One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on March 15, 2008, 03:55:08 AM
-
Mike's done his top 50 for 2008.
Tigers Foley, Richo and Browny missed out.
Only the top 10 are listed on the net. If anyone can post the whole top 50 that would be great :).
1. Jonathan Brown (Brisbane)
2. Chris Judd (Carlton)
3. Dean Cox (West Coast)
4. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
5. Gary Ablett jnr (Geelong)
6. Daniel Kerr (West Coast)
7. Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)
8. Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle)
9. Matthew Scarlett (Geelong)
10. Adam Goodes (Sydney)
The big mover between seasons is Lance Franklin.
As usual, there are 15-20 players desperately unlucky to miss.
They include Hawthorn's best-and-fairest winner Brad Sewell, the veterans Cameron Ling and Darren Milburn (Geelong), Dustin Fletcher and Matthew Lloyd (Essendon), Matthew Richardson and Nathan Brown (Richmond), Brett Kirk (Sydney), Scott West (Western Bulldogs) and Tyson Edwards (Adelaide), and the likely next wave of gun players: Aaron Davey, Nathan Foley, Jed Adcock, Jarrad Waite, Heath Shaw, Dane Swan, Ryan Griffen and Adam Cooney.
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/sport/afl/story/0,26576,23375596-19742,00.html
-
Foley only lead the comp in centre clearances and winning contested footy playing in a crap midfield where he got little help too. Please explain Mike? ??? ::)
-
Mike's top 50 list in full
1. Jonathan Brown (Brisbane)
2. Chris Judd (Carlton)
3. Dean Cox (West Coast)
4. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda)
5. Gary Ablett jnr (Geelong)
6. Daniel Kerr (West Coast)
7. Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)
8. Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle)
9. Matthew Scarlett (Geelong)
10. Adam Goodes (Sydney)
11. Darren Glass (West Coast)
12. Brad Johnson (Western Bulldogs)
13. Lance Franklin (Hawthorn)
14. Shaun Burgoyne (Port Adelaide)
15. James Bartel (Geelong)
16. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda)
17. Scott Lucas (Essendon)
18. Luke Hodge (Hawthorn)
19. Brendan Fevola (Carlton)
20. Simon Black (Brisbane)
21. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
22. Brad Ottens (Geelong)
23. Nick Stevens (Carlton)
24. Joel Corey (Geelong)
25. Andrew McLeod (Adelaide)
26. Travis Cloke (Collingwood)
27. Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide)
28. Barry Hall (Sydney)
29. Brent Harvey (North Melbourne)
30. Cameron Mooney (Geelong)
31. Steven Johnson (Geelong)
32. Simon Goodwin (Adelaide)
33. Tadgh Kennelly (Sydney)
34. Brendan Lade (Port Adelaide)
35. Sam Fisher (St Kilda)
36. Robert Murphy (Western Bulldogs)
37. Craig Bolton (Sydney)
38. Ben Rutten (Adelaide)
39. Paul Chapman (Geelong)
40. Daniel O'Keefe (Sydney)
41. Luke Power (Brisbane)
42. Dale Thomas (Collingwood)
43. Lindsay Gilbee (Western Bulldogs)
44. Hamish McIntosh (North Melbourne)
45. Nathan Bock (Adelaide)
46. Jamie Charman (Brisbane)
47. Luke Montagna (St Kilda)
48. Campbell Brown (Hawthorn)
49. Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood)
50. Brett Deledio (Richmond)
-
Mike's top 50 list in full
42. Dale Thomas (Collingwood)
Please explain this guy in front of Foley. ::)
-
One mans opinion and unfortunately he has a column in the press so his opinion :gotigers matters more than anyone elses????
-
40. Daniel O'Keefe (Sydney)
ROFLLMAO. Last time I checked Daniel O'Keefe hadn't played a game of AFL.
I assume he means Ryan O'Keefe 8)
-
My typo Bluey :shh
Riewoldt at 4 is laughable. He's a worse kick for goal than Richo and misses the crunch goals.
Fevola at 19 :o ???
Nick Stevens at 23 when he only played 4 games last year ???.
Pendlebury below Thomas ???
Bartel, Hodge, Harvey and Chapman are far too low.
Foley is ahead of Lids.
-
No worries MT :rollin
-
Mikes Top 50 lists are based on the drugs he snorts at night with foggy glasses
take no notice of them JB at #1 is a joke
-
Hamish McIntosh, Lindsay Gilbee, Tadgh Kennelly, Jamie Charman shouldnt be in the top 50 at the expense of Foley
-
Deledio got in the top 50 & he done nothing yet hows that work
what about Bowden his better than Deledio
-
Deledio got in the top 50 & he done nothing yet hows that work
what about Bowden his better than Deledio
What else can you expect from someone who nominates the best footballers for the past 150 years when he was not alive to watch a great deal of them play( just another 'MUG JOURNO!')
-
Anyone that listens to a halfwit like Sheahan should be taken out and shot. He's a nobody has been all his life and will continue to be. He does these thing's to keep his name about the place.
He's the typical one who's mother was slapped when he was born and not the other way around.
And just who did he play for ? And how did he go ? Is this the reason why he's a so called sports writer ?
When he was a little kid his parent tie a chop to him just to keep the dog close by. Once he was kidnapped and they bought him back and paid the parents $1000.00 to keep him.
-
Deledio got in the top 50 & he done nothing yet hows that work
what about Bowden his better than Deledio
What else can you expect from someone who nominates the best footballers for the past 150 years when he was not alive to watch a great deal of them play( just another 'MUG JOURNO!')
Thats Exactly correct
-
And just who did he play for ? And how did he go ?
He played for Werribee in the VFA and North Hobart in the TFL. Was apparently a decent player, hard at it.
-
Mike's top 50 list in full
42. Dale Thomas (Collingwood)
Please explain this guy in front of Foley. ::)
Because from what I've read lately on this forum no less Thomas is an absolute gun :rollin :rollin Personally I think he is along way off but I digrese
I would like to sincerely thank Mike for his top 50 list - he has restored my faith in the belief that I've held for a number of years and that is he is a twit :rollin ;D
:gotigers
-
seriously WP as much as l like the talent of Thomas, Pendlebury, Deledio, Franklin, they dont deserve to be rated in a top 50 list as there are far more proven footballers who are playing the game that the young lads themselves would tell you they look up to
as we all know MS is a total twit
-
Nathan Bock? Uve got 2 be kidding me
-
Deledio got in the top 50 & he done nothing yet hows that work
what about Bowden his better than Deledio
Back Pockets shouldnt be in the top 50 especially those that have played for the 16th placed club.
-
Deledio got in the top 50 & he done nothing yet hows that work
what about Bowden his better than Deledio
Back Pockets shouldnt be in the top 50 especially those that have played for the 16th placed club.
you tellin me Deledio is a better player than Bowden seriously
just cause your in the wooden spoon team dont mean you cant make top 50 players
our main problem is the forward line they dont convert & they dont defend the forawrd line its not always the backline fault
our backline has been undermanned since the late 80s. Bowden should be payed a million dollars extra for the job his done on players bigger than him. His put his body on the line time after time thats why he wins JD medals
Its time for him to get relief & go into the forward line where we lack kicking large scores & get that percentage up every year
anyway Bowden deserves to be in that Top 50, l dont care what anyone says he one of the leagues good players
Take him out of the team we really turn to poo
Deledio's time will come in a few years when he stamps himself on the league but IMO his done nothing to warrant being in the 50 & thats goes for Thomas, Pendlebury, Franklin & a few others your not a champion at 60 odd games you need to stand out like John Coleman
-
Its time for him to get relief & go into the forward line where we lack kicking large scores & get that percentage up every year
That should have happened years ago but Joel seems to have been banished from the forward line since a couple of brain implosions in 2001 against Adelaide and Hawthorn cost us games.
-
:rollin 2001 a long time ago ???
why is Richo still in the forward line ??? his cost us so many games l cant count them all. why is he not banished :lol
-
I totally agree with you Tigermonk.
-
:rollin 2001 a long time ago ???
why is Richo still in the forward line ??? his cost us so many games l cant count them all. why is he not banished :lol
Richo can't play in the backline ;).
I know it makes no sense but Joel has not played in our forward line since that Hawthorn game 7 years ago (not that I'm counting lol).
-
MT l can remember one night game against Collingwood where Richo started after haltime in the backline & he dominated, in the last 1/4 he even run forward & kicked a rubbish goal from outside 50 on a tight angle on the run. His confidence was so high.
but he missed so many easy goals in the first half the skunks squad really nailed him
can't remember the year but it was in the last 6-7 years. l will try find the video of that game but he was at CHB
-
I remember a game at the Dome a couple of years ago where he was sent to the backline during time-on as a loose man to help prevent the opposition from scoring and then gave us all heart failure everytime he went near the ball lol.
-
Sheahan = :wallywink