One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on September 15, 2008, 03:39:08 AM
-
Just a reminder that the JJ Liston Trophy is being held tonight at Moonee Valley Racing Club at 7.00pm.
All the best to Tivs who will be a big show to win it :gotigers.
-
Any news in on how Tivs went?
-
Podsiadly from Werribee won
16 Votes - James Podsiadly
15 Votes - Peter Summers
15 Votes - Brett Johnson
14 Votes - Paul Kennedy
-
Thanks CUB. :thumbsup
Would have been nice for Tivs but alas.
-
Txt message from bg25;
Tivs came equal 3rd on 14 votes tied with 3 others.
-
Podsiadly from Werribee won
Shame he can't be picked up as a mature rookie as IIRC he was on an AFL list as a youngster. We tried a couple of years ago. He tore Casey apart on the weekend.
-
Silvester and Horne made the VFL team of the year according to the vflfooty site
B: Horne Silvester Biddlecomb
HB: Picken Baird Goodes
C: Stretton B Johnson Roach
HF: Kennedy Pods Mariglianni
F: Barlow Sautner Nahas
R: Stevennson Pinwll Summers
INT: Byrne Wall Kenna Iacobucci
http://www.vflfooty.com/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=3320&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0
-
Podsiadly from Werribee won
Shame he can't be picked up as a mature rookie as IIRC he was on an AFL list as a youngster. We tried a couple of years ago. He tore Casey apart on the weekend.
The rule was changed, probably as a direct result of that.
We couldn't take him as a mature age rookie because he had been on the Essendon and Collingwood lists, even though he had not played a senior game for either.
Tristan Cartledge was mature age rookied this year even though he he had been on the Essendon list and played 7 games for them.
Pods is getting on a bit. Still might be worth a look, if he's interested.
-
Tristan Cartledge was mature age rookied this year even though he he had been on the Essendon list and played 7 games for them.
Don't think so, I think you'll find he fit in under the normal rookie rules, which is why he's ineligible next year
-
Woops, he does too. He's not eligible to be mature age rookied because he's played senior games.
Pods is eligible because he hasn't played a senior game, which (unfairly) wasn't the case a few years back.
-
Cheers for that FF. How old is Podsiadly?
-
Drafted by Essendon as a 17yo in 1999, so he'd be 26. (Can't find his DOB).
Rookied by Collingwood at the end of 2002.
-
Courtesy of an email from CaseyRadio on vflfooty :cheers
R1 vs Geelong: 3. White 2. Morton 1. Cartledge
R2 vs Bullants: 3. Silvester 1. Shelton
R3 vs Nth Ball: 2. Hughes
R4 vs Port Mel: 1. Jackson
R5 vs Box Hill: 3. Tivendale 1. Bowden
R6 vs C'wood: 3. Cotchin 2. N.Caruso 1. Tivendale
R7 vs Geelong: 3. Carnell 2. Tivendale 1. F.Caruso
R8 vs Bendigo: 3. Tivendale 2. Polak
R9 vs Werribee: 3. Cartledge 2. Riewoldt 1. Oakley-Nicholls
R10 vs Tassie: 1. Carnell
R11 vs Casey:
R12 vs stuff'n:
R13 vs Box Hill: 3. F.Caruso 2. Silvester 1. Tivendale
R14 vs Port Mel:
R15 vs W'town: 3. Tivendale 2. Jackson
R16 vs Nth Ball: 1. Cartledge
R17 vs Bullants: 3. Hyde 2. Howat
R18 vs Sandy: 3. F.Caruso 1. Tivendale
R19 vs Casey: 3. Collard
R20 vs Bendigo: 3. Hughes 2. Howat 1. F.Caruso
Tivendale 14
F.Caruso 8
Cartledge 5
Hughes 5
Silvester 5
Carnell 4
Howat 4
Collard 3
Cotchin 3
Hyde 3
Jackson 3
White 3
N.Caruso 2
Polak 2
Morton 2
Riewoldt 2
Bowden 1
Oakley-Nicholls 1
Shelton 1
-
LMAO@ That shitman, Bowden,only getting one vote at VFL level and Tivendale tearing it up.
HTF anyone can say he is a champion is beyond me.
Lazy,politically correct suck with an inflated opinion of himself.
Go on - Let me hear how wrong i am and why.......... :sleep
-
Joel only played 4 VFL games (Rds 3-6) and Coburg lost two of them Ox ;)
Umps don't always get it right either. Geoff Raines didn't get a vote in the 1980 Brownlow count. Tivs who kicked 6 goals in round 20 against Sandy only got 1 vote ???. If Tivs got the 3 he would've shared last night's Liston with Podsiadly.
-
lol - 4 games and lost twor for one vote as a senior player:lol
U gotta wonder HTF he got back in :shh :-* :thumbsup
-
Tiv was very stiff, should have got 3 votes in that game when he kicked 6 from the midfield.
Load of crap.
Glen Carrick from the Coburg reserves took out the B&F for the Reserves section which was a great effort considering he played 11 games in the Ressies and 9 games in the Seniors.
-
Playing a farewell AFL game and missing the last Bendigo game as a result probably cost Tivs the Liston too.
Fort Caruso got plenty of votes for someone who seemed to be in and out of the VFL seniors all year.
Drafted by Essendon as a 17yo in 1999, so he'd be 26. (Can't find his DOB).
Rookied by Collingwood at the end of 2002.
Shame he's too old for us although if I was the Bulldogs and in desperate need of a big key forward target I would seriously consider it.
-
Tiv was very stiff, should have got 3 votes in that game when he kicked 6 from the midfield.
That would be the Sandy game in round 18.
6 goals, close to 40 touches and 1 vote ... Ok then :wallywink
-
SEN's VFL segment just said Coburg wouldn't be able to afford to keep Tivs now he's off an AFL list unless they packaged in some assistant coaching role for him at Richmond.
-
SEN's VFL segment just said Coburg wouldn't be able to afford to keep Tivs now he's off an AFL list unless they packaged in some assistant coaching role for him at Richmond.
I think you are onto something there MT :shh