One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on October 02, 2013, 01:11:01 AM
-
Mike has Cotch at 33 and Dusty at 36.
31-40:
http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/mike-sheahan-reveals-the-players-ranked-31-50-in-annual-end-of-season-top-50/story-fndv8ufg-1226731149453
41-50:
http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/mike-sheahan-reveals-the-players-ranked-41-50-on-his-top-50-for-2013/story-fnelctok-1226730757847
-
Does this mean Jacko will be top 30?
:lol
-
Does this mean Jacko will be top 30?
:lol
No this means that the RFC is done & dusted in Mike's eyes
-
I wonder if Rance or Chaplin sneak in as top defenders?
-
I wonder if Rance or Chaplin sneak in as top defenders?
:lol
Chaplin wouldn't get a game in a quality side
-
Balls, Coach. You had it in for him before he even played a game for us. He was a solid pick up. The numbers don't lie. Our defense was our strength this year and Chappy was a big part of that. End your silly vendetta, you nasty pasty.
-
I wonder if Rance or Chaplin sneak in as top defenders?
:lol
Chaplin wouldn't get a game in a quality side
He already is ;)
-
Balls, Coach. You had it in for him before he even played a game for us. He was a solid pick up. The numbers don't lie. Our defense was our strength this year and Chappy was a big part of that. End your silly vendetta, you nasty pasty.
Probably because I've seen him play for 10 years. he's an ok player and the only people who rate him are those who rate whimps that play as loose man. Are you a Nick Maxwell fan by chance? Why were Port happy to drop him off their list? Might have something to do with them rating J.Hombsch as a better player and he hardly got a game for Port this year :lol Let's not forget all his high finishes in their B&F as well.
Tell me of a good forward he has beaten? Chappy is a reasonable 3rd tall who reads the play well. Yeah he helped our back six improve but that's not hard when you're replacing Jayden Post.
Funny how you have a vendetta if you don't rate our players as top notch yet still maintain they're not bad players. The gardener has never and will never be a top defender. JasonCloke.com/NickMaxwell
I wonder if Rance or Chaplin sneak in as top defenders?
:lol
Chaplin wouldn't get a game in a quality side
He already is ;)
Get real. We're reasonable, not quality.
-
Try this on for size you nut sack slick Willy
He plays mostly as a 3rd tall or loose man. Like I said before, I'd take him as a 3rd tall but not sure we need one? He doesn't get a gig at FB or CHB for Port so why would he get one here? He is a bit soft and his kicking can be suspect. I've said that I think he can play but I think we're better off chasing a better shut down defender. Someone like Merrett.
All I want is for the people here to tell me why they think Chaplin is a very good player. WAT stated that Chaplin is a very good player but won't give his reasons.
Had it out for him since before he came here? hhmmm. And you were all expecting a monster full back werent you? Because wasn't that what we lacked. Well correct me if I am wrong but didn't Rance take the best forward each week this year?
-
Chaplin became more of a man on man defender from about halfway through the season when it was obvious it was ridiculous seeing Rance get hammered by Cloke while Chaps was playing loose. think the penny dropped and saw him standing big fwds plenty in the run home. Talking too much poo coach, lotta hate
-
pretty fair comments by coacher i would have thought, except abusing old slick willy, that's not on
-
Chappers :clapping Tigers defense harder to break into than a nun's knickers. Woah :shh
-
Defence has been good this year, still think we need a monster fullback but...
:cheers
-
Why is he called the gardener? >:(
-
because he cut Coach's grass
-
Does this mean Jacko will be top 30?
:lol
Jacko not named in the 11-30 bracket.
What chance a top ten finish.
:lol
-
Chaplin became more of a man on man defender from about halfway through the season when it was obvious it was ridiculous seeing Rance get hammered by Cloke while Chaps was playing loose. think the penny dropped and saw him standing big fwds plenty in the run home. Talking too much poo coach, lotta hate
No hate, just dealing in facts. You didn't answer my question(s). Were you expecting a monster full back like everyone else on here? And name me the top forwards that he has beaten. It's not that hard. Well, it is actually....:lol
And before someone else has a crack, I'll say it again. I was more than content with his recruitment and I have said he improves the backline, but that's not the question at hand ;D
You blokes should be on your knees. It's clear my description of him from well before he was recruited is absolutely spot on.
Here's to the Coach :cheers 3 cheers for Coach!
Let's go Coach!
Regards,
Coach
:cheers
-
Chaplin became more of a man on man defender from about halfway through the season when it was obvious it was ridiculous seeing Rance get hammered by Cloke while Chaps was playing loose. think the penny dropped and saw him standing big fwds plenty in the run home. Talking too much poo coach, lotta hate
No hate, just dealing in facts. You didn't answer my question(s). Were you expecting a monster full back like everyone else on here? And name me the top forwards that he has beaten. It's not that hard. Well, it is actually....:lol
And before someone else has a crack, I'll say it again. I was more than content with his recruitment and I have said he improves the backline, but that's not the question at hand ;D
You blokes should be on your knees. It's clear my description of him from well before he was recruited is absolutely spot on.
Here's to the Coach :cheers 3 cheers for Coach!
Let's go Coach!
Regards,
Coach
:cheers
:bow
-
Right on brother :thumbsup
-
I agree with Coach.
The comments he played man on man later in the year are rubbish. Don't know how many times the commentators would say Chappy was just setting up in space and you could see it at the games too. Got destroyed by Tippet
-
Chaplin became more of a man on man defender from about halfway through the season when it was obvious it was ridiculous seeing Rance get hammered by Cloke while Chaps was playing loose. think the penny dropped and saw him standing big fwds plenty in the run home. Talking too much poo coach, lotta hate
No hate, just dealing in facts. You didn't answer my question(s). Were you expecting a monster full back like everyone else on here? And name me the top forwards that he has beaten. It's not that hard. Well, it is actually....:lol
And before someone else has a crack, I'll say it again. I was more than content with his recruitment and I have said he improves the backline, but that's not the question at hand ;D
You blokes should be on your knees. It's clear my description of him from well before he was recruited is absolutely spot on.
Here's to the Coach :cheers 3 cheers for Coach!
Let's go Coach!
Regards,
Coach
:cheers
Are you done? ;D
You didn't ask me any questions, but for the record, I expected him to rotate on the big fwds and was hoping he wasn't going to play solely as a loose man. We have others who should do that. Just bc someone plays a particular role at another club doesn't mean that cannot be earmarked to change elsewhere.
I don't care what you and other ignorant posters say, I know what I saw - the penny dropped for the coaching staff after the pies game where poor rance was isolated on Cloke and torn a new one whilst chappy was running around playing loose man. In the second half of the season he has stood Roughead, Tippett, rotated on and off pavlich/Clarke against freo and petrie against North. He has also played loose at times bc hes good at it and he wasn't need structurally in some games like GWS, GC, Essendon, so don't give me this BS that he doesn't play man on man.
-
I agree with Coach.
The comments he played man on man later in the year are rubbish. Don't know how many times the commentators would say Chappy was just setting up in space and you could see it at the games too. Got destroyed by Tippet
Im sorry, but your post is FOS. You slag off my POV as garbage and then go ahead in the same post and admit he has played on a key fwd in tippet. ::)
-
Wow, you mad bro? Now I know how Chucky feels. I'd give him rep. If I didn't ask any questions then why did you reply to my post with a bunch irrelevant points? Where have I said he hasn't played on anyone? I asked if you thought he was a monster full back and asked of top forwards he has beaten. Wow the hostility, this is unreal. Never said the guy couldn't play the game, he can. Just highly overrated by some
You're arguing against yourself. I never said he wasn't good at playing loose or that he doesn't occasionally play on an opponent. I've said as much in previous posts. Now get on your knees and....
Regards,
The Coach
-
Where have I said he hasn't played on anyone?
Regards,
The Coach
he's an ok player and the only people who rate him are those who rate whimps that play as loose man. Are you a Nick Maxwell fan by chance?
JasonCloke.com/NickMaxwell
You never said it, just implied it
Pretty simple, I replied to the above insinuation, saying I thought that was crap and somehow that's me making irrelevant points.
-
I agree with Coach.
The comments he played man on man later in the year are rubbish. Don't know how many times the commentators would say Chappy was just setting up in space and you could see it at the games too. Got destroyed by Tippet
Im sorry, but your post is FOS. You slag off my POV as garbage and then go ahead in the same post and admit he has played on a key fwd in tippet. ::)
My post was before you elaborated that he would switch up, your first one sounded like you meant he played soley as a KPD after pies game.
-
Here's the full top 50
50. Todd Goldstein
49. Brad Ebert
48. Josh Gibson
47. Andrew Walker
46. Richard Douglas
45. Robert Murphy
44. Grant Birchall
43. Daniel Wells
42. Brendan Goddard
41. Mathew Stokes
40. Eric Mackenzie
39. Ryan Crowley
38. Jack Steven
37. Will Minson
36. Dustin Martin
35. Jordan Lewis
34. Pearce Hanley
33. Trent Cotchin
32. Corey Enright
31. Tom Liberatore
30. Andrew Mackie
29. Luke Hodge
28. Chris Mayne
27. Jeremy Cameron
26. Josh Kennedy (Syd)
25. Nick Riewoldt
24. Michael Johnson
23. Rory Sloane
22. Travis Cloke
21. Steve Johnson
20. Chad Wingard
19. Steven Motlop
18. Jobe Watson
17. Travis Boak
16. David Mundy
15. Josh Kennedy (WC)
14. Scott Thompson (NM)
13. Nathan Fyfe
12. Patrick Dangerfield
11. Daniel Hannebery
10. Harry Taylor
9. Sam Mitchell
8. Ryan Griffen
7. Dane Swan
6. Kieren Jack
5. Jarrad McVeigh
4. Jarryd Roughead
3. Scott Pendlebury
2. Joel Selwood
1. Gary Ablett
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/mikes-top-50-2013/10-1