One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: tigtuff12 on November 01, 2011, 11:48:57 AM
-
with the end of year delistings now announced from all clubs, just wondering if anyone sees any value there for PSD/rookie picks?
full breakdown of delistings in the HUN:
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/departmentoftrade
any fit our age bracket and/or requirements?
-
I don't mind Ed Lower.
Paul Bevan has vanished would have had decent currency 3 years ago.
Wouldn't touch Wonemerri and idiot whilst talented is injury prone. Pies wouldn't have delisted him if they didn't think he had a future. No point.
Motlop, too old.
Setanta, no chance.
-
I got nothin'. As pope said, Bevan a couple of years ago for sure, but not now. 28 is too old for a hard at it backman.
JON gone again... :rollin
And a bad time for the Westhoff family.
-
Sentanta would be our best ruckman :lol
-
I reckon Setanta will get picked up somewhere
-
I reckon Setanta will get picked up somewhere
yeah GWS I reckon
-
yeah, perfect for giving the youngsters a bit of protection, has experience, gives him a year or two more in the game and it isn't like he cannot play at all, will never be a star but is serviceable and a bigger body. I suspect Sheeds is also keen to play up the Irish connection in Sydney too, there is a strong Irish heritage there, it is something he wouldn't let slide.
-
No to Motlop. Brad idiot is too injury prone. If wasn't so would nominate him. If anyone I would nominate Blake but having said that he is only a tap ruckman and struggles to get possessions. No player really stands out
-
What about Ladsen from Hawthorn?
27 yo start of next season, 181cm, 86kgs
For mine a couple years too old but as experienced player :huh
-
Hope Motlop gets picked up. Gets a bad wrap from muppets with NFI. Has worked his ass off over the last year and a half.
-
Hope Motlop gets picked up. Gets a bad wrap from muppets with NFI. Has worked his ass off over the last year and a half.
Which one?
-
Daniel. I dont want him here ;D just hope he gets another shot at it
-
Hope Motlop gets picked up. Gets a bad wrap from muppets with NFI. Has worked his ass off over the last year and a half.
:lol
-
I don't mind Ed Lower.
Paul Bevan has vanished would have had decent currency 3 years ago.
Wouldn't touch Wonemerri and idiot whilst talented is injury prone. Pies wouldn't have delisted him if they didn't think he had a future. No point.
Motlop, too old.
Setanta, no chance.
Wouldn't touch idiot although talented? Must be double jointed!
-
Just not much around this year I am afraid....better off leaving it or can we use the pick for something like a Podsiadly or old mate from Freo that did his knee..??
-
Hope Motlop gets picked up. Gets a bad wrap from muppets with NFI. Has worked his ass off over the last year and a half.
:lol
Shut up
-
Why are you so angry?
-
Why are you so angry?
It's your glasses! It's making me angry too >:( >:(
-
TOPIC....TOPIC..... :whistle :police:
-
Why are you so angry?
It's your glasses! It's making me angry too >:( >:(
Just showing a warm welcome to our newest ruckman.
-
okay i will throw a few names out there. both delistings and players from minor leagues.
fevola.
daniel farmer
joel houghton
tom lee
jordan jones
callum ilson
waylen manson
kyle horsley
nick carnell
david mirra
callum sinclair
willie wheeler
beau wilkes.
-
okay i will throw a few names out there. both delistings and players from minor leagues.
fevola.
daniel farmer
joel houghton
tom lee
jordan jones
callum ilson
waylen manson
kyle horsley
nick carnell
david mirra
callum sinclair
willie wheeler
beau wilkes.
What's the story with Daniel Farmer? He was only drafted last season and copped the arse already!! Grew up supporting the Tigers would love to know what went wrong?
-
okay i will throw a few names out there. both delistings and players from minor leagues.
fevola.
daniel farmer
joel houghton
tom lee
jordan jones
callum ilson
waylen manson
kyle horsley
nick carnell
david mirra
callum sinclair
willie wheeler
beau wilkes.
What's the story with Daniel Farmer? He was only drafted last season and copped the behind already!! Grew up supporting the Tigers would love to know what went wrong?
dunno most collingwood supporters ive spoken too dont vrte him.
personally i liked him a lot kids dont lose their talent over night.
i know we will only use picks 15 26 55 and perhaps a psd pick. personally id like to take horsley carnell and lee with late nd psd picks. that means we somehow delist another couple or delist one and move newman.
would like to rookie farmer mirra wheeler and houghton.
-
Willy wheeler played some good games for the burgs, anyone know why he was dropped?
-
Willy wheeler played some good games for the burgs, anyone know why he was dropped?
no idea but a fair few people ive spoken to cant work out why carnell is overloked every yr especially by us. most think he would be an upgrade on many of our players.
every time ive seen him play hes all the attributes to be a decent afl player.
-
All the players on our delisted list are better than Mcguane and if he gets a game next year ill shoot myself :banghead :banghead
What is happening with Mcaffer?
-
What is happening with Mcaffer?
He is staying at the Scum........For now ;)
-
Willy wheeler played some good games for the burgs, anyone know why he was dropped?
no idea but a fair few people ive spoken to cant work out why carnell is overloked every yr especially by us. most think he would be an upgrade on many of our players.
every time ive seen him play hes all the attributes to be a decent afl player.
Willy Wheeler hasn't been "dropped". I believe he is sigend for Coburg for 2012. He would just be on the list of players nominated for the draft
BTW Wheeler is tiny, people say we have enough midgets on our list. Willy Wheeler makes Shane Edwards look like Hercules
-
Hercules Poirot? How cool would that moustache be in a tigers jumper, dunno bout the gut though..
-
Willy wheeler played some good games for the burgs, anyone know why he was dropped?
no idea but a fair few people ive spoken to cant work out why carnell is overloked every yr especially by us. most think he would be an upgrade on many of our players.
every time ive seen him play hes all the attributes to be a decent afl player.
Agree Carnell had played well, come to think of it even the small fella who was kicking bags of 5 towards seasons end, could easily replace some of our senior players.. his name evades me now
-
Agree Carnell had played well, come to think of it even the small fella who was kicking bags of 5 towards seasons end, could easily replace some of our senior players.. his name evades me now
The small fella is Willy Wheeler E_E_A
-
...Carnell would be def worth a look - especially as a rookie spot...also claw, I've heard/red good things about Beau Wilkes - could be another worth a punt...
throwing up some other more "established" names, anyone see any value in a Ben Ross or Gavin Urqhart from North? Setanta too old (and not really all that good)? John McCarthy as a midfield addition/depth player? Joel Houghton was pick 36 & a fair sized forward that kicked some bags of goals as a junior, is only 20 - any upside? any of the Gold Coast delistings? is Ladson any value/too old?
any thoughts or any other blokes worth a look in?
-
Agree Carnell had played well, come to think of it even the small fella who was kicking bags of 5 towards seasons end, could easily replace some of our senior players.. his name evades me now
The small fella is Willy Wheeler E_E_A
I Remember now WP, it was Power. Little bloke had some BOG even when we had 8-10 RFC listed players running around for the burgs
-
Agree Carnell had played well, come to think of it even the small fella who was kicking bags of 5 towards seasons end, could easily replace some of our senior players.. his name evades me now
The small fella is Willy Wheeler E_E_A
I Remember now WP, it was Power. Little bloke had some BOG even when we had 8-10 RFC listed players running around for the burgs
Sam Power? Brother of Luke? Former AFL player de-listed by both Bulldogs & N0rt?
Would be massive pass for mine
-
Sorry WP what I was saying is that Carnell and Wheeler both played well in the burgs, But even Power showed more than some of our senior listed players. I would definetly not want him in our side but it was worth noting that he played better than our rfc listed players on more than one occasion.
-
...Carnell would be def worth a look - especially as a rookie spot...also claw, I've heard/red good things about Beau Wilkes - could be another worth a punt...
throwing up some other more "established" names, anyone see any value in a Ben Ross or Gavin Urqhart from North? Setanta too old (and not really all that good)? John McCarthy as a midfield addition/depth player? Joel Houghton was pick 36 & a fair sized forward that kicked some bags of goals as a junior, is only 20 - any upside? any of the Gold Coast delistings? is Ladson any value/too old?
any thoughts or any other blokes worth a look in?
to be honest i have always liked wilkes as a player had a very good yr at claremont and imo has psomething to offer.he would definately be sound insurance if rance went down. the one i really like from claremont is tom lee. a quick agile 20yo 195cm
kpp.
was cut from adelaide and came home. word was he was just too immature when drafted.
houghton was one i wanted us to draft in 09. i had him in a group of talls with astbury and shaw. he is a good mark lots of agility and a good motor for a big guy.he spent a bit of time as a mid as a junior and wasnt really looked upon as a kpp by most. dont know what went wrong at freo people i know from the club are a bit bemused by his axing. would not be surprised if they are not looking to now rookie him.
-
Would the Nth Lower be worth a look? His brother had a great year for Freeo. Worth having train to look if he can perform over the pre season.
-
I wouldn't want anyone from Coburg. They weren't a bottom 4 VFL side for nothing :P. Guys like Carnell and Wheeler wouldn't make it at AFL level. Too short and small to begin with. The SANFL is a stronger league than the VFL anyway so I would look there first.
Would the Nth Lower be worth a look? His brother had a great year for Freeo. Worth having train to look if he can perform over the pre season.
Pass.
Unless some semi-decent player with good skills has a falling out with his club and wants to leave (eg: Houli last year) then we should stick to building up our list via the draft. We've been down the path before of recruiting other clubs offcuts and all that shortcut does is get us to ninth and fills our list with more list cloggers :scream.
-
How about Farren Ray as an upgrade on Edwards?
Uncontracted, 25yrs, 146 games, 187cm, missed like 2 games in three years, 11 finals, avg.20 disp @ Saints
:chuck
-
How about Farren Ray as an upgrade on Edwards?
Uncontracted, 25yrs, 146 games, 187cm, missed like 2 games in three years, 11 finals, avg.20 disp @ Saints
:chuck
I reckon he'll stay at the Saints
but agree :chuck
;D
-
Would have Ray and give a nut up over Edwards in a heartbeat......Edwards... :scream
-
:chuck