Jeromey Webberley [merged]

[gerkin greg]

He's in my 22.
Tuck and Grigg shouldn't be

Happy birthday webbs 

[Coach]

but McG is back

[the claw]

earlier in the yr he was fairly regularly in the bests at coburg. at the time the likes of jackson nahas and edwards were rreally struggling and i felt his form should have been rewarded with a game or two.

he is a good kick but i scratch my head to find what else he brings to the afl table. can anyone name just one outstanding and redeeming attribute in his game, other than being a good kick which lets face it a player of his type and size has to be at afl level.

to me hes a dime a dozen type  that you can find in any state league with  the real killer being his size.
 in saying that his good coburg form should have been rewarded. he should  have been  given the chance to firstly show what hes got this yr and secondly to cement a spot in the team.

[MintOnLamb]

Tucky was a dime a dozen player last year, in fact if he had played this same game this time last year I believe our season would have been different. IF JW is on the list and his form is good at Coburg then he should get a game. Greg Williams wouldn't get a game based on looks and ability on the form sheet, but gee could he play or what!!
If we see enough to draft these players and they perform well at sub AFL then give them a go. In all reality finishing 8th is a waste of time anyway, and at best that is where we will finish, just one more game and in the end, it will mean nothing apart for the long suffering supporters, it is about time we find out what these players have got and what can they bring to the big stage.
I want to finish in top 4, if JW is in our second best 6 players then he will be instrumental in achieving that goal.
Can he grow into an elite player, does he have the skills, do we need him or not, what can he bring to our senior side?
Personally I have some issues with our club's player selection process in that Jackson gets a game week in and week out except for suspension and in reality he is pretty handy for the opposition.
I think there are favourites and players who miss out for one reason or another and others who should be getting a game but miss out due to someone's ego.
End of the day then it is up to our coaches

[JVT]

earlier in the yr he was fairly regularly in the bests at coburg. at the time the likes of jackson nahas and edwards were rreally struggling and i felt his form should have been rewarded with a game or two.

he is a good kick but i scratch my head to find what else he brings to the afl table. can anyone name just one outstanding and redeeming attribute in his game, other than being a good kick which lets face it a player of his type and size has to be at afl level.

to me hes a dime a dozen type  that you can find in any state league with  the real killer being his size.
 in saying that his good coburg form should have been rewarded. he should  have been  given the chance to firstly show what hes got this yr and secondly to cement a spot in the team.

Agree he deserved games early on, from Rounds 1-6 he should have got a few, especially with how Hackson was playing.

I guess the fact he isn't playing now says our list is getting better depth wise, and with all due respect to him, with his skill levels he would be a depth player at best in the better clubs.

[rogerd3]

earlier in the yr he was fairly regularly in the bests at coburg. at the time the likes of jackson nahas and edwards were rreally struggling and i felt his form should have been rewarded with a game or two.

he is a good kick but i scratch my head to find what else he brings to the afl table. can anyone name just one outstanding and redeeming attribute in his game, other than being a good kick which lets face it a player of his type and size has to be at afl level.

to me hes a dime a dozen type  that you can find in any state league with  the real killer being his size.
 in saying that his good coburg form should have been rewarded. he should  have been  given the chance to firstly show what hes got this yr and secondly to cement a spot in the team.

good points made, he should have been given the opportunity whilst he was red hot.

[Danog]

earlier in the yr he was fairly regularly in the bests at coburg. at the time the likes of jackson nahas and edwards were rreally struggling and i felt his form should have been rewarded with a game or two.

he is a good kick but i scratch my head to find what else he brings to the afl table. can anyone name just one outstanding and redeeming attribute in his game, other than being a good kick which lets face it a player of his type and size has to be at afl level.

to me hes a dime a dozen type  that you can find in any state league with  the real killer being his size.
 in saying that his good coburg form should have been rewarded. he should  have been  given the chance to firstly show what hes got this yr and secondly to cement a spot in the team.

Hes a very good linkman.

[Coach]

to me hes a dime a dozen type  that you can find in any state league with  the real killer being his size.

Spot on

[gerkin greg]

Coach sat on his head one day

Was the bottom of a pack but

[Gigantor]

when you have no other options.....you have to play him

[the claw]

Tucky was a dime a dozen player last year, in fact if he had played this same game this time last year I believe our season would have been different. IF JW is on the list and his form is good at Coburg then he should get a game. Greg Williams wouldn't get a game based on looks and ability on the form sheet, but gee could he play or what!!
If we see enough to draft these players and they perform well at sub AFL then give them a go. In all reality finishing 8th is a waste of time anyway, and at best that is where we will finish, just one more game and in the end, it will mean nothing apart for the long suffering supporters, it is about time we find out what these players have got and what can they bring to the big stage.
I want to finish in top 4, if JW is in our second best 6 players then he will be instrumental in achieving that goal.
Can he grow into an elite player, does he have the skills, do we need him or not, what can he bring to our senior side?
Personally I have some issues with our club's player selection process in that Jackson gets a game week in and week out except for suspension and in reality he is pretty handy for the opposition.
I think there are favourites and players who miss out for one reason or another and others who should be getting a game but miss out due to someone's ego.
End of the day then it is up to our coaches

agree with that apart from the dime a dozen comment on tuck.

on tuck. theres not a lot of players who get so much inside ball as him definately not a dime a dozen player.
 his  redeeming attribute has always been his ability to get inside ball and plenty of it.even under wallace he did this well.

 it has been other things that has seen him struggle. things like kicking, decision making, defensive pressure.
 
the silly thing is the way he plays he shouldnt need to kick to often and when he does only within his limitations.  do this and a lot of the decision making is fixed. defensively hes worked hard on this and its no longer a real issue. he does have the odd lapse now and then. the need to win contested ball imo has seen tuck come into his own.
 i would say in this he has always been VERY GOOD if not elite.
to me in this he has always had a role to play and we have not had others who can do this role.
tuck and foley have always been important cogs in the wheel because of their inside work.

[mightytiges]

Last chance for Webbs today you'd reckon. A battle between him and mini Maric to keep their spot next week.

[bojangles17]

Is webberely in the side today as well?

[Bengal]

yep,, it should suit him playing against younger bodies

[tony_montana]

If anybody needed confirmation (again) cannot play at this level