One-Eyed Richmond Forum

Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on July 06, 2013, 05:02:44 PM

Title: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 06, 2013, 05:02:44 PM
Ivan hopefully will be back  :pray

Fire away ....?  :help
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Simonator on July 06, 2013, 05:04:20 PM
Injuries ?

Jackson
Ellis


Bring in Arnott and Tuck for these two. Bring in Astbury for Batch
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Rampstar on July 06, 2013, 05:05:37 PM
Out  Jackson (inj) Stephenson,Batchelor and White all ommitted
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 06, 2013, 05:08:20 PM
We've already lost next week's game
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Rampstar on July 06, 2013, 05:09:22 PM
We've already lost next week's game

If we lose next week their will be no finals for us in 2013  :'(
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Ruanaidh on July 06, 2013, 05:10:14 PM
Out  Jackson (inj) Stephenson,Batchelor and White all ommitted
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack
Would agree with all those bar White, who had a crack. Would add Vlaustin to the outs if his form today was caused by a lingering injury.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 06, 2013, 05:15:14 PM
We've already lost next week's game

If we lose next week their will be no finals for us in 2013  :'(

We'll lose... It's our destiny
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Dubstep Dookie on July 06, 2013, 06:10:59 PM
McBean and Arnots in

Take your pick for outs
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: TigerLand on July 06, 2013, 06:25:00 PM
Out: Stephenson, Dea, Jackson, McBean
In: I.Maric, Houli, Tuck, Edwards




Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Lozza on July 06, 2013, 06:25:22 PM
Have a horrid feeling that Arnot/Tuck will get injured tomorrow. After watching todays games it how our luck is running, couldn't take a trick today.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: The Big Richo on July 06, 2013, 06:29:19 PM
Out: Hardwick

In: John Northey
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: yellowandback on July 06, 2013, 07:45:00 PM
Out: Stephenson, Dea, Jackson, McBean
In: I.Maric, Houli, Tuck, Edwards

Sheesh, McBean is stiff!
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: dwaino on July 06, 2013, 08:07:41 PM
Out: Stephenson, Dea, Jackson, McBean
In: I.Maric, Houli, Tuck, Edwards

Sheesh, McBean is stiff!

 :lol
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Eat_em_Alive on July 06, 2013, 08:15:34 PM
Where was houli today? Injured? Got to the game 5 mins in and saw dea running Around instead
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: WilliamPowell on July 06, 2013, 08:20:19 PM
Can you drop 18 no make that 22  :banghead

INS: Maric, Tuck, Houli, Arnot

OUTS: Stephenson, Dea, Bathelor, Jackson (inj)

Alot of blokes are very lucky
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: bojangles17 on July 06, 2013, 08:38:34 PM
Out  Jackson (inj) Stephenson,Batchelor and White all ommitted
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack
White was prob amongst our best with 19 possies and 2 goals...did you see the game   ::)
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: TigerLand on July 06, 2013, 08:40:47 PM
Out: Stephenson, Dea, Jackson, McBean
In: I.Maric, Houli, Tuck, Edwards

Sheesh, McBean is stiff!

Lol, very stiff lol
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: TigerLand on July 06, 2013, 08:41:26 PM
Can you drop 18 no make that 22  :banghead

INS: Maric, Tuck, Houli, Arnot

OUTS: Stephenson, Dea, Bathelor, Jackson (inj)

Alot of blokes are very lucky

Thought of you today WP. I know how much you hate North.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Smokey on July 06, 2013, 08:42:07 PM
Out   White
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack

Gee Ramps, think that's harsh.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: WilliamPowell on July 06, 2013, 08:46:34 PM

Out   White
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack

You've got to be joking Ramps

Matty White is one player who always has a crack, did again today pity some of his more credentialed team mates didn't show the same the same intensity

Thought of you today WP. I know how much you hate North.

Was a very bad day. Could see a loss coming 20 minutes into the 1st qtr but not that sort of loss

Pathetic

Terrific, just terrific TM
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Eat_em_Alive on July 07, 2013, 08:02:16 AM
If anything Matty white derserves a full game and at the least the supersub spot.
Would hope to bring in maric, houli, tuck, arnott, mcbean/griff and a better attitude
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Jackstar is back!!! on July 07, 2013, 10:51:00 AM
Outs.   Stephenson, Dea , Batchelor  Vlastin
Ins.     Maric  ,       Houli    Petterd    Tuck.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Gigantor on July 07, 2013, 11:01:01 AM
I understand people wanting to bring in Griff.he has all the attributes,tall,strong,thumping kick etc.All I ask is that people go and watch him in the magoos,he cant get near the pill.I reckon if they shoved a heat seeking device in the blasted thing he would still avoid it.
More than  anyone on our playing list I hope he makes it, because talls that can roost the pill 60 metres all the time ,only come along once every decade or so I reckon
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 07, 2013, 11:03:26 AM
Out  Jackson (inj) Stephenson,Batchelor and White all ommitted
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack
White was prob amongst our best with 19 possies and 2 goals...did you see the game   ::)

White is not good enough to play 25% + game time
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 07, 2013, 11:03:54 AM
out

white
king
jackson
orren
grigg
aaron edwards
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Tigeritis™©® on July 07, 2013, 11:09:01 AM
After playing North with 4 goal Tarrant 24y/o and 3 goal Black 22y/o as well as 15 mark Hansen 24y/o teaching our team a valuable lesson;
It pays to play youngsters & give them games.

Lockup has done ok but it's a waste of time and yesterday showed us why.

We still don't know if Griffiths, Elton are worth persisting with.

With Petrie in his 30s North don't have those questions about their youngsters.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Simonator on July 07, 2013, 11:13:15 AM
Although he doesnt deserve it according to his VFL form ( havent heard from the latest game ) I recon it might be worth bringing Griffiths up for batch, were going to have to see what hes made of at some time right?
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Gigantor on July 07, 2013, 11:17:49 AM
If anything bring Elton up,hes shown more than griff
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 07, 2013, 11:38:51 AM
Did

Hansen
 Black
 Tarrent

have to prove them self at VFL?

 I doubt it.

They were played cause high draft picks
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Rampstar on July 07, 2013, 11:53:23 AM
Out  Jackson (inj) Stephenson,Batchelor and White all ommitted
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack
White was prob amongst our best with 19 possies and 2 goals...did you see the game   ::)

White is not good enough to play 25% + game time

And thats the exact reason why he needs to go back to Coburg. IMHO you cant have a player who is a specialist sub which is what he is becoming. You need someone who can do good things over the course of the match. Not just the last quarter ans Matty has never been able to do it over the course of whole games on a consistent basis.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: eliminator on July 07, 2013, 11:53:50 AM
Maric, Houli, Tuck and biscuit in
Out Ellis(inj), A Edwards, Stephenson and Dea

There is merit in dropping Batchelor but who do you bring in . If Batchelor is dropped would consider Griffiths Astbury or Elton.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Hellenic Tiger on July 07, 2013, 12:03:27 PM

Out   White
In - Anybody prepared to have a fair dinkum crack

You've got to be joking Ramps

Matty White is one player who always has a crack, did again today pity some of his more credentialed team mates didn't show the same the same intensity

Thought of you today WP. I know how much you hate North.

Was a very bad day. Could see a loss coming 20 minutes into the 1st qtr but not that sort of loss

Pathetic

Terrific, just terrific TM

Coming out and running through the banner I quipped with a friend they had no intensity.
Some where laughing and talking to one another and walked through the banner.
Terrible.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Tigeritis™©® on July 07, 2013, 01:04:16 PM
Did Hansen. Black? Torrent have to prove them self?

 I doubt it.

They were played cause high draft picks
I agree.  Sometimes you just have to play them.

Elton 20y/o round 1 pick 26 (2011) 1 games.
Griffiths 21y/o round 2 pick 19. (2009) 19 games

Black 22 y/o round 2 pick 25 (2009) 14 games
Vickery 23 y/o round 1 pick 8 (2008) 67 games
Tarrant 23 y/o round 1 pick 15 (2007) 30 games
Rance 23 y/o round 1 pick 18 (2007) 80 games
Hansen 24 y/o round 1 pick 3 (2006) 91 games
Riewoldt 24 y/o round 1 pick 13 (2006) 126 games.

Some guys just get games even when sometimes they struggle and lets face it we've seen it from Vickery and Rance.
It's time to put some games into the youngens. Griff is Ready.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Jackstar is back!!! on July 07, 2013, 08:51:27 PM
Maric, Houli, Tuck and biscuit in
Out Ellis(inj), A Edwards, Stephenson and Dea

There is merit in dropping Batchelor but who do you bring in . If Batchelor is dropped would consider Griffiths Astbury or Elton.

Petterd
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Chuck17 on July 07, 2013, 09:02:13 PM
Lol at peturd bombing it in with those precision helicopter kicks, just what we need

Dr Jack is back in da house
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Dubstep Dookie on July 07, 2013, 09:04:40 PM
Maric, Houli, Tuck and biscuit in
Out Ellis(inj), A Edwards, Stephenson and Dea

There is merit in dropping Batchelor but who do you bring in . If Batchelor is dropped would consider Griffiths Astbury or Elton.

Petterd

Get real
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: the claw on July 07, 2013, 10:31:12 PM
nothing hs changed for me.
structure needs to be the following and it doesnt neccesarily have to be the following tall players.
b/  #### - chaplin - astbury
hb/ ####  - rance - ####  so that is one tall in astbury in. would play morris vlastuin and dea as the sml/med backs.

hf #### - riewoldt - #### .
f/ vickery - griffiths/mcguane/mcbean - #### .  in one of griffiths,mcguane,or mcbean, vickery plays as the floating ruckman forward. when hes in the ruck we at the least maintain two genuine kpfs. we could then use aaron  edwards as a medium.
 would look to have s edwards play more as a sml forwrd and seeing as there are no other options kingy is the best of a bad lot to keep his place.


r/  maric - #### - ####  obviously in ivan who  changes with his ruck partner vickery both forward and on the bench.

mids onballers
cotchin, deledio, tuck,martin,foley, ellis, newman, conca, arnot, houli.

ins would go - astbury, maric,tuck houli one of griffiths, mcbean,mcguane.

outs would go batchelor, white, stephenson, jackson grigg.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: mightytiges on July 08, 2013, 05:05:37 AM
Out: Stephenson, Dea, Ellis (inj.)

In:  Maric, Houli, Tuck
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Penelope on July 08, 2013, 08:16:16 AM
Did Hansen. Black? Torrent have to prove them self?

 I doubt it.

They were played cause high draft picks
I agree.  Sometimes you just have to play them.

Elton 20y/o round 1 pick 26 (2011) 1 games.
Griffiths 21y/o round 2 pick 19. (2009) 19 games

Black 22 y/o round 2 pick 25 (2009) 14 games
Vickery 23 y/o round 1 pick 8 (2008) 67 games
Tarrant 23 y/o round 1 pick 15 (2007) 30 games
Rance 23 y/o round 1 pick 18 (2007) 80 games
Hansen 24 y/o round 1 pick 3 (2006) 91 games
Riewoldt 24 y/o round 1 pick 13 (2006) 126 games.

Some guys just get games even when sometimes they struggle and lets face it we've seen it from Vickery and Rance.
It's time to put some games into the youngens. Griff is Ready.
The strange thing is these stats counter your argument.

The blokes you have listed have averaged more games per year of service than these blokes you reckon didnt have to earn their spot in the seconds for north.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: dwaino on July 08, 2013, 10:10:19 AM
In: Petterd, Arnot, Griffiths
Out: Cotchin, Dea, Riewoldt
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 08, 2013, 10:45:30 AM
Ellis should play. Big boy Mcevoy copped a heaver knock and played. Don't get soft Tigers
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Stripes on July 08, 2013, 11:00:07 AM
Out: Stephenson, Dea, Ellis (inj.)

In:  Maric, Houli, Tuck

My choices too. Only question mark I have is Ellis is an outside runner while Tuck is an inside extractor. Maybe just a couple of role swaps on the day but otherwise good selections for mine.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Tigeritis™©® on July 08, 2013, 11:16:32 AM
Did Hansen. Black? Torrent have to prove them self?

 I doubt it.

They were played cause high draft picks
I agree.  Sometimes you just have to play them.

Elton 20y/o round 1 pick 26 (2011) 1 games.
Griffiths 21y/o round 2 pick 19. (2009) 19 games

Black 22 y/o round 2 pick 25 (2009) 14 games
Vickery 23 y/o round 1 pick 8 (2008) 67 games
Tarrant 23 y/o round 1 pick 15 (2007) 30 games
Rance 23 y/o round 1 pick 18 (2007) 80 games
Hansen 24 y/o round 1 pick 3 (2006) 91 games
Riewoldt 24 y/o round 1 pick 13 (2006) 126 games.

Some guys just get games even when sometimes they struggle and lets face it we've seen it from Vickery and Rance.
It's time to put some games into the youngens. Griff is Ready.
The strange thing is these stats counter your argument.

The blokes you have listed have averaged more games per year of service than these blokes you reckon didnt have to earn their spot in the seconds for north.
Your probably right Al.  :lol
But my point is that some guys are given games ie. Reiwoldt, Vickery, Hansen, early in their careers despite having poor performances.
Who thought Jack was ever going to be more than a third tall? I didn't.
Vickery is still frustrating. Hansen despite poor performances has finally showed something down back.
Scott said if they didn't give his guys a shot they'd be still playing reserves. That's why they made the decision to trade Lockup. Actually the decision was made after they got thrashed by the dawks last year. Now because of this they are forced to play those guys and ultimately they develop quicker.
The same could be said for Roughhead at the dawks and Hawkins at Geelong. It took them a while but they were better off playing regular senior footy.
Lockup may get us to finals but after he's finished we are still waiting on Griffiths/Elton/McBean.
IMO Griffiths should be tried as the third tall to fast track his development and help the team dynamics for the future.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: lamington on July 08, 2013, 11:58:11 AM
We need Dylan Grimes back desperately. That is all.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 08, 2013, 12:03:15 PM
Richmond's reality-check defeat to North Melbourne was compounded by an ankle injury to Daniel Jackson, the late withdrawal of Bachar Houli with a hamstring issue, and the accidental concussion of promising youngster Brandon Ellis.

The trio is in doubt for the Tigers' clash with Gold Coast at Cazaly's Stadium, where they are winless from two encounters with the Suns.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-08/out-or-doubt-for-stars
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 08, 2013, 12:06:20 PM
Richmond's reality-check defeat to North Melbourne was compounded by an ankle injury to Daniel Jackson, the late withdrawal of Bachar Houli with a hamstring issue, and the accidental concussion of promising youngster Brandon Ellis.

The trio is in doubt for the Tigers' clash with Gold Coast at Cazaly's Stadium, where they are winless from two encounters with the Suns.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-08/out-or-doubt-for-stars

Lol no Ellis, Houli or Jacko. Might as well not show up.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: gerkin greg on July 08, 2013, 12:09:03 PM
two squibs and a dud, my how things have changed
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 08, 2013, 05:09:06 PM
The Barometer - Round 16
Herald-Sun
Monday, July 8 2013


RICHMOND

ON THE BLOCK:
Brandon Ellis was substituted out of the heavy loss to the Roos with concussion. He must pass tests this week but should be deemed fit to face the Suns. Nick Vlastuin returned but struggled to have an impact, while Matt Dea didn’t have his best day. Orren Stephenson will only survive if Maric doesn’t come up.

ON THE CUSP:
IF Damien Hardwick wants a good, solid big-bodied midfielder to strengthen his engine room against the young Suns then Shane Tuck is his man. The veteran collected 30 disposals for Coburg in the VFL and again impressed with his attitude and leadership. Luke McGuane booted a pair of goals while Maric is an outside chance of returning from a groin strain. Houli said on Sunday he should be fine to return for Multicultural Round.

SAM LANDSBERGER’S FORECAST:
PAUL Roos reckons the Tigers played the worst 47 seconds in footy history 12 months ago when they somehow squandered a lead against Gold Coast in Cairns. The Tigers are 0-2 against the Suns at the tropical spot and Saturday will end their deal to play home games up there for good. If it ends in another loss the Tigers will lose a huge chunk of credibility – and it could spell trouble with Sydney (away) and Hawthorn to follow.

http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/the-barometer-whos-hurt-and-whos-in-line-stuff-1226675920493
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Coach on July 08, 2013, 05:10:17 PM
two squibs and a dud, my how things have changed

Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: lamington on July 08, 2013, 06:13:52 PM
I don't suppose Richo could come into our forward line to provide another marking option?
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 08, 2013, 06:21:54 PM
Ivan, Houli and Jacko expected to be right to play this week; Ellis to be tested.

http://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/2013-07-08/key-tigers-in-the-frame-for-gold-coast-clash
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: RedanTiger on July 08, 2013, 07:29:06 PM
Richmond's reality-check defeat to North Melbourne was compounded by an ankle injury to Daniel Jackson, the late withdrawal of Bachar Houli with a hamstring issue, and the accidental concussion of promising youngster Brandon Ellis.

The trio is in doubt for the Tigers' clash with Gold Coast at Cazaly's Stadium, where they are winless from two encounters with the Suns.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-08/out-or-doubt-for-stars

Straight swaps.
Jackson for Tuck
Houli for Petterd
Ellis for Arnot

Also Maric for Stephenson.

Doubt it would happen though. Those changes would be picking a team on form rather than the pets.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: 1965 on July 08, 2013, 07:37:10 PM
two squibs and a dud, my how things have changed



Good comment Coach

 :lol
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Hellenic Tiger on July 08, 2013, 08:11:31 PM
Richmond's reality-check defeat to North Melbourne was compounded by an ankle injury to Daniel Jackson, the late withdrawal of Bachar Houli with a hamstring issue, and the accidental concussion of promising youngster Brandon Ellis.

The trio is in doubt for the Tigers' clash with Gold Coast at Cazaly's Stadium, where they are winless from two encounters with the Suns.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-08/out-or-doubt-for-stars

Straight swaps.
Jackson for Tuck
Houli for Petterd
Ellis for Arnot

Also Maric for Stephenson.

Doubt it would happen though. Those changes would be picking a team on form rather than the pets.

Petterd didn't play against Nort Reds. You mean Dea. :laugh:
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: MintOnLamb on July 09, 2013, 09:51:40 AM
RFC site states
"And in-form midfielder Daniel Jackson is expected to be fit to play the Suns, despite being hampered by an ankle injury in the match against the Kangaroos."
Thank god. We may as well put Nahas and McGuane back in as well.

For my money if Tuck doesn't play this week they can stick their club up their back side. Arnott should be in as well. We were as weak as urine last week. My grandmother has more fight in her and she's been dead 3 years.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 09, 2013, 11:20:04 AM
They will make Tuck retire 10 years early.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 09, 2013, 01:23:01 PM
In the mix: round 16

Nathan Schmook
afl.com.au
Tuesday, July 9, 2013


Richmond

Half-back Bachar Houli, who was a late withdrawal against the North Melbourne, is expected to return from hamstring soreness for Saturday night's clash against Gold Coast in Cairns. Ruckman Ivan Maric is also set for inclusion after two weeks on the sidelines because of a groin strain. Stoppage specialist Shane Tuck has returned from a shoulder injury through the VFL and appears ready for an AFL recall, while Matthew Arnot and Ricky Petterd have pressed strong claims with Coburg. Brandon Ellis will need to pass a concussion test this week, while Daniel Jackson (ankle) is expected to be fit.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-09/afls-in-the-mix-round-16
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 09, 2013, 01:31:05 PM
In the mix: round 16

Nathan Schmook
afl.com.au
Tuesday, July 9, 2013


Richmond

Half-back Bachar Houli, who was a late withdrawal against the North Melbourne, is expected to return from hamstring soreness for Saturday night's clash against Gold Coast in Cairns. Ruckman Ivan Maric is also set for inclusion after two weeks on the sidelines because of a groin strain. Stoppage specialist Shane Tuck has returned from a shoulder injury through the VFL and appears ready for an AFL recall, while Matthew Arnot and Ricky Petterd have pressed strong claims with Coburg. Brandon Ellis will need to pass a concussion test this week, while Daniel Jackson (ankle) is expected to be fit.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-07-09/afls-in-the-mix-round-16

Any idea how they do the concussion test?
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 09, 2013, 01:52:35 PM
Any idea how they do the concussion test?
All the players do the test prior to the season IIRC to calibrate their "normal" state. So when they do the test again after suffering concussion, the doctor can compare and see if the player has suffered any ill effects from a knock to the head.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Phil Mrakov on July 09, 2013, 01:56:08 PM
Any idea how they do the concussion test?
All the players do the test prior to the season IIRC to calibrate their "normal" state. So when they do the test again after suffering concussion, the doctor can compare and see if the player has suffered any ill effects from a knock to the head.

And Chappy failed it after the pies game?
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Muscles on July 09, 2013, 07:31:00 PM
.... and Ramadan started today, so that will impact Houli in the Cairns heat ....
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: WilliamPowell on July 09, 2013, 08:09:41 PM
.... and Ramadan started today, so that will impact Houli in the Cairns heat ....

I remember him (Houli) mentioning last year that under certain conditions in particular with regard to employment and being able undertake his job properly he can get special permission to break the fasting for short periods
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: the claw on July 09, 2013, 09:34:47 PM
b/ morris - chaplin - rance
hb/ ellis  - astbury - vlastuin
c/ deledio - tuck - ellis
hf/ newman - riewoldt - martin
f/  vickery - mcbean -  s edwards
r/ maric - cotchin -  foley
int/  a edwards  - arnot - conca - houli

wont happen.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Tiger Tragic on July 09, 2013, 09:48:58 PM
b/ morris - chaplin - rance
hb/ ellis  - astbury - vlastuin
c/ deledio - tuck - ellis
hf/ newman - riewoldt - martin
f/  vickery - mcbean -  s edwards
r/ maric - cotchin -  foley
int/  a edwards  - arnot - conca - houli

wont happen.

Good team claw.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 10, 2013, 12:12:57 AM
nothing hs changed for me.
structure needs to be the following and it doesnt neccesarily have to be the following tall players.
b/  #### - chaplin - astbury
hb/ ####  - rance - ####  so that is one tall in astbury in. would play morris vlastuin and dea as the sml/med backs.

hf #### - riewoldt - #### .
f/ vickery - griffiths/mcguane/mcbean - #### .  in one of griffiths,mcguane,or mcbean, vickery plays as the floating ruckman forward. when hes in the ruck we at the least maintain two genuine kpfs. we could then use aaron  edwards as a medium.
 would look to have s edwards play more as a sml forwrd and seeing as there are no other options kingy is the best of a bad lot to keep his place.


r/  maric - #### - ####  obviously in ivan who  changes with his ruck partner vickery both forward and on the bench.

mids onballers
cotchin, deledio, tuck,martin,foley, ellis, newman, conca, arnot, houli.

ins would go - astbury, maric,tuck houli one of griffiths, mcbean,mcguane.

outs would go batchelor, white, stephenson, jackson grigg.

I agree with the need for three proper talls at each end.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 10, 2013, 12:13:39 AM
.... and Ramadan started today, so that will impact Houli in the Cairns heat ....

I remember him (Houli) mentioning last year that under certain conditions in particular with regard to employment and being able undertake his job properly he can get special permission to break the fasting for short periods

From God?
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 10, 2013, 12:18:24 AM
b/ morris - chaplin - rance
hb/ ellis  - astbury - vlastuin
c/ deledio - tuck - ellis
hf/ newman - riewoldt - martin
f/  vickery - mcbean -  s edwards
r/ maric - cotchin -  foley
int/  a edwards  - arnot - conca - houli

wont happen.

This is my overall best 22.

If Grimes was fit I would play him but I like Astbury as the first replacment.

If Knights was fit he would get Aaron Edwards spot. Given the current situation I would Helbig or McDonut.

b/ morris - chaplin - rance
hb/ ellis  - astbury/or Grimes - vlastuin
c/ deledio - tuck - ellis
hf/ newman - riewoldt - martin
f/  vickery - mcbean/or Griffiths -  s edwards
r/ maric - cotchin -  foley
int/   - arnot - conca - houli

no aaron edwards -

great minds think alike..  8)



Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 10, 2013, 12:23:39 AM
b/ morris - chaplin - rance
hb/ ellis  - astbury - vlastuin
c/ deledio - tuck - ellis
hf/ newman - riewoldt - martin
f/  vickery - mcbean -  s edwards
r/ maric - cotchin -  foley
int/  a edwards  - arnot - conca - houli

wont happen.

 :-X


Rance - Grimes - Morris
Ellis - Chaplin - Houli
Vlastuin - Tuck - Conca
S Edwards - Riewoldt - Arnot
McBean - Vickery - Martin
Maric - Deledio - Cotchin
Knights - NEwman - Foley
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: dwaino on July 10, 2013, 12:39:22 PM
In: Cousins
Out: Cotchin

http://www.richmondfc.com.au/club/events/tommy-hafey-club.workstation
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 11, 2013, 12:08:20 PM
nothing hs changed for me.
structure needs to be the following and it doesnt neccesarily have to be the following tall players.
b/  #### - chaplin - astbury
hb/ ####  - rance - ####  so that is one tall in astbury in. would play morris vlastuin and dea as the sml/med backs.

hf #### - riewoldt - #### .
f/ vickery - griffiths/mcguane/mcbean - #### .  in one of griffiths,mcguane,or mcbean, vickery plays as the floating ruckman forward. when hes in the ruck we at the least maintain two genuine kpfs. we could then use aaron  edwards as a medium.
 would look to have s edwards play more as a sml forwrd and seeing as there are no other options kingy is the best of a bad lot to keep his place.


r/  maric - #### - ####  obviously in ivan who  changes with his ruck partner vickery both forward and on the bench.

mids onballers
cotchin, deledio, tuck,martin,foley, ellis, newman, conca, arnot, houli.

ins would go - astbury, maric,tuck houli one of griffiths, mcbean,mcguane.

outs would go batchelor, white, stephenson, jackson grigg.

good post
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Ruanaidh on July 11, 2013, 12:30:44 PM
Why are observers (myself included) differing so much from the selection panel.......ipso facto - game-plan first, players to suit that game-plan second. We haven't bought into the current game-plan as it hasn't reaped rewards against quality sides. The next 4 weeks will tell if it lives or dies.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: Judge Roughneck on July 11, 2013, 01:29:11 PM
Why are observers (myself included) differing so much from the selection panel.......ipso facto - game-plan first, players to suit that game-plan second. We haven't bought into the current game-plan as it hasn't reaped rewards against quality sides. The next 4 weeks will tell if it lives or dies.

I would argue that due to injury and selection decisions - we at time at missing half our our best 22.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 11, 2013, 03:04:06 PM
Richmond v Gold Coast

Coming off their worst loss of the season expect Damien Hardwick to ring the changes for the trip to Cairns to take on bogey side Gold Coast. Brandon Ellis is touch and go after being concussed, while Matt Dea was quiet and Daniel Jackson is battling an ankle issue. First-year player Nick Vlastuin appears to have hit a wall and looks likely to be sent back to the VFL. Big inclusions with Bachar Houli, Shane Tuck and Ivan Maric all set to play.

An even bigger inclusion for the Suns though with captain Gary Ablett to play after missing last week's loss with a calf injury. Sam Day will miss with a groin injury with Matthew Warnock and Seb Tape in line to replace the key position player.

http://www.sportal.com.au/news-display/afl-team-whispersround-16-243232
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: one-eyed on July 11, 2013, 03:18:02 PM
Coburg have a bye this weekend due to the VFL split round. So whoever gets dropped will be having the weekend off along with the rest of our non-22ers.
Title: Re: Changes for next week's game against the Suns?
Post by: eliminator on July 11, 2013, 04:46:57 PM
Richmond v Gold Coast

Coming off their worst loss of the season expect Damien Hardwick to ring the changes for the trip to Cairns to take on bogey side Gold Coast. Brandon Ellis is touch and go after being concussed, while Matt Dea was quiet and Daniel Jackson is battling an ankle issue. First-year player Nick Vlastuin appears to have hit a wall and looks likely to be sent back to the VFL. Big inclusions with Bachar Houli, Shane Tuck and Ivan Maric all set to play.

An even bigger inclusion for the Suns though with captain Gary Ablett to play after missing last week's loss with a calf injury. Sam Day will miss with a groin injury with Matthew Warnock and Seb Tape in line to replace the key position player.


http://www.sportal.com.au/news-display/afl-team-whispersround-16-243232


Afl website saying Houli going to miss



Edited to correct quote