So let me get this straight, you rated Jack and Hislop the same. I will not even bother............
Just when you think you have heard it all somebody comes out with something even more ridiculas!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That's funny......
I don't know why I bother.... but here goes..... they play different roles. So based on their positions & roles within in the team I thought Jack's year was worth a 5
And regarding Hislop based on the role which he was given (which as I said what people think of that role is a totally seperate discussion point) I'd give a 5 as well....
With all due respect WP, you saying these guys had the same impact in their respective positions and their roles is just insulting to Jack.
Jack kicked 30 odd goals in a forward line that is terrible at best and an on ball group that cannot even 'get it' and when they do finally 'get it', most cannot kick.
And Hislop, I would not even know what his role is? He doesn't play small, and he doesn't play tall. He is not quick, cannot mark and his kicking is average.
Maybe it is just me? But these two were miles apart this year.
