One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on November 18, 2009, 03:34:34 PM
-
SEN says Cogs, JON, Petts and Patto have nominated for the draft.
Some of the others (not the full list):
Luke Ablett
Luke Ball
Jordan Bannister
Bentick
Simon Buckley
Cameron Cloke
Leigh Fisher
Daniel Harris
Rhan Hooper
Kane Tenace
-
Some wishful thinking by most named on that list especially by the ex-Tigers.
With Hooper nominating for the National draft and not training with us this week perhaps we have told him we're not interested.
-
With Hooper nominating for the National draft and not training with us this week perhaps we have told him we're not interested.
If he was as fat and unfit as many noted then I hope we have said no - he mustn't have learned too much from his delisting.
-
Putt has nominated as well. Here's the full list from the AFL site.
No draft nomination for ex-Lion
By Mic Cullen | Wed 18 November, 2009
THE FULL list of discarded players who have nominated for the next week's 2009 NAB AFL Draft has been released and former Lions defender Joel Macdonald's name isn't on it.
The omission heightens speculation that Macdonald has agreed to a deal that will see him picked up in the pre-season draft, possibly by Melbourne which has the first pick.
Graham Polak's name is also missing from the list as he is hoping to be taken by Richmond in December's rookie draft.
Also appearing on the list are Carlton's Cameron Cloke, Melbourne's Russell Robertson, North Melbourne's Jesse Smith, the Lion Rhan Hooper and Hawthorn's Mitch Thorp.
Smith (Hawthorn), Hooper (Richmond) and Thorp (Melbourne) have joined those clubs for pre-season training in the hope of being re-drafted.
Delisted players who have nominated for the 2009 NAB AFL Draft:
Luke Ablett (Sydney Swans), Jarryd Allen (St Kilda),
Luke Ball (St Kilda), Jordan Bannister (Carlton), Adam Bentick (Carlton), Ryan Brabazon (Sydney Swans), Simon Buckley (Melbourne),
Chris Bryan (Collingwood), Adam Campbell (Fremantle), Cameron Cloke (Carlton), Scott Clouston (Brisbane Lions), Eljay Connors (St Kilda), Mark Coughlan (Richmond),
Jake Edwards (Carlton),
Leigh Fisher (St Kilda), Andrew Foster (Fremantle),
Greg Gallman (Adelaide), Jonathan Giles (Port Adelaide), Nick Gill (Adelaide),
Scott Harding (Brisbane Lions), Daniel Harris (North Melbourne), Rhan Hooper (Brisbane Lions),
Aaron Kite (Adelaide),
Matthew Laidlaw (Sydney Swans), Nick Lower (Port Adelaide), Malcolm Lynch (Western Bulldogs),
Dan McKenna (Geelong Cats), Jamie McNamara (West Coast), Matt Maguire (St Kilda), John Meesen (Melbourne),
Michael Newton (Melbourne),
Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls (Richmond), Daniel O'Keefe (Sydney Swans), Guy O'Keefe (Western Bulldogs), Paul O'Shea (Western Bulldogs),
Adam Pattison (Richmond), Kayne Pettifer (Richmond), Sam Power (North Melbourne), Dean Putt (Richmond),
Matt Riggio (North Melbourne), Russell Robertson (Melbourne), Jason Roe (Brisbane Lions),
Scott Simpson (Geelong Cats), Wayde Skipper (Western Bulldogs), Jesse Smith (North Melbourne), Danny Stanley (Collingwood),
Kane Tenace (Geelong Cats), Mitchell Thorp (Hawthorn), Matthew Tyler (Brisbane Lions),
Cameron Wight (Western Bulldogs), John Williams (Essendon), Michael Wundke (North Melbourne)
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/87261/default.aspx
-
With Hooper nominating for the National draft and not training with us this week perhaps we have told him we're not interested.
If he was as fat and unfit as many noted then I hope we have said no - he mustn't have learned too much from his delisting.
Hooper wasn't at training today although the AFL site still has him on our permission to train list.
There's not much to choose from looking at all those names. From a PSD point of view there's no one on that list that makes you say get him :-\. If Melbourne take Joel MacDonald then we have the first live pick.
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
He's not on the list WAT but I would take MacDonald, none of the others would work for us.
-
A little whisper is that Melbourne may take Kane Tenace with first pick.
-
Any other players still in contract limbo who may go PSD?
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
He's not on the list WAT but I would take MacDonald, none of the others would work for us.
He is on today's list on the AFL website and he has been linked to the Hawks, they have a reputation of picking up overweight players and winning premierships with them!!
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Mail around that Hooper is a "bad egg"" .
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Mail around that Hooper is a "bad egg"" .
Jesse Smith - crock
Matt Maguire - crock
Michael Newton - not good enough for the side that finished lower than us on the ladder
Luke Ball - Maybe, but not with a first or second round pick, after which time he will be gone.
WAT the answer to your question is probably no-one. Some may be drafted and give good service to their new club, but except for ball and his leadership I cant see any of those bringing anything to the club that we cant get from a untried kid.
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Mail around that Hooper is a "bad egg"" .
Jesse Smith - crock
Matt Maguire - crock
Michael Newton - not good enough for the side that finished lower than us on the ladder
Luke Ball - Maybe, but not with a first or second round pick, after which time he will be gone.
WAT the answer to your question is probably no-one. Some may be drafted and give good service to their new club, but except for ball and his leadership I cant see any of those bringing anything to the club that we cant get from a untried kid.
Jesse Smith will get picked, actually all 4 will
-
Maybe Hooper was in the gym on the treadmill, other than him who the hell would we even bother with out of that lot???????????
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Mail around that Hooper is a "bad egg"" .
Jesse Smith - crock
Matt Maguire - crock
Michael Newton - not good enough for the side that finished lower than us on the ladder
Luke Ball - Maybe, but not with a first or second round pick, after which time he will be gone.
WAT the answer to your question is probably no-one. Some may be drafted and give good service to their new club, but except for ball and his leadership I cant see any of those bringing anything to the club that we cant get from a untried kid.
Jesse Smith will get picked, actually all 4 will
Doesn't mean that they will be any bloody good though.
;)
-
one thing for certain, none of the Richmond players delisted will get picked up
-
one thing for certain, none of the Richmond players delisted will get picked up
Isn't Patto a chance as a backup ruckman?
:thumbsup
-
one thing for certain, none of the Richmond players delisted will get picked up
Isn't Patto a chance as a backup ruckman?
:thumbsup
Where at ? Balwyn ?
-
one thing for certain, none of the Richmond players delisted will get picked up
Isn't Patto a chance as a backup ruckman?
:thumbsup
Where at ? Balwyn ?
Hilarious!!
-
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Smith has the talent but can he ever get on the park. The only one you would look at of the four.
Maguire like Browny is finished. Both careers stuffed by a badly broken leg.
Newton - meh!
Ball - not as far gone as Cogs was but Ball is too slow nowdays.
-
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Smith has the talent but can he ever get on the park. The only one you would look at of the four.
Maguire like Browny is finished. Both careers stuffed by a badly broken leg.
Newton - meh!
Ball - not as far gone as Cogs was but Ball is too slow nowdays.
I reckon big "juice' Newton can play.
Got great hands.
Reckon he gave our backs grief in a game not so long ago.
-
Well lets see.
Jesse Smith
Matt Maguire
Michael Newton
Luke Ball.
All four could fit into Punt Road
Smith has the talent but can he ever get on the park. The only one you would look at of the four.
Maguire like Browny is finished. Both careers stuffed by a badly broken leg.
Newton - meh!
Ball - not as far gone as Cogs was but Ball is too slow nowdays.
I reckon big "juice' Newton can play.
Got great hands.
Reckon he gave our backs grief in a game not so long ago.
Newton vs Richmond
R4 2009: 10k, 2h, 6m, 2.4
R18 2009: 12k, 6h, 6m, 1.0
He hardly owned us with those stats lol although playing well against Richmond in 2009 is hardly a recommendation anyway to be redrafted :nope. He only kicked 3 goals once as a forward. DUD!