One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: MintOnLamb on August 22, 2017, 04:14:40 PM
-
We are a chance for the flag this year about 15% IMHO.
It's all fluff anyway as if didn't happen BUT . . .
What if Treloar had picked Richmond instead of Collingwood ?
Do you think we would be up to 25% chance ?
Posters comments??
Just goes to show how important landing these larger fish is and how focused we will need to be over the upcoming draft to ensure we maximise our Premiership Window, which will be wide open next year.
-
Unfortunately Treloar had too much man love for Buckley.
Treloars first mistake was leaving the Giants .
-
We wouldnt have Rioli, Prestia or Caddy if we got Trelaor. Id say hes made a good choice for him. Im no longer bitter on that one, we made good on what we ended up with
-
I think we are more than 15% if we can beat Saints by more than 5 goals this weekend. I'd put us more like a 25-30%
-
I think we are more than 15% if we can beat Saints by more than 5 goals this weekend. I'd put us more like a 25-30%
Let's hope so, I went to the last game, tragedy, if we are a contender i would like to see an emphatic victory
-
Just goes to show how important landing these larger fish is and how focused we will need to be over the upcoming draft to ensure we maximise our Premiership Window, which will be wide open next year.
If Dusty leaves that window is no longer wide open.
Even if he stays, I will reserve my judgement until I see us solve our 2nd KPF issue with a genuine tall forward threat.
-
Just with the booing of treloar yesterday, can anyone confirm if it is was racially motivated, does he have aboriginal blood in him?
-
Just with the booing of treloar yesterday, can anyone confirm if it is was racially motivated, does he have aboriginal blood in him?
Don't think so. We're just booing him cos he chose the Pies.
Or are you being facetious?
-
Just with the booing of treloar yesterday, can anyone confirm if it is was racially motivated, does he have aboriginal blood in him?
Don't think so. We're just booing him cos he chose the Pies.
Or are you being facetious?
I'm being facetious
-
Just with the booing of treloar yesterday, can anyone confirm if it is was racially motivated, does he have aboriginal blood in him?
Don't think so. We're just booing him cos he chose the Pies.
Or are you being facetious?
I'm being facetious
:clapping
-
I'm booing him because he's Black AND white
-
RACIST
-
I’d like to thank the original land owners and elders for the right to post on this forum. :shh
-
I’d like to thank the original land owners and elders for the right to post on this forum. :shh
Which land are we talking about? "Internet land" is definitely not owned by the elders.....
-
If there is money in it they will claim it
-
Hows that better list going you jumped up little prick
-
;D
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Db_VsQoVwAAS6xn.jpg)
-
Gee I love Cotch, a hard as nails player with elite skill and an aggressive nature on the field
-
Adam Treloar says the sky is the limit for the Magpies this year, admitting he’s pictured winning a premiership.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/collingwood-star-adam-treloar-says-hes-pictured-winning-a-premiership-with-the-magpies/news-story/f0d28013fd63196880e47ee714026830
:rollin
-
Adam Treloar says the sky is the limit for the Magpies this year, admitting he’s pictured winning a premiership.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/collingwood-star-adam-treloar-says-hes-pictured-winning-a-premiership-with-the-magpies/news-story/f0d28013fd63196880e47ee714026830
:rollin
I can picture myself driving around in a Lamborghini but it aint gonna happen
-
Adam Treloar says the sky is the limit for the Magpies this year, admitting he’s pictured winning a premiership.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/collingwood-star-adam-treloar-says-hes-pictured-winning-a-premiership-with-the-magpies/news-story/f0d28013fd63196880e47ee714026830
:rollin
I can picture myself driving around in a Lamborghini but it aint gonna happen
Hiring one for an hour isn't that expensive I think....
-
Adam Treloar says the sky is the limit for the Magpies this year, admitting he’s pictured winning a premiership.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/collingwood-star-adam-treloar-says-hes-pictured-winning-a-premiership-with-the-magpies/news-story/f0d28013fd63196880e47ee714026830
:rollin
:lol
Smashed by the Tiges, scraping over the line against Brisbane has him dreaming of a flag :lol
-
Flog - Flag
There is only a vowel in it.
-
It will be interesting to see how the pies fare later this year. A few people writing them and Treloar off. But wasn't it this time last year all the media and social media clogs were saying same old tigers and "How Richmondy"
We are good, but not invincible
-
Adam Treloar says the sky is the limit for the Magpies this year, admitting he’s pictured winning a premiership.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/collingwood-star-adam-treloar-says-hes-pictured-winning-a-premiership-with-the-magpies/news-story/f0d28013fd63196880e47ee714026830
:rollin
I can picture myself driving around in a Lamborghini but it aint gonna happen
He could always photo shop his face over Cotch later this year
-
Poor Adam never learns to keep his dopey mouth shut :nope.
(http://images.ucomics.com/comics/ga/2010/ga101107.gif)
-
Treloar = Thehoar
-
So did The Simpsons steal that gag from Garfield or vice versa? :shh
-
So did The Simpsons steal that gag from Garfield or vice versa? :shh
Does it matter?
Still funny either way :thumbsup
-
Speaking to Damian Barrett on the In The Game podcast, GWS chief executive Dave Matthews responded to the comments by firing shots back at Treloar.
"I saw his comments, he sounded a lot more sure of himself now than when he was with us," Matthews said.
"I think about his final year at the club where he was absolutely adamant he was staying, wasn't going anywhere.
"I think sometimes players, and this has happened to the Gold Coast too, go for the money.
"It ends up being a go-home factor. But I would have thought his decision, as much as anything, came down to money.
"He was very, very clear, Adam, that he was going to stay with us. He was equally clear that Richmond was going to be his club of choice.
"And then he made a decision that was equally sure that Collingwood was going to be his club of choice.”
Matthews also spoke of how the Treloar move came about.
"It was an unusual time, a very unusual time, and how he got to Collingwood is probably a podcast in itself," he added.
"When you lose your footy manager (Graeme Allan) and a player who is indicating he wants to stay, then talks about going to Richmond, and ends up at Collingwood with that footy manager, it was an unusual set of circumstances.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2019/07/03/gws-chief-takes-aim-at-collingwood-midfielder/
-
Hows that better list going you jumped up little prick
:wave.
-
Trelol
-
Lots of stats but I thought he had minimal influence tonight. Just numbers. Didn't look tough either and it was nice to see Martin deck him late!
-
Oh damn, I missed that, gonna have to find that bit on a replay somewhere. Did he tussle the hair on his unconcious head?
-
Just flattened him a little in the last Q I think. Just enough not to pay a free but to make it clear :D
-
Trelolol
-
"Pies have the better list" :biglaugh
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/450/2019/09/21/716999.jpg)
-
He will be broken if we win next week. It will be 2-0 since he made his decision to go to the wobbles.
2 premierships for us with our crap list and 0 Flags for him and his beloved coach.
-
Iv'e come around to Trelol a little, It's not so much the players but their dirty rotten supporters that get me.
So relaxed and Calm now they are out, just going to enjoy this.
Side Note: So who's Lids going for :shh
-
If we did get treloar 2-3 years ago we would have missed out on Prestia?
-
If we did get treloar 2-3 years ago we would have missed out on Prestia?
Would have cost two first rounders which ended up being Rioli and Presta.
Getting Prestia also influenced Caddy and Lynch.
And as part of the Caddy trade we moved our 4th round pick up the order and we took Graham with that pick.
-
poor ol T-LoL he was lured in by figjam and figjam pumped him up to be a figjam in his own image where as here, he would of been made part of a team effort. That is the difference. Collingwood are a crackup, we just need to look at something and they want it.
-
Adam is actually a pretty decent bloke like most footy players, so I do feel empathy for him.
I only hope we go on to win next week because ive waited 30+ years for the club to be this good and have this opportunity and they don't come around often.
-
He probably is, I wouldn't know, haven't met him. I can only make my broad sweeping generalisations, wild accusations and spiteful put downs based on what little information I gleen from carefully edited media beat ups that are at my disposal.
-
He probably is, I wouldn't know, haven't met him. I can only make my broad sweeping generalisations, wild accusations and spiteful put downs based on what little information I gleen from carefully edited media beat ups that are at my disposal.
Classic Owl
-
If we did get treloar 2-3 years ago we would have missed out on Prestia?
Would have cost two first rounders which ended up being Rioli and Presta.
Getting Prestia also influenced Caddy and Lynch.
And as part of the Caddy trade we moved our 4th round pick up the order and we took Graham with that pick.
Thanks for the info
So it worked in our favour I believe.
-
Yeah but he shared his feelings in a that doco and spoke well on the Wimpley & Slobbo show so we're all supposed to like him now... :shh
-
"I think Collingwood have a better list, a younger list, who in a couple of years time can hopefully win a premiership"
Adam Treloar rates the Pies ahead of the Tigers, Nov 18, 2015
https://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-11-18/pies-have-a-better-list-than-tigers-treloar
(https://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/d31899310bba7ec4b6f7d282c5daaab0?width=700)
(https://s3.ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/multitools.newscdn.com.au/multitools/factbox/content/1569636626681/AFL-GRAND-FINAL-NEWS_f-vpyaU8D.jpg)
(https://cdn.newsapi.com.au/image/v1/2e486beeff53fcdf837e11f886f2e0e6?width=700)
:wave
-
Nek Menit
(https://static2.stuff.co.nz/1323819947/155/6138155.jpg)
-
Treloar is going to cop it even more now from our supporter base when we play Collingwood next year.
-
Another little stat for Buckley's flagless protege.
Richmond has won as many flags in the past 3 years as Collingwood has won in the past 60.
Tiges: 2 flags in past 3 years.
Pies: 2 flags in past 60 years.
-
Wonder if he did a scomo when he signed up "ill burn for you" haha
-
Another little stat for Buckley's flagless protege.
Richmond has won as many flags in the past 3 years as Collingwood has won in the past 60.
Tiges: 2 flags in past 3 years.
Pies: 2 flags in past 60 years.
Ohh I like this, they got nothing now :rollin cant wait to play them next year
-
Was a blessing in disguise that he went to the Pyes , would have cost 2 1st round picks
-
Pies were willing to trade Treloar to the Suns.
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/collingwood-considered-a-gold-coast-suns-request-to-trade-adam-treloar/news-story/5615c265dc41a0e8cf82a064cf23f4a9
-
Says a lot about the difference in cultures between us and the Pies right now. You're clearly only seen as a commodity at Collingwood.
-
Treloar in doubt to play against us with another soft tissue injury (calf strain).
https://www.afl.com.au/news/435121/magpies-gun-strains-calf-in-first-session-back
-
5 years of nothing later :wallywink.
-
Was a blessing in disguise
-
The gift that keeps on, keeps on giving
-
The gift that keeps on, keeps on giving
Bless him :pray
-
im starting to feel a bit sorry for him. I heard an interview where he did admit it was a mistake, and that he was young and stupid or something like that
I hate the pies more than anyone, though after our second flag i cared even less about what he said. Though i can never stop seeing eddie's face as we saw last night.
that bloke is half the reason why most people hate the pies
-
Yeah tbh, think it's time to move on from this comment. Was a long time ago, he was young and stupid.
Some of you don't have the young excuse...
-
I don’t think we’ve made nearly enough of his comment. It’s a masterclass in how to STFU when talking about other clubs
-
He gets zero sympathy from me regarding this comment. If he said “Eddie would help my partner with her media career at channel 9 so I picked Collingwood” then I would actually give him props for the straight up honesty.
Especially him patting Cotchin on the head in 2016, he needs to wear this comment until he retires.
-
He’s a flog of the highest order
-
Most punchable head since Ballantyne... :shh
-
Could be headed north...missus just signed to play with the Qld Firebirds...#BeamsMkII :shh
-
“I just think Brisbane have a better list”
-
Anyone want Treloar? ;D
Collingwood looking to trade him. He doesn't want to leave and has refused to move to a Qld club but begrudgingly would to another Victorian club.
source: Tom Morris on SEN/Foxsports
-
Haha
Flop
-
The flog can play...but he's one more hammy away from being cooked...and you know...he's a flog... :shh
-
Would obviously be a good addition on form and talent but too costly and well, you know. He had his chance.
-
Treloar on $700k according to Tom Browne.
Further to my story this morning regarding Adam Treloar, the background to my point was that I’m told Collingwood told Adam find a club, and we’ll arrange the trade. I put this Collingwood, who didn’t respond. And Treloar’s manager. Who didn’t directly address it.
There is no guarantee Treloar will leave Collingwood. But the key point here is Collingwood are either pushing or open to it. And Treloar’s comments on 360 were all about him fulfilling his side of the contract / bargain.
The suns have to clear space by trading Wright and Brodie. They cant can’t afford Treloar at this very second. Brisbane don’t have $700,000 plus in their cap either. A lot to play out
ttps://twitter.com/TomBrowne7
-
Maybe Collingwood will have a better list without him. All jokes aside, Collingwood seems to be a bit of a graveyard for young talented players. They break em.
-
Adam Treloar asked Collingwood two weeks ago whether the club wanted him and the response he received was emphatic.
No we don’t.
As reported by foxfooty.com.au at the time, the direct messaging left the midfielder feeling frustrated and hurt.
Further conversations since have left the player even more disillusioned with the club and hurt by their approach. The Magpies have told him they don’t see him as part of their plans – despite him reaffirming his preference to stay - and would consider paying more than $200,000 of his 2021 salary even if he was at another club.
They’ve also told him he is difficult to coach at times, with no further explanation or clarification.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trades-2020-adam-treloar-trade-contract-collingwood-gold-coast-suns-future-queensland-kim-ravaillion-news/news-story/137bca3f3a44b83ecb569c41b2325a41
-
Adam Treloar asked Collingwood two weeks ago whether the club wanted him and the response he received was emphatic.
No we don’t.
As reported by foxfooty.com.au at the time, the direct messaging left the midfielder feeling frustrated and hurt.
Further conversations since have left the player even more disillusioned with the club and hurt by their approach. The Magpies have told him they don’t see him as part of their plans – despite him reaffirming his preference to stay - and would consider paying more than $200,000 of his 2021 salary even if he was at another club.
They’ve also told him he is difficult to coach at times, with no further explanation or clarification.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trades-2020-adam-treloar-trade-contract-collingwood-gold-coast-suns-future-queensland-kim-ravaillion-news/news-story/137bca3f3a44b83ecb569c41b2325a41
Whilst i don’t have a huge amount of sympathy for Treloar, on the surface he seems to have copped the rough end on this one. From my understanding his contract is back ended too.
-
Pies have no loyalty to their players. A disgraceful organisation.
-
Would happily take Treloar for 200k less his salary. Extraordinary stuff.
-
Adam Treloar asked Collingwood two weeks ago whether the club wanted him and the response he received was emphatic.
No we don’t.
As reported by foxfooty.com.au at the time, the direct messaging left the midfielder feeling frustrated and hurt.
Further conversations since have left the player even more disillusioned with the club and hurt by their approach. The Magpies have told him they don’t see him as part of their plans – despite him reaffirming his preference to stay - and would consider paying more than $200,000 of his 2021 salary even if he was at another club.
They’ve also told him he is difficult to coach at times, with no further explanation or clarification.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trades-2020-adam-treloar-trade-contract-collingwood-gold-coast-suns-future-queensland-kim-ravaillion-news/news-story/137bca3f3a44b83ecb569c41b2325a41
Whilst i don’t have a huge amount of sympathy for Treloar, on the surface he seems to have copped the rough end on this one. From my understanding his contract is back ended too.
Sleep with dogs, catch fleas
-
Stay away from Treloar, he had his opportunity and he shafted us.
Go after Dunkley.
-
Stay away from Treloar, he had his opportunity and he shafted us.
Go after Dunkley.
Agree with you on treloar
As for Dunkley, he's contracted Dogs wont trade him
-
Stay away from Treloar, he had his opportunity and he shafted us.
Go after Dunkley.
Agree with you on treloar
As for Dunkley, he's contracted Dogs wont trade him
Yes I agree, I saw your reply in the other thread, Dunkley will be very expensive, a bridge too far.
-
if you ask me he is a little prat and has been found out
-
Getting smacked by the Karma bus for sure but he'll still be on $800-$900k per year for playing footy on the Gold Coast. Between Lolingwood and GC they'll have to pay his contract in full. Not someone we should be feeling sorry for.
-
if you ask me he is a little prat and has been found out
/thread :shh
-
(http://oneeyed-richmond.com/images/other/Treloar_cry2.jpg)
Somebody That They Used to Know
(Apologies to Gotye)
Remember when Treloar and Collingwood got together
Like when Eddie said he felt so happy he could die
Adam told himself that Nathan was right for him you see
And didn't want 'non-premiership list' Richmond as his company
But that was his delusion and it's an ache I still remember
At Collingwood you can get addicted to a certain kind of sadness
Like resignation to losing finals, always in the end
So when Treloar and the Pies found that they couldn't win a flag
Well Adam said that they could still be friends
But the Pies admitted that they were glad it was over
But Treloar said, "Nathan didn't have to cut me off"
"Make out like it never happened and that I was nothing"
"And I don't even need your love"
"But you treat me like a stranger and that feels so rough"
"No, you didn't have to stoop so low"
"Have Pendles clean out my locker and ask for a high draft pick number".
I guess Adam that is karma though
Now you're just somebody that they used to know
Now you're just somebody that they used to know
Now you're just somebody that they used to know
;D
-
Get him to Tigerland
-
0 and 3 for Trelol
-
Ramps, so Treloar got his wish to be like Buckley :lol
Suns have gone cold on Treloar btw. Talk of him ending up at the Dogs if Dunkley leaves.
-
I think we can Pin this up on the "Classic Blunders" cork board at this stage.
-
Apparently Collingwood players have told Treloar to GAGF
-
Apparently Collingwood players have told Treloar to GAGF
Collingwood midfielder Adam Treloar was told last week that senior players don’t want him at the football club anymore, according to SEN Chief Sports Reporter Sam Edmund.
“What we can say as absolute fact is Nathan Buckley had a phone conversation with Adam Treloar last week where he told him that Collingwood’s more senior players didn’t want him around the club anymore.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2020/11/01/adam-treloar-told-hes-no-longer-wanted-by-senior-teammates/
-
Apparently Collingwood players have told Treloar to GAGF
Collingwood midfielder Adam Treloar was told last week that senior players don’t want him at the football club anymore, according to SEN Chief Sports Reporter Sam Edmund.
“What we can say as absolute fact is Nathan Buckley had a phone conversation with Adam Treloar last week where he told him that Collingwood’s more senior players didn’t want him around the club anymore.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2020/11/01/adam-treloar-told-hes-no-longer-wanted-by-senior-teammates/
More poor work from the pies.
Load his contract, never pay the heavy back end, then try to trade him out whilst also trashing him as a bloke along the way.
Should be investigated by the integrity unit.
-
When did the Pies extend his contract to 2025?
When he was drafted?
Cause a lot has gone for a bloke who has 5 years to go on his contract.
You would’ve thought that there would have been some warning signs before now
-
He can’t stay but no one will take for more than 500 grand, lol Collingwood were so keen on winning this bloke, 2 first round picks I believe
-
He can’t stay but no one will take for more than 500 grand, lol Collingwood were so keen on winning this bloke, 2 first round picks I believe
Not to mention what they have up for Beams
-
Collingwood appear to have a salary cap problem. Victorian clubs are now circling for Treloar, aware $600,000 of his $900,000 and a second round pick might be the best Collingwood do. It’s a mess.
https://twitter.com/TomBrowne7
-
Surely there's no way we even consider AT after his last back flip an FU to the Tigers.
Na. Had his Chance.
-
No ego at our club. If he comes cheap and helps win our next Premiership then bring him on.
-
Hang on.
Is he gettable for pick 32 and we would only have to pay him $600,000?
No thanks :D
-
I’d have him for the right price - if he’s prepared to use his running both ways and settle for 8-10 less possessions as a result of a defensive focus, he would be a huge acquisition. As good as our midfield was in the finals this year, we have a few over 30 next year.
-
Dimma like hard contact players, he's good but is he a Dimma style player? I would worry more about that factor than the cost of picks or money.
-
After watching the last dance and how the team took in Rodman despite previous tension, I was absolutely in awe how the bulls took him in with open arms knowing he would help them with championships.
If treloar can leave his ego, play hard for the team and obvious take a pay cut I would seriously entertain the idea.
-
Massive no for me, too many issues, we have a group of midfielders coming through and I would prefer them before Treloar...
-
Unless you're a matchwinning freak named Dusty who can go where he likes then you've got to be a selfless two way runner to play midfield under Dimma. A lot of Pies including Treloar go missing when the game isn't going their way forward. Treloar is also too often a butcher of the ball.
-
His kick to handball ratio is already way off and when he does kick it he has turned it over pretty badly
-
He’s over rated badly, wouldn’t pay more than $300k a season for him
-
Andy Maher on SEN said Treloar would make Richmond better even if Tiger supporters don't like to hear that.
-
Andy Maher on SEN said Treloar would make Richmond better even if Tiger supporters don't like to hear that.
Sorry Andy, not sure he would
He had his chance, chose not come to Tigerland and we got Prestia anyway.
-
Sam Edmund on SEN said tonight he would do Treloar to Richmond if he was us as Cotchin isn't getting any younger.
-
These journos seriously have NFI.
Trade radio takes the interest out of trade week.
-
Sam Edmund on SEN said tonight he would do Treloar to Richmond if he was us as Cotchin isn't getting any younger.
Not even good enough to tie up his shoe laces :scream
-
Watch this space. I think he’ll go Hawks but we are in the mix. Dimma is warming to the idea.
-
We are into it for the right price, both draft pick and the amount Collingwood will pay
His preference is to go to club that has a chance at the Premiership which imho isn’t Hawthorn
Not sure if he fits at Richmond and has already shown he doesn’t always keep his word so he might go to north or hawthorn
-
Sam Edmund on SEN said tonight he would do Treloar to Richmond if he was us as Cotchin isn't getting any younger.
Chalk and cheese :lol
-
All depends on how much of a pinhead he is for me.
He was clearly told by Collingwood to tell the media that he chose them because their list is better.
No wankers at the club tho if possible.
-
I think he is exactly what we need. If he is available at a good price get him in I say.
-
Good player. You'd be silly not to consider him if the price is reasonable.
-
No, the player demonstrated a complete lack of respect for us as a side, our captain Trent Cotchin (remember when he patted him on the head) and Blair Hartley and these commentators want and are recommending we take him now when he's a basket case. Stay way clear of this joker and if we as a club have any self respect will not go anywhere near this DH.
-
I'd want Collingwood paying 300/year and only a modest pick price
-
No, the player demonstrated a complete lack of respect for us as a side, our captain Trent Cotchin (remember when he patted him on the head) and Blair Hartley and these commentators want and are recommending we take him now when he's a basket case. Stay way clear of this joker and if we as a club have any self respect will not go anywhere near this DH.
But just imagine the melts if he came over and we won another flag!
-
No, the player demonstrated a complete lack of respect for us as a side, our captain Trent Cotchin (remember when he patted him on the head) and Blair Hartley and these commentators want and are recommending we take him now when he's a basket case. Stay way clear of this joker and if we as a club have any self respect will not go anywhere near this DH.
But just imagine the melts if he came over and we won another flag!
Personally I believe keeping one's self respect organizationally is a lot higher than any potential gain that may come from his acquisition, but that is just my view and I hope it is the clubs.
-
No place for grudges in a forward looking organisation. If he makes us a stronger team we consider him on merits.
-
No, the player demonstrated a complete lack of respect for us as a side, our captain Trent Cotchin (remember when he patted him on the head) and Blair Hartley and these commentators want and are recommending we take him now when he's a basket case. Stay way clear of this joker and if we as a club have any self respect will not go anywhere near this DH.
But just imagine the melts if he came over and we won another flag!
Personally I believe keeping one's self respect organizationally is a lot higher than any potential gain that may come from his acquisition, but that is just my view and I hope it is the clubs.
Nope, it's the other way around. Club is a business and the best measure of success is winning flags. If a player like Treloar can help us do that then it's in our best interest.
Leave the ego at the door as we like to say where I work.
-
Treloar also isn't going to want to make some guys agree to a slight paycut to squeeze him in.
They'll be 'LOL eff off'
-
Treloar has told teammates he no longer wants to play with Collingwood.
Wants to play for a Victorian club that will play finals.
- Tom Morris on Foxsports.
-
Apparently Collingwood players have told Treloar to GAGF
Collingwood midfielder Adam Treloar was told last week that senior players don’t want him at the football club anymore, according to SEN Chief Sports Reporter Sam Edmund.
“What we can say as absolute fact is Nathan Buckley had a phone conversation with Adam Treloar last week where he told him that Collingwood’s more senior players didn’t want him around the club anymore.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2020/11/01/adam-treloar-told-hes-no-longer-wanted-by-senior-teammates/
If this is true there’s only one question from me.......Why?
-
Funny club Collingwood, it wasnt that long ago figjam and look at me Maguire cleaned out most of the so called rat pack including a Collingwood stalwart family ( Shaw’s)
Might be more to do with bad decisions by back ending so many contracts than the player
Treloar has 5 years to go on a contract and he is 28, just a crazy decision making. They imported and paid overs for players for years and now they have to pay what they owe.
For the right price , contract length and pick he would cost, but I doubt that would happen unless he picks us and agrees to alteration
-
No mention of Richmond which will please some.
Media linking the Saints & Hawks but also talking about a 3-way swap: Treloar -> Dogs, Dunkley -> Dons, Bombers' first rounder -> Pies.
-
Collingwood will only get a high pick if the Pies cover the majority of his wage, which defeats the purpose of getting rid of him.
-
No mention of Richmond which will please some.
Media linking the Saints & Hawks but also talking about a 3-way swap: Treloar -> Dogs, Dunkley -> Dons, Bombers' first rounder -> Pies.
Pick 6 for Treloar hell no haha. Not unless they are paying like half his contract?
Pies have a gun to their head. All other clubs should lowball them and tell them to gagf and pay him the full wage for feeling sad on the sidelines like Beams while they either shed quality players they can't afford or breach the TPP cap.
Elsewise, a cheap pick. Mid-late second maybe.
-
No, the player demonstrated a complete lack of respect for us as a side, our captain Trent Cotchin (remember when he patted him on the head) and Blair Hartley and these commentators want and are recommending we take him now when he's a basket case. Stay way clear of this joker and if we as a club have any self respect will not go anywhere near this DH.
But just imagine the melts if he came over and we won another flag!
Sadly you have no idea. all the best.
Personally I believe keeping one's self respect organizationally is a lot higher than any potential gain that may come from his acquisition, but that is just my view and I hope it is the clubs.
Nope, it's the other way around. Club is a business and the best measure of success is winning flags. If a player like Treloar can help us do that then it's in our best interest.
Leave the ego at the door as we like to say where I work.
-
No, the player demonstrated a complete lack of respect for us as a side, our captain Trent Cotchin (remember when he patted him on the head) and Blair Hartley and these commentators want and are recommending we take him now when he's a basket case. Stay way clear of this joker and if we as a club have any self respect will not go anywhere near this DH.
Was that when Cotchin chirped off at him, thinking we'd won the game & Treloar patted him on the head when Collingwood won and said "too soon"...? Just a bit of banter mate.
We were all young and stupid once. I'd welcome Treloar with open arms. Couldn't see him coming here however.
-
I'll put my hand up and say I rather not have him at Tigerland. Just don't rate him, never have and certainly don't at $900k a year
And it is that $900k a season that I'd see as the biggest stumbling block getting him
Even allowing for the Pies supposedly "generous" offer of paying $100-$150k of that $900k I don't believe we could fit him under our cap (not that anyone has a cluecwhat next year's cap is at the moment ::))
Getting him isn't just about the salary in 2021 but right through to 2025.
We have a number of our up and comers going out of contract (Bolton, Balta, Baker etc) next season and beyond and we don't want to end up where we can't keep them because of cap pressures or not be able to reward them how they deserve to be.
What about Prestia, Grimes, Lambert etc? They will all come out of contract durong that period and they deserve to be the priorities
Yes, Cotchin and Reiwoldt are closer to the end of their careers so in time there will be room there but we also have Lynch on a contract that by all reports has been back ended.
Our Club has built something very special, everyone has bought into it and will continue to do so because they all value it. Think that is far more important than that getting Treloar
-
I'll put my hand up and say I rather not have him at Tigerland. Just don't rate him, never have and certainly don't at $900k a year
And it is that $900k a season that I'd see as the biggest stumbling block getting him
Even allowing for the Pies supposedly "generous" offer of paying $100-$150k of that $900k I don't believe we could fit him under our cap (not that anyone has a cluecwhat next year's cap is at the moment ::))
Getting him isn't just about the salary in 2021 but right through to 2025.
We have a number of our up and comers going out of contract (Bolton, Balta, Baker etc) next season and beyond and we don't want to end up where we can't keep them because of cap pressures or not be able to reward them how they deserve to be.
What about Prestia, Grimes, Lambert etc? They will all come out of contract durong that period and they deserve to be the priorities
Yes, Cotchin and Reiwoldt are closer to the end of their careers so in time there will be room there but we also have Lynch on a contract that by all reports has been back ended.
Our Club has built something very special, everyone has bought into it and will continue to do so because they all value it. Think that is far more important than that getting Treloar
Agree 100% WP.
Plus ask Dusty who is taking ‘unders’ and anyone else, why Treloar can walk in, get paid a fortune, stuff up chances for our up and comers getting games, just because he wants to come to a club who is in the premiership window.
IMHO, getting “Trailer” is the sort of decision that would have been made in the “olde days” and would stuff up the fabric of the team.
Please, no for me re Adam Treloar.
-
agree with WP here.
500k max and 2 years only. That is not going to happen so its a massive pass.
-
Go find our own Treloar one that doesn't cost 900k and has good hamstrings.
It's a moot point anyway.
We just can't afford him...
-
Only at the right price for a 28 year old, can get it but average skill, let the stupid clubs pay overs.
-
BIG NO
-
There's a lot of tea in China ... not even for all of it! :thumbsdown
-
BIG NO
NO
-
Collingwood willing to offer picks in return plus Treloar.
- Tom Browne on twitter.
-
Have to say I love their desperation.
Really shot themselves in the foot, basically outing him and showing their hand.
My preference is he stays and wrecks their TPP or goes but still costs them a bucket.
-
Have to say I love their desperation.
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_pfckJwHDzW8/RwKosZqlsOI/AAAAAAAABhI/50DcseG_gTw/s1600/2007.10.01.02.jpg)
:shh
-
Have to say I love their desperation.
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_pfckJwHDzW8/RwKosZqlsOI/AAAAAAAABhI/50DcseG_gTw/s1600/2007.10.01.02.jpg)
:shh
Best thing posted in this thread
-
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EmgcAXKVgAE81T5?format=jpg&name=900x900)
https://twitter.com/paigecardona/status/1326340886888816640
-
Treloar will end up at the Dogs, Dunkley the Bombers and someone at Collingwood in salary cap needs a better calculator
-
Collingwood will be forced to pay $300,000 for each of the next five seasons to move Adam Treloar to the Western Bulldogs, according to Trade Radio's Sam Edmund.
The Bulldogs are willing to pay Treloar $600,000 a season, leaving a significant shortfall and forcing the Magpies to pay a total of $1.5m over the remainder of Treloar's lucrative deal.
https://www.afl.com.au/trade/trade-talk
-
Gee dogs, just let them hang themselves ffs
-
Gee dogs, just let them hang themselves ffs
Yep. Running fast off a short ledge is our Pies atm
-
Edit: Scratch that.
SEN now saying Treloar has been traded to the Dogs.
-
wheels falling off, lovely. It's like a little bonus cherry on top of the Premiership cup...lovely Trade war II -->Tigers, no casualties, Collingwood, massive karate kick to own face, salary cap blow out, losing trumpeted marquis players, humiliation, and a big arse shaped slice of humble pie.
-
The Treloar Trade:
DOGS GET: Treloar, 26, 33 and 42
PIES GET: Pick 14 and future 2nd round pick
https://twitter.com/traderadio
#firesale
-
All those "Make Collingwood Great Again" Hats are getting piffed into bins quicker than you can spell rebuild
(https://i.chzbgr.com/full/2906840576/h1FA9C775/face-punch)
-
Treloar confirmed a report he was told by Buckley his teammates no longer wanted him at the club, but the coach refuted that to a point.
"This is a break-up, this is something he was aware of 12 months ago that became more real now. It's been obviously difficult for him and difficult for us as a football club, but it was a business decision, unfortunately," Buckley said.
"The leaders were aware of the decision the list management group had made soon after the season. That was done out of respect for the leaders and for them to provide genuine support and have a knowledge of what Adam and we were facing.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/524568/-this-is-a-break-up-buckley-on-treloar-chat-short-and-sharp-conversations
-
Maybe next year you little flog
-
He was pretty good tonight.
-
He was pretty good tonight.
Nah kicked a few goals but was shocking in defence
-
Probably close to best for the Dogs, some of their players were appalling though.
-
5 years in a row now he has either watched the club he rejected win the flag or he's played in the losing side on Grand Final day. Ouch!
-
Probably close to best for the Dogs, some of their players were appalling though.
Daniel's second half in particular was an absolute shocker.... :shh
-
5 years in a row now he has either watched the club he rejected win the flag or he's played in the losing side on Grand Final day. Ouch!
Haha omg. Savage
-
I almost feel sorry for him now it looks like a conspiracy 😂
-
27d & 3 goals. Some people judge harshly
-
Absolutely they are.
He had a pretty good game I thought. Quite a number of WB players behind him..
-
I almost feel sorry for him now it looks like a conspiracy 😂
I heard he’s an anti vaxxer
-
ROfl
-
Just saying he can’t defend for poo