Questions for Lynch as Tigers enter fourth straight preliminary finalPeter Ryan
The Age
October 10, 2020An errant left knee from Richmond's Tom Lynch has left the star forward vulnerable to the whim of the AFL's match review officer after the Tigers won their way into their fourth consecutive preliminary final with a 31-point win over an undermanned St Kilda at Metricon Stadium.
The Tigers were too good from start to finish with Lynch kick-starting their victory with a goal within the first minute in his first match back from the hamstring injury he suffered in round 17.
However the incident, which occurred in the third quarter when Lynch lowered his left knee into the collarbone of Saints' defender Dougal Howard and conceded a 50-metre penalty, will give the Tigers a sleepless night as they contemplate a tough trip to Adelaide to play Port Adelaide for a spot in the grand final.
Although the contact wasn't forceful and is more than likely to incur a fine, it was unnecessary and off the ball from a player who has earned the wrath of the match review officer already this season.
It was a critical moment in a match that was otherwise predictable with the Tigers winning too many centre clearances for the Saints' defenders to cope, with the small Richmond forwards feasting on loose balls inside their forward 50.
Shai Bolton was the most dynamic with three goals in the first half, his second a brilliant, courageous goal when he did not break stride as four Saints closed in on him.
When he threw the ball on to the outside of his boot and it went through the goals it was clear the night belonged to Richmond.
Shane Edwards was handy too at ground level with the Tiger talisman kicking a goal after Jayden Short took his team's first intercept mark for the finals series, starting a rebound that was as clinically efficient as a Roger Federer backhand.
It was a clear sign the Tigers were going to be too good for the fledgling Saints who entered the match without tap ruckman Paddy Ryder, father-to-be Jake Carlisle and suspended defender Ben Long.
They then lost Josh Battle - who entered the game under a cloud with a foot injury - for a quarter as he required treatment on the foot while Ben Paton copped a head knock that left him bloodstained. Tim Membrey went off with a leg injury in the final minutes too.
Ryder's absence was felt at centre bounces where Richmond dominated with nine centre clearances to two late in the second quarter when their score was 9.1 to the Saints' three goals.
While most of Richmond couldn't miss (apart from Lynch who kicked 2.5 and one out on the full) the Saints were blowing any chance they had with poor set shot kicking.
Battle, Rowan Marshall and Max King missed gettable chances in the third quarter as St Kilda tried to claw their way back into the match and left the margin 23 points at the final change.
Although it felt as though Richmond were in cruise control as they headed towards their first semi-final win since 2001, St Kilda did not go away just hanging in the game for long enough to keep it interesting.
It was not until Jason Castagna benefited from Edwards' poise by marking directly in front of goal and kicking accurately that the result was certain particularly with their centre square dominance meaning the ball lived in their forward half for most of the game.
St Kilda have plenty to be encouraged about however after surging back up the ladder on the back of five recruits with only Brad Hill out of that quintet disappointing overall. They won a hard-fought final and held themselves together under duress against Richmond when they looked set to blow them apart.
They were a class below the experienced Tigers who found space on both the field and scoreboard early and then controlled the tempo.
Richmond will be a match for Port Adelaide having lost a classic encounter in round 11 with the two teams four wins apiece since they met in the 2014 elimination final.
Richmond 5.1 9.1 10.4 12.8 (80)
St Kilda 2.2 3.6 5.11 6.13 (49)
Goals
Richmond: Bolton 3, Edwards 2, Lynch 2, Prestia, McIntosh, Martin, Castagna, Rioli
St Kilda: Savage, Butler, Steele, Battle, Ross, Kent
Best
Richmond: Edwards, Martin, Nankervis, Bolton, Baker
St Kilda: Steele, Marshall, Jones, Clark
https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/richmond-tigers-enter-fourth-preliminary-final-in-a-row-20201009-p563s1.html