Official Team for Round 19

[Loui Tufga]

the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1

That was part of my "captain obvious" stament...fact

[Jackstar is back again]

the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1

That was part of my "captain obvious" stament...fact

For football club to do that, I would beleive that is a complete lack of vision. considering of his output against Geelong
Also he had broken ribs when he played round 4 and missed the next 3 weeks
Unfortunately not a level playing field for some players at punt rd

[Loui Tufga]

would think Hislop and Hicks are a total waste of space
What else do you think is garbage ?
Our list is poor, Recruiting been ordinary

It's all after the fact, it's easy to pot players and recruiting when it dosent work out but we never hear from you prior to the draft? Why? With all your knowledge you should be head of recruiting! What are your thought for this years draft? Who should we look at rookieing? You must of scouted plenty of players by now to have a good feel as to who we should be targeting?
Why don't you show your hand now so in a couple of years time you can actually say I told you so with some credibility.

[Jackstar is back again]

mate , read my posts from 4-5 years ago

[Loui Tufga]

the Tuck reason is 100% spot on i might add.
decision was made before round 1

That was part of my "captain obvious" stament...fact

For football club to do that, I would
beleive that is a complete lack of vision. considering of his output against Geelong
Also he had broken ribs when he played round 4 and missed the next 3 weeks
Unfortunately not a level playing field for some players at punt rd

So we are the only club on earth to do somthing like this to our players?
I can think of a dozen separate instances where a club has thought a player will not be a part of there plans going forward hence they are left to rot in the VFL. Some have even gone on to play in a premiership

[Francois Jackson]

"its all after the fact"

hahahaha

Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.

Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.

Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.

Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.

[Loui Tufga]

mate , read my posts from 4-5 years ago

I have waded back through the crap before, I couldn't find much that made any sence? Please feel free to enlighten me of your oricle ways

[Jackstar is back again]

mate , read my posts from 4-5 years ago

I have waded back through the crap before, I couldn't find much that made any sence? Please feel free to enlighten me of your oricle ways

 

[Jackstar is back again]

"its all after the fact"

hahahaha

Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.

Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.

Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.

Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.

thank you

[Loui Tufga]

"its all after the fact"

hahahaha

Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.

Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.

Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.

Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.

Dude, I'm not saying we havnt made some monumental stuff ups regarding our drafting just saying Jstar has a habit of bringing up the obvious but is never willing to put his money where his mouth is before the drafts!

[Francois Jackson]

Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.

Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects

 

[Loui Tufga]

Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.

Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects

 

Mate, I agree with you 100%, IMO the 2005 draft has hurt us more than any, that was a compleat eff up

[Francois Jackson]

"its all after the fact"

hahahaha

Tiger tassie im not sure how long you have followed Richmond for but if you knew about footbll you would've known Hislop was a complete waste of time.

Hislop was a reject that Essendon didnt want. Thompson and Mclovin Ditto.

Most people on this site thought they were duds 4 years ago and still think that.

Other clubs are picking up gems through the rookie draft and what do we get.

Dude, I'm not saying we havnt made some monumental stuff ups regarding our drafting just saying Jstar has a habit of bringing up the obvious but is never willing to put his money where his mouth is before the drafts!

i cant speak for him for Jack, what i can see is the RFC is not in a position to take risks and IMO we still make stupid risky decisions.

Why rookie Hislop again. Rookie draft is a powerful draft if used correctly yet we screw it up every year.

I was also dead against the Conca move and still am. I think he will be a serviceable player but not A grade.

Now its my opinion and i may be wrong

All i want is the best for the club and thats get rid of rubbish. Now we hold onto your mcguane/Edwards type till they are worthless.

[Jackstar is back again]

Conca was playing 2,s footy in Perth last year I might add

[Coach]

Adding to that Mclovin was playing reserves at the Buldogs when Wallett/Miller through all their wisdom decided a 3 yrs contract was deserving.

Hislop and Thompson couldnt get a game at their respective clubs and while others were raping the draft we still were picking up other clubs rejects

 

McMahon played close to 20 senior games for the Dogs that year despite popular belief. Still wouldn't have traded for him but he wasn't in the twos all year