One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on October 07, 2008, 01:05:48 AM
-
Richmond has placed Kayne Pettifer, Dean Polo, Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls and Danny Meyer on the trade table.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/hawthorn-to-meet-swan-okeefe/2008/10/06/1223145262706.html
-
I don't see the point trading Meyer.
former 1st rounder, can kick, was in coburgs best @ end of season - looks fit and in form, finally.
better small defender option than King or Raines.
-
Well Well Well who would have thought?????
Meyer, Petts, JON on the trade table.
Well strike me pink i am in total shock because all 3 have shown so much.
I will be glad to see the back of all 3 of these pathetic footballers, especially the last 2. Its a disgrace we held onto them for so long.
Petts should have been gone 2 years ago but not at the RFC, we keep till they are worthless.
Polo is a keeper IMO but the rest can shu the door on the way out
-
Richmond has placed Kayne Pettifer, Dean Polo, Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls and Danny Meyer on the trade table.
http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/hawthorn-to-meet-swan-okeefe/2008/10/06/1223145262706.html
That's it ???
-
Petts might get us a 3rd or 4th rounder.
-
Well Well Well who would have thought?????
Meyer, Petts, JON on the trade table.
Well strike me pink i am in total shock because all 3 have shown so much.
I will be glad to see the back of all 3 of these pathetic footballers, especially the last 2. Its a disgrace we held onto them for so long.
Petts should have been gone 2 years ago but not at the RFC, we keep till they are worthless.
Polo is a keeper IMO but the rest can shu the door on the way out
Held on to both for so long? Meyer has been on the list for 4 years, 2-3 of those were injured
JON only been on the list for 3 years and he's only 20 YEARS OLD!!!
Unbelievable
Polo is hardly a keeper either, it's bizarre how some average players like Polo get such an easy ride from the supporters for doing not much at all, where others like Hughes cop it for not doing enough as a key forward in less time that Polo's been on the list. If Polo going can fix some of the structure of the list, make it happen.
-
Looks like we aren't really interested in too much trade involvement. Throwing those 4 names down on the table will do nothing to create interest in any other club.
-
Greg Denham on KB's show this morning:
* Carlton's list is better managed than Richmond's. That's why they have plenty of salary cap space and Richmond has got a new list manager. The Richmond board has also put heavy spending constraints on the football department irrespective of how much salary cap space they may or may not have.
* Meyer from what he's seen is not up to it.
* Schulz up for trade too.
* KB said why would you go after Seaby if McIntosh is on the market? Denham said McIntosh is miles better than Seaby.
-
Greg Denham on KB's show this morning:
* Carlton's list is better managed than Richmond's. That's why they have plenty of salary cap space and Richmond has got a new list manager. The Richmond board has also put heavy spending constraints on the football department irrespective of how much salary cap space they may or may not have.
* Meyer from what he's seen is not up to it.
* Schulz up for trade too.
* KB said why would you go after Seaby if McIntosh is on the market? Denham said McIntosh is miles better than Seaby.
Is Denham a Carlton supporter?
Of course Carlton has plenty of cap space. 7 years of spoons and priority picks. No-one on their list would deserve anymore than 25k a year.
-
Greg Denham on KB's show this morning:
* Carlton's list is better managed than Richmond's. That's why they have plenty of salary cap space and Richmond has got a new list manager. The Richmond board has also put heavy spending constraints on the football department irrespective of how much salary cap space they may or may not have.
* Meyer from what he's seen is not up to it.
* Schulz up for trade too.
* KB said why would you go after Seaby if McIntosh is on the market? Denham said McIntosh is miles better than Seaby.
Is Denham a Carlton supporter?
Of course Carlton has plenty of cap space. 7 years of spoons and priority picks. No-one on their list would deserve anymore than 25k a year.
That's abit rough.
Ackland is clearly worth 900k over 3 years.
-
Polo is hardly a keeper either, it's bizarre how some average players like Polo get such an easy ride from the supporters for doing not much at all, where others like Hughes cop it for not doing enough as a key forward in less time that Polo's been on the list. If Polo going can fix some of the structure of the list, make it happen.
I don't know about Polo getting an easy ride from supporters but I don't think he was given much of a chance this season just gone. I also think he is above being an "average player".
Polo like Meyer has only been on the list 4 years and he missed most of last year after a shoulder reco.
It would seem he has some currency...
My arguement is I think there are others on our list (with currency) who should on the table too and going by what the media is suggesting are not
-
Greg Denham on KB's show this morning:
* Meyer from what he's seen is not up to it.
From what he's seen. :D I'm guessing that would be stuff-all.
-
Polo is the only one of the 4 with some trade value. Petts doing his knee at his age would turn clubs off and JON and Meyer would have zilch value.
Greg Denham on KB's show this morning:
* Meyer from what he's seen is not up to it.
From what he's seen. :D I'm guessing that would be stuff-all.
Denham has been the minister of misinformation for years. You would think a so-called footy expert would at least know and acknowledge Meyer suffered from a chronic hip complaint.
-
Well Well Well who would have thought?????
Polo is a keeper IMO but the rest can shu the door on the way out
he wont stay, TW clearly is not a fan, many have gone past him , the most recent whako Jacko...he's no chance of staying, I only hope we can muster interest as we may give him away at this rate with R3 looking very best we can do
-
i rkn that jacko has shown enough to stay at tigerland, he avg 20 disp in his last 6 games ;)
we shoud keep, hes still pretty young right???
-
i rkn that jacko has shown enough to stay at tigerland, he avg 20 disp in his last 6 games ;)
we shoud keep, hes still pretty young right???
he'll definately be kept, he's now ahead of Polo in the selectors eyes...Polo is too lean and for a skinny guy he aint quick
-
Polo in my opinion should still be a required player.
Jacko needs to have more awareness at times.
-
Polo in my opinion should still be a required player.
Jacko needs to have more awareness at times.
Keep 'em both
-
Meyer is supposedly going to Port Adelaide now .... anyone have an update on the whole Thomson situation.
-
Meyer is supposedly going to Port Adelaide now .... anyone have an update on the whole Thomson situation.
That'd be really disappointing, getting rid of a very good kick for someone who is a suspect kick
-
Meyer is supposedly going to Port Adelaide now .... anyone have an update on the whole Thomson situation.
That'd be really disappointing, getting rid of a very good kick for someone who is a suspect kick
I dont like Meyer as a Footballer, i never had but this is a valid point.
We have never had strong kicks in our team but if there is a small chance Danny might come good we should keep him.
Wouldn't surprise me if we see another Rodan type trade where Danny comes good.
He has done nothing to suggest this but he is a GOOD kick and that is crucial
-
Meyer is supposedly going to Port Adelaide now .... anyone have an update on the whole Thomson situation.
That'd be really disappointing, getting rid of a very good kick for someone who is a suspect kick
Trade has added no value to the playing list in my opinion and has taken away our pick 42 in a deep draft.
-
Yep dejavu Infamy I was thinking the exact same thing much in the way many lamented in 2007 when Rodan was starring at Port and we were diabolical and stone motherless last. If Meyer has good foot skills keep him why trade for a bloke who is similar in stature yet has inferior skills to what you are giving away. Just seems illogical and senseless to me.