J.J. Liston Trophy - Good Luck Tivs

[one-eyed]

Just a reminder that the JJ Liston Trophy is being held tonight at Moonee Valley Racing Club at 7.00pm.

All the best to Tivs who will be a big show to win it  .

[Hellenic Tiger]

Any news in on how Tivs went?

[cub]

Podsiadly from Werribee won

16 Votes - James Podsiadly
15 Votes - Peter Summers
15 Votes - Brett Johnson
14 Votes - Paul Kennedy

[Hellenic Tiger]

Thanks CUB. 
Would have been nice for Tivs but alas.

[mightytiges]

Txt message from bg25;

Tivs came equal 3rd on 14 votes tied with 3 others.

[mightytiges]

Podsiadly from Werribee won

Shame he can't be picked up as a mature rookie as IIRC he was on an AFL list as a youngster. We tried a couple of years ago. He tore Casey apart on the weekend.

[one-eyed]

Silvester and Horne made the VFL team of the year according to the vflfooty site

B: Horne Silvester Biddlecomb
HB: Picken Baird Goodes
C: Stretton B Johnson Roach
HF: Kennedy Pods Mariglianni
F: Barlow Sautner Nahas
R: Stevennson Pinwll Summers
INT: Byrne Wall Kenna Iacobucci

http://www.vflfooty.com/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=3320&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0

[Fishfinger]

Podsiadly from Werribee won

Shame he can't be picked up as a mature rookie as IIRC he was on an AFL list as a youngster. We tried a couple of years ago. He tore Casey apart on the weekend.

The rule was changed, probably as a direct result of that.
We couldn't take him as a mature age rookie because he had been on the Essendon and Collingwood lists, even though he had not played a senior game for either.

Tristan Cartledge was mature age rookied this year even though he he had been on the Essendon list and played 7 games for them.

Pods is getting on a bit. Still might be worth a look, if he's interested.

[Infamy]

Tristan Cartledge was mature age rookied this year even though he he had been on the Essendon list and played 7 games for them.

Don't think so, I think you'll find he fit in under the normal rookie rules, which is why he's ineligible next year

[Fishfinger]

Woops, he does too. He's not eligible to be mature age rookied because he's played senior games.

Pods is eligible because he hasn't played a senior game, which (unfairly) wasn't the case a few years back.

[mightytiges]

Cheers for that FF. How old is Podsiadly?

[Fishfinger]

Drafted by Essendon as a 17yo in 1999, so he'd be 26. (Can't find his DOB).

Rookied by Collingwood at the end of 2002.

[one-eyed]

Courtesy of an email from CaseyRadio on vflfooty  


R1 vs Geelong:    3. White         2. Morton       1. Cartledge
R2 vs Bullants:    3. Silvester                          1. Shelton
R3 vs Nth Ball:                         2. Hughes
R4 vs Port Mel:                                               1. Jackson
R5 vs Box Hill:    3. Tivendale                          1. Bowden
R6 vs C'wood:     3. Cotchin      2. N.Caruso      1. Tivendale
R7 vs Geelong:    3. Carnell       2. Tivendale     1. F.Caruso
R8 vs Bendigo:    3. Tivendale   2. Polak
R9 vs Werribee:   3. Cartledge   2. Riewoldt      1. Oakley-Nicholls
R10 vs Tassie:                                                1. Carnell
R11 vs Casey:
R12 vs Frank'n:
R13 vs Box Hill:   3. F.Caruso    2. Silvester      1. Tivendale
R14 vs Port Mel:
R15 vs W'town:   3. Tivendale   2. Jackson
R16 vs Nth Ball:                                             1. Cartledge
R17 vs Bullants:  3. Hyde          2. Howat
R18 vs Sandy:     3. F.Caruso                          1. Tivendale
R19 vs Casey:     3. Collard
R20 vs Bendigo:  3. Hughes      2. Howat         1. F.Caruso


Tivendale        14
F.Caruso           8
Cartledge          5
Hughes             5
Silvester           5
Carnell              4
Howat               4
Collard              3
Cotchin             3
Hyde                 3
Jackson             3
White                3
N.Caruso           2
Polak                 2
Morton              2
Riewoldt            2
Bowden             1
Oakley-Nicholls  1
Shelton             1

[Ox]

LMAO@ That shitman, Bowden,only getting one vote at VFL level and Tivendale tearing it up.

HTF anyone can say he is a champion is beyond me.

Lazy,politically correct suck with an inflated opinion of himself.

Go on - Let me hear how wrong i am and why..........

[mightytiges]

Joel only played 4 VFL games (Rds 3-6) and Coburg lost two of them Ox

Umps don't always get it right either. Geoff Raines didn't get a vote in the 1980 Brownlow count. Tivs who kicked 6 goals in round 20 against Sandy only got 1 vote  ???. If Tivs got the 3 he would've shared last night's Liston with Podsiadly.