One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on April 27, 2023, 06:22:02 PM
-
In: Ross, Soldo, Broad, Sonsie, Bauer
Out: Prestia (general soreness), Maurice Rioli (hamstring)
Source: RFC twitter.
-
RICHMOND
B: Noah Balta Dylan Grimes Tylar Young
HB: Jayden Short Nick Vlastuin Daniel Rioli
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Tim Taranto Marlion Pickett
HF: Liam Baker Dustin Martin Trent Cotchin
F: Samson Ryan Noah Cumberland Jack Riewoldt
R: Ivan Soldo Shai Bolton Jacob Hopper
Int: Nathan Broad Ben Miller Jack Ross Tyler Sonsie
Judson Clarke Hugo Ralphsmith Jacob Bauer Rhyan Mansell
Richmond will confirm its Round 7 team on Friday night at 5.00pm AEST.
The Club will then name its substitute 60 minutes prior to the first bounce on Sunday.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1317211/five-tigers-added-to-squad/
-
Some good ins but soldo, seriously ?
-
Lol, how desperate for a ruckman are we.
-
Gold Coast's squad for those interested.
B: S.Lemmens, S.Collins, D.Macpherson
HB: B.Long, C.Ballard, W.Powell
C: L.Weller, B.Humphrey, D.Swallow
HF: B.Ainsworth, M.Chol, B.Ellis
F: N.Holman, B.King, J.Lukosius
FOLL: J.Witts, M.Rowell, N.Anderson
I/C (FROM): M.Andrew, R.Atkins, A.Davies, B.Fiorini, J.Jeffrey, H.Oea, M.Rosas, A.Sexton
IN: Alex Davies, Alex Sexton, Hewago Oea, Joel Jeffrey, Rory Atkins
OUT: Levi Casboult (Rested), Touk Miller (Injured)
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-teams-round-7-2023-team-news-lineups-full-squads-ins-and-outs-changes-injuries-fixture-games-latest/news-story/555b4cada21c2e686fee4467a75f60b8?recommendedCount=0
-
With the desperate soldo selection i reckon the team should have gone the following.
Mansell - Miller - Grimes
Broad - Balta - Rioli
Banks - Martin - Pickett
Soldo - Hopper - Prestia
Taranto - Riewoldt - Cumberland
Bauer - Ryan - Bolton
Sonsie - Short - Baker - Cotchin
Dow.
Out Young, Vlastuin, McIntosh, Rioli, Clarke
Ins - Bauer, Broad, Banks, Sonsie, Soldo, Dow sub.
The Soldo and Broad selections reek of desperation both should in an ideal world be playing two's. That alone says it all about our depth or lack there of.
-
I think Broad is a straight in but agree on Soldo.
-
Ben Miller looked out of his depth vs Dees. Assume they don’t want Witts to expose the rucks again.
-
Ben Miller looked out of his depth vs Dees. Assume they don’t want Witts to expose the rucks again.
Exactly. I don't rate Soldo when he is paired with Nank but we need some experience against Witt's and therefore is more a requirement than desperate. Broad is a straight back in. He did all the preseason, played well the first few games, was not out with injury and would of trained the whole time he was suspended. Again not a desperation move but more of a logical decision.
-
If Soldo is fit, happy for him to play. Witts is a good ruck.
Broad, Sonsie, Bauer and Ross should all play too.
Drop Mansell, Ralph, Clarke. Prestia and Rioli already out.
-
If Soldo is fit, happy for him to play. Witts is a good ruck.
Broad, Sonsie, Bauer and Ross should all play too.
Drop Mansell, Ralph, Clarke. Prestia and Rioli already out.
2nd this
-
If Soldo is fit, happy for him to play. Witts is a good ruck.
Broad, Sonsie, Bauer and Ross should all play too.
Drop Mansell, Ralph, Clarke. Prestia and Rioli already out.
2nd this
Yep x 3
-
Dimma said Bauer won't play this week.
Broad, Soldo and Ross seem to be the ins based on what Dimma said.
-
Updated.
In: Ross, Soldo, Broad, Sonsie
Out: Prestia (general soreness), M.Rioli (hamstring), Ralphsmith (omitted), Mansell (omitted), Clarke (omitted)
Source: RFC twitter.
-
RICHMOND's finalised team:
B: Noah Balta Dylan Grimes Tylar Young
HB: Jayden Short Nathan Broad Daniel Rioli
C: Kamdyn McIntosh Tim Taranto Tyler Sonsie
HF: Liam Baker Dustin Martin Marlion Pickett
F: Samson Ryan Noah Cumberland Jack Riewoldt
R: Ivan Soldo Shai Bolton Jacob Hopper
Int: Nick Vlastuin Ben Miller Jack Ross Trent Cotchin
Emg: Jacob Bauer Rhyan Mansell Judson Clarke Hugo Ralphsmith
The Club will name its substitute 60 minutes prior to the first bounce on Sunday.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1317530/four-return-for-suns-clash/
-
My gut feel is Mansell or Hugo will be sub
Have to say it looks a far more balanced side with Broad back down back
-
Good changes, prolly HRS as sub again. Soldo is a calculated risk, but one worth taking given the importance of centre bounce these days, and with Witts in there for them.
Very glad to see Ross and Sonsie in, and Broady of course.
-
Ben Miller looked out of his depth vs Dees. Assume they don’t want Witts to expose the rucks again.
Miller is utility who under normal circumstances would just give a Soldo or Nankervis a break and come up against a similar type to himself.
We actually played a 206cm 104kg ruckman in Ryan and he didnt fare too well either.
Still think Miller is a better bet in defense than Young.
-
Updated.
In: Ross, Soldo, Broad, Sonsie
Out: Prestia (general soreness), M.Rioli (hamstring), Ralphsmith (omitted), Mansell (omitted), Clarke (omitted)
Source: RFC twitter.
Can't really complain with the ins. Some of these changes should have been made last week.
Only query is we've gone in with all three of Ryan, Soldo and Miller. Obviously worried about Witts dominating the hitouts at the stoppages as well as Soldo running out of juice. If we knew Soldo could get through the whole game, then I'm guessing Bauer may have come in for Miller.
Presumably, Clarke is the sub. Surely not Mansell nor Hugo.
-
Interesting that Pickett is named at HFF and Sonsie on the wing. Wonder if that will eventuate. I guess the plan is to sub Soldo out late for some extra run. Or early if it ain't working!
-
Interesting that Pickett is named at HFF and Sonsie on the wing. Wonder if that will eventuate. I guess the plan is to sub Soldo out late for some extra run. Or early if it ain't working!
Saw that. Pickett given the role to apply physical forward pressure with Maurice out?
-
Interesting that Pickett is named at HFF and Sonsie on the wing. Wonder if that will eventuate. I guess the plan is to sub Soldo out late for some extra run. Or early if it ain't working!
Saw that. Pickett given the role to apply physical forward pressure with Maurice out?
Like Jack Graham?
-
Interesting that Pickett is named at HFF and Sonsie on the wing. Wonder if that will eventuate. I guess the plan is to sub Soldo out late for some extra run. Or early if it ain't working!
Saw that. Pickett given the role to apply physical forward pressure with Maurice out?
Like Jack Graham?
Yep, pretty much that role you would think. Whether Pickett can snag a couple as well like Graham has done in the past is yet to be seen.
-
Gold Coast
IN: R.Atkins, A.Davies, A.Sexton
OUT: M.Andrew (omitted), M.Rosas (omitted), T.Miller (injury), L.Casboult (managed)
-------------------------------------------
B: S.Lemmens, S.Collins, D.Macpherson
HB: B.Long, C.Ballard, W.Powell
C: L.Weller, B.Humphrey, D.Swallow
HF: B.Ainsworth, M.Chol, B.Ellis
F: N.Holman, B.King, J.Lukosius
FOLL: J.Witts, M.Rowell, N.Anderson
I/C: R.Atkins, A.Davies, B.Fiorini, A.Sexton
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-teams-round-7-2023-team-news-lineups-full-squads-ins-and-outs-changes-injuries-fixture-games-latest/news-story/555b4cada21c2e686fee4467a75f60b8
-
Bellis ;D
-
Sonsie was told he would be playing wing. Pickett forward would be a good move as he is good in the air and provides pressure on the ground.
-
Ben Miller looked out of his depth vs Dees. Assume they don’t want Witts to expose the rucks again.
Miller is utility who under normal circumstances would just give a Soldo or Nankervis a break and come up against a similar type to himself.
We actually played a 206cm 104kg ruckman in Ryan and he didnt fare too well either.
Still think Miller is a better bet in defense than Young.
Leave Miller back.
-
Sonsie was told he would be playing wing. Pickett forward would be a good move as he is good in the air and provides pressure on the ground.
I’ve thought since the elimination final last season that sonsie had all the attributes to be an excellent winger. Happy he’s getting trialed there and hopefully he goes well.
-
I didn’t realise sonsie had that good of a tank. Here’s hoping it works out. Pickett is deceptively strong so would more than happy to experiment with him in the forward line
-
Sonsie was told he would be playing wing. Pickett forward would be a good move as he is good in the air and provides pressure on the ground.
Happy for him to play wing but really do question if he has the tank for it. Both Pickett and McIntosh cover a lot of kms with their gut running. Skill wise has it covered but the gut running?
Will be an interesting watch that's for sure
-
And pickett provided some good defensive marking too, not sure if there part of sonesies game ? Either way I’m happy sonesie is playing and Pickett might just flourish as a high half forward
-
Have suggested and wanted to try Pickett forward for a long time.
Great mark, aerial ability and kicking. Quick on the lead too.
If it's not working out with either him or Sonsie they could just swap!
-
Bauer, Hugo and Mansell all playing VFL.
So Clarke will be the sub.
-
Have always said Pickett should be played across hb. Based on what he was doing in the WAFL when we drafted him. When he played there he was outstanding. Tough, hard, uncompromising, accountable with plenty of run and carry.