One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 02, 2016, 03:13:02 AM
-
Fire away .... :-\
-
Outs :- duds.
Ins:- kids
-
But there aint nuffin in the cupboard
Lennon just comes in and plays forward
McBean for Krusty - Will never happen but :banghead
Why bother Footscary will obliterate us - Do I make the effort to go to this one is the ?
OUT - Me ?
-
Ins
Hammer , McBean , Rioli , Marcom
Outs
Maric, Vickery , Lambert , Broad
-
Ins
Hammer , McBean , Rioli , Marcom
Outs
Maric, Vickery , Lambert , Broad
I know Broad made some mistakes last night but it's to be expected with a kid in his second game. He also did some nice things too. Worth seeing a bit more of IMO. It's either him or Batch and I think we have all seen enough of Batch to know what he brings.
Lambert has been quite for a while and I agree he needs to go back.
Maric, put a stuff in him, he is done.
Vickery has been woefull, it's time to say goodbye.
-
as said above, i don't think it matters, Dogs by 10 Goals+
in - kids kids & more kids. give Broad the rest of the year to show us something, if we drop him who do we bring in? Batchelor?
-
I like Broad
But if there were moments that sunk a team last night
Nathan was involved in both
Too slow to get rid of ball
His kicking is suspect as well
-
I like Broad
But if there were moments that sunk a team last night
Nathan was involved in both
Too slow to get rid of ball
His kicking is suspect as well
You like Broad, why? What's he actually done that's likeable so far? Or is he just another good bloke?
-
Have watched him at VFL level and he reads the game well
Problem is huge transition from VFL to AFL
-
Have watched him at VFL level and he reads the game well
Problem is huge transition from VFL to AFL
just remember its hard to explain these things to people who have not played football :snidegrin
-
Have watched him at VFL level and he reads the game well
Problem is huge transition from VFL to AFL
Does read the game well and is damaging offensively at VFL level. However you can notice his deficiencies in 1 v 1 contests and by foot at VFL level and they only become more glaring with the step up to AFL.
-
Ins
Hammer , McBean , Rioli , Marcom
Outs
Maric, Vickery , Lambert , Broad
I know Broad made some mistakes last night but it's to be expected with a kid in his second game. He also did some nice things too. Worth seeing a bit more of IMO. It's either him or Batch and I think we have all seen enough of Batch to know what he brings.
Ive got to say BT I'm very surprised you in particular like Broad, looks a tad soft IMHO.
-
Ins
Hammer , McBean , Rioli , Marcom
Outs
Maric, Vickery , Lambert , Broad
I know Broad made some mistakes last night but it's to be expected with a kid in his second game. He also did some nice things too. Worth seeing a bit more of IMO. It's either him or Batch and I think we have all seen enough of Batch to know what he brings.
Ive got to say BT I'm very surprised you in particular like Broad, looks a tad soft IMHO.
l like Broad as well. has something to offer the side. We need new blood
-
Have watched him at VFL level and he reads the game well
Problem is huge transition from VFL to AFL
Does read the game well and is damaging offensively at VFL level. However you can notice his deficiencies in 1 v 1 contests and by foot at VFL level and they only become more glaring with the step up to AFL.
Correct
-
moar looob
-
As long as Vickery, Lambert, Ellis B,
Grt flicked
Who cares :'(
I don't
Dishonest footy club
Wasted season that if the club bothered to honrst about was shot after round 4
-
how can someone have deficiencies with their kicking yet be damaging offensively?
-
At least when the season is shot ,the silver lining is you get to see the youth coming through.
We have been denined this opportunity.
Every week is just a rearranging of deck chairs.
-
how can someone have deficiencies with their kicking yet be damaging offensively?
Ability to find football, space, run and carry etc. Plenty of blokes with shoddy foot skills who are damaging offensively (see Dangerfield)
-
Ins
Hammer , McBean , Rioli , Marcom
Outs
Maric, Vickery , Lambert , Broad
I know Broad made some mistakes last night but it's to be expected with a kid in his second game. He also did some nice things too. Worth seeing a bit more of IMO. It's either him or Batch and I think we have all seen enough of Batch to know what he brings.
Ive got to say BT I'm very surprised you in particular like Broad, looks a tad soft IMHO.
Nar, didn't say I liked him but think he needs more than two games of AFL footy to judge him on. Rance probably would have been flicked too if you went on his first few games.
I just don't want to see Batchelor ever again as I have seen enough to know he is well below AFL standard. Even more so Houli if they persist with him across HB.
-
The Barometer - Round 16
Herald-Sun
5 July 2016
RICHMOND
ON THE BLOCK: No fresh injuries from a disastrous loss to Port Adelaide but there are a lot of players out of form. Ty Vickery’s poor run continued and fellow tall forward Ben Griffiths was possibly even worse, failing to take a mark. Kane Lambert couldn’t get into the game, Shane Edwards was a massive disappointment and then there’s Ivan Maric. He’s been a warrior but Ivvy looked miles off the pace, recording just two disposals and dropping several marks.
ON THE CUSP: Shaun Hampson will come straight back if he passes a fitness test and Daniel Rioli played in the VFL after returning from his grandfather’s funeral in Darwin — although he must have still been getting his bearings when he won a centre clearance and kicked the ball 50m the wrong way. Jason Castagna is a likely inclusion after picking up plenty of the ball and kicking three goals in the VFL. Andrew Moore also had plenty of it and Liam McBean kicked two goals as the Tigers fell two points short against Casey.
ON THE BLOCK: OK, what now? The finals are shot, putting Richmond fans out of their misery a couple of months earlier than usual. Damien Hardwick says he’ll have a look at the kids in the run home which means possible debuts for Oleg Markov and Dan Butler and more chances for Castagna, Nathan Drummond, Ben Lennon and the great white hope McBean. There isn’t much else in the cupboard but at least Jayden Short and Connor Menadue showed there is something to work with on Friday night. It’s going to be a long eight weeks.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/barometer-how-do-your-clubs-playing-stocks-look-after-round-15/news-story/ace4e044690380d070bbeb386ed79524
-
If McBean doesn't come into the side then Hardwick should be tarred and feathered.
-
Have watched him at VFL level and he reads the game well
Problem is huge transition from VFL to AFL
He is already 23 and has no out standing attributes. At 23 he is close to his ceiling thanks but no thanks.
-
Hmm team for bullies.
FB: Grimes - Astbury - Conca. Astbury only because there is no one else. Would give Elton REST OF THE YR if he was fit BEFORE WE INEVITABLY DELIST HIM.Grimes will have to play tall good luck with that i suppose.
HB: Deledio - Rance - Castagna.
C:: Menadue - Martin - Grigg. Grigg only because of his run and spread and his experience. Plus he has played some half decent footy.
R:: Hampson - Cotchin - Miles. How i wish we had a Josh Kennedy or Pat Cripps type to name here.
HF: Lennon - Riewoldt - Rioli
FF: Short - Griffiths - McBean. Beaner can also pinch hit in the ruck. If he is to be any sort of ruckman he may as well start now.If mcBean is not picked i would throw in the deep end where the sharks may bite em in half either C Moore or Chol.
Int: C Ellis if fit - Drummond - Edwards - Townsend.
7 or 8 changes but we dont lose structure there is plenty of experience around the kids we throw in and the side for want of a better way of saying it has a good flow to it with most bases covered.
It will probably get belted by games end but who gives a poo.
-
Wasted season that if the club bothered to honrst about was shot after round 4
Shot after NAB 3.
-
how can someone have deficiencies with their kicking yet be damaging offensively?
Because what they find damaging, we all find offensive?
-
In the Mix: Round 16
Nathan Schmook
AFL.com.au
5 July 2016
RICHMOND
This is the Tigers' most intriguing week at selection this season after conceding they can't play finals.
There is an expectation the match committee will start looking to youth in the final eight rounds and dashing half-back Jason Castagna is at the front of the queue, having earned a chance through his VFL form.
Tall forward Liam McBean is the player the club needs to know if it will go forward with after two games in four seasons, and he should be given a chance.
Daniel Rioli (12 tackles in the VFL) should also return.
Ruckman Shaun Hampson (knee) faces a fitness test this week, as does defender Jake Batchelor (back).
Half-forward Ben Lennon is close after one game in the VFL back from injury, as is midfielder Nathan Drummond, who has played five matches after 12 months sidelined with a knee injury.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-07-05/in-the-mix-round-16
-
Wasted season that if the club bothered to honrst about was shot after round 4
Shot after NAB 3.
yes, this exactly
-
Townsend.
What's your basis for Townsend Clawski?
-
Townsend.
What's your basis for Townsend Clawski?
Rhymes with Seasonsend?
-
Townsend.
What's your basis for Townsend Clawski?
Just a few reasons.
1/ we need a big bodied inside mid with some tougness cmon we all see it.There is only two options Townsend or A Moore surely we have all seen enough of Moore over what 8 seasons now.
2/ Townsend is relatively young only played what 30 odd AFL games and like a lot of our kids i would like to see them give him a decent crack at it and see what he can produce.
I dont agree with this b/s of playing for one maybe two games and if they dont show enough out they go.
3/ He does have some real attributes for an inside role. Personally would give him a run with role and have the opposition take him to the ball.It may be a way to remedy his lack of disposals.Plus in enough of his games he has done some pretty decent taggoing roles against some real good players more like him. Watson and Kennedy both come to mind.
I think there is a role for him and i think there is still a decent amount of improvement left in him.
Whats to lose we need to give all the players who dont get a regular game a decent crack at it. They will either show something and maybe do enough to be kept or they may well do nothing at least we will know for sure.
-
our best inside mid is Vlastuin......
any decent coach would know that...and any decent coach would also know that Townsend has disposal abilities below that of one Taylor Hunt
-
our best inside mid is Vlastuin......
any decent coach would know that...and any decent coach would also know that Townsend has disposal abilities below that of one Taylor Hunt
2 very different types being compared and I disagree anyhow as most of Hunts disposals are those pea hearted go nowhere possessions.
-
that is 2 names to come to the club to help improve things yet they are 2 big floppers Hunt & Townsend. You can get rougher players out of the local footy who could do better serious
-
moar looob
:lol