Votes Round 18, 2005 - RFC vs Carlton

[mightytiges]

Closes eyes and throws darts at names

3. Hartigan - about the only one when the game was still a contest that could hit a target
2. Tuck - always gives his all.
1/2 each Moore and Tambling - more an encouragement vote. Moore for presenting up forward and Tambling for endeavour and 2 goals. Made mistakes but I couldn't find anyone else who deserved a vote as his teammates made just as many. 

[JohnF]

3 - Campbell - He made some mistakes and gave away some stupid free kicks but he was good in the clinches and did well for the amount of time he played.

2 - Hartigan - Didn't get much of it but probably used it the best out of all the players out there today.

1 - Tambling - Done alright

Pettifer, Deledio and Tuck were also ok

[letsgetiton!]

3- pettifer
2- tambling
1- deledio

[Razorblade]

3 - Tambling
2 - Deledio
1 - Moore

[WilliamPowell]

What a shocker........... Tezza mentioned in his press conference it was the kids that did their jobs - aint that the truth

3 - Hartigan - ran the lines and attacked the ball. Also thought his disposal was the best it's been for the season

2 - Pettifer - presented time and time again

1 - Deledio - class and skill but and I know I sound like a broken record he needs to tighten up defensively.

Just out of interest I didn't give Tuck any votes because he was way to loose on Kouta and Kouta killed us. I thought Cogs played better this week but he spent alot of time on Stevens and Stevens kicked 4 goals

Also I think today Will Thursfield would have learnt a helluva lot

And THE GOLDEN TURNUP (aka the Johnny Manton Medal): after a few weeks break I am giving ther GT this week to ..........

....................

Rory Hilton - fair dinkum he takes a screamer - big deal. He ran around at times today like he was jogging alond the St Kilda foreshore. 

[JohnF]

His Jon Dorotich moment summed up our day.

[DallasCrane]

3. Hartigan
2. Tuck
1. Pettifer

[letsgetiton!]

 I thought Cogs played better this week but he spent alot of time on Stevens and Stevens kicked 4 goals

mmmmmmm i think cogs had only 6 touches after quarter time, and many of his kicks were floating hospital passes, this kid has planty of courage but his skill is shocking. give him one more yr and if his skill dosnt improve use his rep as gr8 trade bait, i am sick and tired of tiger players getting rave reviews when they have subsubsubstandard skill level, getting the ball is one thing, using it properly is another. stephens spanked him today

[Bulluss]

3-Hartigan
2-Pettifer
1-Deledio

[Roar]

3 - Tuck
2 - Hartigan
1- Tambling

[cub]

3- tuck
2 - deledio
1- tambling

[Fishfinger]

3 - Bowden
2 - Hartigan
1 - Pettifer

[one-eyed]

Votes for round 18

Hartigan   3  2       3 3 3 2     2 = 18
Tuck        2              2    3 3    =  10
Pettifer           3    2  1 2       1 =   9
Tambling  .5 1 2 3          1 1    =  8.5
Deledio          1 2  1    1    2    =   7
Cambo        3                         =   3
Bowden                               3 =   3
Moore      .5      1                   =  1.5

Leaderboard after round 18

Tuck        170
Richo      119
Cogs       101
Brown       76
Johnson    70
Bowden     63
Hyde         48
Newman    43
Deledio     39
Krakouer   31
Cambo      29
Gas           26.5
Graham     23
Chaffey     21
Kellaway    18.5
Hartigan     18
Stafford      14
Pettifer       12
Knobel       11
Simmonds   9
Tambling     8.5
Tivendale     7
Hall             3
Thursfield    2
Moore         1.5
Raines        1
Morrison     1