One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: mat073 on September 19, 2016, 11:45:07 AM
-
Steven Morris and Todd Elton are never going to make it . Both list cloggers are contracted for next year .
Surely they can't be on big coin . Pay them out . Marcon had more upside than these two .
Surely its a no brainer .
-
Inb4 the list is over 10
-
Steven Morris and Todd Elton are never going to make it . Both list cloggers are contracted for next year .
Surely they can't be on big coin . Pay them out . Marcon had more upside than these two .
Surely its a no brainer .
Except that their contracts will contribute to the cap - which means that we can't really pick up any other players to fill their spots.
So in actual fact we'd just have 2 less players to choose from. We played 41 listed players last season.
-
Inb4 the list is over 10
Bit rough on toddy and Morris to be the two named
-
couldn't agree more mate list cloggers have been for 3 years and then throw in the 2 moores townsend hunt
-
Our list management guys are doing a fantastic job
-
It's a shame Morris was just starting to perform before he did his knee.
ltob will be delisted next year for sure.
-
couldn't agree more mate list cloggers have been for 3 years and then throw in the 2 moores townsend hunt
Andrew Moore is out of contract so he can still be delisted, think there will be more delisting once trade time starts
Townsend unfortunately was given 2 years (a BH special ;D)
Hunt has 12 months to go as well and although people don't want to hear or acknowledge it, he last 8 or so weeks were good, showed up some of his more talented team mates IMESHO
-
Dunno about 'good'
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
-
Yeah good is a stretch
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Richmond fc
Where trying equates to good
-
Hardwick needs to be 1st cab off the rank.
-
Yeah good is a stretch
Massive stretch.
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Surely we are past this level of acceptance.
I'll have a red hot crack if you want that to be your yardstick. Need quality. Hunt is certainly not that
-
(http://blog.airsplat.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/ERM-JG-M4-6613T.jpg)
Conscription.
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Surely we are past this level of acceptance.
I'll have a red hot crack if you want that to be your yardstick. Need quality. Hunt is certainly not that
Isn't it more of indictment on others that Hunt's best which is average has him ending up one of our better players in the 2nd half of the season?
That's not saying we don't need better but what it shows how poor our better players were
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Surely we are past this level of acceptance.
I'll have a red hot crack if you want that to be your yardstick. Need quality. Hunt is certainly not that
Isn't it more of indictment on others that Hunt's best which is average has him ending up one of our better players in the 2nd half of the season?
That's not saying we don't need better but what it shows how poor our better players were
Touche. Hunt isn't the guy you get rid of if he is in your best 22. But it's an indictment of our list management. Thank god FJ has been demoted.
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Surely we are past this level of acceptance.
I'll have a red hot crack if you want that to be your yardstick. Need quality. Hunt is certainly not that
Isn't it more of indictment on others that Hunt's best which is average has him ending up one of our better players in the 2nd half of the season?
That's not saying we don't need better but what it shows how poor our better players were
Touche. Hunt isn't the guy you get rid of if he is in your best 22. But it's an indictment of our list management. Thank god FJ has been demoted.
not yet, this draft he's in charge for the final time
-
I thought he had been demoted to part time?
-
Wasnt actually a demotion, he made the decision to stand down from full time duties months ago well before the review was even on the cards, clubs just used it to make it look like they're making changes. But its all happening after the drafts
He'll be a part time consultant bc his views are so highly regarded
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Surely we are past this level of acceptance.
I'll have a red hot crack if you want that to be your yardstick. Need quality. Hunt is certainly not that
Isn't it more of indictment on others that Hunt's best which is average has him ending up one of our better players in the 2nd half of the season?
That's not saying we don't need better but what it shows how poor our better players were
Touche. Hunt isn't the guy you get rid of if he is in your best 22. But it's an indictment of our list management. Thank god FJ has been demoted.
I'd probably say more of a poor reflection of the coaching staff. I think we'd all agree we have a lot of underperforming talent on our list. I put the blame for that squarely on the coaching staff.
-
Steven Morris and Todd Elton are never going to make it . Both list cloggers are contracted for next year .
Surely they can't be on big coin . Pay them out . Marcon had more upside than these two .
Surely its a no brainer .
Geez man, when you turn you go full tilt! Marcon more upside than Todd Elton :lol :lol even Morris you're probably pushing it
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Surely we are past this level of acceptance.
I'll have a red hot crack if you want that to be your yardstick. Need quality. Hunt is certainly not that
Isn't it more of indictment on others that Hunt's best which is average has him ending up one of our better players in the 2nd half of the season?
That's not saying we don't need better but what it shows how poor our better players were
indubitably
So it's more like "good by Richmond standards"
Nothing to right home to granma about generally
-
Steven Morris and Todd Elton are never going to make it . Both list cloggers are contracted for next year .
Surely they can't be on big coin . Pay them out . Marcon had more upside than these two .
Surely its a no brainer .
Geez man, when you turn you go full tilt! Marcon more upside than Todd Elton :lol :lol even Morris you're probably pushing it
Elton got whacked ( literally) by Cotchin for being an absolute chicken heart during the Sydney game . 5 years in the system .
Marcon looked quite serviceable in his second game - only to be dropped and then dumped.
You could never question the endeavor of little Stevie Morris but we can all see his limitations. Worst player to play 80+ games in recent memory.
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Agree Taylor did have a decent dip most weeks
Especially last 2 months
Credit where it's due
-
Wasnt actually a demotion, he made the decision to stand down from full time duties months ago well before the review was even on the cards, clubs just used it to make it look like they're making changes. But its all happening after the drafts
He'll be a part time consultant bc his views are so highly regarded
Lol They can't even demote the dud recruiter themselves. Hackson had to do it for them. He would have still remained if he didn’t step down.
-
Dunno about 'good'
Never once walked away from a game thinking he didn't have a "dip" can't say the same about a number of others
And yes "good" based on what his role in the side is, he did his job
Agree Taylor did have a decent dip most weeks
Especially last 2 months
Credit where it's due
Still need to upgrade him if we ever want to win a flag. You could put everyone on this forum on the field for us. They'll try their guts out but we'll be thrashed. Trying your guts out doesn't matter if you just don't have the talent. Geelong knew they had to upgrade but we are happy to have him.
Tells me why Geelong are playing this weekend and we are on holidays.....
-
You could put everyone on this forum on the field for us. They'll try their guts out
Think a few will probably just sit and sook, more their style
-
You could put everyone on this forum on the field for us. They'll try their guts out
Think a few will probably just sit and sook, more their style
I train well.
-
You could put everyone on this forum on the field for us. They'll try their guts out
Think a few will probably just sit and sook, more their style
I train well.
:lol
-
You could put everyone on this forum on the field for us. They'll try their guts out
Think a few will probably just sit and sook, more their style
I train well.
:lol
:lol :lol
-
l'm surprised none of you have mentioned Shane Edwards. This guy is a list clogger. Played a handful of good games & just a flash of footy in 2 hours each week. He would be on the very top of my list. A very weak footballer IMO
-
l'm surprised none of you have mentioned Shane Edwards. This guy is a list clogger. Played a handful of good games & just a flash of footy in 2 hours each week. He would be on the very top of my list. A very weak footballer IMO
People have mentioned Edwards. And it has been multiple times that he is on the trade table. Catch up.
-
l'm surprised none of you have mentioned Shane Edwards. This guy is a list clogger. Played a handful of good games & just a flash of footy in 2 hours each week. He would be on the very top of my list. A very weak footballer IMO
People have mentioned Edwards. And it has been multiple times that he is on the trade table. Catch up.
POINT out to me anywhere here l missed where the name Edwards was mentioned
The last time everyone wanted to keep him cause he was a champion in everyone's eyes. Obviously watching another Edwards cause ours is pee weak
-
Go look for yourself, we have better things to do with our time
-
l'm surprised none of you have mentioned Shane Edwards. This guy is a list clogger. Played a handful of good games & just a flash of footy in 2 hours each week. He would be on the very top of my list. A very weak footballer IMO
People have mentioned Edwards. And it has been multiple times that he is on the trade table. Catch up.
POINT out to me anywhere here l missed where the name Edwards was mentioned
The last time everyone wanted to keep him cause he was a champion in everyone's eyes. Obviously watching another Edwards cause ours is pee weak
Posted earlier today that Edwards is indeed on the trade table
-
l'm surprised none of you have mentioned Shane Edwards. This guy is a list clogger. Played a handful of good games & just a flash of footy in 2 hours each week. He would be on the very top of my list. A very weak footballer IMO
People have mentioned Edwards. And it has been multiple times that he is on the trade table. Catch up.
POINT out to me anywhere here l missed where the name Edwards was mentioned
The last time everyone wanted to keep him cause he was a champion in everyone's eyes. Obviously watching another Edwards cause ours is pee weak
Posted earlier today that Edwards is indeed on the trade table
In this thread ?
-
Mate this is a baby thread, I'm sure you're smart enough to figure out he meant elsewhere