One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 06, 2019, 06:05:31 PM
-
Fire away with your changes for next weekend, if any?
-
Riewoldt in for Rioli..... :shh
But will probably be Chol or The Egg or even both if Caddy's fit... :thumbsdown
-
Lambert might be out due to injury too... :shh
-
Lambert might be out due to injury too... :shh
I doubt it as he looked ok after the game.
-
Ins
, Caddy and Jack
Outs Chol , and Egg
Also consider Baker in for Rioli
All reports he killed them today
-
Ins- Jack, Nank and Baker (give Caddy another week off regardless if fit)
Outs- Rioli, Soldo and Beliis
I thought Eggy fitted in really well- already overtaken Houli and Bellis. :lol
We look more dangerous with Chol in the ruck too.
That first half was awesome! I’ll be watching that again a few times this week.
Jeez McIntosh and Graham lack polish.
-
Assuming they are fit
In: Riewoldt, Nank
Out: McIntosh, Soldo
-
In Jack
Out Someone unlucky......
-
Assuming they are fit
In: Riewoldt, Nank
Out: McIntosh, Soldo
I like it. :thumbsup
Macca was really stinking it up with his disposal today.
-
INS: Jack, Caddy
OUTS: Rioli, Soldo
Yep I'd let Marbs be the sole ruck
-
A multi I just put on-
Wimbledon- Ash Barty $3.25 (our Tiger girl Ash)
Wimbledon- Nadal $5.25 (little wanker but I think he will win it)
World Cup- Australian Cricket team $2.88 (hoping more than anything)
Richmond at the line (v GWS) $1.90 (let’s hope they don’t stuff us)
$93 x $10 = HAPPY DAYS
Get on Tigers
-
The only concern for coach Damien Hardwick came in the final quarter when Kane Lambert was taken from the field with a leg injury.
Source: Herald-Sun (https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/gold-coast-suns-on-the-end-of-92point-smashing-from-richmond/news-story/2f5041dae91beece0b8fa716bd385f1b)
-
out: Rioli for that handball
in: Baker
-
Is Nank fit? I heard he was.
In:
Nank
Jack
Out:
Soldo
Rioli
Bit rough with so much apparent depth now.
Guys like Butler and Graham will probably need to be traded out, with blokes like Baker in the seconds and Ross to come back from injury. Houli should probably retire and let someone like Short, Des or Stack take his spot for good.
Guys like Menadue, Garthwaite, Moore, Townsend and Markov all need to be let go IMO. Plenty of chances but realistically none of them are going to make it. Retain in VFL team or let them try elsewhere.
-
Dream result:
Trade: Butler, Graham,Broad, Menadue,Markov & Bolton*, this year & next year's firsts. BEllis (FA compo), Retire:Houli Delist: Weller, Moore, Aarts ,Slomo
*Up to him & Ralph Carr not us.
Higher picks/Taranto, SPP, Ben Crocker, Will Brodie/Darcy Fogerty, ,Cerra, F.Roberts, 2020 picks for points.
Draft Inside mid, Ben Kelly, upgrade EGG & Chol Rookie - Jai Bolton, Smallwood, Lowson ,Jesse Lonergan/M.Grigg
Disclaimer: Totally aware that most of of this won't actually happen :shh
-
Dream result:
Trade: Butler, Graham,Broad, Menadue,Markov & Bolton*, this year & next year's firsts. BEllis (FA compo), Retire:Houli Delist: Weller, Moore, Aarts ,Slomo
*Up to him & Ralph Carr not us.
Higher picks/Taranto, SPP, Ben Crocker, Will Brodie/Darcy Fogerty, ,Cerra, F.Roberts, 2020 picks for points.
Draft Inside mid, Ben Kelly, upgrade EGG & Chol Rookie - Jai Bolton, Smallwood, Lowson ,Jesse Lonergan/M.Grigg
Disclaimer: Totally aware that most of of this won't actually happen :shh
Where do you come up with this comedy :lol
-
Dream result:
Trade: Butler, Graham,Broad, Menadue,Markov & Bolton*, this year & next year's firsts. BEllis (FA compo), Retire:Houli Delist: Weller, Moore, Aarts ,Slomo
*Up to him & Ralph Carr not us.
Higher picks/Taranto, SPP, Ben Crocker, Will Brodie/Darcy Fogerty, ,Cerra, F.Roberts, 2020 picks for points.
Draft Inside mid, Ben Kelly, upgrade EGG & Chol Rookie - Jai Bolton, Smallwood, Lowson ,Jesse Lonergan/M.Grigg
Disclaimer: Totally aware that most of of this won't actually happen :shh
You been banging on about SPP and Cerra for ages.
Also I heard (probably from you I can’t remember) we had earmarked a Big bodied mid a couple of years ago and we were working hard to get him over when he was able.
Is this (or a version of it) true or are you just hoping it will happen?
Anyway, if true, who is this big bodied mid?
And is it true we are making a play for SPP and/or Cerra?
Can you make a case for these two because I’m not sure they are the answer either?
-
FMD I knew people would fail to comprehend "Dream Result" & "Disclaimer" ...... :shh
Dream result:
Trade: Butler, Graham,Broad, Menadue,Markov & Bolton*, this year & next year's firsts. BEllis (FA compo), Retire:Houli Delist: Weller, Moore, Aarts ,Slomo
*Up to him & Ralph Carr not us.
Higher picks/Taranto, SPP, Ben Crocker, Will Brodie/Darcy Fogerty, ,Cerra, F.Roberts, 2020 picks for points.
Draft Inside mid, Ben Kelly, upgrade EGG & Chol Rookie - Jai Bolton, Smallwood, Lowson ,Jesse Lonergan/M.Grigg
Disclaimer: Totally aware that most of of this won't actually happen :shh
Where do you come up with this comedy :lol
Aw what's a matter diddums,, did I name some of your favourite Dudley Shytetrucks in the speculative outs? :shh
[
You been banging on about SPP and Cerra for ages.
Also I heard (probably from you I can’t remember) we had earmarked a Big bodied mid a couple of years ago and we were working hard to get him over when he was able.
Is this (or a version of it) true or are you just hoping it will happen?
Anyway, if true, who is this big bodied mid?
And is it true we are making a play for SPP and/or Cerra?
Can you make a case for these two because I’m not sure they are the answer either?
For the umpteenth time -We've been into Cerra since he was drafted, well documented that he's homesick and is a mad Tiger(posted pictures of himself social media celebrating at the 2017 GF) , we met with SPP last year. ((YBB will back me up on this)..he's on the outer at Port and has fallen out with Hinkley - only played last night because Boak withdrew late....Tarranto at this stage is higly unlikely and solely based on rumour from an unreliable Arsebook page.. .there are stronger rumours linking us to Matt Crouch on whom I'm not keen hence why I didn't mention him as part of my dream result...we were also linked to Cunnington but {thankfully IMO) that ship has now sailed.. EDIT: The other blokes I mentioned -Crocker, Fogherty, Brodie & Roberts- because they'dll fill needs, are all good players/shown talent, shouldn't cost that much and aren't getting regular games at their current clubs...:shh :shh
The other stuff - apart from Bolton being traded and as I made pretty clear -was purely just my wishful thinking... :shh :shh :shh
-
Can 100% guarantee that Jack is playing next week and was filthy he didn’t play yesterday. He and Lynch are practising leading into space that avoids them getting in each other’s way. Exciting times ahead
-
Damien Hardwick is about to have a nice headache
With Jack Riewoldt on the cusp of returning from his long-term knee injury, Damien Hardwick has some juggling to do in his forward line. Although the opposition on Saturday was well below the standard of what Richmond will face in coming weeks, its small forwards roared to life. Surrounding Tom Lynch and improving Mabior Chol, the mosquito fleet that characterised the Tigers' 2017 flag was red-hot. Five goals to Jason Castagana, three to Kane Lambert, two to Shai Bolton and Daniel Rioli and another clean and energetic performance from Sydney Stack (19 touches, one goal) gave Richmond a plethora of avenues to goal. Hardwick will have to shuffle his team to accommodate Riewoldt, and even if it takes time for he and Lynch to click (they've partnered just four times this season), the Tigers suddenly look supremely dangerous again inside their forward 50. - Michael Whiting
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-07-07/nine-things-we-learned-from-round-16
-
Can 100% guarantee that Jack is playing next week and was filthy he didn’t play yesterday. He and Lynch are practising leading into space that avoids them getting in each other’s way. Exciting times ahead
Good to see someone has been watching training from behind the fence last week 👍
-
Not sure about Cerra. Not sure what all the fuss is about in the same way as Jack Martin at GC
Certainly wouldnt give up much for him
-
Kelly and Coniglio both suffered injuries late yesterday’s game.
https://m.afl.com.au/news/2019-07-07/kelly-coniglio-injuries-compound-giants-form-slump
-
Im feeling really confident about this game .
-
FMD I knew people would fail to comprehend "Dream Result" & "Disclaimer" ..... :shh
Dream result:
Trade: Butler, Graham,Broad, Menadue,Markov & Bolton*, this year & next year's firsts. BEllis (FA compo), Retire:Houli Delist: Weller, Moore, Aarts ,Slomo
*Up to him & Ralph Carr not us.
Higher picks/Taranto, SPP, Ben Crocker, Will Brodie/Darcy Fogerty, ,Cerra, F.Roberts, 2020 picks for points.
Draft Inside mid, Ben Kelly, upgrade EGG & Chol Rookie - Jai Bolton, Smallwood, Lowson ,Jesse Lonergan/M.Grigg
Disclaimer: Totally aware that most of of this won't actually happen :shh
Where do you come up with this comedy :lol
Aw what's a matter diddums,, did I name some of your favourite Dudley Shytetrucks in the speculative outs? :shh
[
You been banging on about SPP and Cerra for ages.
Also I heard (probably from you I can’t remember) we had earmarked a Big bodied mid a couple of years ago and we were working hard to get him over when he was able.
Is this (or a version of it) true or are you just hoping it will happen?
Anyway, if true, who is this big bodied mid?
And is it true we are making a play for SPP and/or Cerra?
Can you make a case for these two because I’m not sure they are the answer either?
For the umpteenth time -We've been into Cerra since he was drafted, well documented that he's homesick and is a mad Tiger(posted pictures of himself social media celebrating at the 2017 GF) , we met with SPP last year. ((YBB will back me up on this)..he's on the outer at Port and has fallen out with Hinkley - only played last night because Boak withdrew late....Tarranto at this stage is higly unlikely and solely based on rumour from an unreliable Arsebook page.. .there are stronger rumours linking us to Matt Crouch on whom I'm not keen hence why I didn't mention him as part of my dream result...we were also linked to Cunnington but {thankfully IMO) that ship has now sailed.. EDIT: The other blokes I mentioned -Crocker, Fogherty, Brodie & Roberts- because they'dll fill needs, are all good players/shown talent, shouldn't cost that much and aren't getting regular games at their current clubs...:shh :shh
The other stuff - apart from Bolton being traded and as I made pretty clear -was purely just my wishful thinking... :shh :shh :shh
Lonergan and Grigg :help these guys are spuds...worse than those you mention as being trade or delist :lol Stop bringing yourself undone with this nonsense :shh
-
As rookie picks either of them would be an upgrade on Aarts and fill a far more pressing depth need - try again champ... :shh
-
You broke Machine's golden rule - never suggest anything that doesn't involve Menadue being at the RFC......:shh
-
Mick Warner on Talking Footy tonight said Jack is back this week and Nank will be back the following week.
-
You broke Machine's golden rule - never suggest anything that doesn't involve Menadue being at the RFC......:shh
:shh :shh
-
You broke Machine's golden rule - never suggest anything that doesn't involve Menadue being at the RFC......:shh
If Menadue goes the replacements need to be better. Those players mentioned are not and the fact they are mentioned as possible listed players is concerning. There are reasons why they are no longer on AFL lists :shh
-
You broke Machine's golden rule - never suggest anything that doesn't involve Menadue being at the RFC......:shh
If Menadue goes the replacements need to be better. Those players mentioned are not and the fact they are mentioned as possible listed players is concerning. There are reasons why they are no longer on AFL lists :shh
They wouldn't be replacing Menadud, they'd be replacing Aarts, Weller & Townsend..... :shh
-
You broke Machine's golden rule - never suggest anything that doesn't involve Menadue being at the RFC......:shh
If Menadue goes the replacements need to be better. Those players mentioned are not and the fact they are mentioned as possible listed players is concerning. There are reasons why they are no longer on AFL lists :shh
They wouldn't be replacing Menadud, they'd be replacing Aarts, Weller & Townsend..... :shh
Okay...still they are no better than these players and in fact, they are way behind :shh thank god you're not the list manager :whistle
-
SNIP :banghead
Debate the point without weak, childish name calling >:(
-
Menadue has to come in this week doesn't he? Was playing some great footy earlier in this season and very unlucky to be dropped 3 times
-
In the Mix - Round 17
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
9 July 2019
RICHMOND
Get them in: Spearhead Jack Riewoldt is a real chance to return this week from a PCL injury, no doubt causing headaches at selection after a 92-point win. Liam Baker (29 disposals, eight marks) impressed in defence in the VFL, while Jack Higgins (22 and a goal) continues to press for a recall.
Under the pump: There weren't many who didn't contribute in the thumping victory, but Derek Eggmolesse-Smith may find himself back in the VFL purely on a last-in, first-out basis with Riewoldt pressing and Shane Edwards able to swing back.
Medical room: Versatile tall Noah Balta injured his quad in the VFL, assuring Mabior Chol of another AFL game. Josh Caddy missed the Gold Coast win with a leg injury.
Verdict: Some very tough decisions to be made this week. Eggmolesse-Smith for Riewoldt (and a few magnet changes), while Daniel Rioli may be the one to make way for Josh Caddy if fit.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-07-09/in-the-mix-whos-pushing-for-selection-for-round-17-
-
Riewoldt and Caddy just got through training
As did Nank
Interesting selection this week
-
I wouldn’t bring caddy straight back in. Has been mostly poor this year, let him find some form in the vfl.
Jack in for McIntosh for me.
-
I wouldn’t bring caddy straight back in. Has been mostly poor this year, let him find some form in the vfl.
Jack in for McIntosh for me.
KMac won't be dropped me thinks ;D
It's funny I watched the replay while home sick on Monday. TV coverage as always doesn't give a clear indication of what players do or don't do.
MacIntosh and Broad were our best gut runners both ways last weekend by a long way but the replay didn't show that. Yes Kam's disposal was average at times but he played his role well.
Can't see him being dropped
-
IN:
Riewoldt, Caddy
OUT:
Eggmolesse-Smith, Broad
-
Looking forward to Caddy making our forward line slow & dysfunctional again.... :shh
-
Houli has put in two poor performances in a row. Won't be dropped but should be put on notice.
-
Looking forward to Caddy making our forward line slow & dysfunctional again.... :shh
He must have been carrying an injury this year even while playing because last year he was neither slow or dysfunctional with his 46 goals.
And if that is the case, and with a few players back, he should either get it 100% right or go back to the twos and work on some fitness.
-
Jeez id like to see us find a spot for Baker.
That kid has something IMO and he is getting better every game.
Surely most can see he is a better player than Bellis and won’t go missing when things get tough.
Dimma needs to start thinking about what our best side will look like if/when we make finals.
-
Jeez id like to see us find a spot for Baker.
That kid has something IMO and he is getting better every game.
Surely most can see he is a better player than Bellis and won’t go missing when things get tough.
Dimma needs to start thinking about what our best side will look like if/when we make finals.
I really like baker and was very surprised to see him dropped. I know you dislike Bellis but don’t think Baker is suited to his role. See him as a forward half playmaker that runs through the middle like Edwards. Maybe he could come in for Rioli but think we’d be losing too much pace up front especially with Bolton spending more time up the ground.
-
Jeez id like to see us find a spot for Baker.
That kid has something IMO and he is getting better every game.
Surely most can see he is a better player than Bellis and won’t go missing when things get tough.
Dimma needs to start thinking about what our best side will look like if/when we make finals.
Good call and would also like to see him replace Ellis as I believe he will become a better player. Tough little player is Baker!
-
100% agree. When I see a kid with this level of talent playing VFL I get nervous that they will be inclined to leave.
Need to find spots for the like of Jack, Baker and Balta etc.
Jeez id like to see us find a spot for Baker.
That kid has something IMO and he is getting better every game.
Surely most can see he is a better player than Bellis and won’t go missing when things get tough.
Dimma needs to start thinking about what our best side will look like if/when we make finals.
-
IN:
Riewoldt, Caddy
OUT:
Eggmolesse-Smith, Broad
Don't see us dropping two defenders for two forwards but sadly Eggy might be the unlucky one to make way for Jack. The Giants' forward line is tall. The only other options would be to play with one ruck (one of Soldo or Chol goes) or drop a small forward (which on form would be Rioli). Personally, don't either either of the latter two happening.
-
Jeez id like to see us find a spot for Baker.
That kid has something IMO and he is getting better every game.
Surely most can see he is a better player than Bellis and won’t go missing when things get tough.
Dimma needs to start thinking about what our best side will look like if/when we make finals.
I really like baker and was very surprised to see him dropped. I know you dislike Bellis but don’t think Baker is suited to his role. See him as a forward half playmaker that runs through the middle like Edwards. Maybe he could come in for Rioli but think we’d be losing too much pace up front especially with Bolton spending more time up the ground.
I don’t think Baker would take Bellis spot on a wing but we could throw about 5 players into a wing (Bolton, Lambert, Edwards, Rioli, Stack, even Georgie) and play Baker where he is more suited.
Baker, like a few other young guys we have has a bit of X factor about him IMO.
Just my opinion
-
IN:
Riewoldt, Caddy
OUT:
Eggmolesse-Smith, Broad
Don't see us dropping two defenders for two forwards but sadly Eggy might be the unlucky one to make way for Jack. The Giants' forward line is tall. The only other options would be to play with one ruck (one of Soldo or Chol goes) or drop a small forward (which on form would be Rioli). Personally, don't either either of the latter two happening.
I don't see Broad getting dropped. If giants play a tall forwardline they may play Chol down back.