One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Captain__Blood on February 10, 2006, 10:58:49 PM

Title: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: Captain__Blood on February 10, 2006, 10:58:49 PM

I know there are threads on our best 22 etc,  but this is a tad different. Dispite what I think of the players in the is side I most think realisticly Plough will put on the feild.


FB:  Kellaway Gaspar Hartigan
HB:  Johnson Schulz J Bowden
 C:  Deledio Coughlan Hyde
HF:  Pettifer Richardson P Bowden
FF:  Brown Stafford Krakouer
OB: Simmonds Tuck Newman

 I: Hall Tivendale Chaffey Knobel

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: mightytiges on February 11, 2006, 02:50:12 AM

Rodan will be definitely in our best 22 under Wallace and IMO Tezza will have a fit speedy Tambo ahead of old stages like Tivs and Chaffey. Pace and talent is the key to Wallace's gameplan.

Based on the Learmonth game, I agree CB that Paddy Bowden will be in the 22 also which I didn't have last week.

B:   Hartigan      Gaspar       Kellaway
HB: Newman      Schulz        J.Bowden
C:   Hyde          Coughlan      Rodan
HF: Deledio       Richardson    Pettifer
F:   Brown         Stafford      Tambling
R:   Simmonds   Johnson      Tuck

Int:  Knobel    Krakouer   P.Bowden   Hall   

Emerg: Foley  Tivendale  Thursfield

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: blx on February 11, 2006, 05:58:32 AM

im waitin till match week thursday  :thumbsup

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: bluey_21 on February 11, 2006, 06:17:28 PM

Quote from: blx on February 11, 2006, 05:58:32 AM

im waitin till match week thursday  :thumbsup

Me 2

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: Captain__Blood on February 17, 2006, 09:31:47 PM

After seeing the Inter-Club match my guess at this stage our our best 22 in Wallace's eyes:

Hartigan Gaspar Kellaway
Newman Schultz Bowden
Deledio Coughlan Hyde
Pettifer Richardson P Bowden
Brown Stafford Krakouer
Simmonds Tuck Johnson

Knobel Tambling Rodan Hall

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: F0551L on February 17, 2006, 11:32:39 PM

thats a very impressive 22 Captain fairly balanced and on paper very capable   hopefully the "bonding"that choco talks about will give them that extra edge and we can all be proud of them

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: PuntRdRoar on February 18, 2006, 12:02:42 PM

i dont think the traditional b, hb, c, hf, f, ru, ic ...view of the world is needed any more. Id just rather have a top 22- with 6 - 7 talls max with 15-16 runners.

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: Captain__Blood on February 18, 2006, 12:57:57 PM

Quote from: RampagingTiger on February 18, 2006, 12:02:42 PM

i dont think the traditional b, hb, c, hf, f, ru, ic ...view of the world is needed any more. Id just rather have a top 22- with 6 - 7 talls max with 15-16 runners.

They still somewhat still play in the basic FB, HF etc. system.

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: Captain__Blood on February 19, 2006, 02:07:42 AM

After seeing the inter-club game i'll have a crack at what I reckon Wallace reckons it our best side heading into Round 1:


Hartigan Gaspar Kellaway
J Bowden Schultz Newman
Deledio Coughlan Hyde
Pettifer Richardson P Bowden
Krakouer Stafford Brown
Simmonds Tuck Johnson
Rodan Tambling Hall Knobel

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: bluey_21 on February 20, 2006, 10:06:56 PM

Quote from: mightytiges on February 11, 2006, 02:50:12 AM

Rodan will be definitely in our best 22 under Wallace and IMO Tezza will have a fit speedy Tambo ahead of old stages like Tivs and Chaffey. Pace and talent is the key to Wallace's gameplan.

Based on the Learmonth game, I agree CB that Paddy Bowden will be in the 22 also which I didn't have last week.

B:   Hartigan      Gaspar       Kellaway
HB: Newman      Schulz        J.Bowden
C:   Hyde          Coughlan      Rodan
HF: Deledio       Richardson    Pettifer
F:   Brown         Stafford      Tambling
R:   Simmonds   Johnson      Tuck

Int:  Knobel    Krakouer   P.Bowden   Hall   

Emerg: Foley  Tivendale  Thursfield

Pretty much the same for me MT except i'd have Rodan off for Raines IMO

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: mightytiges on February 21, 2006, 03:58:41 PM

Quote from: bluey_21 on February 20, 2006, 10:06:56 PM

Quote from: mightytiges on February 11, 2006, 02:50:12 AM

Rodan will be definitely in our best 22 under Wallace and IMO Tezza will have a fit speedy Tambo ahead of old stages like Tivs and Chaffey. Pace and talent is the key to Wallace's gameplan.

Based on the Learmonth game, I agree CB that Paddy Bowden will be in the 22 also which I didn't have last week.

B:   Hartigan      Gaspar       Kellaway
HB: Newman      Schulz        J.Bowden
C:   Hyde          Coughlan      Rodan
HF: Deledio       Richardson    Pettifer
F:   Brown         Stafford      Tambling
R:   Simmonds   Johnson      Tuck

Int:  Knobel    Krakouer   P.Bowden   Hall   

Emerg: Foley  Tivendale  Thursfield

Pretty much the same for me MT except i'd have Rodan off for Raines IMO

If Raines can back up his form then it's headscratching time as to who to take out. A good problem to have. Rodan's be good over the whole preseason so I'm waiting to see how he goes against real competition. 

Title: Re: My crack at our most realistic starting 22 this year.
Post by: Captain__Blood on February 22, 2006, 03:01:11 PM

Quote from: bluey_21 on February 20, 2006, 10:06:56 PM

Quote from: mightytiges on February 11, 2006, 02:50:12 AM

Rodan will be definitely in our best 22 under Wallace and IMO Tezza will have a fit speedy Tambo ahead of old stages like Tivs and Chaffey. Pace and talent is the key to Wallace's gameplan.

Based on the Learmonth game, I agree CB that Paddy Bowden will be in the 22 also which I didn't have last week.

B:   Hartigan      Gaspar       Kellaway
HB: Newman      Schulz        J.Bowden
C:   Hyde          Coughlan      Rodan
HF: Deledio       Richardson    Pettifer
F:   Brown         Stafford      Tambling
R:   Simmonds   Johnson      Tuck

Int:  Knobel    Krakouer   P.Bowden   Hall   

Emerg: Foley  Tivendale  Thursfield

Pretty much the same for me MT except i'd have Rodan off for Raines IMO

Rodan is flying over the pre-season.

He'll be in the 22.