One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: Jackstar is back!!! on August 11, 2019, 06:05:43 PM
-
Out Chol and Bolton
In Dusty and Cotch
Pickett ?
-
We won't play with one ruck and go shorter against the Eagles. If Chol is to be dropped then Soldo has to come in. IMO it wasn't the day for talls. Jack was ordinary too apart from kicking 2 goals.
I wouldn't bring back Cotch yet. Give his hammy the extra week.
In: Dusty
Out: Ross
-
Out: Chol, Stack (looked like a show off today)
In Soldo, Martin
Give Cotchy another week.
Not sure about all the fuss re Pickett. Looked ok but a few in front of him IMO
-
Out: Chol, Stack (looked like a show off today)
In Soldo, Martin
Give Cotchy another week.
Not sure about all the fuss re Pickett. Looked ok but a few in front of him IMO
Pickett was ordinary in the 2s today. I thpught Ross wad good considering his long absence.
-
In:
Dusty
Cotch
Balta
Mac
Out;
Bolton
Chol
Ellis
Rioli
-
Poor Ross. Did some good things but felt being out for so long he took a bit to adjust to the pace of the game. He’s gotta make way for martin
-
Clearly underdone but stacks of talent and potential
-
We won't play with one ruck and go shorter against the Eagles. If Chol is to be dropped then Soldo has to come in. IMO it wasn't the day for talls. Jack was ordinary too apart from kicking 2 goals.
I wouldn't bring back Cotch yet. Give his hammy the extra week.
In: Dusty
Out: Ross
Cotchin is right to go
Trained this morning
-
Id keep Ross in and drop someone like Ellis
-
I’d play Bolton .. don’t understand why people want him out so quickly
I might be missing something
-
i dunno...but it was the worst richmond performance this year...if it wasnt for 5 or 6 players we wouldhave been smashed by a better team.....
martin in
ellis out
-
I’d play Bolton .. don’t understand why people want him out so quickly
I might be missing something
Had 10 disposals last week and again this week
Gave little today
-
I’d play Bolton .. don’t understand why people want him out so quickly
I might be missing something
Had 10 disposals last week and again this week
Gave little today
Set up goals when the game was on the line in the first half.....
-
Out: Chol, Caddy, Bolton
In: Balta, Dusty, Cotch
-
I’d play Bolton .. don’t understand why people want him out so quickly
I might be missing something
Had 10 disposals last week and again this week
Gave little today
Set up goals when the game was on the line in the first half.....
Must watch a different game to me 🤦♂️
-
Dimma reckons both Cotch and Dusty will play next week.
About Cotch:
"Trent ran full speed today. Once again, conservative call, but we'll welcome him back next week, which will be good."
About Dusty:
Our expectation is he'll play this week."
Source: Hardwick's post-match presser.
-
I'd drop Bolton for giving away the 2 x 50 metre penalties
That was shocking and so incredibly stupid.
Outside of that thought he was average
INS: Cotchin, Martin, MacIntosh
OUTS: Bolton, Baker and BEllis (too much bab BEllis today)
-
I’d play Bolton .. don’t understand why people want him out so quickly
I might be missing something
Had 10 disposals last week and again this week
Gave little today
Set up goals when the game was on the line in the first half.....
Must watch a different game to me 🤦♂️
Did you watch the game at all? Stats show he had 3 score involvements all in the first half which set up the win...... :shh
-
Out Chol, Bolton, Ellis
In. Martin, Cotchin, Balta
There were a few others that didn't justify a game next week and I could pretty much guarantee this will not be the charges but it's my selections.
-
I'd drop Bolton for giving away the 2 x 50 metre penalties
That was shocking and so incredibly stupid.
Outside of that thought he was average
INS: Cotchin, Martin, MacIntosh
OUTS: Bolton, Baker and BEllis (too much bab BEllis today)
Yep Bolton losing form at the wrong time of the year I feel.
Thought he was underwhelming today.
-
I'd drop Short before Bolton.
K Mac in, I think we are missing his gut running.
-
Brandon “Snugglers” Ellis was atrocious especially in that first half. I counted atleast three times in that first half he needed a new pair of undies. :banghead
-
Apart from the idiotic double 50 my main issue with Bolton's game was all the half-hearted tackling efforts.... :shh
-
Watch the replay jack
-
Does it actually count as a replay if he hasn't watched it before? :shh
-
Out: chol, Ellis, Ross
In: balta, cotch, dusty
-
I'd drop Bolton for giving away the 2 x 50 metre penalties
That was shocking and so incredibly stupid.
Outside of that thought he was average
INS: Cotchin, Martin, MacIntosh
OUTS: Bolton, Baker and BEllis (too much bab BEllis today)
Bolton played very poorly in particular in the second half. He turned the ball over needlessly and gave away that needless penalty. Agree with INS however not sure about dropping Baker.
-
We won't play with one ruck and go shorter against the Eagles. If Chol is to be dropped then Soldo has to come in. IMO it wasn't the day for talls. Jack was ordinary too apart from kicking 2 goals.
I wouldn't bring back Cotch yet. Give his hammy the extra week.
In: Dusty
Out: Ross
Agree with comments about Jack. Not up to his usual high standards.
-
Liam Jones towelled Jack up yesterday.
-
I must admit I watched the game from a bar in Bali but I thought Baker was good.
And I thought the Bolton free kick was BS to start with and the 2x 50’s were even bigger BS.
Let’s not hang him for an over zealous moron umpire.
The reason we are where we are this year are because of players like Baker and Bolton and a few other young guys, and dropping them would be a mistake IMO.
-
Is Bolton spending more time in the forward line again instead of in the guts were he was doing well.From now on it will be 2 rucks not only Nank can not do that against top sides like eagles.
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
3 possessions isn’t doing your job 🤦♂️
Plus the marking attempt when standing alone in forward pocket had to seen to be believed
Give Balta another crack
Was given a crack at Centre Bounces on 5 occasions yesterday and won 4
-
damn,...Ross out after his first game back? No stuffing way, he is a player. Dirty game, dirty day, no injuries the main thing. Bolton stuffed up, (that crap in a final could sink us). Baker was a bit down and Ellis too. All out for me.
Mack, Martin and Cotchin back in
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
3 possessions isn’t doing your job 🤦♂️
Plus the marking attempt when standing alone in forward pocket had to seen to be believed
Give Balta another crack
Was given a crack at Centre Bounces on 5 occasions yesterday and won 4
Yeah I saw that missed Mark but there was another of our players who did the same which resulted in a goal after a chain.
Wet weather footy = chest marks
Doesn't help when it's constantly being kicked at their head or higher :shh
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
3 possessions isn’t doing your job 🤦♂️
Plus the marking attempt when standing alone in forward pocket had to seen to be believed
Give Balta another crack
Was given a crack at Centre Bounces on 5 occasions yesterday and won 4
Oh no a second ruck only got three touches in a downpour... you've called for him to be dropped every week since his first match this year....obviously another one who gave you the brush off after training...:shh
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
3 possessions isn’t doing your job 🤦♂️
Plus the marking attempt when standing alone in forward pocket had to seen to be believed
Give Balta another crack
Was given a crack at Centre Bounces on 5 occasions yesterday and won 4
Wasn't his best but he is the best tackling machine for a big bloke since, well, Nankervis. He also loves to tackle hard and don't think that goes unnoticed by the coaches. Even oppo players are getting nervous when they know he's on their tail.... :shh
-
Chol made some great tackles, got their ruck a ripper in one of em
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
3 possessions isn’t doing your job 🤦♂️
Plus the marking attempt when standing alone in forward pocket had to seen to be believed
Give Balta another crack
Was given a crack at Centre Bounces on 5 occasions yesterday and won 4
Wasn't his best but he is the best tackling machine for a big bloke since, well, Nankervis. He also loves to tackle hard and don't think that goes unnoticed by the coaches. Even oppo players are getting nervous when they know he's on their tail.... :shh
You obviously don’t watch Soldo tackle 🤦♂️
-
Chol did his job given the conditions- even appeared to out ruck Kruezer a couple of times- I'd bring in CCJ before Slomo anyway....the latter is on the list as cover for Nankervis, not to partner him... :shh
3 possessions isn’t doing your job 🤦♂️
Plus the marking attempt when standing alone in forward pocket had to seen to be believed
Give Balta another crack
Was given a crack at Centre Bounces on 5 occasions yesterday and won 4
Wasn't his best but he is the best tackling machine for a big bloke since, well, Nankervis. He also loves to tackle hard and don't think that goes unnoticed by the coaches. Even oppo players are getting nervous when they know he's on their tail.... :shh
You obviously don’t watch Soldo tackle 🤦♂️
I do but he can't catch guys running away from him. Soldo is great if the guy grabs the ball in front of him and is stationary. Chol has the pace to run some smaller blokes down or at least infer pressure. Soldo cannot do that or are you watching something else when the game is actually being played?
-
...probably his phone... :shh
-
Chol hasn't used his so called athleticism much in the past few weeks.
Can't be carrying blokes that only get 3 touches a game in finals....
-
damn,...Ross out after his first game back? No stuffing way, he is a player.
Agree t'wit t'woo - truly mind boggling that there's even a suggestion he be dropped.. :shh
-
5 changes for me
Martin and Cotchin will happen regardless. The other three ins McIntosh, Balta, Pickett
4 outs are straight fwd imo
Ellis, Short, Baker, Broad. Last one is a toughy but i chose Caddy over both Rioli and Bolton
Straight fwd in the sense Martin Cotchin and McIntosh for Ellis, Short and Baker
Balta for Broad not only was he poor but imo we need the extra size Balta gives this week.
Pickett well he didnt do a real lot but has to be better for the second run.If we are serious about him playing finals we probably have to play him the last two games.
-
damn,...Ross out after his first game back? No stuffing way, he is a player.
Agree t'wit t'woo - truly mind boggling that there's even a suggestion he be dropped.. :shh
Yep. The guy is a gun. Comes in after missing 15 weeks of footy, plays 50% only in the VFL and just continues where he left off. Amazing.... :shh
-
Pickett doesnt deserve a call up based on his performance in the reserves
-
Yes he does...was clearly a class above... :shh
-
Yes he does...was clearly a class above... :shh
Needs to get more of the footy for a senior call up.
-
Yes he does...was clearly a class above... :shh
Ah no
Wasn’t clearly classes above
Didn’t understand defensive set up at times when off half back , that’s why he is playing to learn
One thing for certain Tiges need to improve to beat West Coast next week.
-
I’m not calling for Ross to go out based on his performance but more for team balance. Kids got a very bright future but I’d rather keep the likes of Bolton in to run through the middle who offers genuine X factor to add to the grunt work of cotch dusty Prestia graham etc.
Can we drop both Ellis and short and still have enough outside run is the question. If so then I would go:
Out: chol, short, ellis
In: balta, cotch, dusty
Btw I can’t see how people are calling for baker to be dropped unless they think his replacement balances the team better. Just seems like there’s a couple every week who no matter what he does call for him to be dropped.
-
Can see your perspective there re Ross. He'd be stiff though. Don't think either of BElly/Short will be dropped, someone has to make way for the big dogs however.
-
I'll try again assuming cotchy is back
In Cotchin, Martin, Soldo
Out Chol, Stack, Ross
Ross stiff was very close to B Ellis
Stack will probably stay in
-
There is some seriously talented players people are suggesting to be dropped which is bloody good thing this time if the year.
The next two weeks will tell a story but as I said earlier I hope Dimma sticks with the guys that got us to here. Regardless of if they were quite on Sunday in a very scrappy game.
My outs if I were coach
-Ross, Bellis
My ins
-Dusty, Cotch
Not a bad couple of ins!!
I would like to find a way to get McIntosh back in and the only other one I think has struggled is Short, although I think he was better on the weekend.
-
No way stack gets dropped! He and lynch were some of the few highlights when we were getting pantsed in the middle of the year!
-
Yes he does...was clearly a class above... :shh
Ah no
Wasn’t clearly classes above
Didn’t understand defensive set up at times when off half back , that’s why he is playing to learn
One thing for certain Tiges need to improve to beat West Coast next week.
He only got the footy 15 times at reserves level. If he can get that to 25 to 30 times then ok but 15 possies ar reserves level isnt good enough for a senior call up.
-
Wouldn't be dropping Ross need him in the guts helps Martin and Cotchin and Prestia to in and under player.Martin can push forward to.
-
Yes he does...was clearly a class above... :shh
Ah no
Wasn’t clearly classes above
Didn’t understand defensive set up at times when off half back , that’s why he is playing to learn
One thing for certain Tiges need to improve to beat West Coast next week.
He only got the footy 15 times at reserves level. If he can get that to 25 to 30 times then ok but 15 possies ar reserves level isnt good enough for a senior call up.
He's an impact player not an accumulator.... don't listen Jackstar's clueless nonsense .... :shh
-
I have my own view. If a player only gets it 15 times at reserves level then that is not enough to get a senior call up. Pickett needs to show that he can find the footy. Its that simple.
-
No it really isn't that simple and surely you can't be either...he's not a Tim Kelly type high a possession player and never has been...averaged < 20 in the WAFL - we knew that when we drafted him and so did all the other clubs who would've all taken him had he not been injured - watch the replay on seven plus taking into account it's third game for the year and second in three months and see why the coaching staff are all desperate to get him into the senior side before the finals..:shh
-
Correct. Imagine Cyril playing reserves....
If you require 25 possessions plus he'd never have been promoted to the seniors..... :shh
-
Time will tell I suppose.
-
Remember the days where we would struggle to find 22 good players?
Now we are discussing which of the 30 in form players we should leave out.
-
In the Mix - Round 22
Sarah Black
afl.com.au
13 Aug 2019
RICHMOND
Get them in: Damien Hardwick has the pleasant task of trying to fit Brownlow medallists Dustin Martin (soreness) and Trent Cotchin (hamstring) into a side that's won seven straight games. From the twos, small forward Jake Aarts starred with 24 and three goals, while Callum Coleman-Jones (19 disposals, six marks) is steadily building a case for the second ruck/forward role.
Under the pump: It may be time forMabior Chol to have a break in the VFL. The run of wet conditions hasn't helped, but the big man managed just 53 per cent game time and four disposals. Shai Bolton (11 disposals) didn't have a huge impact, while Daniel Rioli (10) was also quiet.
Medical room: The only casualty from the weekend was rookieDerek Eggmolesse-Smith (corked buttock) in the VFL.
Verdict: Jack Ross and Jack Graham did enough to hold their own, meaning Bolton and Rioli could be in trouble for Cotchin and Martin. The option of swapping Chol for Coleman-Jones orNoah Balta is also on the table.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-08-13/in-the-mix-whos-pushing-for-selection-in-round-22
-
According to Mark Stevens there's still doubts over Cotch and Dusty:
Dusty in according to Balme but Club has not confirmed.
Cotch could miss another week (see other thread).
Watch here: https://twitter.com/7NewsMelbourne/status/1161197696595746816
-
According to Mark Stevens there's still doubts over Cotch and Dusty:
Dusty in according to Balme but Club has not confirmed.
Cotch could miss another week (see other thread).
Watch here: https://twitter.com/7NewsMelbourne/status/1161197696595746816
Balmey also said last years preliminary final there was nothing wrong with Dusty and Dave , we all know how that ended 🤦♂️😂
-
Dustin Martin, who missed last weekend's slugfest with Carlton with 'soreness', is likely to return to face the Eagles.
First-year draftee Jack Ross is also in the frame to continue after 13 weeks out from ankle surgery.
https://7news.com.au/sport/afl/cotchin-to-miss-afl-eagles-date-c-398734
-
Cotchin not playing.
-
I saw the last quarter of the reserves last week and all I did was watch Pickett. Based on that only I would be happy to have him play ahead of Snugglers Ellis any day.
Granted I didn’t see him accumulate many disposals during that quarter but he is tough, he is poised and he is skilful and most importantly he doesn’t take a backward step nor does he shirk from a contest.
That puts him ahead of both Snugglers and Short-step as both were terrible on Sunday against the blues.