One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: TigerLand on September 30, 2013, 06:12:11 PM
-
Seeing as its silly season, over a few froths with a Saints mate of mine, we tossed up some trades between our club. We agreed on a win/win trade of Leigh Montagna for some young talent / draft picks.
Would take this guy in a heart beat. Wont win a flag at Saints, should have won their Best and Fairest this year, thought he was very good.
All depends on what we give up for him but I'd be keen to take him on, certainly before a Paul Chapman or a Darren Jolly type who are both injury prone and past their best.
If we are going to go after any 'mature/experienced' player I'd seriously look at Montagna.
Think Saints would want out 1st pick for him but if we had a deal with a Ben Griffiths and maybe an exchange of our pick 13 for their pick 21. As Saints are in huge need for a big body in defence.
Would love Montagna at Richmond. :gotigers
Thoughts?
-
isnt he like 30 years? do we really need a 30 year old midfielder? if you wanna have a go at someone at stk then go for Nick Riewoldt plonk him down at CHF and watch us give the flag a shake.
-
Pass
-
"Fingers" Montagna.
Pass.
-
Pass unless cheap, which he won't be. Big Chappy. :clapping
-
We wont be chasing Montagna. Roo is our Saints target! :cheers
-
As long as Milne doesn't come too when we got our pants down and back turned
-
are you saying it's ok if montagna comes when we have our pants down and back turned.
-
Would rather bring Wayne Campbell out of retirement
-
Leave him at the Saints to sing with Sooky Rewoldt
-
If we are going to go after any 'mature/experienced' player I'd seriously look at Montagna.
Think Saints would want out 1st pick for him but if we had a deal with a Ben Griffiths and maybe an exchange of our pick 13 for their pick 21. As Saints are in huge need for a big body in defence.
I would take Montagna but not at anywhere near the price you mentioned. Not for a 1st rounder and certainly not for a down trade including Griff. Something like Griff and a 4th round pick for Montagna maybe, but only maybe at best. Montagna is past his best now and not worth a high pick any more.
-
Nope, he skinnier than Robyn Nahas!!!!
-
Pass as in, wouldn't fit in our best 22?
Surely he would, I'd take him over Chapman.
-
Would be very handy but is 30 and would still be in the 5-600k pay bracket - not going to happen.
-
$500-600k you're joking man. Probably $400-450max IMO. Especially now that he's going to hit 30.
Too old. If he was two years younger maybe.
-
Pass unless cheap, which he won't be. Big Chappy. :clapping
lets go the whole hog chappy, longer and adams will do fine throw in a few state leaguers ive had my eye on and away we go. now how do we get it done.
-
Pass unless cheap, which he won't be. Big Chappy. :clapping
lets go the whole hog chappy, longer and adams will do fine throw in a few state leaguers ive had my eye on and away we go. now how do we get it done.
Getting Longer isn't possible and we aren't going for him because we have nothing to give. Other than that it's pretty simple.
-
Pass as in, wouldn't fit in our best 22?
Surely he would, I'd take him over Chapman.
Pass as in, too expensive to trade for. Chappy is a free agent. Montagna will cost a highish pick.
-
Pass unless cheap, which he won't be. Big Chappy. :clapping
lets go the whole hog chappy, longer and adams will do fine throw in a few state leaguers ive had my eye on and away we go. now how do we get it done.
I agree with those players as you know but i doubt we'll get any of them.
It's worth a shot but chappy mat end up st peptide hill, Adams and fuckwitwood, and I see longer now if not on his way to hawks a chance but our first pick plus a player. Now that Leppa is there his valuation of our players is different to voss.
Thoughts? What do you think it will take to get all 3 if any?
-
Pass as in, wouldn't fit in our best 22?
Surely he would, I'd take him over Chapman.
Pass in I wouldn't take him
And yes I would take Chapman in a heartbeat over Montagna. Chapman plays hard, our kids could learn a lot
-
Montagnards
:lol
Who hacked billy's account
-
$500-600k you're joking man. Probably $400-450max IMO. Especially now that he's going to hit 30.
Too old. If he was two years younger maybe.
hed easily be their highest paid player behind roo. This current contract hes on would have been his biggest given how many stars were at the saints early in his career compared to the past few years. Too expensive
-
Montagnards
:lol
Who hacked billy's account
Bloody ipad auto correct
All fixed now ;D
-
Montagnards
:lol
Who hacked billy's account
Bloody ipad auto correct
All fixed now ;D
You and that iPad really need mediation or an intervention! ;D
-
Montagnards
:lol
Who hacked billy's account
Bloody ipad auto correct
All fixed now ;D
You and that iPad really need mediation or an intervention! ;D
I need to bin it
But can't because it was a gift :-\
-
Montagnards
:lol
Who hacked billy's account
Bloody ipad auto correct
All fixed now ;D
You and that iPad really need mediation or an intervention! ;D
I need to bin it
But can't because it was a gift :-\
Just drop it in the bath.
Problem solved.
:thumbsup
-
Whats with us (supporters) now wanting all these old players. We've been down this path and it never stuffing works. :banghead
-
Montagnards
:lol
Who hacked billy's account
Bloody ipad auto correct
All fixed now ;D
You and that iPad really need mediation or an intervention! ;D
I need to bin it
But can't because it was a gift :-\
Just drop it in the bath.
Problem solved.
:thumbsup
Or better yet just don't use it then you don't have to complain about it ::)
-
Whats with us (supporters) now wanting all these old players. We've been down this path and it never stuffing works. :banghead
We haven't been down this path before, we're getting recycleds for minimal cost.
The old path was to trade away 2nd and 3rd round picks on Billy Nicholls, Tim Fleming and Justin Blumfield.
-
Or better yet just don't use it then you don't have to complain about it ::)
Wow what a great idea, don't know why I didn't think of that one myself ::)
It's a pity that things aren't that simple ::)
I need to bin it
But can't because it was a gift :-\
Just drop it in the bath.
Problem solved.
:thumbsup
I couldn't and wouldn't do that cosidering who gave it to me
-
If you want anyone from St Kilda get Blakey. Absolute champ.
-
Montagna was a free agent end of last year
Why dafuq would you trade for this gimp now?
-
No. Need an inside mid not outside. Although he is a good footballer his age goes against him.
-
this poo still got legs for 3 pages?