One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on August 04, 2025, 11:46:02 PM
-
AFL Round 22
RICHMOND vs St Kilda
Saturday, 9th August @ the M.C.G.
Start time: 1:20 PM
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/7147
-
Richmond v St Kilda Preview
Lachlan Geleit
SEN
7 Aug 2025
I guess Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera is worth the price of admission.
Apart from that, there's not much going for this game apart from both sets of fans sniffing another potential win to finish off the season.
For the Tigers, after a few solid weeks, they came back down to earth last weekend on the Gold Coast, losing to the Suns by 84 points.
Even though the Tigers seem destined to finish somewhere from 15th to 17th, Richmond fans would be fairly pleased with how their season has gone with the young group picking up five wins and showing positive signs.
As for St Kilda, they can make it three straight here after two incredibly tight wins over both Melbourne and North Melbourne under the roof at Marvel Stadium.
The main man behind those wins has no doubt been Wanganeen-Milera with the young star all but certain now to lock in an All-Australian berth.
Even though the Saints have only won one of their last five at the MCG, they deserve to go in pretty warm favourites in this game.
While Richmond have a chance if their defence plays as it did from Round 18 to 20 where they gave up an average of 62 points, the Saints probably have a bit too much class, particularly in transition with Wanganeen-Milera and Jack Sinclair.
Realistically, the Saints should be leaving the ‘G with their eighth win of the season should they play anywhere near their capabilities.
Prediction: St Kilda by 30 points.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2025/08/07/who-will-win-and-why-tips-and-predictions-for-afl-round-22
-
Barrett stating the bleedingly obvious.
(https://resources.afl.com.au/photo-resources/2020/11/17/8a4c2df0-2497-41a0-85ac-8cab8feed48a/richmond.jpg?width=1511)
IF ...
Taranto, Lynch and Broad are the ins for Saturday's game against the Saints ...
THEN ...
surely the Tigers are a chance. Instantly, look a whole better on paper.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1382066/sliding-doors-if-damo-wasnt-worried-about-the-pies-before-then
-
'A lot to play for' against Saints
By Anna Pavlou
RFC website
8 Aug 2025
Richmond coach Adem Yze admits that the side took a backward step last week, but is refusing to allow it to carry over against St Kilda on Saturday.
The Tigers welcome back three veterans in Tim Taranto, Nathan Broad and Tom Lynch for the clash at the MCG, which offers a needed boost.
"We've got to make amends for last week's performance. We're looking week-to-week, we're not looking at a block of games," Yze said on Friday.
"We weren't happy with the way we performed last week. We felt like we took a step backwards.
"We get a chance to make amends this weekend, and all we're looking at is the way we'll play against St Kilda and provide a contest that our Tiger Army are proud of."
And while priorities aren't on September for either side, it hasn't dampened the spirit in Yze's men to compete.
"Both teams aren't playing for finals, but there's a lot to play for," he said.
"They'll be talking about the exact same thing, finishing off the season in the right way and hopefully we can just do it better tomorrow."
Excitingly, the playing group is also feeling refreshed after a week back at home.
"Our players have had a good week, they've got some energy and spirit, and we're looking to bring that tomorrow," Yze said.
But Yze knows he'd be silly to think a game against the Saints, who have been in strong form in recent weeks, will be simple.
"The last two or three weeks, they've (St Kilda) been really competitive. You can see what they did in the last quarter against Melbourne," Yze said.
"We understand their strengths and understand where our opportunities lie.
"We're in a process right now that we want to play a certain way. We'll go in backing ourselves and backing our system."
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1853869/a-lot-to-play-for-against-saints
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Richmond (5-15) and St Kilda (7-13) are both out of finals contention, but the Saints are riding high on the back of consecutive wins inspired by Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera.
Like Hawthorn's Sam Mitchell before him, Yze said the St Kilda superstar had been giving him nightmares during the planning process.
"He had me up at two o'clock this morning thinking about it," Yze said.
"But we're in a process right now where we want to play a certain way and we'll go in backing ourselves and backing our system.
"We'll keep an eye on how much impact he's having."
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1383492/richmond-tigers-love-veteran-tom-lynch-playing-on-the-edge-star-st-kilda-saint-nasiah-wanganeen-milera-giving-adem-yze-nightmares
-
Lyon highlighting Richmond has the older team
-
If there is a team more frustrating to watch than our own it’s a Ross Lyon coached team.
-
And as usual, leaders letting us down with poor skills
-
We're making them look pretty good so far
-
This is pathetic. No pressure. Skills putrid.
Go man on man FFS.
-
Basic skill errors from Vlastuin, Lynch and Mcintosh.
We really need to get the ball into the hands of our skilled players.
-
Short easy turnover now. So all our leaders can’t hit targets, what hope do we have
-
Freaken turnovers are killing us.
-
Alix Tauru is v nice
-
Quarter time
Richmond 1.0-6
St Kilda 3.2-20
Goal: Mansell
Well that was pathetic :help. 22 mins to score and that goal is our only score :facepalm. Just 10 tackles = lack of workrate = bruise free footy. Lucky to be only 14 pts down.
-
I don't know what Yze is saying to the boys but lack of intent comes down to the coach and the coaching staff.
If that crap is allowed at our club then the whole lot of them cap pee off and we need to get a couching group that have some base line standards that the team is expected to attain as the norm.
-
St Kilda had 50 marks in that one quarter :help.
Stats to 1/4 time:
Ross 7 disposals
Nank 6
Short 6
Sonsie 6
Kmac 5
Miller 5
Floss 5
Disposals 78 - 112 .... ( contested: 27 - 30 )
Efficiency% 71 - 79
Marks 29 - 50
Tackles 9 - 22 ::) :facepalm
Clearances 10 - 9 .... ( centre: 3 - 1 )
Inside 50s 9 - 14
In50 eff.% 11 - 36 ...... just 11% eff. going inside F50 :help
Hitouts 10 - 7
Frees 3 - 4
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/7147#team-stats
-
Vlastuins disposal is shakey
-
We were out and Trezise with no awareness stuffs it up.
-
I don't know what Yze is saying to the boys but lack of intent comes down to the coach and the coaching staff.
If that crap is allowed at our club then the whole lot of them cap pee off and we need to get a couching group that have some base line standards that the team is expected to attain as the norm.
Lack of intent comes down to the coaching staff? That’s stuffing stupid
-
Balta :gotigers
12 - 20
-
Trezise won't use his left foot and it's stuffing the team up.
-
Nank! Take at least 1 mark!!!! :banghead :banghead :banghead
-
So poor by Ross
-
That's what happens when you can't tackle. :banghead
-
Why kick it in the air Mansell? If he kept it grounded we had the numbers inside F50 at ground level. Lack of footy smarts. The turnover then gifts St Kilda a goal the other way :banghead.
-
They've put
Dumb Dumb Balta in the ruck. :clapping :clapping :clapping
-
Another terrible kick inside 50 (Kmac) :banghead.
-
Really impressive effort from Armstrong there. Stayed relevant in the contest
-
Armstrong very good then and goals :gotigers
But sheesh we burn our teammates across HF :banghead. Just lucky then.
21 - 26
-
Nice throw ump ::).
But another mistackle followed that and they get a goal out of it :scream.
-
That's what happens when you can't tackle. :banghead
We are the worst tackling team in the league.
-
That's a better kick Mansell :gotigers
27 - 33
Credit where it's due. That was good umpiring with that advantage call.
-
Great chasing Lynch :clapping.
Misses again though.
29 - 33
-
Nank 0 marks first half :help
-
Half-time
Richmond 1.0 4.5-29
St Kilda 3.2 5.3-33
Goal: Mansell 2, Balta, Armstrong.
Not pretty but a much better quarter as we kept the game mostly in our forward half. If only we were smarter with our decision making going inside F50 to make the most of it.
-
Stats to 1/2 time:
Sonsie 15 disposals
Ross 13
Banks 12
Hopper 12
Kmac 10
Miller 10
Nank 10
Taranto 10
Mansell 9
Prestia 9
Floss 9
Short 8
Young 8
Balta 7
Broad 6
Lynch 5
Trezise 5
Hotton 4
Rioli 4
Armstrong 3
Campbell 3
Brown 2
Green 0 ..... sub not used yet.
Disposals 175 - 221 .... ( contested: 65 - 64 )
Efficiency% 70 - 75
Marks 49 - 75
Tackles 24 - 46
Clearances 20 - 20 .... ( centre: 5 - 3 )
Inside 50s 24- 23
In50 eff.% 29 - 30
In50 marks 4 - 5
In50 tackles 6 - 2
Hitouts 24 - 18
Frees 7 - 7
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/7147#team-stats
-
Richmond has trailed at half-time in 16 games this season, the most of any team, and has a win-loss record of just 2-14 in those games.
The Tigers pinned the Saints in their defensive half in the second quarter, having 68% time in the forward half and nine forward half intercepts, but they were unable to take advantage, scoring just 0.4 (4) from them.
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/7147#timeline
-
If the Taranto was dropping the ball, then so was Hill's ump ::).
-
You have an open teammate leading and you burn him to kick long to a St Kilda mark :scream.
-
The witches hat, Short is at his best again in defense.
-
Hard work but we finally got one. Kmac goals :gotigers.
In front!
36 - 35
-
Why play on Mansell? :banghead
-
Offer NWM a blank cheque
-
Lynch kicking like he's missed 5 weeks of footy :P.
-
Seth you do that in the F50 not the D50.
-
Geez we've burnt free teammates on transition today. The lazy long kick is causing the turnovers.
-
Great bend on the kick Timmy :gotigers
44 - 36
-
3/4 time
Richmond 1.0 4.5 6.8-44
St Kilda 3.2 5.3 5.6-36
Goal: Mansell 2, Balta, Armstrong, McIntosh, Taranto.
You can tell it's a game between bottom 5 sides, but we deserve to be in front. Up to us now to bring it home.
Miller has been excellent so far.
-
Soft goal. No one near NWM in the middle of the park :facepalm.
-
3 up and no one down. Basics Tiges :banghead.
-
Lynch finally finds his radar :gotigers
50 - 43
-
Be great to see Nank stand up and take some grabs now either in defence or down the line intercepts.
Let's see if he can stand up as captain.
-
Summed up our day. Just butchery going inside 50 :facepalm.
-
We're making it easy for them. The turnovers this quarter are just killing us.
-
We look out on our feet. Really soft last quarter.
Yze still hasn't used the sub Green.
-
Kicks to a 1 on three :help :banghead
-
Seriously! Really poor kick Tim. We had 4 players free running at HF and we kick to a 1 vs 3 :facepalm.
-
Kmac you had a better kick in Brown right next to you. Once again we burn our teammate :facepalm.
-
Why why why why didn't helicopters Macintosh give the ball to Brown :help :banghead
What an idiot!
-
Campbell was absolutely pathetic the last quarter .. horrendous
-
That's what happens when you can't tackle. :banghead
We are the worst tackling team in the league.
30 odd tackles for the game again.
Unbelievable poor
-
Seriously! Really poor kick Tim. We had 4 players free running at HF and we kick to a 1 vs 3 :facepalm.
Thought it was pretty good kick. Just missed
-
Well if we wanted to tank that last quarter, we did our best to do it. Some absolute bizarre decision making.
Anyway, enjoy another meaningless late season win Saints that pushes you into middle of the ladder no man's land.
-
Seriously! Really poor kick Tim. We had 4 players free running at HF and we kick to a 1 vs 3 :facepalm.
Poor decision making but I continue to ask why are our players allergic to shepherding their team mates. He could have almost run that all the way to 30m from goal if any of the 3 team mates around him decided to shepherd the 1 saints player applying pressure.
-
Did any of us really want the win in that one?
Terrible game of footy.
Enjoy the win Saints fans.
-
Seriously! Really poor kick Tim. We had 4 players free running at HF and we kick to a 1 vs 3 :facepalm.
Thought it was pretty good kick. Just missed
It missed because it was poor percentage kick to an outnumbered isolated teammate. We did it all day. Burning overlapping running teammates in space going the lazy long poor option to St Kilda's numbers.
-
A competitive loss is far from the end of the world especially with the risk of moving up the ladder but we lost the tackle count by 41 despite have 63 less disposals. There’s no real excuse for this other than a lack of intent/effort and you don’t need talented players for that.
-
Seriously! Really poor kick Tim. We had 4 players free running at HF and we kick to a 1 vs 3 :facepalm.
Poor decision making but I continue to ask why are our players allergic to shepherding their team mates. He could have almost run that all the way to 30m from goal if any of the 3 team mates around him decided to shepherd the 1 saints player applying pressure.
Agree but that's another issue TK. We don't just do the basics like shepherding and tackling.
-
Why would you not use the sub?
Yze cooked
-
A competitive loss is far from the end of the world especially with the risk of moving up the ladder but we lost the tackle count by 41 despite have 63 less disposals. There’s no real excuse for this other than a lack of intent/effort and you don’t need talented players for that.
63 less disposals of which all went backwards
-
Did any of us really want the win in that one?
Terrible game of footy.
Enjoy the win Saints fans.
Yes, me.
-
Did any of us really want the win in that one?
Terrible game of footy.
Enjoy the win Saints fans.
Yep, a poor standard match which is why we almost won it. St Kilda were woeful. The only positive from losing that game is that we pretty much seal up two top 3 picks even if we beat Norf next week.
-
Why would you not use the sub?
Yze cooked
Absolutely ridiculous
-
Why would you not use the sub?
Yze cooked
(https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/20140304adf8439709_211.jpg)
VFL team also playing for a top 6 spot. Can Green now be a late in and play a full game tonight in the ressies?
-
Saints winning games in the seasons junk time .
It would have been nice to get the W , but it doesn’t matter.
We are highly competitive against mediocre teams. Another stepping stone .
I just hope this time next year we are winning these type of games .
-
Final Score
Richmond 1.0 4.5 6.8 7.10-52
St Kilda 3.2 5.3 5.6 8.8-56
Goal: Mansell 2, Balta, Armstrong, McIntosh, Taranto, Lynch.
Port, Carlton & Melbourne will be happy. They've moved up a draft spot ahead of the Saints.
-
Did any of us really want the win in that one?
Terrible game of footy.
Enjoy the win Saints fans.
Only game we want to win is the north one!
-
Did any of us really want the win in that one?
Terrible game of footy.
Enjoy the win Saints fans.
Wanted to lose by a point but I ran into one of the young players this morning and felt bad about that mindset we
-
Why would you not use the sub?
Yze cooked
Yze said post-game that it based on how the game was playing out and he decided not to use Green. He also added that we've previously not used the sub, so it wasn't something new.
VFL team also playing for a top 6 spot. Can Green now be a late in and play a full game tonight in the ressies?
Yze stated that Green can play in the VFL tonight if we decide to go down that path.
-
Did any of us really want the win in that one?
Terrible game of footy.
Enjoy the win Saints fans.
Yes, me.
x 2
-
why would we not want to beat those pricks?
weird logic. I wanted to win.
we would not have moved up so that cant be the reason.
terrible performance IMO. Some senior players like Balta and Hoppers had shockers.
-
Seriously! Really poor kick Tim. We had 4 players free running at HF and we kick to a 1 vs 3 :facepalm.
Forget 4 blokes free
He was less that 40 metres out he could have kicked it himself
As for Kaspy :banghead :banghead
I know the the draft picks are important but we should have won that game
And I peeved we didn't
-
Really annoyed lost that game.
-
Always want to win
💩 game
Feel sorry for stkilda supporters
They will never be anything
-
I’d really like a 6th win. History says the really rubbish teams sit at around 5 wins. 6 and more feels like a real improvement. We’re in that group with Dees, Bombers, Saints and Roos this year. Will be interesting to see who stays there next year and who improves
-
Team Stats:
Disposals 332 - 394 ..... ( contested: 120 - 109 ; uncontested: 206 - 273 )
Efficiency% 72 - 76
Kicks 204 - 257
Handballs 128 - 137
Turnovers 61 - 56
Marks 100 - 151 .... ( contested marks: 11 - 7 )
Tackles 41 - 80 :P
Clearances 36 - 31 .... ( centre: 6 - 7 ; stoppages: 30 - 24 )
Inside 50s 41 - 43
In50 eff.% 39 - 37
In50 marks 7 - 12
In50 tackles 15 - 7
Hitouts 41 - 26
Bounces 4 - 7
One %ers 36 - 40
Frees 16 - 18
Individual possies:
Ross 26
Taranto 23
Hopper 20
Sonsie 20
Banks 19
Short 19
Vlastuin 19
Prestia 18
Mansell 17
Young 17
Broad 15
Miller 15
Nankervis 15
McIntosh 14
Balta 12
Lynch 12
Hotton 10
Trezise 10
Campbell 9
Rioli 9
Armstrong 8
Brown 5
Green 0 .... sub not used.
https://www.afl.com.au/afl/matches/7147#player-stats
-
"Are you actually, genuinely trying to win?"
Kane Cornes fires up at Adem Yze for letting Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera run free against the Tigers on First Up:
VIDEO: https://x.com/AFL/status/1954496262662988087
-
This made the Clangers segment on the fox footy show Bounce.
Taranto had Campbell running towards 50 on his own plus Lynch and Balta inside 50 free for the easy hit up. Instead, he went for Mansell vs 3 Saints defenders.
(http://oneeyed-richmond.com/images/tactics/TarantoOptionsR222025.jpg)