One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 12, 2013, 12:42:19 AM
-
Ch 7 last night were keen to show a few replays of Chaplin getting Schulz high with his extended arm. Basil Zemplis was saying no doubt the Match Review Panel will take at look at that as they look at everything.
-
Gee whiz, a bit of a stretch if they sight him. Sarge went in to shepherd and Chaplin stuck an arm up. Was unnecessary but it was soft as.
-
Forceful no.
Reckless not really.
Negligent no.
This is the MRP however and what is safe one week can have the Penang executioner called for duty the next. Let's just wait and see.
-
It's Richmond
They'll be frothing out the mouth at the thought of Chappy not playing against the Bummers.
2 weeks.
-
it was crude and clumsy (?) prolly worth a stern talking to.
most of the time the MRP are more worried about result rather than intent and i dont thing sarge even felt it.
....but, as with most decisions made by the Awful Football League, who stuffing knows what will happen?
-
he never connected so really should get off
looked a lot worse than it actually was
-
It's Schulz's fault, wanted to take Chappy out but didn't know how to :rollin
It will get looked at and depending on what side the coin comes down will determine his fate ;D
-
Ch 7 last night were keen to show a few replays of Chaplin getting Schulz high with his extended arm. Basil Zemplis was saying no doubt the Match Review Panel will take at look at that as they look at everything.
Regardless of the outcome, Basil Zempilas showed himself yesterday to be a fool with some of his commentary. Was the ring leader in the awful production that was the Ch 7 coverage yesterday. I have no time for this tosspot whatsoever.
-
Will be viewed but won't be penalized as there was not enough force in the contact IMHO.
-
insufficient contact
-
Nothing in it imo, but the MRP has surprised us in the past. :(
-
Good to see the double fister show some sort of pig. Even if it was somewhat cowardly
-
The coin toss came down in our favour
Chaplin's contact to Schulz wasn't even looked at :rollin
Jay Schulz not so lucky for strking Rance in the first qtr. Got a week but with an early plea and good record he can take a reprimand ;D
See: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-05-13/mrp-statement-round-seven
-
The coin toss came down in our favour
Chaplin's contact to Schulz wasn't even looked at :rollin
Jay Schulz not so lucky for strking Rance in the first qtr. Got a week but with an early plea and good record he can take a reprimand ;D
See: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-05-13/mrp-statement-round-seven
Mark Robinson in his Herald-Sun 'Tackle' column had Tucky being charged for striking ::) but the MRP didn't look at Tucky's actions either. It wouldn't have mattered anyway with Tucky out injured for weeks.
-
The coin toss came down in our favour
Chaplin's contact to Schulz wasn't even looked at :rollin
Jay Schulz not so lucky for strking Rance in the first qtr. Got a week but with an early plea and good record he can take a reprimand ;D
See: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-05-13/mrp-statement-round-seven
Mark Robinson in his Herald-Sun 'Tackle' column had Tucky being charged for striking ::) but the MRP didn't look at Tucky's actions either. It wouldn't have mattered anyway with Tucky out injured for weeks.
Should have punched Redden in the face. Wouldn't have mattered in the grand scheme of things would have been deserving. ;D
-
The coin toss came down in our favour
Chaplin's contact to Schulz wasn't even looked at :rollin
Jay Schulz not so lucky for strking Rance in the first qtr. Got a week but with an early plea and good record he can take a reprimand ;D
See: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-05-13/mrp-statement-round-seven
Mark Robinson in his Herald-Sun 'Tackle' column had Tucky being charged for striking ::) but the MRP didn't look at Tucky's actions either. It wouldn't have mattered anyway with Tucky out injured for weeks.
Should have punched Redden in the face. Wouldn't have mattered in the grand scheme of things would have been deserving. ;
Totally gutless and cheap shot by Redden.
-
you come back on the field you're fair game IMO
play on
-
you come back on the field you're fair game IMO
play on
Agreed. But Tucky should have punched him in the face while he was laughing at him. ;D
-
Blues BF board is worth a read after Betts copped 5 weeks reduced to 3. :lol
-
Blues BF board is worth a read after Betts copped 5 weeks reduced to 3. :lol
Agree with Betts deserves to be rubbed out
But struth it makes you wonder how they (MRP) come up the reports and penalties that they do
there is just no consistency
-
The coin toss came down in our favour
Chaplin's contact to Schulz wasn't even looked at :rollin
Jay Schulz not so lucky for strking Rance in the first qtr. Got a week but with an early plea and good record he can take a reprimand ;D
See: http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-05-13/mrp-statement-round-seven
told ya
and westoff should had been reported for faking head high hit to win a free
-
Kelly from Geelong who copped 2 weeks for what used to be fair bump has had his appeal dismissed
Penalty stands :gobdrop :gobdrop
RIP the Bump
Thank goodness Scott Turner isn't playing here ads he'd get life under is new pathetic system
-
Kelly from Geelong who copped 2 weeks for what used to be fair bump has had his appeal dismissed
Penalty stands :gobdrop :gobdrop
RIP the Bump
Thank goodness Scott Turner isn't playing here ads he'd get life under is new pathetic system
What about Lindsay Thomas in round 1. Garbage.
If Nought kid gets off so should the Geelong kid. :wallywink
You can't clear one and suspend the other. :stupid
-
He clearly got him high, how's that fair?
-
Goddard said it wasn;t high. So either he didn't get him high or Goddard is a liar. Lying about it should warrant an equal suspension of 2 games. :shh
-
Goddard said it wasn;t high. So either he didn't get him high or Goddard is a liar. Lying about it should warrant an equal suspension of 2 games. :shh
Agree with this ;D
Thomas got his opponent high, didn't have eyes for the ball only his opponet, was off the ground as well and did more damage but they (MRP) says that's OK because it was a head clash even though at the end of it Thomas' arm is up and away from his bofy
Kelly doesn't raise his arm, is off the ground, doesn't cause any damage even the opponent says that and he cops 2 weeks
Could go on and on case after case that have gone up this season and one minute it's rpeortable the next it's not.
Consistency is the issue here. We don't have any and that's why people are confused and angry
RIP the Bump