What will be best XXII come mid season?

[Judge Roughneck]

* Cousins, Cotchin, Coughlan, Connors, when fit, all best XXII ?
* Pattison, #2 ruckman
* Johnson, best tagger
* Thomson ? Tambling?

[Danog]

B: Chris Newman, Kelvin Moore, Will Thursfield
HB: Richard Tambling, Luke McGuane, Dean Polo
C: Trent Cotchin, Shane Tuck, Mark Coughlan
HF: Nathan Brown, Matthew Richardson, Jack Riewoldt
F: Mitch Morton, Adam Pattison, Matthew White
Foll: Troy Simmonds, Brett Deledio, Nathan Foley
I/C: Adam Thomson, Tom Hislop, Daniel Connors, Alex Rance
Emg: Andrew Collins, Daniel Jackson, Robin Nahas

I can't find a spot for Cousins, unless Thomson and Hislop are eternally destined to fight for 1 spot.

[mightytiges]

Full forward possie is the ?

B:   Polo            Moore     McGuane
HB: Connors     Rance      Newman
C:    Richo        Deledio     Cotchin
HF:  Brown       Riewoldt   Tambling
F:    Morton       Hughes    White
Foll: Simmonds   Tuck     Foley
I/C: Graham, Hislop, Jackson, Coughlan
Emg: Thursty, Bowden, Schulz

I left Cousins out too until he comes back and shows he is able to play a few games in a row.

[peggles]

good to see everyone leaving johnson out.  hopefully the match committee catches on as well.  team selection shouldn't be based on sentimentals.  game has past him by.  lets face it, he's slow, poor disposal.  the only thing going for him was that he was hard at it.  but we've now gotten some hardnuts like hislop and thomson in the team (also cogs) johnson shouldn't even think about coming back.  retire now i say

[mightytiges]

good to see everyone leaving johnson out.  hopefully the match committee catches on as well.  team selection shouldn't be based on sentimentals.  game has past him by.  lets face it, he's slow, poor disposal.  the only thing going for him was that he was hard at it.  but we've now gotten some hardnuts like hislop and thomson in the team (also cogs) johnson shouldn't even think about coming back.  retire now i say

I left Sugar out because he's injured. 8 weeks more out after missing the past month would mean he'll be very underdone by the time he does comes back. At best for Sugar would be a round 15-16 return. The season is 3/4 gone by then.

[Judge Roughneck]

I would like to see:

Moore McGaune Polo
Newman Rance Tambling
Cotchin Deledio Tuck
Richo Reiwoldt Brown
Cousins Pattison Morton
Simmonds Coughlan Foley
Connors Thomson White Hislop

Collins - Post - Edwards

[Judge Roughneck]

Out

King
Schultz
Edwards
Bowden
Jackson
Graham

Hislop?
Tambling?
McGaune?



 

[wayne]

OUT

Bowden
Brown
Simmonds
Tambling
King
Schulz

[TigerLand]

B: Newman - Thursfield - Polo
HB: McGuane - Moore - Rance
C: Richardson - Tuck - Deledio
HF: Brown - Riewoldt - White
FF: Connors - Pattison - Morton

R: Simmonds - Foley - Coughlan

INT: Cousins - Hislop - Collins - Tambling

[Tigermonk]

still dreaming about teams
75% of our side is so far under developed it wont matter who is in the team
these players cannot adapt to modern game AFL
we are the whipping boys, The St-Kilda of the last era
we are poo

[Go Richo 12]

We we really need the Cleaver to fire. We are impotent up forward. I want to see Jack Riewoldt on a wing ala Richo!

[Tigermonk]

anybody who puts Troy Simmonds in thier team has lost reality
Serious his the worst Ruckman going around the AFL
He cannot keep playing injured

[Tigermonk]

We we really need the Cleaver to fire. We are impotent up forward. I want to see Jack Riewoldt on a wing ala Richo!

Start Vickery in the goals this weekend & break him in at 200mm he give us some height & something to shoot at

[WilliamPowell]

Start Vickery in the goals this weekend & break him in at 200mm he give us some height & something to shoot at

He played Coburg ressies last week Monk

Somehow I don't think he is ready... actually after watching him I know he aint ready

[Tigermonk]

l was away last weekend so l missed alot of footy action
but l would chuck him in