Official team R3 vs Swans

[the claw]

Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.

Miller is athletic enough to play chb. Probably the one who has to take Amarty. Young seems a decent fit for McClean and Grimes to McDonald.
Worst comes to worst we throw Balta back.

With Grimes out, they probably both have to play, but IMO it's sub-optimal. You want at least one of your KPDs to be an intercept marking guy. Neither Miller nor Young are that. The Sydney small forwards will have a field day. Papley to kick 6+.

You still need talls to combat the three talls Sydney go with in McDonald, Amarty, and McClean. Which now will be Young, Miller and Broad. We have Balta up our sleeve if it gets out of hand. Its down to the likes of Rioli Vlastuin Broad to combat their smaller players.
along with help from the mids.

[the claw]

Final INS and OUTS

Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT

RICHMOND

In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)

SYDNEY

In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant

Great to see Sonsie get a chance

Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.

[Damo]

Final INS and OUTS

Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT

RICHMOND

In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)

SYDNEY

In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant

Great to see Sonsie get a chance

Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.

You didn’t have him in your “ins”

[eliminator]

Hope Sonsie has a really good game

[the claw]

Final INS and OUTS

Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT

RICHMOND

In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)

SYDNEY

In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant

Great to see Sonsie get a chance

Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.

You didn’t have him in your “ins”

Nice try.

[Damo]

Final INS and OUTS

Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT

RICHMOND

In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)

SYDNEY

In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant

Great to see Sonsie get a chance

Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.

You didn’t have him in your “ins”

Nice try.

Wtf are you talking about ???

As per the following

YOU DIDNT HAVE HIM IN YOUR INS

 

Ins: Young , Broad, Naismith, Sonsie , Cumberland.

Outs: Dow, Grimes, Banks, McIntosh, Short. Pickett/Short?.

Cmon people what harm can it do Giving Lefau another run. It was not an ideal situation with how he got his debut.

[one-eyed]

Richmond

B:     Tylar Young          Nathan Broad        Nick Vlastuin

HB:  Jayden Short          Tom Brown           Daniel Rioli

C: Kamdyn McIntosh      Tim Taranto        Marlion Pickett

HF:  Seth Campbell      Rhyan Mansell      Maurice Rioli

F:     Noah Balta           Shai Bolton           Tom Lynch

R:  Toby Nankervis        Jack Ross            Liam Baker

Int:  Tyler Sonsie     Thomson Dow     Sam Banks     Ben Miller    Mykelti Lefau   


Emg:  Hugo Ralphsmith    Kane McAuliffe      Sam Naismith       



The Club will then name its substitute 60 minutes prior to the first bounce on Sunday.

https://www.richmondfc.com.au/news/1517173/four-changes-for-easter-sunday-clash

[georgies31]

Our senior players are immune to criticism keep on getting picked puzzling. Get the games into the kids with the senior players performing the rest spend time in the vfl.

[the claw]

Will be interesting to see if Young and Miller both play. Not too many sides play two negating defenders, so not sure if there is room in the side for both.

Miller is athletic enough to play chb. Probably the one who has to take Amarty. Young seems a decent fit for McClean and Grimes to McDonald.
Worst comes to worst we throw Balta back.

Not one senior player dropped  kids taking the wrap for there poor form.
[/quote

Any way this week.

B:   Vlastuin - Young - Grimes
HB: Rioli - Miller - Mansell

C: Pickett - McAuliffe - Broad
R:Nankervis  - Martin - Bolton
 
HF: Campbell - Balta - Sonsie
F:   Naismith - Lynch - Cumberland

Int: Taranto -  Ross - Baker - Short - Lefau.

Surely it is McAuliffe time No hopper No Dusty even no Prestia who is short in stature but as solid as they come.
Nope it will be a skinny flanker you can just see it happening.

In this thread alone. Not sure what your point is

[the claw]

Final INS and OUTS

Richmond v Sydney at the MCG, 4pm AEDT

RICHMOND

Okay i will bite in just about every thread this week ive been talking him up and demanding he play. But a simple brain fade over looking the obvious had me miss him out in team selection and your all over it..
Apologies i thought you were being well a dick head. Seems we have to  beliteral and correct with absolutely everything we say around here at times.

In: T.Young, N.Broad, M.Rioli, T.Sonsie
Out: J.Trezise (ankle), J.Clarke (omitted), D.Grimes (wrist), D.Martin (calf)

SYDNEY

In: R.Fox, C.Mitchell
Out: H.Cunningham (concussion), S.Wicks (omitted)

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1096308/teams-another-tiger-out-bevos-jamarra-call-swans-debutant

Great to see Sonsie get a chance

Just don't get it. Atm we have no Prestia, no Hopper, and now no Martin, all bigger bodies in the midfield yet we cannot promote a kid who is banging the door down all off season.
Seems to me we are not even looking at like for like replacements when it comes to injury but just promoting those who have been around the longest despite their form.

You didn’t have him in your “ins”

Nice try.

Wtf are you talking about ???

As per the following

YOU DIDNT HAVE HIM IN YOUR INS

 

Ins: Young , Broad, Naismith, Sonsie , Cumberland.

Outs: Dow, Grimes, Banks, McIntosh, Short. Pickett/Short?.

Cmon people what harm can it do Giving Lefau another run. It was not an ideal situation with how he got his debut.

as i said i have talked him up at just about every opportunity and i know you have seen myb posts so what is your problem.
Big deal i left him out in one thread an over sight but hey i bet you don't have those moments.