One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Diocletian on November 23, 2018, 05:29:40 PM
-
Aarts...meh ...not AFL standard, not even our best VFL-listed player....very average pick.... :-\
-
The Chol is back! :clapping
-
Just as I suspected we passed on the last pick to keep a spot free for the mid-season draft....smart IMO....reckon we might need another tall come winter.....:shh
Pleased we retained Chol but only adding the mediocre Aarts who fills no real urgent need was underwhelming to say the least...basically a downgrade on Stengle.... :shh :shh
-
I would have only taken Townsend. I wouldn't have redrafted Chol and I don't think Aartz will add anything.
-
Full Rookie Draft
ROUND 1
1. Carlton Hugh Goddard (St Kilda)
2. Gold Coast Suns Michael Rischitelli (Gold Coast)
3. St Kilda Callum Wilkie (North Adelaide)
4. Brisbane Lions Ryan Bastinac (Brisbane Lions)
5. Fremantle Ethan Hughes (Fremantle)
6. Western Bulldogs Lachie Young (Dandenong Stingrays)
7. Adelaide Kieran Strachan (Port Melbourne VFL)
8. Essendon Tom Jok (Collingwood VFL)
9. Port Adelaide Tobin Cox (Glenelg)
10. North Melbourne Tom McKenzie (Northern Knights)
11. Geelong Tom Atkins (Geelong VFL)
12. Sydney Swans Durak Tucker (Peel Thunder)
13. GWS Giants Passed
14. Hawthorn Damon Greaves (East Perth)
15. Melbourne Kade Chandler (Norwood)
16. Richmond Jake Aarts (Richmond VFL)
17. Collingwood Tim Broomhead (Collingwood)
18. West Coast Eagles Harry Edwards (Swan Districts)
ROUND 2
19. Carlton Tom Bugg (Melbourne)
20. Gold Coast Suns Jack Leslie (Gold Coast Suns)
21. Brisbane Lions Jacob Allison (Brisbane Lions)
22. Fremantle Tobe Watson (Swan Districts)
23. Western Bulldogs Jordon Sweet (North Adelaide)
24. Adelaide Paul Hunter (Adelaide)
25. Essendon Matt Dea (Essendon)
26. Port Adelaide Cameron Hewett (Port Adelaide)
27. North Melbourne Kyron Hayden (North Melbourne)
28. Sydney Swans Harry Reynolds (Sandringham Dragons)
29. GWS Giants Passed
30. Hawthorn Will Golds (Oakleigh Chargers)
31. Melbourne Passed
32. Richmond Jacob Townsend (Richmond)
33. Collingwood Sam Murray (Collingwood)
34. West Coast Eagles Josh Smith (Collingwood)
ROUND 3
35. Carlton Passed
36. Gold Coast Suns Brad Scheer (Gold Coast Suns)
37. Fremantle Ryan Nyhuis (Fremantle)
38. Western Bulldogs Passed
39. Adelaide Jordon Butts (Murray Bushrangers)
40. Essendon Passed
41. North Melbourne Tom Wilkinson (Southport NEAFL)
42. Sydney Kurt Tippett (Sydney)
43. Hawthorn Tim Mohr (GWS Giants)
44. Melbourne Passed
45. Richmond Mabior Chol (Richmond)
46. West Coast Passed
ROUND 4
47. Gold Coast Suns Harrison Wigg (Gold Coast Suns)
48. North Melbourne Passed
49. Hawthorn Will Langford (Hawthorn)
50. Richmond Passed
ROUND 5
51. Gold Coast Suns Passed
52. Richmond Passed
CATEGORY B ROOKIES
Western Bulldogs Buku Khamis
Fremantle Jason Carter
Port Adelaide Kai Pudney
Port Adelaide Martin Frederick
Geelong Blake Schlensog
Sydney Swans Sam Wicks
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-rookie-draft-2018-afl-rookie-draft-live-updates-order-and-results/news-story/bc4b368c7933714c19fc1f12bc9cc03d
-
I would have only taken Townsend. I wouldn't have redrafted Chol and I don't think Aartz will add anything.
Agree. Would have taken Towners and the best state league Ruck and mid available with the next 2 picks.
-
Chol deserves another shot - was close before his injury and has huge upside, way moreso than Plodosaurus Soldo.... :shh
Aarts is puzzling....not a need and far better VFL players out there like Gibbons & Lentini.... but even if we were doing the old promote from within to motivate thing there were better options there too like Mannagh and Ernest........ :shh :shh
-
Anyone know if we're adding any Cat B rookies from our NGA this year?
-
Aarts...meh ...not AFL standard, not even our best VFL-listed player....very average pick.... :-\
Not surprised the rookies him. Was always going to
Just staggered we used our first rookie pick on him.
-
Do you think it was the correct choice? Even from just the options within our VFL list, let alone all the options outside of it?
-
Do you think it was the correct choice? Even from just the options within our VFL list, let alone all the options outside of it?
No, haven't been impressed with him at VFL. Said many times some of our VFL lists blokes are average VFL players
If we were determined to take someone from VFL list I would have gone Mannagh
-
Do you think it was the correct choice? Even from just the options within our VFL list, let alone all the options outside of it?
No, haven't been impressed with him at VFL. Said many times some of our VFL lists blokes are average VFL players
If we were determined to take someone from VFL list I would have gone Mannagh
At least Aarts can play
Chol selection is staggering
Cant play
-
Rubbish. Very very promising this year until he got injured.
-
:shh
-
I would have only taken Townsend. I wouldn't have redrafted Chol and I don't think Aartz will add anything.
Agree. Would have taken Towners and the best state league Ruck and mid available with the next 2 picks.
I looked at the Fox Sport 25-50 list after the draft and the one that stood out to me due to height was Harry Reynolds.
Only played four games for Sandringham Dragons after playing APS footy.
Went to Sydney at pick 28 Rookie.
190cm midfield/forward. Will be interesting to see how he goes. Same with Fort and Sweet in the ruck.
-
Rubbish. Very very promising this year until he got injured.
Oh dear
Been on list for 3 years
1 game 1 disposal
Thats a fact
Thats not rubbish
Better off looking around Australia and find a kid who can play
Sydney Stack in Perth is the perfect example
-
Sorry, but I refuse to take advice from someone who said Hampson was a good player because you watched him kick a footy at training without watching the ball onto his boot....:shh
-
Haha stuff me drunk ....his whole argument is based on one game as a still raw 19 year-old over two years ago and that he's been on the list three years- which is at least how long the club said he would take to come on when they drafted him as a project tall- no wonder this club was a rabble when they were employing clueless halfwits like him.... :shh
-
:shh :shh