round 22 2009.
It's obvious Dimma has put the cue in the rack. His selections reek of this.
-
stuff off Miller in Griffiths out.
I just turned on Hardwick.
-
will be interesting to see if griffiths plays at all this weekend. Is he being dropped (to coburg) or being rested?
-
He was named at coburged and Ronald aint stuffing happy :banghead
-
When I seen Griffths out for Miller it just made we sick :banghead.I would love to know the clubs thinking on this.Match commitee is weake as pee and have no clue.Who is our future Miller,Thurfield or Mcgaune??? or is it Griffths and Posty.Dimma is makeing poor decsions week after week.W e need a Neil Balme there who understands footy not rejects.
-
Do they need to play a number of games at Coburg to play finals?
Yeah they do buit seeing Coburg isn't going to play finals it's a mute point don't you think
and BTW................
Go Millzy ;D :rollin
-
half of you blokes dont want us to win another game this year so we can secure a top ten pick, but then when we dont pick our best side you bitch and moan? ???
Hardwick knows Griffiths and probably even Post are gonna be there next year. He is giving Miller, Farmer and Dea a chance to make a statement before he makes an assessment on their future. There is a good chance that all of them will be cut at the end of the year.
There are too many armchair experts on here that carry on like they could coach us to a flag, when in reality they are just clueless, reactionary whackos without an ounce of foresight or credibility.
The brutal truth is that this is where the club is at. Dimma has made some mistakes recently, yes, but everyone makes these, champion players and coaches included. Have we forgotten what kind of list he inherited? He needs at least another year before we can seriously judge his worth.
He's no fool, Dimma.
I for one, still think he is the right man for the job.
-
half of you blokes dont want us to win another game this year so we can secure a top ten pick, but then when we dont pick our best side you bitch and moan? ???
Hardwick knows Griffiths and probably even Post are gonna be there next year. He is giving Miller, Farmer and Dea a chance to make a statement before he makes an assessment on their future. There is a good chance that all of them will be cut at the end of the year.
There are too many armchair experts on here that carry on like they could coach us to a flag, when in reality they are just clueless, reactionary whackos without an ounce of foresight or credibility.
The brutal truth is that this is where the club is at. Dimma has made some mistakes recently, yes, but everyone makes these, champion players and coaches included. Have we forgotten what kind of list he inherited? He needs at least another year before we can seriously judge his worth.
He's no fool, Dimma.
I for one, still think he is the right man for the job.
Well said Willy, I can still see the light