One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on May 15, 2011, 05:16:28 PM
-
Frustrating loss. Edwards will miss if he has a fractured cheekbone. Any other changes?
Fire away....
-
Won't happen but I'd love to see Browne get rewarded for his good VFL form. Webberley in for Edwards
-
Won't happen but I'd love to see Browne get rewarded for his good VFL form. Webberley in for Edwards
Agree Webberley is a given. Today makes it just so much more confusing to me, as to what the match committee sees in Graham. Browne has very good exposed form and can't get a crack. What am I missing?
-
Won't happen but I'd love to see Browne get rewarded for his good VFL form. Webberley in for Edwards
Agree Webberley is a given. Today makes it just so much more confusing to me, as to what the match committee sees in Graham. Browne has very good exposed form and can't get a crack. What am I missing?
I don't think Browne is the answer. I truly hope he proves me wrong but at this stage in his career he's way way way off AFL level. That said I don't think anyone couldve been worse than Graham was today.
-
Graham out- and i will have a go at it. :lol
-
lost a bit of pace with white out and edwards subbed early.
Id guess white back in for titch.
If graham got a rest i wouldn't be surprised, but i doubt he'll be dropped to coburg.
-
our problem is our key defenders
-
Bombers play three really big guys, maybe we should too. We had no one to play on Minson and Hille is a much better player
-
Cant see Rance getting a game next week
-
Cant see Rance getting a game next week
Who d'ya think can come in for him, Jack? Has Astbury been getting much of it in the twos? Moore isn't ready and Thursty has been injured.
-
Cant see Rance getting a game next week
Who d'ya think can come in for him, Jack? Has Astbury been getting much of it in the twos? Moore isn't ready and Thursty has been injured.
Reason being he aint tall enough
The 39,000 that went today would have seen that
-
outs: nason, Gus, Edwards.
Ins: open to discussion.
-
Outs: Graham, Edwards, Nason (they can't keep playing him as the sub)
Ins: Browne, Webberley, Tuck (if fit)
-
White in ?
-
Out: Graham, Nason, Edwards
In: Post, Morton, Webberley
If I have to sit through anymore games with Angus Graham trespass on an AFL Ground I'll spew up. Ben Hudson was an inspiration yesterday. I'm sick of getting absolutely smashed in the ruck, effing sick of it, it's called a 2nd effort and work rate. :banghead
We will get absolutely destroyed by Hille, Bellchambers or Ryder who ever they decide to put in the ruck. Essendon have 3 ruckman on their list better than our 1st. Infuriating to watch. It seems we have no other option, which infuriates me even more.
-
Out: Graham, Nason, Edwards
In: Post, Morton, Webberley
If I have to sit through anymore games with Angus Graham trespass on an AFL Ground I'll spew up. Ben Hudson was an inspiration yesterday. I'm sick of getting absolutely smashed in the ruck, effing sick of it, it's called a 2nd effort and work rate. :banghead
We will get absolutely destroyed by Hille, Bellchambers or Ryder who ever they decide to put in the ruck. Essendon have 3 ruckman on their list better than our 1st. Infuriating to watch. It seems we have no other option, which infuriates me even more.
morton r u serious, he has shown nothing
-
Nason too small, can't have Helbig, Nason, King and Nahas in the same side. Not against Essendon.
Nason needs a full game in the 2's.
Hoping White is fit to take his spot back actually. Forgot about White.
-
if fit hell be in
-
Rance is no chance to get dropped. He is playing probably a 3rd or 4th defender who is playing as our #1 or 2 defender.
I think he is going ok.
-
White in ?
Yes if he is fit but I don't think he'll come up
-
Out: Graham, Nason, Edwards
In: Post, Morton, Webberley
If I have to sit through anymore games with Angus Graham trespass on an AFL Ground I'll spew up. Ben Hudson was an inspiration yesterday. I'm sick of getting absolutely smashed in the ruck, effing sick of it, it's called a 2nd effort and work rate. :banghead
We will get absolutely destroyed by Hille, Bellchambers or Ryder who ever they decide to put in the ruck. Essendon have 3 ruckman on their list better than our 1st. Infuriating to watch. It seems we have no other option, which infuriates me even more.
you are stupid, droping a ruckman & not replacing Graham with a ruckman just goes to show your a stuffin idiot lol
-
2 very hard games has taken a toll on the playing group. freshen them up
-
Have merged these topics
Popelord there was already a thread about changes for next week, don't think we need 2 :thumbsup
-
Have merged these topics
Popelord there was already a thread about changes for next week, don't think we need 2 :thumbsup
;D
-
maybe we should go into next weeks game with fit players naming 5
-
Rance is no chance to get dropped. He is playing probably a 3rd or 4th defender who is playing as our #1 or 2 defender.
I think he is going ok.
He is going terrible.
Has had 8 goals kicked against him last 2 weeks by ordinary players -Keppler Bradley and Will Minson
His game was error riddled today
-
Out: Graham, Nason, Edwards
In: Post, Morton, Webberley
If I have to sit through anymore games with Angus Graham trespass on an AFL Ground I'll spew up. Ben Hudson was an inspiration yesterday. I'm sick of getting absolutely smashed in the ruck, effing sick of it, it's called a 2nd effort and work rate. :banghead
We will get absolutely destroyed by Hille, Bellchambers or Ryder who ever they decide to put in the ruck. Essendon have 3 ruckman on their list better than our 1st. Infuriating to watch. It seems we have no other option, which infuriates me even more.
you are stupid, droping a ruckman & not replacing Graham with a ruckman just goes to show your a effin idiot lol
His name is Tyronne Vickery and you can share the load with Post.
Have another coffee
-
maybe we should go into next weeks game with fit players naming 5
That's a great idea, thanks for sharing and wasting everyones time.
-
Have merged these topics
Popelord there was already a thread about changes for next week, don't think we need 2 :thumbsup
Thanks WP, didn't see it
-
Definite outs for me at this stage:
Nason (omitted)
Edwards (fractured cheekbone)
White in ?
Yes if he is fit but I don't think he'll come up
It was only concussion wasn't it? He should be right this week. What makes you think he wont get up WP?
-
White has a shoulder
-
Thought they said there was no damage to it? ???
-
Definite outs for me at this stage:
Nason (omitted)
Edwards (fractured cheekbone)
White in ?
Yes if he is fit but I don't think he'll come up
It was only concussion wasn't it? He should be right this week. What makes you think he wont get up WP?
As Jack's mentioned White has a shoulder injury and although I am not sure how bad it is but I reckon you are better to take the cautious approach with them
-
And BTW stick to the topic without the petty sniping
-
I'm not sure that personnel changes will help as much as a major attitude change will.
I'll be looking for;
- Defensive pressure in the forward 50. This was nonexistent v the Dogs.
- Defensive pressure from our midfield, thru the corridor and getting back to help the defenders. The criticism of our defenders has been harsh and not unwarranted, but the lack of pressure on the Doggies ball carrier and the resulting quality of delivery had a lot to do with it.
- A ruckman who watches the ball at centre bounces and taps the ball to our advantage occasionally.
- Better setups at stoppages in the defensive 50. Didn't see the stats on Bullies scores from stoppages, but I'm thinking it wasn't good for us.
- Better setups in the F50 - it was too easy to double team Jack with too much crowding in the forward line.
That'll do for a start.
-
I'll be looking for;
- A ruckman who watches the ball at centre bounces and taps the ball to our advantage occasionally.
Muscles you'll be disappointed unless Browne plays.
-
Muscles you'll be disappointed unless Browne plays.
I've been thinking about the Gus/Browne thing and I've been wondering if Browne has the fitness to ruck with only TV to back him up? Would a Browne/Post combination be too top heavy against the Bumblers?
-
Watson is out injured for our match, plus the next 2. :thumbsup
-
White has a shoulder
He has two shoulders, one left, one right - :rollin - and he uses both to good effect on the footy field.
If he plays against the Bummers, just watch him laugh when one of them tests either shoulder and watch them cry when he barrells them with either shoulder too.
I wouldn't believe everything you read in the press mate. :shh
Richmond said "GENERAL SORENESS" - why would a journalist write SHOULDER? Maybe the typesetter didn't have room for two words.
If you have worked at a footy club then you would know all about - DUCKS and DRAKES.
-
Watson out for the Bumbers.
-
White has a shoulder
He has two shoulders, one left, one right - :rollin - and he uses both to good effect on the footy field.
If he plays against the Bummers, just watch him laugh when one of them tests either shoulder and watch them cry when he barrells them with either shoulder too.
I wouldn't believe everything you read in the press mate. :shh
Richmond said "GENERAL SORENESS" - why would a journalist write SHOULDER? Maybe the typesetter didn't have room for two words.
If you have worked at a footy club then you would know all about - DUCKS and DRAKES.
Seen him at the shell garage on the weekend, should be right to go this week
-
Seen him at the shell garage on the weekend, should be right to go this week
[/quote]
How's his shoulder? Which one is it again? :rollin
-
Heath Hocking is out for the Bombers. Suspended for 3 weeks ...
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/114009/default.aspx
-
Out : Edwards
In: Webberley or Tuck if available. Gourdis played well for Coburg maybe in the mix if selectors angry at Rance.
-
I wouldn't believe everything you read in the press mate. :shh
Richmond said "GENERAL SORENESS" - why would a journalist write SHOULDER? Maybe the typesetter didn't have room for two words.
And I pay very little attention to what the Club injury list says only because they have a tendency not give a full list of who's injured let alone what the problem is....O'Reilly, Jakobi, Thursfield Connors weren't listed for weeks want me to go on ;D
-
White has a shoulder
last i saw he had 2 shoulders
-
watson, hocking, watson -> out
:gotigers
????
-
white has two shoulders and essendon have two watsons? timmy going in for a prostate check? might find some missing bombers supporters that went AHOL last year.
-
Hurley, Watson, hocking out
-
They said tonight Essendon are going to challenge the Hocking 3-week suspension :stupid.
-
Anyone know how Derickx is going. From what i remember he can also play back and would be one of the few we have that could throw some weight around down there, leaving (shudder) Gus in the ruck Ty up forward. 3 talls, then Gus could concentrate purely on the centre of the ground.
-
Seen him at the shell garage on the weekend, should be right to go this week
How's his shoulder? Which one is it again? :rollin
[/quote]
well you should know, your his mate.
::)
-
RICHMOND - In the Mix
Matt White (shoulder) and Shane Edwards (facial fracture) were both injured in the loss to the Western Bulldogs. White must pass a fitness test to retain his place in the team while Edwards' prognosis is still to be determined. Shane Tuck (ribs) will also face a fitness test as he pushes for selection in the team to take on Essendon on Saturday night. Jeromey Webberley was named in the best players for Coburg in the VFL and looms as a replacement for White or Edwards.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/114061/default.aspx
-
who writes this poo?
White injured against the dogs? To retain his place? Webberly to replace him?
moron :wallywink
-
Hocking has accepted the 3 weeks so it's confirmed he's out along with Watson with his hammy.
-
Hocking has accepted the 3 weeks so it's confirmed he's out along with Watson with his hammy.
hurley extremely doubtful as well
-
Hocking has accepted the 3 weeks so it's confirmed he's out along with Watson with his hammy.
hurley extremely doubtful as well
I read that he's already ruled out.
-
Dogs had multiple quality players out last week too so I'm not pinning too much hope of this news but I guess has to be positive for us
-
Dogs had multiple quality players out last week too so I'm not pinning too much hope of this news but I guess has to be positive for us
without Watson/hocking what is the essendon midfield?
Stanon, Heppel, howlett, mcveigh, Lonergan?
We should beat these f*cks
-
Dogs had multiple quality players out last week too so I'm not pinning too much hope of this news but I guess has to be positive for us
without Watson/hocking what is the essendon midfield?
Stanon, Heppel, howlett, mcveigh, Lonergan?
We should beat these f*cks
i was saying the same thing last week - no Hall, no higgins, no Johnson, no aker who will kick their goals? bloody wil hack minson and lindsay bloody gilbee thats who. They'll miss them but will work through it, confident sides can cover short term losses in personel
-
Who's our defensive coach? Trade him in for someone who can teach basic defensive fundamentals like punching ball on goal line, standing defensive side at stoppage, marking ball when NOT under any pressure, punching ball when opponent is trying to mark etc.
-
i was saying the same thing last week - no Hall, no higgins, no Johnson, no aker who will kick their goals? bloody wil hack minson and lindsay bloody gilbee thats who. They'll miss them but will work through it, confident sides can cover short term losses in personel
I already feel ill at the prospect of someone like that emo wanker Reimers kicking a bag against us.
-
Out - Edwards Nason
In - 2 of these Tuck Hislop White
-
Out - Edwards Nason
In - 2 of these Tuck Hislop White
hislop???? Are u serious?? We will be going backwards if he plays again.
-
Out - Edwards Nason
In - 2 of these Tuck Hislop White
Agree, but I'd add Webberley to the potential ins as well, he must be close
Has Tuck missed too much footy to come straight back in? not sure
-
I don;t believe Hislop has a future at the club. Believe Webberley should be rewarded for his efforts at coburg
-
Yep your right Webberly does deserve a go and maybe in front of Hislop.
I would like to just see him one more time against his old team 'last chance saloon' so to say.
-
Gus Graham dropped :thumbsup
-
With Moore on the LTIL and Hislop named in the bests two weeks in a row I wouldn't be surprised if he is elevated soon to see if he can push for a new contract. Just needs to keep up the Coburg form.