One-Eyed Richmond Forum
Football => Richmond Rant => Topic started by: one-eyed on November 30, 2022, 03:15:27 PM
-
(https://www.theadvocate.com.au/images/transform/v1/crop/frm/117478009/9ff8a81c-5f42-4d67-b68a-bbe91eb9c6f6.JPG/r0_0_4000_2667_w1200_h678_fmax.jpg)
Mid-forward
Height: 182cm
Weight: 73kg
D.O.B: 29-12-2004
-
Video highlights:
Watch here: https://twitter.com/AFL/status/1597806103248584707
Tasmanian Seth Campbell has been picked up by the Tigers as a rookie.
He can play all over the ground but performed best as a half-forward.
-
SNAPSHOT: “A clever and crafty forward who works opponents over up the ground, and hurts them on the way back to goal.”
A late addition to the National Combine list, Seth Campbell has been made to prove himself in 2022. The Burnie native emerged as one to watch after Tasmania’s Under 17 clash with Queensland last year, and quickly became a key cog in the Devils’ mid-forward rotation as a top-ager.
Campbell averaged 19 touches, 4.7 inside 50s and over a goal per his 13 NAB League games this season, earning Allies selection and even breaking through for a senior TSL berth with North Launceston. It was there where he produced arguably his standout performance, booting 10.6 from 32 disposals to leap firmly onto the draft radar.
https://central.rookieme.com/afl/player/seth-campbell/
-
(https://resources.richmondfc.com.au/photo-resources/2022/11/30/cfacf165-2d90-40d5-9d36-e19637cd419d/2022-NAB-AFL-DRAFT_Article-3-.png?width=952&height=592)
Campbell joins Richmond via rookie draft
Richmond has used its first selection in the 2022 rookie draft (No. 12 overall) to recruit Tasmania Devils high forward/midfielder Seth Campbell.
Recruited from: Tasmanian Devils
Position: High forward/midfielder
Height: 182cm
Weight: 73kg
DOB: 29/12/2004
What the Richmond recruiters say about Campbell...
"Seth originally played his football with the Burnie Football Club before playing senior football with North Launceston in 2022.
"He was a strong contributor for his Tasmania U18 NAB League side, playing 13 games this year as a running midfielder and averaging 19 disposals while kicking 16 goals. His form was rewarded with selection into the Allies U18 team where he played three matches, his best game coming against South Australia where he recorded 15 disposals and two goals.
"He also managed 10.6 from 32 disposals at senior level in just his third league game for North Launceston earlier this year.
"We like his footy smarts, running strength and ball use. He has class with his feet while also seeing the game well to get into dangerous positions in the flow of play. He is a dangerous goalkicker."
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1253051/campbell-joins-richmond-via-rookie-draft/
-
Again not really sure this is what we needed, although the club maintains we draft on talent only.
We have a surplus of mids now with Taranto and Hopper coming in.
Cumberland, MRJ, Bolton our first in small forwards. Clarke and Castagna in the magoos.
Good luck to him but meh, still leaves me feeling exposed about our KPF stocks.
-
another small another safe bet who may get senior games but will be nothing special.
-
Seth Campbell kicks 10 goals
Burnie's Seth Campbell was in fine for for Launceston after being name a late selection for the national AFL draft combine
Watch here: https://www.msn.com/en-au/entertainment/tv/seth-campbell-kicks-10-goals/vi-AA10HA6P?ocid=UE09DHP%2CUE09DHP&category=foryou
-
https://www.instagram.com/p/Clk4D6OP2fF/
-
‘Family bleeds yellow and black’: Tassie draftee ready for Tiger Land
Up until this week he’d clashed with his family over their support of Richmond, but this Tassie AFL draftee says he’ll have no issues joining the Tiger Train as he begins his dream AFL career.
https://www.themercury.com.au/sport/he-bled-red-black-and-white-but-now-campbell-is-ready-to-join-the-bandwagon-at-punt-rd/news-story/3d01bdcfef6c2eac344e3ad7e4162813
-
Tassie Devils coach Jeromey Webberley believes Seth Campbell is an ideal fit for Richmond, who secured the services of the talented, young forward via the AFL’s rookie draft earlier this week.
Campbell produced a string of impressive performances for the Tassie Devils in the NAB League competition throughout the 2022 season.
Webberley, who played 16 senior games with Richmond from 2010-12, envisages the 17-year-old eventually having a significant impact at Tigerland.
“Seth is an exciting prospect,” Webberley told The Mercury newspaper.
“He’s small (182cm, 73kg), but he’s got really good leg speed and endurance and loves a goal . . . he kicked 10.6 in a state league game against North Hobart.
“His last two years have been outstanding in the Devils program. This year he had some awesome games.
“He’s going to provide a lot of excitement for Richmond in their forward half. He’s a real Richmond type player with that leg speed and defensive pressure, and a really nice finisher.
“I’m really excited about what Seth is going to deliver at Richmond.”
https://www.themercury.com.au/sport/he-bled-red-black-and-white-but-now-campbell-is-ready-to-join-the-bandwagon-at-punt-rd/news-story/3d01bdcfef6c2eac344e3ad7e4162813
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1254046/former-tassie-tiger-hails-new-tassie-tiger
-
First day at Tigerland.
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FjKty9XVsAI624Y?format=jpg&name=large)
https://twitter.com/Richmond_FC/status/1599531923558518784
-
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/450/2022/12/05/1025906.jpg)
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/450/2022/12/05/1025903.jpg)
(https://www.aflphotos.com.au/images/thumbs/800/2022/12/05/1025928.jpg)
-
"I'm so stoked to be out here and to play alongside some Tassie boys".
📹 We caught up with new Tiger Seth Campbell.
Watch here: https://twitter.com/Richmond_FC/status/1600697172538064896
-
It was in just his third game of senior football with Tasmanian club North Launceston that Seth Campbell produced one of the best-ever performances by a young player in the TSL competition.
Playing against North Hobart at North Hobart Oval late in the 2022 home-and-away season, the clever forward, who has been likened to veteran Hawthorn star Luke Breust, racked up 32 disposals and kicked 10 goals (10.6).
Highlights here: https://twitter.com/TasStateLeague/status/1559424180457992192
Full article here: https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1257558/seth-s-spectacular-scoring-spree
-
Of our newbies, Seth was the one that stood out today for mine. Seemed to work hard off the ball to run to the right spots to create options and with the ball finished off well kicking a couple of goals.
-
Off to hospital with that lower leg/ankle injury :(.
-
Poor bastard's cursed.... :facepalm
-
To go straight to hospital you'd think it might be broken
-
another small another safe bet who may get senior games but will be nothing special.
If i could id like to retract that statement. Ive watched him as best i can and done a bit of digging since that post.
Yes he is a small and as such as a late pick a likely safe bet but i keep going back to some glimpses here and there and i think he has a fair bit to offer. You see Some things and they just stick in the mind if people can get that.
-
Took notice of small fwd #SethCampbell's fine 3rd place finish in the recent 2km time trial. The 19yr old livewire was showing plenty at the start of last season before his untimely injury. Seems past his issues now & has put in the work. Can't wait to see his game unleashed.
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GD7Szn9bgAAPXU6?format=jpg&name=medium)
https://twitter.com/Tigers_of_Old/status/1747066956073906451
-
Has a touch of class does Seth and his off the ball work is sensational. Hope he plays games this year.
-
Has a touch of class does Seth and his off the ball work is sensational. Hope he plays games this year.
If we are serious he should be starting in the fwd half and the aim should be he plays all year unless form warrants otherwise.
-
All the best to Seth in his debut on the weekend :clapping.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/video/1501510/campbell-phones-friends-and-family
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1501016/campbell-to-debut-against-suns
-
Know jack poo about him and wouldn’t pretend otherwise
But one thing is obvious , he’s well liked by his teammates
And off that footage, he seems like such a great young kid, with a lovely family
Good luck young fella , do the jumper proud
-
Really happy for this bloke :clapping
Battled some tough injuries last year, his first in the system.
Showed some strong qualities in the fee VFL games I watched
Congrats Seth
-
Looks good
-
The only (albeit very small) positive so far.
-
Well done Wayne.
Well deserved. Hard work and has a crack. Has some really nice qualities.
-
Him, MRJ & Vlastuin are about the only three that haven't totally embarrassed themselves so far..... :shh
-
Him, MRJ & Vlastuin are about the only three that haven't totally embarrassed themselves so far..... :shh
Totally agree, it's also time to say goodbye to Grimes
-
Very good 1st up performance
Deserves a run of games
-
this boy showed many how to get the job done.
along with TT seth had the most tackles with 4. Seth had more tackles than grimes, young, ross, macca and baker. floss so basically our whole backline :banghead
-
Was very good
-
Was talking to a bloke from Burnie at the pub yesterday. Let’s just say, Seth did not have an easy private school pathway into footy. Had to work super hard. Sounds like a great kid.
-
Campbell’s fine first-up display
By Richmond Media
2 days ago
Talented, young forward Seth Campbell made an impressive debut for Richmond in last Saturday’s opening round match against Gold Coast with two top-class goals. Richmond Media caught up with him post-game for an appraisal of his debut appearance. Here is what he had to say . . .
His first goal in AFL football, from a clever snap
“I just played with instinct and the ball ended up in my lap. I was in a good position and just snapped it over the shoulder . . . Seeing it going through, I didn’t know what to do. I didn’t know how to celebrate . . . The boys just got around me and it was unbelievable.”
Strong support from Tiger teammates
“They supported me. Every time I got the ball or with my rotations or playing my structure, the boys helped me with everything like that, and they made it easier for me.”
His second goal, from a set shot
“That was awesome. That was us on the comeback and we had the momentum and it just felt awesome with the Tiger Army getting behind us.”
Easing the nerves
“It was after I kicked that first goal, everything just dropped, and I was just playing footy like I’ve been doing.
Thriving on the quick tempo
“It was very fast. I didn’t really realise how much I was running because the adrenalin was just going the whole game. But it was awesome . . . amazing. I loved every minute of it.”
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1503877/campbells-fine-first-up-display
-
Second game blues...looked a bit overawed on the big stage..80k at the MCG under lights v Carlton is quite a different kettle of fish to a lazy Saturday arvo at Metricon..... :shh
-
Second game blues...looked a bit overawed on the big stage..80k at the MCG under lights v Carlton is quite a different kettle of fish to a lazy Saturday arvo at Metricon..... :shh
Disagree. Kicked a huge goal in the last when Mansell, Lynch, Bolton miss goals they should kick. May not have one every contest but he has a crack this kid. Loved his spoil that resulted in Balta goal in the 2nd.
-
Was still well down on last week - to be expected - no big deal at this stage.... :shh
-
Just keep playing him. Needs and deserves a run of games.
So much to like
-
Just keep playing him. Needs and deserves a run of games.
So much to like
Exactly
-
Could be the cleanest player on the list. His hands are so sticky and I am yet to see him double grab. Class.
-
Seems like Seth, mrj, Cumberland, coulthard are all competing for the same spot. Would expect different combinations of the 4 throughout the year. Campbell has impressed me though
-
Looks to have great balance and footy nous and most importantly he doesn't panic.
Skills aren't the worst in the team but many of our more experienced players could learn a thing or two watching his second and third efforts. I really like his pressure on the ball carrier and he isn't scared to take the game on and show his ability. :thumbsup
-
Looks to have great balance and footy nous and most importantly he doesn't panic.
Skills aren't the worst in the team but many of our more experienced players could learn a thing or two watching his second and third efforts. I really like his pressure on the ball carrier and he isn't scared to take the game on and show his ability. :thumbsup
👍🏿
-
Looks to have great balance and footy nous and most importantly he doesn't panic.
Skills aren't the worst in the team but many of our more experienced players could learn a thing or two watching his second and third efforts. I really like his pressure on the ball carrier and he isn't scared to take the game on and show his ability. :thumbsup
Beat me to it was looking for this thread when it popped up.
Reckon we have found one with him and i think he should be groomed to also be a part of midfield rotations.
-
Another excellent effort today.
-
After three games of AFL football, Campbell is averaging 12.0 disposals, 5.3 contested possessions, 2.7 marks, 1.0 goal, 4.3 score involvements, 2.7 inside-50s, 2.3 tackles and 269.7 metres gained per match.
Among potential AFL rising star nominees, he is ranked No. 3 for goals per game, No. 5 for metres gained per game, No. 6 for score involvements per game, No. 6 for tackles inside 50 per game, No. 7 for marks inside 50 per game, No. 8 for inside-50s per game, No. 8 for clearances per game and No. 10 for contested possessions per game.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1514874/seth-shines-on-the-big-stage
-
Equal most inside 50s for us with 8.
Seth's game today:
14 disposals (11k, 3h, 5c, 9u, 42.9 eff.)
2 marks
1 tackle
8 inside 50s
2 intercepts
416 metres gained
3 score involvements
1 goal assist
1 behind
81% time on ground
-
They just have to keep playing this kid
What find he has been
-
Another real solid performance i think he could play mid field for us as well.
-
Is perfect where he is. Looked great and opportunities to make a huge mark on this game but snuffed a couple of relatively easy shots on goal
-
A find
-
Seth Campbell has forced his way into Richmond’s senior side in 2024.
The Tasmanian small forward battled injuries last year which restricted him to just five VFL games and as a rookie draft selection, not many expected him to come on so quickly.
After five games, the 19-year-old is third at the club for inside 50s with 19, has provided four goal assists (equal third with Dustin Martin), and is equal seventh for score involvements with 19.
https://www.sen.com.au/news/2024/04/10/your-afl-clubs-most-improved-player-so-far-in-2024-and-biggest-surprise/
-
YOUNG TIGER EYES TRIGGER
RICHMOND rookie Seth Campbell will trigger a contract extension after the Tigers' early-season bye.
The 19-year-old was limited to just five VFL games in his first season at Punt Road due to injury and only secured an extension in September.
But after a strong pre-season, new Richmond coach Adem Yze rewarded him with a debut and has played the Tasmanian across the first six games of the 2024 season.
Campbell kicked two games against Gold Coast in Opening Round and has shown he can handle the intensity at AFL level since then, rewarding the club’s faith in him last year.
Seth Campbell snaps through his first goal at AFL level to give his side a much-needed major late in the second term
Richmond is expected to rework an extension in the coming weeks for Campbell and reward the small forward with a two-year deal.
Tigers GMs Blair Hartley and Tim Livingstone have a number of list management decisions to make this year on a wide range of premiership players.
Dustin Martin, Dion Prestia, Dylan Grimes, Toby Nankervis, Kamdyn McIntosh and Jack Graham are all out of contract.
Unlike the names above, Liam Baker is not a free agent but is out of contract and is weighing up his future.
While those decisions will take time, Campbell's early-season rise has taken care of one piece of list management for Richmond. – Josh Gabelich
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1110336/swans-big-contract-call-lions-table-offer-to-mid-tigers-trigger
-
Is perfect where he is. Looked great and opportunities to make a huge mark on this game but snuffed a couple of relatively easy shots on goal
Na would be a very good mid why pencil him in as only a forward when he could be so much more.
If i thought he had the tank, atm id be wanting him to play on a wing instead of the two ancient has beens we keep picking there.
-
Getting back to the form he showed on debut.... :shh
-
Is perfect where he is. Looked great and opportunities to make a huge mark on this game but snuffed a couple of relatively easy shots on goal
Na would be a very good mid why pencil him in as only a forward when he could be so much more.
If i thought he had the tank, atm id be wanting him to play on a wing instead of the two ancient has beens we keep picking there.
Na. Perfect where he is.
-
Na has midfielder written all over him.
Hes doing alright atm but is being wasted there.
-
Getting back to the form he showed on debut.... :shh
:shh :shh
-
Goal in last quarter reminded me of Maxfield on the run in 1995.
-
Was right in front of us. Never missing from the time he hit it. Great goal!
-
Goal in last quarter reminded me of Maxfield on the run in 1995.
Hmm where did stewie maxfield play most of his games??.
How did Dan Rioli go just playing Forward. Unlike Dan this kid has traits to play as a genuine mid rather than a hbf.
-
Goal in last quarter reminded me of Maxfield on the run in 1995.
Hmm where did stewie maxfield play most of his games??.
How did Dan Rioli go just playing Forward. Unlike Dan this kid has traits to play as a genuine mid rather than a hbf.
He definitely has the physique and kahunas.
-
One of the few bright spots from the game I thought.
-
One of the few bright spots from the game I thought.
Yep thwt pick up in the 2nd on the run was brilliant
-
Looks a keeper.
-
Reminds me of Simon Black .
-
"I've never seen a bigger choke than that anywhere!"
Tyler Sonsie might never let poor Seth Campbell forget this (https://abs-0.twimg.com/emoji/v2/svg/1f605.svg)
#9AFLSFS | NIne & 9Now 🖥️
(https://cdn4.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/image-6355114425112-755x432.jpg) (https://x.com/FootyonNine/status/1802162241317302431)
https://x.com/FootyonNine/status/1802162241317302431
-
Seth had 9 score involvements and a goal to go with his 15 touches. A rare positive from yesterday.
Campbell's game yesterday:
15 disposals (11k, 4h, 4c, 11u, 80% eff.)
4 marks
2 tackles
3 clearances
7 inside 50s
362 metres gained
4 intercepts
9 score involvements
1 goal assist
1 goal
2 behinds
72% time on ground
-
Campbell has been a key positive among the Richmond playing group this season. He’s played 18 senior games and is averaging 11.6 disposals, 3.1 marks, 2.6 inside-50s, 3.8 score involvements, 221.8 metres gained per match, and has kicked a total of 10 goals.
Among AFL rising star contenders, he is ranked fourth in total inside-50s, fourth in bounces, seventh in goal assists and eighth in score involvements.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1618770/seth-a-2024-success-story-for-tigers
-
His best game yesterday. He seemed to be the only one capable of hitting a target inside 50 and a few nice kicks into the corridor too. Crazy that this kid can do it but all short can do is bomb it long.
-
I wish he could get a bit more of it!
-
I wish he could get a bit more of it!
Is still only 19 and plays in the grave yard spot of small forward.
Kid will be fine and he will get enough ball.
Will reiterate he looks like he could play midfield with ease. If he has the tank and thats the question does he have the tank? i would be playing him for the rest of the year on a wing.
-
I wish he could get a bit more of it!
Can't get more of it of you not where the ball is
Seeing his playing as a HF he is getting it enough
Looking forward to seeing im spending more time in the middle as his career progresses
-
Give him a wing this week. Why the hell not.
Mrj, Mansell and Bolton small forwards. Bauer, Blight and Kossie the talls.
-
Staggering he hasn't received a "Ris9ng Star" nomination
Been solid all season
-
Staggering he hasn't received a "Ris9ng Star" nomination
Been solid all season
Because atm he's merely the best of a bad bunch and looks better than he actually is in a shyte truck of a side that's getting flogged nearly every week........ :shh
-
Looks and plays a bit like Dragisevic
-
Looks and plays a bit like Dragisevic
For whatever reason drags was one of my fav players when I was a little kid. It was only many years later when I thought to look him up, I was very surprised to see he only played 30 or so games in his entire career lol
-
Looks and plays a bit like Dragisevic
For whatever reason drags was one of my fav players when I was a little kid. It was only many years later when I thought to look him up, I was very surprised to see he only played 30 or so games in his entire career lol
Absolute same for me.
Crook knees robbed a guy who could kick some crazy goals over his head etc.
Used to love Rory Hilton too.
-
Lmao the good old days of Richo & Knights carrying 20 duds every week.... :shh
-
Looks and plays a bit like Dragisevic
For whatever reason drags was one of my fav players when I was a little kid. It was only many years later when I thought to look him up, I was very surprised to see he only played 30 or so games in his entire career lol
Dragacevic was set to be a superstar.. was fantastic. Great skills.. unfortunately, like cogs, his knee injury was a car wreck.. destroyed their careers
-
Lmao Dragadurry was a stuffing dud not fit to mentioned in the same breath as Cogs.... :shh
-
Lmao Dragadurry was a stuffing dud not fit to mentioned in the same breath as Cogs.... :shh
Cogs a class above
Like comparing Jurica and Richo
-
Not comparing Richo with Jurica but Walls completely destroyed Jurica.
-
Lmao Dragadurry was a stuffing dud not fit to mentioned in the same breath as Cogs.... :shh
You're a fool, this kid was electric as a junior, did you ever watch his development in Geelong? I did!!! He was just starting his career. You're the one who thinks knows it all but is just a full blown egomaniac know it all. . Dragas knee stuffed him right up.justvas cogs!!!!
-
Lmao Dragadurry was a stuffing dud not fit to mentioned in the same breath as Cogs.... :shh
You're a fool, this kid was electric as a junior, did you ever watch his development in Geelong? I did!!! He was just starting his career. You're the one who thinks knows it all but is just a full blown egomaniac know it all. . Dragas knee stuffed him right up.justvas cogs!!!!
lmao.... was so "electric" as a junior he slid all the way to pick 55 and we took James White before him..... :shh
-
:lol
-
Only in tiger supporters deluded minds was Dragacevic electric. Amasing what so many years of mediocrity yr on end did to tiger minds.
We just needed something any thing to hang the old hat on.
-
Only in tiger supporters deluded minds was Dragacevic electric. Amasing what so many years of mediocrity yr on end did to tiger minds.
We just needed something any thing to hang the old hat on.
Be fair
The tiger mind in question apparently looks after an olive farm in Italy
Patience is important
-
I was a little kid. Don’t ask me why I liked him or even what my favourite memory of him was because I will struggle to give you an answer for either. All I remember is him being one of my favs lol
-
Only in tiger supporters deluded minds was Dragacevic electric. Amasing what so many years of mediocrity yr on end did to tiger minds.
We just needed something any thing to hang the old hat on.
Be fair
The tiger mind in question apparently looks after an olive farm in Italy
Patience is important
Do olive's have adverse affects on the mind if your around them a lot.?Gotta be some sort of explanation :snidegrin
-
Not comparing Richo with Jurica but Walls completely destroyed Jurica.
:clapping :clapping :clapping
-
Staggering he hasn't received a "Ris9ng Star" nomination
Been solid all season
Can't agree with this. Had 4 or 5 good games a few near or at the standard and a whole pile of very quite games.
He was that quite earlier in the year that we rightly gave him a rest under the guise of rest or some such thing.
Leading into the Port game he probably should have been dropped again.
If i was going to be highly critical of him id say the lack of consistency and ability to stay in games is one of the bigger ones. But hey we all realise he is still only 19 and this happens.
This will probably be interpreted as me bashing one of our young players and that is not true. He shows a lot of promise and looks good in areas but he has a long way to go.
Not sure apart from 4 or so games he would be thought of for Rising star. And no he has not been solid all year.
-
Staggering he hasn't received a "Ris9ng Star" nomination
Been solid all season
Can't agree with this. Had 4 or 5 good games a few near or at the standard and a whole pile of very quite games.
He was that quite earlier in the year that we rightly gave him a rest under the guise of rest or some such thing.
Leading into the Port game he probably should have been dropped again.
If i was going to be highly critical of him id say the lack of consistency and ability to stay in games is one of the bigger ones. But hey we all realise he is still only 19 and this happens.
This will probably be interpreted as me bashing one of our young players and that is not true. He shows a lot of promise and looks good in areas but he has a long way to go.
Not sure apart from 4 or so games he would be thought of for Rising star. And no he has not been solid all year.
Saved yourself there, otherwise yes highly & unduly critical!
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
Even he isn't consistent.
Has managed about 45 DT points the last two games, hasn't cracked the ton yet in his debut season.
-
He's no good then either :shh
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
Even he isn't consistent.
Has managed about 45 DT points the last two games, hasn't cracked the ton yet in his debut season.
....
We can agree to disagree. They're just stats and tell a story but they don't tell you what happened with the stat.
Please don't speak to me like that as well. It's bloody rude and I deserve to be treated with more respect. I give plenty of respect to people on this forum myself.
-
SNIP and edit
I've made it clear in the last couple of weeks
Any posts that directly snipe, insult, bait and troll other posters will be removed and/or edited.
There's no need for it...
Great point made above
We can agree to disagree, there's no need for the petty insults
And before people start complaining, there are at least 2 posts where I made it clear why we were making this change
-
..I am going to make this very clear :banghead
A post has been removed because it contained another insult; just like the post I removed and edited this morning.
Posters can stand by their opinions, that's not the point. You can stand by an opinion without belittling other posters by insulting them by calling them "morons" or as in the recently removed post "stuffing precious".
Just on a fortnight ago the mods on this site in particular me were accused by a poster of favouring other posters when it came to baiting, trolling and insults
At that time I made it clear going forward I would be removing any posts that baiting, trolling and insults
Below is part of what I wrote:
"Finally, constant baiting and trolling is against site rules. But get your point so today I will remove every single post that could be deemed as baiting and trolling..OK?
And as I've said before, be careful with what you wish for"
I also said that if people had an issue they could take it up with the poster who made the accusation of favouring posters.
So since then I stayed true to my word and removed a number of posts
SO again rather taking a pot shot at me, take it up with the poster whose accustions instigated the changes
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
Pfffttt Really.
Im all for playing kids knowing they will struggle at times and a lot of the time maybe not up to the standard. Fmd that is a given yet i say play em. Why is that.
why sugar coat this situation play em but why talk about them as being something more than they are.
Why do we have to build em when they have not done a lot.
Nope i dont need em to be winning undeserved rising star nominations to keep playing them. Nope im happy to play em warts and all because that is where we are at.
When will supporters learn to not build players up to something they are not only to tear them down when they don't meet expectations. FMD it happens all the time.
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
Pfffttt Really.
Im all for playing kids knowing they will struggle at times and a lot of the time maybe not up to the standard. Fmd that is a given yet i say play em. Why is that. If you cannot work that out your dummer than i thought.
why sugar coat this situation play em but why talk about them as being something more than they are.
Why do we have to build em when they have not done a lot.
Nope i dont need em to be winning undeserved rising star nominations to keep playing them. Nope im happy to play em warts and all because that is where we are at.
When will supporters learn to not build players up to something they are not only to tear them down when they don't meet expectations. FMD it happens all the time.
I actually agree with your assessment of SC.
Good skills, footy nous, strong shoulders etc.
And is a kid, needs to develop and be more consistent.
That's exactly how I'd describe him.
But on the topic of Rising Star I don't think it's a stretch to imagine that one of his better games this year could have earned a nomination.
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
Pfffttt Really.
Im all for playing kids knowing they will struggle at times and a lot of the time maybe not up to the standard. Fmd that is a given yet i say play em. Why is that. If you cannot work that out your dummer than i thought.
why sugar coat this situation play em but why talk about them as being something more than they are.
Why do we have to build em when they have not done a lot.
Nope i dont need em to be winning undeserved rising star nominations to keep playing them. Nope im happy to play em warts and all because that is where we are at.
When will supporters learn to not build players up to something they are not only to tear them down when they don't meet expectations. FMD it happens all the time.
You forgot to read WP's post :lol
But I agree with most of that. It's just that you advocate playing the kids and then jump on here and say "well they haven't done anything yet!!!".
It's the pre 2017 Clawski cycle all over again. You call for kids to play and then a few years later you call for them to be delisted. You are literally never content as a supporter and it's just bloody miserable.
-
..I am going to make this very clear :banghead
A post has been removed because it contained another insult; just like the post I removed and edited this morning.
Posters can stand by their opinions, that's not the point. You can stand by an opinion without belittling other posters by insulting them by calling them "morons" or as in the recently removed post "stuffing precious".
Just on a fortnight ago the mods on this site in particular me were accused by a poster of favouring other posters when it came to baiting, trolling and insults
At that time I made it clear going forward I would be removing any posts that baiting, trolling and insults
Below is part of what I wrote:
"Finally, constant baiting and trolling is against site rules. But get your point so today I will remove every single post that could be deemed as baiting and trolling..OK?
And as I've said before, be careful with what you wish for"
I also said that if people had an issue they could take it up with the poster who made the accusation of favouring posters.
So since then I stayed true to my word and removed a number of posts
SO again rather taking a pot shot at me, take it up with the poster whose accustions instigated the changes
Who is the poster? If you're referring to me I hope you have some evidence to back up your claims. I did rightly point out that you'd removed a harmless post of mine and let a lot of abuse slide from others. Given I wasn't actually baiting anyone with my post nor have I been involved in a slanging match with anyone here for a long time, I thought you were being unfair.
I mean, you only have to read a certain part of clawski's post to see he's abused someone for the 687th time this year because they have a slight disagreement with him. It's just not consistent across the board.
But hey, if my words to you are now inspiring rule changes then just add me to the moderating team. I'll fix this place right up :shh
-
Says play the kids then writes an essay about how none of them have the consistency of Harley Reid
Pfffttt Really.
Im all for playing kids knowing they will struggle at times and a lot of the time maybe not up to the standard. Fmd that is a given yet i say play em. Why is that. If you cannot work that !!!!!
why sugar coat this situation play em but why talk about them as being something more than they are.
Why do we have to build em when they have not done a lot.
Nope i dont need em to be winning undeserved rising star nominations to keep playing them. Nope im happy to play em warts and all because that is where we are at.
When will supporters learn to not build players up to something they are not only to tear them down when they don't meet expectations. FMD it happens all the time.
You forgot to read WP's post :lol
But I agree with most of that. It's just that you advocate playing the kids and then jump on here and say "well they haven't done anything yet!!!".
It's the pre 2017 Clawski cycle all over again. You call for kids to play and then a few years later you call for them to be delisted. You are literally never content as a supporter and it's just bloody miserable.
Yep i apologise have deleted that comment.
I pretty much do it with all of our kids. Rarely call for their heads in their first three or four seasons unless they show themselves to be out right duds.
But i do point out their foibles and what they need to improve on.
Wp said he had a real consistent year and deserved a rising star because of it. I disagreed i dont think he has played to a consistently high standard and its something he needs to work on.
Has he played a game or two to warrant a rising star nom? maybe but that depends on how well others have gone those weeks.
-
That’s fair crawski. Would say he looks like he has enough attributes to make it. Consistency is the key.
-
That’s fair crawski. Would say he looks like he has enough attributes to make it. Consistency is the key.
Fair. i have been fair right thru this thread apart from the first post which was more a crack at the club and its drafting than Seth.
I retracted that comment after watching a bit of him. Had a debate with you about where we should play him and have only been positive until the WP post.
Funny as soon as you say something that can be construed as a criticism and a negative people only see the negative and jump up and down.
-
Seth Campbell has signed on at Richmond until the end of 2026
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1635444/campbell-commits
The 19-year-old made his debut in the Opening Round against the Gold Coast and has been a mainstay for the season, playing 20 games.
The Tasmanian, who missed most of his debut season in 2023 with adductor and leg issues, has averaged 11 disposals and two tackles per game.
Campbell’s endurance, strong decision-making, and foot skills make him suited for a wing and half-forward role, though he has also had some exposure through the midfield this year.
The youngster said he had loved his time at Richmond and was excited to see what the future would bring.
“I have definitely played more games than I thought I was going to, but with the injuries and everything that has happened, it has become an opportunity for us young boys,” he said.
“I feel like a few of us have stepped up and played our role the best we can and had our opportunity, which has been really good.
“There is definitely a lot of young talent at the moment at Tigerland, and I think we are just getting better and better.
“I think over the next couple of years, we are just going to keep growing and we will be really competitive.”
Richmond General Manager, Football Talent Blair Hartley said Campbell had taken huge strides in 2024.
“After an injury-interrupted first year with us, Seth has taken his opportunities with both hands this season,” Hartley said.
“To play essentially a full season of AFL football this year will hold Seth in great shape in the future as he learns physically and mentally the demands of elite football.
“Seth is a talented kid with a great work ethic, so it will be exciting to see what he can achieve across the coming years.”
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1635444/campbell-commits
-
When's Tassie coming in again? :shh
-
Think a few people blew their loads early over this bloke - he's actually not that good....fumbly, panicky, poor decision maker, makes a lot of unforced errors...another who can't tackle and lacks physical presence... :shh
-
Think a few people blew their loads early over this bloke - he's actually not that good....fumbly, panicky, poor decision maker, makes a lot of unforced errors...another who can't tackle and lacks physical presence... :shh
No, you've got it wrong.
He's all of those things, just tired at the end of the year, carrying more than a kid his age should.
-
Think a few people blew their loads early over this bloke - he's actually not that good....fumbly, panicky, poor decision maker, makes a lot of unforced errors...another who can't tackle and lacks physical presence... :shh
No, you've got it wrong.
He's all of those things, just tired at the end of the year, carrying more than a kid his age should.
So you’re actually saying Dio is correct
But Seth is tired ?
-
Think a few people blew their loads early over this bloke - he's actually not that good....fumbly, panicky, poor decision maker, makes a lot of unforced errors...another who can't tackle and lacks physical presence... :shh
No, you've got it wrong.
He's all of those things, just tired at the end of the year, carrying more than a kid his age should.
So you’re actually saying Dio is correct
But Seth is tired ?
C leary I'm tired haha.
He is the opposite of those things (bar that kick to Hopper).
I thinmk his physicality is great for a kid.
just tired ad d beat by the end of the year
-
B or C+ grader
-
Had a stinker yesterday.
-
He's had quite a few stinkers. Very young still.
-
Yep was poor yesterday but don't think there would many on here who'd of thought he would play 20 odd games in just his 2nd year on the list. Remembering that he missed most of last year with injury
Plenty of upside, reckon he is a future winger
One of few bright lights in a horrific year
-
Other players who played yesterday deserve far greater criticism than Thompson. For example Hopper who played a really poor game.
-
Other players who played yesterday deserve far greater criticism than Thompson. For example Hopper who played a really poor game.
Fair call but who the stuff is Thompson?
-
Other players who played yesterday deserve far greater criticism than Thompson. For example Hopper who played a really poor game.
Fair call but who the stuff is Thompson?
Was unsighted yesterday but did well to back up again the VFL today.... :shh
-
Opinion is divided on this guy it seems. I myself believe he just does not get enough of the ball.
Hope I'm wrong, just don't see him being a long term player, even though his skills are excellent
-
I think as he develops he can find more of the ball.
Least of our concerns
-
Come on people he's 19 ffs.
Rookie drafted.
Missed lots of 2023 with juvenile injuries.
Played 20 games averaging 11+ touches, 0.5 goals and 2 tackles.
Far from our top 20 problems.
-
Come on people he's 19 ffs.
Rookie drafted.
Missed lots of 2023 with juvenile injuries.
Played 20 games averaging 11+ touches, 0.5 goals and 2 tackles.
Far from our top 20 problems.
This.
Crazy criticism.
-
Had a good year as far as games played goes. Also showed a lot of good glimpses. A 19 yo rookie pick with some good attributes for the level im not sure what peoples expectations were but he showed more than enough.
Legit criticism he needs to find more of the ball. Its not a put down its just an area he needs to work on and improve significantly.
Needs to work on size and strength needs to lay more tackles and be more involved with out the ball.
Hopefully he builds on 2024 next year.
They all have things that need work.
-
20 today :birthday
Looking forward to how he progresses in 2025.
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Gf67tl4bQAAWZfR?format=jpg&name=900x900)
https://x.com/Richmond_FC/status/1873140896411337181
-
Moving magnets: The positional change to watch at Richmond
A rookie pick at the end of 2022, Seth Campbell made an impression playing mostly forward for the Tigers last year, kicking 10 goals in 21 games. But the 20-year-old has already been given some more responsibility this pre-season, spending time training with the midfield group in what could be a sign of things to come.
https://www.afl.com.au/news/1266850/moving-magnets-the-positional-change-to-watch-at-your-club
-
Massively overrated #onehitwonder :shh
-
Come on Dio, it's a praccy match haha.
Kids has shown plenty and I think he'll do better in '25 with another preseason under his belt and when we get some mature bodies back in around him.
-
Learning to play through the mid-field
Did a few things that didn't get mentioned in commentary because they were too noisy talking about anything but the game
-
Seth on SEN: [11 min interview]
AUDIO: https://cms.megaphone.fm/channel/NTETP9385767300?selected=NTETP8928579035
---------------------------------------------------------
Tigers head over heels for Seth
Sam Lonergan tipped this . . .
When the Richmond development coach presented young Tiger Seth Campbell with the Cosgrove-Jenkins award, as the Club’s best first year player at last year’s Jack Dyer Medal presentation night, he declared: “This young man is going to provide us with many highlights, I can assure you of that. He’s going to be a highlights package of energy and excitement. And he’s got great work ethic, dedication, along with great spirit . . . He’s going to be a long-term player and a key part of our future.”
Campbell’s scorching run and match-sealing soccered goal for the Tigers in last Thursday night’s Round 1 victory over Carlton at the MCG, followed by a spectacular celebration – a cartwheel and backflip – was an energetic, exciting highlights package of the highest order. And it sent the Tiger Army into raptures.
“I joked before the game that the right time I’d do the backflip . . . We spoke about it last year, but there wasn’t really a scenario to pull the backflip out . . . I thought that was the right place and time,” Campbell said on SEN.
“I’ve been doing back flips since I was a kid, but never really pulled it out in games . . . I was a bit up and about . . . I was pumped. So, I just pulled it out. Thought it was the right time.”
So, would he do it again?
“If there’s 80,000 at the ‘G, and it’s a scenario like that, probably yeah,” he replied.
Aside from the now famous match-sealing goal and dazzling gymnastics display, the talented forward was a valuable contributor throughout the match for Richmond with another goal and seven tackles.
https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1732763/tigers-head-over-heels-for-seth
-
‘SHINING LIGHT’ FOR TIGERS IN ‘UGLY’ UNRAVELLING
Seth Campbell kicked three goals from five scoring shots and looked the Tigers’ most likely offensive threat all afternoon.
Campbell’s liveliness around the sticks gave St Kilda early headaches as the Tigers went toe-to-toe with the hosts.
“The willingness of Richmond’s youngsters to compete has been super impressive,” Demons great Garry Lyon told the Fox Footy broadcast at half-time.
Campbell would’ve had a fourth if not reversed after a score review revealed slight contact with the post, but his impact wasn’t lost on observers.
“I love his finishing … there’s a shining light for the Tigers, he’s managed to be competitive,” Dunstall said of the 20-year-old’s efforts.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/teams/st-kilda-saints/live-afl-2025-st-kilda-saints-vs-richmond-tigers-round-3-super-saturday-live-updates-scores-blog-stats-start-time-aedt-and-how-to-watch-stream/news-story/f1187b1a076333a0267d8a24a89e3454
-
Only bright light of true consistency for the 1st three rounds
-
Keeper
-
Yep he is a keeper.
Until Tassie comes knocking which they will
-
Finally starting to back up the debut and maybe live up to all the hype - or at least some of it. :shh